‘Freedom Of Speech Not Absolute': SC's Message Went Beyond Samay Raina, Hemant Malviya, Wajahat Khan
Comic Samay Raina, cartoonist Hemant Malviya, Wajahat Khan hearings: Over the past two days, SC heard three cases related to freedom of expression, giving one clear message
Article 19(1)(a) of the Indian Constitution guarantees freedom of speech and expression, allowing citizens to freely express their ideas and opinions. However, then comes Article 19(2) which reminds that the freedom is not absolute. It permits the government to impose reasonable restrictions in the interest of sovereignty, state security, public order, decency, morality, and other concerns to maintain balance and protect public interest.
Over the past two days, the Supreme Court (SC) heard three cases related to freedom of expression. The circumstances in the three and the redress sought were different, but the SC had one common message.
Five social media influencers, including 'India's Got Latent' host Samay Raina, on Tuesday appeared before the Supreme Court in a case seeking action against them for ridiculing persons suffering from disabilities. A bench of Justices Surya Kant and Joymalya Bagchi recorded the presence of the social media influencers and asked them to file their replies to the petition.
The top court asked Attorney General R Venkataramani, appearing for the Centre, to prepare social media guidelines by keeping a balance of freedom of speech and expression and rights and duties of others. It said that the freedom of one person should not violate the rights of others and flagged that enforceability of these guidelines is the most difficult part.
The apex court asked Attorney General R Venkataramani, representing the Centre, to prepare social media guidelines while balancing the freedom of speech and expression and the rights and duties of others. Venkataramani sought time to assist the court on the issue and said the enforceability of guidelines would require detailed consideration. 'What we are doing is for posterity. You have to ensure that not a single word is misused by anyone. You have to ensure balance. We have to protect citizens' rights. A framework must be there that the dignity of anyone is not violated," the bench said.
The top court was hearing a petition filed by M/s Cure SMA Foundation seeking a prohibition on the broadcast of derogatory and denigrating content on the digital media against persons with disability. The SC asked the influencers to appear again in-person on the next date of the hearing of the case.
'Kisi ko kuch bhi bol do': SC on cartoonist Hemant Malviya who uploaded cartoons of PM Modi, RSS workers
The Supreme Court on Tuesday granted interim protection from arrest to Indore-based cartoonist Hemant Malviya, who is accused of uploading 'objectionable" cartoons of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and workers of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) on social media.
The case was being heard by a bench of Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia and Justice Aravind Kumar. While granting the cartoonist protection, the Supreme Court remarked that it was not okay to make any statement against anyone. 'Kisi ko kuch bhi bol do (Say anything to anyone). They want to become heroes," the bench said.
Advocate Vrinda Grover, appearing for the cartoonist, said, 'The person can have a critical opinion about things, it does not constitute an offence…"
In response, Additional Solicitor General KM Nataraj remarked, 'The manner in which he has done, is clearly an offence." Justice Dhulia said one of the posts by the cartoonist is 'very, very offensive". 'What is happening today, all kinds of statements are being made. The language they use. There are some among the lawyer community also doing this. We will have to do something on this," Justice Dhulia remarked.
Denying his request on Monday, the bench had said, 'This freedom of speech is being abused by this cartoonist, stand-up comedians."
'Learn to control tongue and words…else govt will have to intervene': SC on Wajahat Khan
While hearing a case related to Wajahat Khan, the 30-year-old co-founder of the Rashidi Foundation, the Supreme Court on Monday said that there is freedom of speech, but this does not mean that anyone can say anything. 'Every person should learn to control his tongue and his words, especially on social media."
Khan had filed a complaint against social media influencer Sharmistha Panoli over alleged defamatory social media posts. However, as his own old tweets surfaced, cases were filed against him in many states. Khan moved the SC, asking the cases to be clubbed.
Khan's lawyer said that the tweets he made were just a reaction, but the court clearly asked, 'Why did you repeat the same mistake?"
The court was told that he had made objectionable comments about those who worship Kamakhya Devi. The court expressed displeasure over this and said that responsibility is necessary before posting anything on social media. 'At times, people think they have the freedom to say anything on social media, but when it is misused, the matter reaches the court. This increases the pressure on the courts. The police also loses focus from the real cases. If people do not control their words, then the government will have to intervene. Nobody wants the government to keep interrupting every time. If mutual brotherhood and understanding remains in the society, then such hateful talks will reduce."
The Supreme Court gave relief to Khan and has sought a response from the state government, but made it clear that this matter is not limited to just one person, but it is a big issue related to the responsibility of all citizens and the right use of social media.
Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from politics to crime and society. Stay informed with the latest India news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated!
tags :
freedom of speech freedom of speech and expression Samay Raina supreme court
view comments
First Published:
Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Bihar set to get 6 functional airports in three years: Chief secy, ETInfra
Advt By Patna: After establishing a strong network of roads, Bihar is witnessing a major leap in the civil aviation sector, with a total of six functional big airports expected in the next three years. This is being done with the aim of having at least one airport within a distance of 200 km from any town in the state. Apart from increasing the number of airports, the state also slashed VAT on aviation turbine fuel from 29 per cent to 4 per cent to attract more flight operators and enhance the state's air to TOI, chief secretary Amrit Lal Meena said the state already has three functional airports: one each at Patna, Gaya, and Darbhanga. Three others are going to be added to the list, including the fourth one at Purnia, which is targeted to be operational in Aug this year. The fifth in the pipeline is Bihta airport, which is expected to be functional by Dec 2027, and the sixth will be Raxaul airport, with the target of starting operation by June addition to the state's major airports, six new small airports are slated to be developed in the next three years at Madhubani, Saharsa, Birpur (Supaul), Valmiki Nagar (West Champaran), Munger, and Muzaffarpur. These airports will be built under the Udan (Ude Desh ka Aam Naagrik) Ramchandra Deore, special secretary in the cabinet secretariat (with additional charge as director of civil aviation, Bihar), said while these small airport sites already exist and are maintained by the state govt, they currently lack infrastructure such as air traffic control towers and terminal buildings required for flight operations. Under the Udan scheme, these facilities will be constructed with about Rs 25 crore allotted to each airport by the Centre – enabling the airports to become fully functional. With the addition of these six, Bihar will have a total of 12 airports (both big and small).Furthermore, the govt has approved the construction of heliports at Jehanabad, Samastipur, and Nalanda, and this project is now in the past year, Bihar saw key developments in civil aviation. The new terminal at Patna's Jay Prakash Narain International Airport was built at the cost of Rs 1,216 crore. The state also urged the Centre to approve an international greenfield airport near Patna. For Darbhanga airport, 76.65 acres were transferred and 89.75 acres were acquired (Rs 244.61 crore).
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
"Did Not Crush Farmers": Jharkhand Minister On BJP Attack Over Son's Reel
Ranchi: Jharkhand Health Minister Irfan Ansari has drawn fire from the Opposition BJP over a video of his 19-year-old son Krish allegedly inspecting a top government hospital in Ranchi. With the BJP targeting the minister with its dynasty line of attack, the latter has denied that his son was inspecting the hospital and claimed that he was there to meet his teacher's parent. A video that has gone viral shows Krish, an engineering student in Uttarakhand, at the Ranchi-based Regional Institute of Medical Sciences. The video, which was first posted online by Krish's friends, shows him at the hospital. A voice is heard telling the patients, "The minister's son is here. Tell him if you have any problems." Krish is then heard pointing to a man standing next to him. "Whatever problems you have, tell him." He is also seen discussing medical bills with hospital authorities. The visuals also show him with Chief Minister Hemant Soren. सोचिए इन INDI ठगबंधियों की शातिर दिमाग घोटाला करने के लिए घटियापन के किस स्तर तक जा सकती है कि झारखंड प्रदेश के स्वास्थ्य मंत्रालय का जिम्मा लेकर इरफान अंसारी खुद घर में बैठकर अपने बेटे को अस्पतालों का निरीक्षण करने भेज रहे हैं। — BJP JHARKHAND (@BJP4Jharkhand) July 19, 2025 Sharing the video on X, Jharkhand BJP said in a post, "Just imagine to what level the cunning minds of these INDI thugs can stoop. Irfan Ansari, who is in charge of the health ministry of Jharkhand, is sitting at home and sending his son to inspect hospitals." State BJP spokesperson Ajay Sah said every ministry in Jharkhand should now have a cabin for the minister's son. "In Jharkhand, symbols of dynasty are now being established instead of democracy. The finance minister's son will now check files, education minister's son will check teachers' attendance and health minister's son will inspect hospitals," he said. Mr Ansari denied that his son was at the hospital for an inspection. "My son is full of compassion and always wants to help others. His teacher's parent was ill. I was in Delhi. When this came to my son's attention, he went to the hospital. There were other patients too from tribal communities in Jamtara and Dumka. To help them, he took money from his mother," he said. Jamtara, Jharkhand: On the viral video of his son, Minister Irfan Ansari says, "My son, Krish Ansari... You know he is full of compassion and always wants to help others. His teacher at DPS, Abhishek ji—his mother or father was ill. I was in Delhi at the time. As a teacher and a… — IANS (@ians_india) July 19, 2025 "When I came to know about the remarks being made, I scolded him. But when I went to the hospital, I realised he did nothing wrong. Why will he inspect? Who is he? Anyone can go to a hospital," the Congress leader said. "My son did not crush a farmer during a protest," he said. Mr Ansari was referring to the 2012 Lakhimpur Kheri incident in which former Union Minister and BJP leader Ajay Kumar Mishra's son Ashish allegedly ran over farmers protesting against the now-scrapped farm laws. "If my son goes and helps people, it must be appreciated. What issue is this? I want to tell the BJP, there are many issues. Don't drag my son into this."
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
US' first big move against Pak-backed terror after Pahalgam attack
US' first big move against Pak-backed terror after Pahalgam attack Team TOI Plus Jul 20, 2025, 13:35 IST IST The US ban on TRF, a proxy for Lashkar-e-Taiba, turns the spotlight on Pakistan's ongoing support for terrorism at a time when Islamabad is trying to draw international attention to the Kashmir issue. India calls it a strong endorsement of the growing counterterrorism ties between New Delhi and Washington In a major embarrassment for Islamabad, the US State Department has designated The Resistance Front ( TRF ) — a proxy for the Pakistan-based Lashkar-e-Taiba ( LeT ) that was behind the April 22 Pahalgam carnage — a 'foreign terrorist organisation'. Washington's move turns the spotlight on Pakistan's ongoing support for terrorism at a time when Islamabad is attempting to draw international attention to the Kashmir issue. Pakistan is reportedly planning to leverage its current presidency of the UN Security Council (UNSC) to initiate an open debate next week on what it calls 'unresolved' international disputes.
