Cardiff Capital Region hit with £5.25m Aberthaw power station settlement
An independent investigation has been launched how the Cardiff Capital Region handed the process
The Aberthaw Power Station pictured before its decommissioning
Taxpayers will have to pay £5.25m bill after a regional body responsible for handling the Cardiff City Deal bungled the awarding of a demolition contract for Aberthaw power station.
The Cardiff Capital Region, a public body which was set up to invest more than £500m in the south Wales as part of the 2016 City Deal, was taken to court over how it awarded a demolition contract for Aberthaw power station, the disused power station it controversially bought from energy giant RWE.
The body, which represents 10 councils, lost a high-court legal challenge brought by a losing bidder, Brown and Mason Group, which concluded in February.
Welsh Government has to plunder reserves to fill national insurance blackhole
READ MORE:
The former coal-powered station was acquired for £8m by the city region in 2022, with contractors Erith beginning demolition work last year. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here
The region's chair Mary Ann Brocklesby gave an update to the Senedd, telling the economy committee that a settlement of £5.25m had been agreed. Brown and Mason had previously said they were seeking £10m. It has yet to be clarified if the £5.25m includes legal costs.
"I'm not able to say much more at this point because we are undergoing an independent review which we commissioned as political leaders to set in train precisely at the point that we knew we were going through a legal process," she said.
Article continues below
Cllr Brocklesby said: "We had to wait until that legal process was over before that independent review could start. "We are awaiting the findings which – subject to legal caveats – we will be making public."
Kellie Beirne, chief executive of the south-east Wales corporate joint committee and Cardiff Capital Region, said: "We're taking this extremely seriously, we recognise the gravity of it and again yes, [it's] something that we don't come and report.
"Apologies again for the short notice but we had clearance, we briefed our internal stakeholders and we felt it important to be as transparent as we possibly could by conveying that this morning at this committee."
She said a full independent review has been ordered. "When that review concludes and we have findings, we'll be able to be much more open about what happened and take steps to ensure that this can't happen again," she said.
Asked whether the court case has impinged on work at the 500-acre site, Cllr Brocklesby insisted: "No, it continues at pace."
Conservative MS Andrew RT Davies said: "When you came before this committee in September 2023, Kellie you said that £40m is but a drop in the ocean.
"I think the words you used were hundreds of millions of pounds will be required. Obviously, this court case has not helped instil confidence in the private sector in coming on board as partners... so, how are you progressing in that goal?"
Cllr Brocklesby replied: "Let's look at the wider ecosystem of CCR: one of the absolute strengths of it is that we have people across the region who are highly valued within their own sectors... who are highly respected not just in Wales but globally."
"In terms of the future of Aberthaw, it does actually look very bright and we're not feeling any effects from the impacts of this highly regrettable procurement issue."
Article continues below
Ms Beirne said Cardiff Capital Region does not have deep enough pockets for what Aberthawr requires following the initial demolition and remediation phase.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leader Live
3 hours ago
- Leader Live
MS shares an update on the Coastal Path in Flintshire
MS for North Wales As Chair of the Senedd's Cross-Party Group on Disability, I met Amnesty International UK's Government and Political Relations Manager - Wales to discuss how we might ensure that the rights of disabled people are given proper legal effect in Wales. I also met with Wrexham-based Community Organising Charity TCC and other members of the coalition of organisations campaigning for the removal of barriers along the Wales Coastal Path in Flintshire, for discussion on further action. I have been working with disabled people and others across Flintshire for a decade, seeking to work with Flintshire County Council to remove all barriers along the Wales Coastal Path that are managed by the Council, allowing access for all. The current situation contravenes both the UK Equality Act (2010) and the legal and policy frameworks of the Welsh Government and Flintshire County Council itself. It was a pleasure to visit the 2025 Royal Welsh Show in Builth Wells, where I was a member of the Gylfinir Cymru/Curlew Wales Panel as Wales Species Champion for the Curlew. My other meetings and visits there included, Adferiad, the member-led charity operating services across every constituency in Wales, that campaigns for and provides services to people with mental health, addiction, and co-occurring and complex needs; British Veterinary Association's Welsh Branch Reception as one of their Honorary Associate Members; The British Army Stand, to meet serving personnel, explore interactive displays, and learn more about the Army's contribution to Welsh society; Farmers' Union of Wales (FUW), to discuss the significant issues facing Welsh Agriculture at the moment; and Natural Resources Wales (NRW), to discuss some of their recent work and my priorities and concerns, and to meet their Senior Leadership team and area specialists. The Senedd's Public Accounts and Public Administration Committee, which I Chair, has identified significant failings in the Welsh Government's handling of the acquisition of Gilestone Farm, near Talybont-on-Usk in Powys. In March 2022, the government paid £4.25m for the freehold of the Farm, as part of a plan to secure the future of Greenman Festival held nearby. There has since been a £0.5 million drop in the asset's value. The Committee's report, published on Monday (28th July) highlights that the purchase was rushed due to end-of-year budget pressures, resulting in avoidable mistakes. To ensure lessons are learned, the Committee will want to carry out further work looking at the Welsh Government's approach to property investments, to assess whether current processes are sufficiently rigorous and fit for purpose. For help, email or call 0300 200 7219.
Leader Live
a day ago
- Leader Live
Working Wales service reaches 200,000th customer milestone
Working Wales, a free advice and guidance service funded by the Welsh Government, has now supported 200,000 people on their employment journeys. Among those who have benefited is 27-year-old James from Wrexham, who turned to the service after five years in the television industry left him at a career crossroads. James said: "I didn't really know what to do. "I didn't want to just get a job anywhere. "I wanted a career that I can work towards – something I can move up in and do something using my skills in a different way." After visiting the Careers Wales centre in Wrexham, James met adviser Laura, who helped him explore his options. James Veal (Image: Supplied) James said: "I was just completely honest with Laura when we met. "And she was really honest with me too. "It was refreshing. "We talked about different careers and ideas, and when I said there were certain jobs I definitely didn't want to do, she didn't question it – she just said, 'That's fine. "Let's talk about what you do want to do.'" During their conversation, Laura noticed James' involvement in a vintage machinery club, where he organised events and managed volunteers. James said: "Laura looked at that and said, 'You've got all these skills in events. "Have you ever thought about working in that?'" With her support, James began applying for roles in events and eventually secured a position as an events assistant at the Llangollen Railway Trust. He said: "Laura helped me see how to read a job application properly... what I need to include in my CV and how to write a cover letter. "Laura helped me to see my potential and boost my confidence. "I'd really recommend Careers Wales. "Especially if you're looking for a new opportunity or career change. "Come and have a chat – they're so friendly and they will help you." The 200,000th customer was Pauline Smith from Cardiff, who sought support after taking voluntary redundancy from her radio production job earlier this year. The 57-year-old was torn between continuing freelance work and pursuing her interest in yoga teaching. Encouraged by a friend, she explored the ReAct+ scheme and booked an appointment with careers adviser Gareth Richards at her local Working Wales centre. ReAct+ is a Welsh Government programme offering tailored advice and financial support for training, travel, and care costs. Pauline said: "It's much more about giving people confidence that they are okay. "It was just nice to talk through with somebody the fact that I've taken redundancy, and to look at where I was at and where I was going to go. "Everybody has something to offer when they walk through those doors – it's just finding out what that is and how confident they are in those." Pauline Smith (Image: Supplied) Nikki Lawrence, chief executive of Careers Wales, said: "Reaching our 200,000th customer is a major milestone for Working Wales and a clear reflection of the impact we're having on individuals and the wider Welsh economy. "James and Pauline's stories highlight how we help people at every stage of life to build their confidence, develop their skills, and find meaningful work." Working Wales, delivered by Careers Wales, offers personalised support to anyone aged 16 and over, whether they are just starting out, facing redundancy, or looking to retrain. The service is available online, by phone, and in-person across Wales.
South Wales Argus
2 days ago
- South Wales Argus
School closures ruled out by Monmouthshire County Council
A petition has claimed Kymin View Primary School, in Wyesham, Monmouth could be closed and the recently established Ysgol Gymraeg Trefynwy would move into its building. But Councillor Laura Wright, Monmouthshire County Council's cabinet member for education, has dismissed school closures as a solution to surplus places and denied any proposal to remove English medium education from Kymin View. The council has said it is having to address falling pupil numbers in Monmouth and Chepstow but has said: 'The county council wishes to clarify that there are no plans to close Kymin View or any other school within the county.' Labour's Cllr Wright said: 'Monmouthshire County Council, schools, parents and members of the community will need to work together to think about how we address surplus places in our schools. However, I have been very clear that school closures are not part of the solution. We are also not proposing to remove English medium education from Kymin View.' Her comments come after the council had issued a statement earlier in the week that described claims over the future of Kymin View as 'speculative' and said it has yet to make any 'firm' proposals on how to deal with surplus places. The statement from Cllr Wright was issued due to 'concern and anxiety in Monmouth prompted by rumours circulating online and in the local media'. Cllr Wright acknowledged the 'higher than average' number of vacant places in Monmouth primary schools needs to be addressed and said: 'As you would expect, there have been some very early stage conversations about the low pupil numbers in some of our schools and the challenge that this presents. Having those discussions is the right and responsible thing for us to do.' At the county council's July meeting it was stated by director of education, Will McLean, the Chepstow and Monmouth school clusters have 'significant numbers of surplus places' which he said was about 200 primary age pupils in both areas. Mr McLean also said it isn't anticipated new housing, including those expected from the council's ongoing local development plan, will produce a 'sufficient' number of youngsters to fill the empty places. He said the council wants to work with the four schools in Monmouth on solutions and said a meeting, with schools earlier in July, looked at what the 'likely solution could be for dealing with surplus places' as well as the long-term future of Ysgol Gymraeg Trefynwy which opened last September within Overmonnow Primary in Monmouth. He said any proposals will have to be made in line with Welsh Government regulations and said working through the options would likely be a 'challenging and complex period'. Mr McLean said reports on addressing surplus places in both Monmouth and Chepstow will likely be brought to the council's scrutiny committees, and the decision making cabinet, in the autumn term. Plans for the school building programme, to be submitted to the Welsh Government, will also be considered though Mr McLean cautioned: 'New schools cost an awful lot of money.'
