Chair Refuses To Apologise, Rejects Use Of ‘Kia Ora' In Council Email
Mataura catchment liaison committee chair Hugh Gardyne has also rejected the use of 'kia ora' in an email reprimanding him for his actions.
The committee Gardyne oversees is one of eight in the region that supports Environment Southland with local river work.
In May, Gardyne gave a blunt presentation to councillors, alleging catchment management was in "a state of paralysis" under the watch of the council chief executive and that communication was ineffective with the general manager in charge.
He was shut down at the end of his talk, when he mentioned an abatement notice later revealed to be one issued by Environment Southland against itself.
A letter from Environment Southland chair Nicol Horrell on 28 May warned Gardyne of his behaviour, saying parts of his presentation were factually incorrect and disrespectful.
"My intention is both to correct your understanding of the facts, and to inform you that councillors will not tolerate any criticism levelled at staff in public meetings or disrespectful behaviour," Horrell wrote.
He added it was incorrect to suggest catchment work was in a state of paralysis and accused Gardyne of not having all the facts.
"I would be interested to know from where you are getting your information."
The letter ended with a suggestion that Gardyne apologise to the chief executive and manager in question, but Gardyne has defended his actions, saying his criticism was about questioning professional ability.
"It doesn't, in my opinion, deserve a response or an apology."
Gardyne said he would speak at council again in the future and the response from the general manager had been "great", following the presentation.
Separately, he also took exception with the use of 'kia ora' in the email sent by Horrell, which delivered the reprimanding letter.
Gardyne requested he instead be addressed with 'hello' or 'dear'.
Horrell told Local Democracy Reporting using the te reo Māori greeting was commonplace and he didn't think its use would be Gardyne's biggest issue.
"I would have thought that that's almost a wee bit racist."
In a letter back to Horrell, Gardyne doubled down on perceived issues with river management and questioned whether the chair's concerns were shared by other members.
Environment Southland oversees eight catchment liaison committees, which help the council develop annual maintenance programmes and budgets, as well as provide a local point of contact.
Gardyne has been involved with the Mataura group since the early 1990s.
Last month, the council said it was working to improve communication with its catchment committees.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Spinoff
13 minutes ago
- The Spinoff
One MP, One Pint: Lessons for the left and Warren G karaoke with Tamatha Paul
In a new series of one-on-one pub chats with MPs, The Spinoff sits down with Green Party and Wellington Central MP Tamatha Paul, who's been taking notes on Zohran Mamdani's rise in New York and worrying about the capital's arts and culture reputation. It's Tamatha Paul's first time in parliament's new bar, Pint of Order, the exclusive drinking hole-in-the-wall set right in the middle of the building's ground floor lobby. Beers are $8, the decor is expectedly politically themed, space is tight and the country's most powerful can be found squashed together on leather seats, all at the cost of $7m to the taxpayer – but if a lowly Spinoff reporter on a modest salary can make it here, then it really can't be so upper-crust. We catch up in a dark corner, with a glass of Parrotdog pilsner in my hand and a coke in Paul's – she isn't much of a drinker although, sure, there were two beers had over the weekend at the Phoenix v Wrexham match. But living with lupus and rheumatoid arthritis means hangovers tend to be week-long, and when you're an MP, you 'can't afford' to have a few days off your A-game. And anyway, Paul reckons she doesn't 'need alcohol to be a vibe'. 'Starting politics when I was 21, I was just super aware that if I was caught partying, smoking, anything – that wouldn't reflect well,' Paul says, remembering the alcohol-related opportunities and events she turned down as a Wellington city councillor. 'Over time I kinda got to a place where I was like, 'oh, young Māori are looking up to me, and I don't want to be representing that'.' Recently, she travelled on her first international government delegation to the US ('I may have archived two Instagram posts about Donald Trump'), to speak with officials and get a sense of life under the second Trump administration. For Paul, the trip provided an opportunity to understand how Trump secured the working-class vote ('I think I've got half the story, they might need to send me on another trip') and watch up-close the rise of Zohran Mamdani (who won the Democratic New York mayoral primary just a few days after she left the city), which gave her some lessons to bring back to Aotearoa. The first being that intellectual elitism and intolerance is tearing the left apart: 'we are the first to shit on each other, and we don't even have to wait for the right to do that.' And secondly, that the 'supremacy' of university education has made polytechnics and trades training seem like the 'poorer cousins' in comparison. 'I think we need to emphasise training and giving people those skills to build the houses and venues we need, to do tech and production for the arts, to fill up our hospitals and rest homes,' she says. Which brings Paul's mind back closer to home, to Te Auaha, Whitireia and WelTec's creative campus in the middle of Wellington city which is facing closure. She reckons there's enough wealthy creatives in the city to be able to purchase the campus and bring it back to life – sure, it'll take 'a bit of political willpower', but it could also be essential to ensuring the city's creative reputation lives on. Paul says she sometimes feels 'like a fraud' when boasting about Wellington being the 'arts and culture capital'. Te Auaha's closure just adds to her lists of cons for creatives in the city, next to the lack of venues on offer and the 'really shitty quality of housing'. As for the pros, at least there's Newtown Festival and Cubadupa, and Paul hopes the organisers behind the latter event could take up the space left by Homegrown – at least for now, we can still claim to be the local festival capital. At 28 years old, Paul is looking forward to playing the long game in parliament. All things considered, she's already had a longer political career than many others who have come through the House, but there's still more than 50 years between herself and parliament's oldest minister. '[Politics is] easier to do when you're young and you don't have heaps of commitments, but you sacrifice being normal, which is hard,' Paul says. 'It completely whacks out your personal timeline for when you want to have kids, when you want to get married … Those are just scary concepts, because I barely have time for myself, but then I'm also getting older.' I tell her I couldn't do what she does, honestly. She tells me she wouldn't mind swapping places – cracking jokes can't be much harder than this. THE SPINOFF PUB Q+A How much should a pint cost? $5 — that's how much they were at the RSA that I worked at [during] high school. Do you have a karaoke go-to? Regulate by Warren G and Nate Dogg, but you need a partner to do it. I'm Warren G, and whoever's got the beautiful Nate Dogg harmonies can join my set up. Favourite place to get a drink in Aotearoa? My all-time favourite nostalgic spot would be Hunter Lounge balcony, but also Ascot for a winter night, and Rogue and Vagabond lawn for a little summer beer. Which three MPs would be on your pub quiz team? Gerry [Brownlee], he's got enormous historic and international knowledge and can cover off sports, and I'm leaning towards Winston Peters, because he's got good political and historic knowledge, but also pop culture knowledge. And I might put Lawrence [Xu-Nan] in there, because he's super smart. Which MP from across the aisle would you most like to share a drink with? Judith Collins, because she's the mother of the House, she's the longest serving woman MP in history, and I think she would have some really constructive advice for a young woman like myself in politics. Is there an alcohol-related law you would like to change? I would like a law change that means that alcohol stores can't be concentrated in deprived areas, and on a local level, I want Wellington City Council to have a local alcohol policy, because alcohol is the biggest driver of harm in our city. I'm not saying I want everyone to be sober – I'm just saying that access plays a big role. What's a policy area we've been nursing without finishing the glass? Fast fashion. What qualities make a good drinking partner? I love having yarns with old people. I think it's because I grew up listening to my granddad and his yarns, but I just love listening to what they have to say. They've lived some lives, you know. Have you ever had a Schnapp's election moment where you regretted your political instinct? Probably. Up next on One MP, One Pint: Labour MP Peeni Henare.
RNZ News
43 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Auckland homelessness spike: Who, or what, is to blame?
Outreach providers say there's been a 90 percent increase in homelessness in Auckland since September last year. Photo: RNZ / Luke McPake Auckland councillors are calling on the government to take action over the growing homelessness problem in the city. Outreach providers say there has been a 90 percent increase in homelessness in Auckland since September last year, after the government tightened up emergency housing eligibility rules . The council's Community Committee wants the government to work with frontline agencies and make sure they are using up-to-date data when dealing with the issue. "No one I know wants to see Kiwis living without shelter, and we're very concerned with the level of rough sleeping and people in cars, and in tents and other things, including in Auckland," Associate Minister for Housing Tama Potaka told Morning Report on Wednesday. Community Committee chair, Councillor Angela Dalton, told Checkpoint on Tuesday recent government policy changes had "made it harder for people to access emergency housing", as had declining people deemed to have contributed to their own lack of accommodation. "I think there's some policies that have been changed that show a lack of compassion because they are making assumptions that people are not trying hard enough." Potaka said there were "a lot of contributing factors and causes" behind the rise in homelessness. "There's a number of things that this government is doing, whether or not it's the build program, making sure we build another 500 social homes in Auckland, Māori housing, Kainga Ora, 1500 new homes with chips, resetting the housing system. You would have heard us talking about granny flats and enabling those… and I look forward to the council actually supporting those actions." Potaka said he had "directed officials to identify some potential target interventions and understand the utilisation rates across transitional housing first, and other support programmes, to make sure we're getting the right utilisation of programmes. "We're also liaising with a lot of those providers like Strive, Auckland City Mission… and a whole range of others in Auckland." He said there was "different data", and "a bit of ambiguity" around how a recent Salvation Army report came to the conclusion there had been a 386 percent rise in people denied help because they had contributed to their own homelessness . "It's very hard to attribute one particular cause… You can't attribute [the rise] just to a policy change. There's a range of causes, and one of the biggest ones, of course, is disconnection with families and with whanau - and that's one of the biggest contributors to people sleeping rough." Ministry of Social Development (MSD) said in June 36 percent of applications for emergency housing were declined, mostly often "because their need can be met in another way", according to group general manager enablement Karen Hocking. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Of those declined emergency housing because it was deemed they had contributed to their own homelessness, Potaka said two-thirds still got some form of assistance. "Overall, the vast majority of people, between 85 percent and 90 percent who apply for emergency housing, get some sort of support for emergency housing." He would not detail what actions could be considered as contributing to one's own homelessness. "There could be a range of circumstances. I'm not going to go into the various types of circumstances that can emerge, but sometimes people do that… "There's a responsibility framework that goes with emergency housing. People who have a genuine need for short-term temporary accommodation in most big towns and cities in New Zealand, there is support, but there is a responsibility framework that goes with it. "For example, you have to undertake some training when you're in emergency housing around budgeting and other things, or getting ready to rent. There's a whole bunch of programmes within the emergency housing framework that are in place to support people to transition out and get to a place which they can stay in a more enduring manner than emergency housing - a catastrophe we all know about." MSD's Hocking gave some examples, however. "We have some concerns that the data used by the National Homelessness Data Project does not adequately reflect the support we are providing New Zealanders," she added. Potaka said rather than just government, it was "actually a whole lot of society that's responsible" for solving the issue, including "councils, whanau, iwi Māori, charitable organisations". "We've got a huge build programme that's in place right now around community housing providers, and a range of others who are actually building homes that hopefully will be suitable for those that have got serious housing deprivation - whether or not that's on the street or people on the social housing waitlist, which, by the way, has come down about 5000 families since we got into administration." Opposition parties have blamed the rise on homelessness on the government's policies . Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Otago Daily Times
2 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Govt to repeal oil and gas ban
By Russell Palmer of RNZ The government is set to repeal the oil and gas ban this week, after a significant 11th-hour change handing discretionary powers to two ministers. A 25-page amendment was published at 5pm on Monday, leaving opposition MPs less than 23 hours to prepare for the debate. The change largely deals with the rules for decommissioning oil and gas fields, and who is responsible for paying for the clean-up. Taranaki's Tui oil field was abandoned in 2019 after its Malaysian owner Tamarind Taranaki went bust, costing taxpayers a total $293 million to clean up, with work concluding just last month. The government initially set aside up to $343.4m for the project. The Labour government in 2021 introduced a law to prevent the government being lumped with such costs again in future. Resources Minister Shane Jones has vowed to restart the oil and gas industry. He said the aim of the amendment was to close a loophole in that 2021 law. "It did not seem correct or moral that the Crown should be left with that liability and the people [at fault] - with some very shrewd manoeuvrings of script - would escape liability. We have solved that problem," he told the House. The changes replace the process of going through the list of previous permit-holders to figure out who pays for decommissioning, instead putting that decision in the hands of the Resources Minister and the Finance Minister. The amendment also removes several clauses from a previous amendment the minister made to the bill, which itself amends the Crown Minerals Act. Labour's Energy and Resources spokesperson Megan Woods led the 2021 law change in response to the Tui Oil Field debacle, and told the Parliament the changes showed the government capitulating to the industry's wishes. "They have bowed to the suggestions of the oil and gas companies and done what they wanted. They have further bowed to the interests of the oil and gas companies in taking eight months to sit with them, find out what they wanted and then bring a bill back to the House. This is not a government that is putting New Zealand first." Labour's Deborah Russell pointed out the Regulatory Impact Statement referred to consultation with affected stakeholders. "Those consulted preferred ministerial discretion to the current act and approach in the bill. In other words, these shadowy participants in the oil and gas industry - a dying industry - who we don't know who they are, much prefer to be able to lobby a minister." Jones was unapologetic about those he consulted with. "Why would you not engage with the stakeholders, the risk-takers, the providers of what precious little gas we have, ruined by the cancel culture." He was unapologetic about a lack of consultation with others, including iwi. "So in the future the engagement will happen. This highly technical matter was not the subject of consultation in a detailed way, it was dealt with with a great deal of confidentiality. And in terms of providing a Māori dimension, I interviewed myself." The amendment passed with the coalition parties in support, with the opposition parties opposed. The third reading, which would see the oil and gas ban repealed, is expected on Thursday. A gas company warned investors would be cautious about coming back to New Zealand without broad political consensus - and with the opposition parties currently staunchly opposed that consensus seems vanishingly unlikely. The government also has a $200m fund set aside in this year's Budget to allow the government to co-invest in new gas fields. It last month pulled out of the Beyond Oil and Gas Alliance, an international coalition for phasing out fossil fuels, in a move the local World Wildlife Fund called an "international embarrassment". That was despite the Climate Minister, Simon Watts, previously saying New Zealand would not need to exit the group.
