Noor Islamic center sues Hilliard for discrimination, violation of Constitutional rights
An entity of the cultural center followed through and filed a federal lawsuit April 14 against the City of Hilliard, city council and City Manager Michelle Crandall alleging discrimination and violation of First Amendment rights.
The lawsuit in federal district court follows an administrative appeal Britton Parkway Holding Inc. filed late last year in Franklin County District Court after the Hilliard council rejected their plan for transforming a 220,000-square-foot vacant office building.
The city's decision not only violated Hilliard's own zoning code and long-term plans, but also violated federal law and 'trampled on BPH's rights protected by the U.S. and Ohio Constitutions,' the lawsuit alleges.
Ronney Abaza, the chair of the Noor board, told the Dispatch in an interview that the local legal action that is still pending does not include any financial damages or penalties, which is part of the reason the federal lawsuit was necessary, he said.
'We've been injured financially by the discrimination that the city has pursued against us,' Abaza said. 'We've been harmed financially and so we want to be compensated for that.'
Joe Miller, an attorney representing BPH, told reporters at an April 14 press conference outside U.S. District Court in downtown Columbus that Hilliard put up barriers to Noor despite multiple attempts from the mosque to work with them.
'The city hopes that the Noor Islamic Cultural Center will go away and just relinquish the building — federal civil rights laws, however, exist for situations such as this,' Miller said. 'Never in my over 25 years of practice have I ever seen such overt discrimination and clear violations of a property owner's civil rights and right to express their faith.'
Miller said that the financial damages will be measured in the millions of dollars. And the longer this goes on, the more lost revenue will accumulate, Abaza added.
BPH purchased the building at 5550 Britton Parkway in February 2024 out of foreclosure with funds raised from the Muslim community in central Ohio. The building, once the site of BMW Financial Services, has been vacant for years amid the downturn in demand for office space following the COVID-19 pandemic.
Noor's plans for the building include keeping some office space and adding a school, STEM center, community event space and some worship use.
City officials refused to negotiate with BPH and its attorneys, the federal lawsuit alleges, and imposed 'completely arbitrary and unprecedented restrictions' standards on how they could use the building.
'Every time BPH addressed and satisfied a contrived demand of the city, defendants divined yet another baseless and unfounded obstacle to deny BPH's rights,' the lawsuit says.
Crandall previously said at a council meeting that the building is in an ideal location for economic development and high-income jobs that help the city, but the lawsuit says that the planned uses for the building would generate far more income tax than it does today.
The city has also approved other overtly Christian projects without fanfare and allowed other developments along the I-270 corridor that are not as lucrative to the city's income tax coffers, the lawsuit states.
'The lack of any rational basis for denying BPH's application reveals the true reason that defendants have fought BPH's redevelopment at every step: defendants simply want to limit Islamic worship in Hilliard,' the lawsuit says.
'(City officials) are targeting and discriminating against the Central Ohio Muslim community behind a thin veil of nonsensical and standardless judgements.'
A spokesperson for the City of Hilliard referred the Dispatch to the most recent statement the city has made about Noor: Hilliard followed existing land use regulations and that staff 'worked hard to accommodate their evolving plans" proposed for the office building.
'Noor has the opportunity to submit a new development plan for the site that aligns with the community plan,' the city's statement from November 2024 says. 'We remain committed to reaching a resolution so the building's potential can be maximized for the benefit of our entire community.'
Anna Lynn Winfrey covers the western suburbs for the Columbus Dispatch. She can be reached at awinfrey@dispatch.com.
This article originally appeared on The Columbus Dispatch: Noor Islamic Cultural Center suing Hilliard in federal court
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
LA City Council bans N-word at public meetings, triggering legal threats
Watch your mouth! The Los Angeles City Council voted Wednesday to ban the use of the N-word and C-word at public meetings — triggering free speech backlash and the threat of a $400 million lawsuit. The controversial vote by the body allows council leadership to issue a warning for any use or variation of the slurs. Repeat offenders can be booted from the chamber and barred from future sessions. Advertisement Council President Marqueece Harris-Dawson, who is black and introduced the measure, said the use of slurs during public comments has made residents hesitant to attend meetings. 3 The council chamber where a 14–0 vote Wednesday banned use of the N-word and C-word during meetings, citing years of disruptive outbursts. Los Angeles Times via Getty Images 'It is language that, anywhere outside this building where there aren't four armed guards, would get you hurt if you said these things in public,' Harris-Dawson told the Los Angeles Times earlier this year. Advertisement He added that public comment has become 'rank, cantankerous, and rude and demeaning and insulting' since Donald Trump's election in 2016, according to the LAist. The Wednesday ban is already drawing legal threats. Wayne Spindler, an attorney and longtime City Hall commenter, said Wednesday he intends to sue. 3 Critics of the new rule, including frequent City Hall speakers, claimed the city was infringing on free speech and promised legal challenges. Getty Images Advertisement 'I'm going to file my $400-million lawsuit that I already have prepared and ready to file,' Spindler said during public comment, adding he plans to read explicit Tupac Shakur lyrics until he's banned from a meeting. Spindler was arrested in 2016 after submitting a public comment card showing a burning cross, a man hanging from a tree and the phrase 'Herb = [N-word],' referring to then-Council President Herb Wesson. Prosecutors declined to bring charges. David Loy, legal director of the First Amendment Coalition, warned the council's policy likely won't survive in court. 3 Council President Marqueece Harris-Dawson said offensive speech has surged since 2016, creating a chilling effect on civic engagement. Los Angeles Times via Getty Images Advertisement 'The First Amendment prohibits the government from censoring speech because it disapproves of that speech,' Loy wrote in a letter to the City Council. The city has lost similar battles before. In 2014, it paid $215,000 to a black man who was removed from a meeting for wearing a Ku Klux Klan hood and a T-shirt with the N-word. The new rule took effect immediately.
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Queen's ‘Garden of Hate' taking case to federal court, rips judge and ‘scurrilous' NY Post coverage
The fight over a community garden in Queens is getting thornier. The attorney for the anti-Israel leaders of Sunset Community Garden in Ridgewood withdrew their state lawsuit against the city and the Parks Department — to make a federal case out of the issue. Since last fall, Jewish Ridgewood residents haven't felt welcome at Sunset Community Garden, thanks to the garden group's pro-Palestinian rhetoric, which included a special section labeled 'Poppies for Palestine.' 4 Some local residents said they do not feel welcome in the community garden, whose leaders asked incoming members to pledge 'solidarity' with the people of Palestine. Instagram @sunsetgardenridgewood Incoming members are also made to pledge 'solidarity with the oppressed and marginalized people' of Palestine' by the garden's management. The Parks Department wanted the group out by June 6 for 'violat[ing] the terms of their license' with the 'unconstitutional wording' of their 'ideological litmus test' for membership, according to court documents. The group responded with a state lawsuit in early June to block the eviction, and The Post was in the courtroom when attorneys for both sides met in court this month. But Jonathan Wallace, the garden leaders' attorney, withdrew the state lawsuit Monday, and told the city he plans to refile the case in federal court, a source said. In a letter this week, the lawyer accused Judge Hasa Kingo of allowing the 'scurrilous' New York Post's coverage to guide his rulings in court. 'The plaintiffs in this case are a community group composed largely of trans people of color, many of whom are immigrants, and who share a powerfully-rooted moral opposition to the horrifying violence committed by a political entity, the nation-state Israel, against the people of Gaza,' the letter read. 4 Attorney Jonathan Wallace objected to coverage from The Post. Michael Nagle 4 The garden's leaders are fighting the city's efforts to oust them. Helayne Seidman 'We could not be further from the ideals and goals stated by Justices Holmes and Brandeis when the Post appears to be influencing outcomes in judicial proceedings,' he added. 'As an old white, proudly Jewish attorney (something that in a 43-year career I never thought until now I would need to mention) I like and am content to be associated with' the garden leaders, Wallace concluded in his letter to Kingo. Christina Wilkinson — a Ridgewood resident who worked to secure funding for the green space, but is now one of its most vocal critics — said the switch to federal court a 'stall tactic,' and believes 'Parks must now remove the violators and find a community partner that will make Sunset Garden an open and inclusive place for all.' 4 Members planting in the garden in June 2024. Instagram @sunsetgardenridgewood She added, 'You have to love the irony of an attorney arguing that the City violated his clients' First Amendment rights, then turning around and complaining about [a Post reporter] being present in the courtroom.' Wallace did not respond to multiple requests for comment. The Parks Department refused to respond to requests for comment.
The Hill
6 hours ago
- The Hill
Boris Johnson blasts Starmer for backing Palestinian state: ‘Ridiculous'
Former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson on Friday slammed the current UK leader for threatening to recognize Palestinian statehood amid the ongoing war in Gaza, calling the move 'ridiculous.' Johnson signaled Prime Minister Keir Starmer's commitment — largely following France's lead — was aimed toward capturing voters' attention, not promoting a ceasefire. 'It's nothing to do with promoting peace in the Middle East. Is nothing to do with advancing a two-state solution,' the former leader of the UK's Conservative Party said in an appearance on NewsNation's ' On Balance.' 'It's everything to do with the continual oscillation of the Labor prime minister between his own two states, a state of paralyzed inaction and a state of panic about what's going on in the Labor Party,' he told host Leland Vittert. Johnson continued, 'The problem in the Labor Party, the governing party in our country, is that they're terrified of losing the votes of the Muslim community. It's nothing to do with helping the Palestinians. It's about managing his own party.' The former leader, who resigned from his role in 2022 amid a scandal during the COVID-19 pandemic and following the U.K.'s withdrawal from the European Union in 2020, criticized broader efforts to recognize Palestine as a sovereign state. 'You're not supposed to recognize a state unless it has clearly defined boundaries, plainly the state of Palestine does not. And it [must] have a government [that] is capable of controlling those borders and part of the government of the putative state of Palestine is the psychotic Islamic fascist terrorist group Hamas,' Johnson said. He also described Palestinian statehood as a 'big reward' for little accomplishment. More calls for a two-state solution have cropped up in recent weeks, as humanitarian conditions in the Gaza Strip remain dire. The United Nations and other groups have pointed to reports of mass starvation and the blocking of aid into the region as cause for concern. The Israeli government has denied such claims and said Hamas is promoting a deadly rhetoric to shame leaders. But Starmer and other nations have flocked to the frontlines, promising aid through air drops and medical treatments for the vulnerable as violence in the region continues nearly two years after Hamas's initial Oct. 7, 2023, attack. Democratic lawmakers, including House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (N.Y.) and Rep. Ro Khanna (Calif.), have pressed the Trump administration to follow in the footsteps of the UK and France — as peace talks have stalled. The U.S. has not agreed to recognize Palestine as a state and Secretary of State Marco Rubio has pushed back on such calls. The administration has also significantly reduced assistance efforts in the Middle East, including the closure of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) and withdrawal from the United Nations Food Program.
