India court acquits 12 men in 2006 Mumbai train bombings
Judges had in 2015 sentenced five of the accused to death and the remaining seven to life imprisonment.
On Monday, a two-judge bench of the Bombay High Court overturned the earlier order, ruling that the prosecution had "utterly failed" to establish that the accused had committed the offences for which they had been convicted.
The prosecution can appeal against the order in a higher court.
On 11 July 2006, seven blasts ripped through the busy commuter trains during the evening rush hour in one of India's deadliest militant attacks.
The bombs, packed into seven pressure cookers and put in bags, detonated within six minutes of each other.
The blasts took place in the areas of Matunga, Khar, Mahim, Jogeshwari, Borivali and Mira Road, with most on moving trains and two at stations.
The bombs appeared to have targeted first-class compartments, as commuters were returning home from the city's financial district.
Indian security agencies blamed the attack on Islamist militants backed by Pakistan, an allegation the country denied.
The accused, who were arrested shortly after the blasts, have been in jail since then. One of them, Kamal Ansari, who had been sentenced to death, died of Covid in 2021.
In 2015, a special court convicted the men of murder, conspiracy and waging war against the country. The prosecution appealed to confirm the death sentences, while the defence sought acquittal.
In July 2024, the Bombay High Court formed the two-judge bench to expedite the hearings.
Reports say that over the next six months, the court conducted more than 75 sittings and examined 92 prosecution witnesses and over 50 defence witnesses.
In the 667-page order on Monday, the court noted that the defence had questioned the credibility of the witnesses produced by the prosecution, as well as the confessional statements made by the accused.
It also acknowledged the defence's contention that the recovered evidence was not maintained in a "sealed condition throughout". — BBC
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab News
5 hours ago
- Arab News
Once a leading force, battered Tunisian party awaits elusive comeback
TUNIS: The party that once dominated Tunisian politics has faded away since President Kais Saied staged a dramatic power grab, with its offices shuttered and leaders behind bars or in exile. But observers say that Ennahdha, the Islamist-inspired movement still considered by some Tunisians as the country's main opposition party, could still bounce back after a devastating government crackdown. On July 25, 2021, Saied stunned the country when he suspended parliament and dissolved the government, a move critics denounced as a 'coup' a decade after the Arab Spring revolt ushered in a democratic transition in the North African country. Many of Saied's critics have been prosecuted and jailed, including Ennahdha leader Rached Ghannouchi, 84, a former parliament speaker who was sentenced earlier this month to 14 years in prison for plotting against the state. Ghannouchi, who was arrested in 2023, has racked up several prison terms, including a 22-year sentence handed in February on the same charge. The crackdown over the past four years has seen around 150 Ennahdha figures imprisoned, prosecuted or living in exile, according to a party official. 'Some believe the movement is dead, but that is not the case,' said political scientist Slaheddine Jourchi. Ennahdha has been 'weakened to the point of clinical death' but remained the most prominent party in Tunisia's 'fragmented and fragile' opposition, Jourchi added. 'Crimes against the country' Riadh Chaibi, a party official and adviser to Ghannouchi, said that even after 'shrinking' its political platform, Ennahdah was still a relevant opposition outlet. 'Despite repression, prosecutions and imprisonment' since 2021, 'Ennahdha remains the country's largest political movement,' Chaibi said. He said the current government has been 'weaponizing state institutions to eliminate political opponents,' but 'once we're free again, like we were in 2011, Ennahdha will regain its strength.' Since 2011, when Ghannouchi returned from exile to lead the party, Ennahdha for years had a key role in Tunisian politics, holding the premiership and other senior roles. But by 2019, the year Saied was elected president, the party's popularity had already begun waning, winning only a third of the 1.5 million votes it had in 2011. Experts ascribed this trend to the party's failure to improve living standards and address pressing socio-economic issues. Ennahdha has also been accused of jihadist links, which it has repeatedly denied. Saied, who religiously avoids mentioning either Ennahdha or Ghannouchi by name, has often referred to the party's years in power as 'the black decade' and accused it of committing 'crimes against the country.' Crowds of Tunisians, increasingly disillusioned as a political deadlock trumped Ennahdha's promise of change, poured into the streets in celebration when Saied forced the party out of the halls of power in 2021. Analyst Jourchi said Ennahdha's rise to power was a 'poorly prepared adventure,' and the party had 'made many mistakes along the way.' Left-wing politician Mongi Rahoui said it was 'only natural that Ennahdha leaders and their governing partners be prosecuted for crimes they used their political position to commit.' Today, the party's activities have been reduced mostly to issuing statements online, often reacting to prison sentences handed down to critics of Saied. 'Weathering repression' But Ennahdha has weathered repression before, harshly suppressed under Tunisia's autocratic presidents Habib Bourguiba and Zine El Abidine Ben Ali. Party leaders were jailed or forced into exile, and Ghannouchi was sentenced to life in prison under Bourguiba but then freed — and later exiled — under Ben Ali. Tunisian historian Abdellatif Hannachi said that the party 'seems to be bending with the wind, waiting for changes that would allow it to return.' It has been in 'clear decline,' he added, but 'that does not mean it's disappearing.' Ennahdha's downfall was not an isolated case. Other opposition forces have also been crushed, and dozens of political, media and business figures are currently behind bars. 'This regime no longer distinguishes between Islamist and secular, progressive and conservative,' rights advocate Kamel Jendoubi, a former minister, recently said in a Facebook post. Saied's government 'wants to silence everything that thinks, that criticizes, or resists,' Jendoubi argued. The opposition, however, remains fractured, failing for example to come together in rallies planned for the anniversary this month of Saied's power grab.
Arab News
10 hours ago
- Arab News
Hamas says French pledge to recognize State of Palestine ‘positive step'
GAZA CITY, Palestinian Territories: Islamist militant group Hamas hailed France's pledge on Thursday to recognize a State of Palestine as a 'positive step' and urged all countries to do the same despite Israeli opposition. 'We consider this a positive step in the right direction toward doing justice to our oppressed Palestinian people and supporting their legitimate right to self-determination,' Hamas said in a statement, after French President Emmanuel Macron's announcement that France would formally state its recognition in September. 'We call on all countries of the world — especially European nations and those that have not yet recognized the State of Palestine — to follow France's lead,' Hamas added.
Arab News
11 hours ago
- Arab News
How two families crossed the rubble of Gaza, fleeing war and hunger
GAZA/CAIRO: The Bakrons and Al-Bareems, two families from opposite ends of Gaza, have criss-crossed the rubble-strewn territory many times during 21 months of war, in search of food and shelter from Israeli attacks. They've sought refuge in the homes of friends and relatives, in school classrooms and in tents, moving frequently as the Israeli military has ordered civilians from one zone to another. The Bareems, from southern Gaza, have a disabled child who they have pushed in his wheelchair. The Bakrons, from the north, stopped wandering in May after two children of their children were killed in an airstrike. 'Our story is one of displacement, loss of loved ones, hunger, humiliation and loss of hope,' said Nizar Bakron, 38, who lost his daughter Olina, 10, and son Rebhi, eight. The families' experiences illustrate the plight of the 1.9 million Gaza residents — 90 percent of the population — that the United Nations says have been displaced during the conflict. Israel's war in Gaza has left much of the enclave in ruins and its people desperate from hunger. It was triggered by an attack by Islamist group Hamas — which governs the Strip — on Israeli border communities on October 7, 2023 that killed some 1,200 people and took 250 hostage. Before the war, Nizar and his wife Amal, four years his junior, had a happy life in Shejaia, a teeming district in the east of Gaza City. Their eldest Adam is 12; the youngest, Youssef, a baby. Photographs, seen by Reuters, show family parties at home and days at the beach. 'When the October 7 attack happened, I knew it wouldn't be something good for us,' Nizar said. They left home the next day for Amal's mother's house further south in Zahra, he said. Five days later Israel began ordering civilians in northern Gaza to move south and, on October 27, it launched a ground invasion. Throughout the war Israel has issued evacuation orders in areas where it plans to conduct operations — though it has also struck elsewhere during those periods. Israel says the orders protect civilians but it strikes wherever it locates Hamas fighters, who hide among the population. Hamas denies using civilians as shields. Palestinians accuse Israel of using the evacuation orders to uproot the population, which it denies. The family left for Nuseirat, an old refugee camp in central Gaza, where they crammed into an apartment owned by Amal's relatives for five months. Israel's bombardment was heaviest in the first months of the war. The Gaza Health Ministry, controlled by Hamas, said the death toll reached 32,845 by the end of March 2024. It has now passed 59,000 people, the ministry says. Food and fuel were becoming very expensive, with little aid arriving. In April, Israel issued an evacuation order and the Bakrons went further south to Rafah on the border with Egypt where there was more to eat. They loaded the car and a trailer with mattresses, clothes, kitchen equipment and a solar panel and drove 15 miles along roads lined with ruins. In Rafah, they squeezed into a classroom of a UN school which they shared with Nizar's two brothers and their families — about 20 people. Their savings were quickly disappearing. Weeks later, a new Israeli evacuation order moved them to Khan Younis, a few kilometers away, and another crowded classroom. In January, a ceasefire allowed them to move back north to Nuseirat, where the family had land. They cleared a room in a damaged building to live in. 'We thought things would get better,' Nizar said. But, after less than two months, the ceasefire collapsed on March 18. Two days later, Bakron's sister, her husband and two daughters were killed in an airstrike in Khan Younis, he said. As Israeli operations escalated, the family fled to Gaza City. They pitched a tent — the first time they had to live in one — against a building on Wehda Street, a central district. On May 25, as most of the family slept, Nizar was sitting outside, talking on the phone, when an airstrike hit and the building collapsed. He pulled away the debris but Olina and Rebhi were dead. His wife Amal and eldest Adam were injured, and the baby Youssef's leg was broken. Nizar does not know how they can move again. The family is in mourning and their car was damaged in the strike, he said. The UN estimates nearly 90 percent of Gaza's territory is covered by Israeli evacuation orders or within Israeli militarized zones, leaving the population squeezed into two swathes of land where food is increasingly scarce. Israel says restrictions on aid are needed to prevent it being diverted to Hamas. World Health Organization chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said on Wednesday Gaza is suffering from man-made starvation . Amal, who still has bruising on her face and wears a brace upon her arm after the attack, grieves for her two children: 'My life changed, from having everything to having nothing, after being displaced.' 'We fear for our lives' Majed Al-Bareem, 32, was a teacher before the war in Bani Suheila, a town east of Khan Younis. He and his wife Samia, 27, have a two-year-old son, Samir. They lived in a pretty two-story house with an external staircase that had plants in pots running up the steps. During Israel's initial offensive, which was focused on northern Gaza, the family stayed put. But early in 2024, Israeli forces pushed into Khan Younis and the Bareems fled their home. They learned afterwards it had been destroyed. 'I had a beautiful house which we built with our sweat and effort,' Majed said. He showed Reuters photos of the ruins. They went to Rafah with Majed's mother, Alyah, 62 and his three sisters. The youngest, Rafah, 19, has Down Syndrome. Days before they left Khan Younis, his eldest sister's husband was shot dead. Her son, Joud, nine, is in a wheelchair. At first, the family stayed in a tent provided by UN aid agencies in a district called Nasr in northern Rafah. Three months later, Israel ordered civilians to evacuate and the family left for Mawasi, a rural area nearby where displacement camps were growing, he said. Although Israel's military had designated Mawasi a safe zone, it struck it throughout the summer, killing scores of people, according to local health authorities. Israel said it was targeting militants hiding in the area. Since the two-month ceasefire ended in March the family has moved repeatedly — so often that Majed said he lost count — between Bani Suheila, Khan Younis and Mawasi. 'We fear for our lives so, as soon as they order us to leave, we do so,' he said. Crossing Gaza's ruined streets with a wheelchair has added to the difficulty. During one journey in May, he and Joud were separated from the family. It took them four hours to travel the five miles to Mawasi along roads littered with debris. 'It was exhausting and scary because we could hear gunfire and bombing,' he said. The family is currently in a tent in Mawasi. Their savings are nearly gone and they can only rarely afford extra rations to supplement the little they get from charitable kitchens. 'We are tired of displacement. We are tired of lack of food,' said Majed's mother, Alyah. Last week, Majed went to Bani Suheila hoping to buy some flour. A shell landed nearby, wounding him in the torso with a shrapnel fragment, he said. It was removed in hospital but left him weak. With Israel and Hamas conducting ceasefire negotiations, the United States has voiced optimism about a deal. Majed says the renewed talks have given him some hope, but he fears they will fall apart, like previous attempts. 'I don't think anyone can bear what we are bearing,' he said. 'It has been two years of the war, hunger, killing, destruction and displacement.'
