MP ‘ill-informed' on seesaw
In a social media post published on Thursday, Tauranga MP Sam Uffindell criticised the Dunedin City Council for wasting ratepayer money on "stupid vanity projects".
He claimed the council had spent $600,000 on a seesaw as part of an inner city playground built during upgrades to George St.
"The message to local government is clear: get your costs under control — Kiwis are doing it tough."
"I mean, how stupid do you have to be," he asked.
Reaction from social media commenters was mixed — some were supportive while others pointed out the overall playground feature had cost less than $600,000 in total.
The council said the play space cost $586,000 and also featured "talk tubes", benches and shading and soft-fall surfaces.
Invoices showed the three seesaws in the playground — a 7m-long, 12m-long and inclusive seesaw — together cost $244,700.
The council had received a $250,000 donation from lead contractor Isaac Construction to go towards the cost of the playground.
Cr Christine Garey said Mr Uffindell was "ill-informed" — "but that's not a surprise".
Children and families loved the playground feature of George St, she said.
"This decision was made long before the cost of living crisis that was caused by his government.
"Did he talk about the huge cost of government regulation imposed by central government on local government? I doubt it."
Cr Andrew Whiley said he and Mr Uffindell attended the same event when the MP was in Dunedin earlier this month where the topic of the seesaws came up.
"I quickly said, 'well, actually, councillors never signed off on the seesaws'," Cr Whiley said.
"I made it quite clear to him that actually councillors had not seen or had the ability to review that prior to it being installed and being signed off by council staff."
Councillors had seen and noted a plan for the play space at an extraordinary planning and environment committee in April 2022, but it did not include the seesaws, Cr Whiley said.
"I never basically understood [how] the playground went from what was in our papers to being what it was finished."
Council central city plan project director Glen Hazelton said councillors voted to note the report in 2022, "including the details on the play space".
The council was "disappointed" by Mr Uffindell's comments.
"The total cost of the entire play space on George St was $586,000," he said.
"At less than 1% of the total budget for George St, we believe the investment in a more people-friendly space is good value for money."
"A number of new retail tenants coming to George St have noted the improvements that make the area more people-friendly, including the play space, as the reason for relocating," Dr Hazelton said.
ruby.shaw@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Oral Questions for Wednesday 30 July 2025
Questions to Ministers Hon MARAMA DAVIDSON to the Prime Minister: E tautoko ana ia i nga korero me nga mahi katoa a tona Kawanatanga? Does he stand by all of his Government's statements and actions? Dr VANESSA WEENINK to the Minister of Finance: What recent announcements has she made about competition? Rt Hon CHRIS HIPKINS to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by all of his Government's statements and actions? CATHERINE WEDD to the Minister of Transport: What steps has he taken to reduce councils' use of road cones in New Zealand? Hon PEENI HENARE to the Minister of Foreign Affairs: Does he stand by his statement that "It is a matter of when, not if, New Zealand will recognise Palestine Statehood"; if not, why not? CHLÖE SWARBRICK to the Prime Minister: E tautoko ana ia i nga korero me nga mahi katoa a tona Kawanatanga? Does he stand by all of his Government's statements and actions? GRANT McCALLUM to the Minister of Agriculture: What recent reports has he seen on farmer confidence? Hon Dr AYESHA VERRALL to the Minister of Health: Does he stand by his statement that "Patient safety is critical to ensure Kiwis have confidence in our healthcare systems"? CAMERON BREWER to the Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs: What recent announcement has the Government made about increasing transparency at the checkout? Hon WILLOW-JEAN PRIME to the Minister of Education: Does she agree with Erica Stanford, who said in 2023 that "we're in a cost of living crisis and everyone is feeling the pinch really, really badly. Teachers are no different than anyone else"; if so, how will a proposed one percent pay increase help secondary teachers with the cost of living crisis? LAURA McCLURE to the Minister for Workplace Relations and Safety: What recent announcements has she made on health and safety reform? DEBBIE NGAREWA-PACKER to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by all his Government's statements and actions? To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
Boy racer legislation introduced to Parliament
Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone New legislation set to bring in harsher penalties for what the government calls "idiot" boy racers, has been introduced to Parliament. Announced in May , the Anti-Social Road Use Legislation Amendment Bill will set up new offences and penalties for people driving dangerously, including costly infringement fees and making vehicle seizure or destruction more common for street racing, burnouts and fleeing police. The bill defines "anti-social road users" as people who flee police, participate in unauthorised street racing, burnouts, intimidating convoys, disorderly dirt bike gatherings, or siren battles. The bill is expected to receive its first reading in August. In a statement, Transport Minister Chris Bishop says those who want to drive dangerously will face serious consequences. "Kiwis are sick of seeing these idiot drivers putting everyone around them at risk, so we're taking action through a range of much tougher penalties," he said. The bill would also give police more powers to manage illegal gatherings by closing roads or public areas, like infringements of $1000 for those who fail to leave areas when told to by police Police Minister Mark Mitchell said the additional powers would support to continue cracking down on illegal events. "We have seen substantive responses to these illegal gatherings, including arrests, checkpoints, and other tactics to shut these events down. These gatherings are dangerous to the participants, to bystanders, and to the public," he said. "Boy racers only care about one thing - their car. Once they realise they're not getting it back, they'll think twice about fleeing police or driving dangerously," Mitchell said. "We have seen substantive responses to these illegal gatherings, including arrests, checkpoints, and other tactics to shut these events down. These gatherings are dangerous to the participants, to bystanders, and to the public." An offender will be exempt from vehicle forfeiture or destruction if they do not own the car (unless they fail to provide information about a driver to police), if it would be "manifestly" unjust, or cause extreme hardship to the offender or undue hardship to someone else. After its first reading, the bill will go through a four month Select Committee process including public consultation.
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
Auckland homelessness spike: Who, or what, is to blame?
Outreach providers say there's been a 90 percent increase in homelessness in Auckland since September last year. Photo: RNZ / Luke McPake Auckland councillors are calling on the government to take action over the growing homelessness problem in the city. Outreach providers say there has been a 90 percent increase in homelessness in Auckland since September last year, after the government tightened up emergency housing eligibility rules . The council's Community Committee wants the government to work with frontline agencies and make sure they are using up-to-date data when dealing with the issue. "No one I know wants to see Kiwis living without shelter, and we're very concerned with the level of rough sleeping and people in cars, and in tents and other things, including in Auckland," Associate Minister for Housing Tama Potaka told Morning Report on Wednesday. Community Committee chair, Councillor Angela Dalton, told Checkpoint on Tuesday recent government policy changes had "made it harder for people to access emergency housing", as had declining people deemed to have contributed to their own lack of accommodation. "I think there's some policies that have been changed that show a lack of compassion because they are making assumptions that people are not trying hard enough." Potaka said there were "a lot of contributing factors and causes" behind the rise in homelessness. "There's a number of things that this government is doing, whether or not it's the build program, making sure we build another 500 social homes in Auckland, Māori housing, Kainga Ora, 1500 new homes with chips, resetting the housing system. You would have heard us talking about granny flats and enabling those… and I look forward to the council actually supporting those actions." Potaka said he had "directed officials to identify some potential target interventions and understand the utilisation rates across transitional housing first, and other support programmes, to make sure we're getting the right utilisation of programmes. "We're also liaising with a lot of those providers like Strive, Auckland City Mission… and a whole range of others in Auckland." He said there was "different data", and "a bit of ambiguity" around how a recent Salvation Army report came to the conclusion there had been a 386 percent rise in people denied help because they had contributed to their own homelessness . "It's very hard to attribute one particular cause… You can't attribute [the rise] just to a policy change. There's a range of causes, and one of the biggest ones, of course, is disconnection with families and with whanau - and that's one of the biggest contributors to people sleeping rough." Ministry of Social Development (MSD) said in June 36 percent of applications for emergency housing were declined, mostly often "because their need can be met in another way", according to group general manager enablement Karen Hocking. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Of those declined emergency housing because it was deemed they had contributed to their own homelessness, Potaka said two-thirds still got some form of assistance. "Overall, the vast majority of people, between 85 percent and 90 percent who apply for emergency housing, get some sort of support for emergency housing." He would not detail what actions could be considered as contributing to one's own homelessness. "There could be a range of circumstances. I'm not going to go into the various types of circumstances that can emerge, but sometimes people do that… "There's a responsibility framework that goes with emergency housing. People who have a genuine need for short-term temporary accommodation in most big towns and cities in New Zealand, there is support, but there is a responsibility framework that goes with it. "For example, you have to undertake some training when you're in emergency housing around budgeting and other things, or getting ready to rent. There's a whole bunch of programmes within the emergency housing framework that are in place to support people to transition out and get to a place which they can stay in a more enduring manner than emergency housing - a catastrophe we all know about." MSD's Hocking gave some examples, however. "We have some concerns that the data used by the National Homelessness Data Project does not adequately reflect the support we are providing New Zealanders," she added. Potaka said rather than just government, it was "actually a whole lot of society that's responsible" for solving the issue, including "councils, whanau, iwi Māori, charitable organisations". "We've got a huge build programme that's in place right now around community housing providers, and a range of others who are actually building homes that hopefully will be suitable for those that have got serious housing deprivation - whether or not that's on the street or people on the social housing waitlist, which, by the way, has come down about 5000 families since we got into administration." Opposition parties have blamed the rise on homelessness on the government's policies . Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
