Woman dies of cancer at 23 despite 80% survival chance; her brothers are now blaming mom's anti-medicine theories for it
Kate Shemirani's daughter, Paloma, was diagnosed with non-Hodgkin lymphoma, a type of cancer. Despite doctors informing her that she had an 80 percent chance of survival with chemotherapy, Paloma refused treatment and instead opted for alternative therapies, reportedly under her mother's influence. She died in July 2024 at the age of 23. Also read | World Cancer Day 2025: Cancer spreads from person to person? Here are 4 most common myths and facts about the disease Kate Shemirani's daughter Paloma was diagnosed with cancer. Paloma's brothers blame their mother's anti-medicine conspiracy theories for her death. (Pic courtesy: Gofundme.com)
In a June 23 interview with BBC Panorama, Paloma's brothers, Gabriel and Sebastian Shemirani, blamed their mother Kate's anti-medicine conspiracy theories for her death. They said that Kate's influence led Paloma to reject chemotherapy and medical treatment. Kate Shemirani is a former nurse whose registration was cancelled reportedly due to promoting misinformation about Covid-19.
Kate styles herself as 'the Natural Nurse' on social media and has 'been known to spread conspiracy theories and once-fringe anti-medicine views to millions' – which her sons believe contributed to Paloma's decision to refuse cancer treatment. Paloma's elder brother Sebastian said: 'My sister has passed away as a direct consequence of my mum's actions and beliefs and I don't want anyone else to go through the same pain or loss that I have.' 'I wasn't able to stop my sister from dying'
The brothers alleged that their mother texted Paloma's boyfriend, Ander, saying, "TELL PALOMA NOT TO SIGN [OR] VERBALLY CONSENT TO CHEMO OR ANY TREATMENT". The brothers further said they hope they can help prevent other deaths like Paloma's, and they believe social media companies should take stronger action against medical misinformation.
'I wasn't able to stop my sister from dying. But it would mean the world to me if I could make it that she wasn't just another in a long line of people that die in this way,' Gabriel said.
According to her sons, Kate's anti-medicine views were accelerated in 2012, when she was diagnosed with breast cancer. Even though she had the tumour removed through surgery, she credited alternative therapies for her recovery and reportedly shared online how she used a programme including juices and coffee enemas to become 'cancer-free'. Kate Shemirani's response to son's claims
Kate has not directly responded to the allegations made against her by her sons in connection with Paloma's death, but has publicly blamed the NHS (National Health Service) for her daughter's death.
She and her ex-husband, Faramarz Shemirani, reportedly said they have evidence that Paloma died due to medical interventions without a confirmed diagnosis or lawful consent. However, the BBC reported it had seen no evidence to support these claims.
Paloma's death highlights that it's essential to rely on credible sources and consult with healthcare professionals for accurate information about cancer. To combat cancer, it is crucial to stop believing common myths. Click here to learn about the nine most prevalent misconceptions about the disease.
Note to readers: This article is for informational purposes only and not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your doctor with any questions about a medical condition.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
29 minutes ago
- Hans India
TGMC and Dental Council caught in a ‘surgical' war
Hyderabad: The Telangana Medical Council (TGMC) and the Telangana Dental Council (TDC) are at loggerheads over professional issues and the nature of their specialisations. The bone of contention is that dental surgeons and oral maxillofacial surgeons (MDS) are performing hair transplant and aesthetic surgeries. While the TGMC issued a notification stating that dental surgeons cannot perform hair transplant within a day, the TDC has asserted that they are qualified to do so. Responding to the notification issued by TGMC, the state dental council has come up with its version regarding the scope of practice of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons (OMFS). It states that these dental surgeons are qualified to perform facial aesthetic procedures and hair transplants. Members from the dental council cite the amendments made by the Dental Council of India (DCI) to the Master of Dental Surgery (MDS) Course Regulations (3rd Amendment). The amendments have been published in the Gazette of India on August 26, 2019, through Notification No. DE-87(3)-2019. According to DCI regulations, oral and maxillofacial surgeons are trained to perform a wide range of procedures, including minor oral surgeries; surgical management of soft tissue injuries, fractures, gunshot wounds, war injuries, and cancers in the head and neck region, craniofacial surgery, surgical correction of aesthetic defects in jaws and face, skin graft harvesting, bone graft harvesting from hip, ribs, skull and lower leg, among several such specialisations. They recalled that during the Covid-19 pandemic, maxillofacial surgeons played a crucial role in removing black fungus (Mucormycosis) infections, setting right neurological problems in the maxillofacial region and laser surgery for lesions and cryosurgery. The TDC has also mentioned that they were medically qualified to perform aesthetic facial surgery, including for facial skin, underlying facial muscles, bone, eyelids, external ear, acne scars, facelifts, blepharoplasty, otoplasty and facial bone recontouring. 'The Telangana Dental Council advises the public not to be misled by statements from any other organisations, councils or bodies regarding this matter, other than those from the Dental Council of India or the respective state dental councils,' it said in a clarification issued on TGMC has stuck to its guns while contending that dentists, dental surgeons, and oral and maxillofacial surgeons do not possess the required qualifications to perform aesthetic procedures and hair transplants. It maintained that they do not have these specialities as a core topic in their curriculum, indicating a lack of formal surgical knowledge and training to go about these procedures. Caught in this professional wrangle that smacks of a battle for one-upmanship are the people, who are unsure of which Council's contentions are right, medically speaking.
India Gazette
3 hours ago
- India Gazette
From space medicine to DNA Vaccines: Union Minister Jitendra Singh calls for synergized, inclusive healthcare model for Viksit Bharat 2047
New Delhi [India], June 29 (ANI): While delivering a thought-provoking keynote address at the Doctor's Day Conclave organized by the ET Times Now, Union Minister of State (Independent Charge) for Science & Technology Jitendra Singh, emphasized that India stands at the crossroads of a health-tech revolution and at the threshold of a grand new chapter, with its economy moving from the 10th to the 4th largest globally and the further ascent continuing. According to a release from the Ministry of Science and Technology, the Minister cited Indian astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla's mission to the International Space Station, carrying indigenous life science kits, as a milestone that may soon give birth to a new medical discipline: Space Medicine. Jitendra Singh called for a 'synergized, inclusive and futuristic healthcare ecosystem' in alignment with the vision of Viksit Bharat @2047. 'Very soon, we might have a dedicated stream in medical academics called Space Physicians. This is the future we must be ready for,' said Jitendra Singh. Addressing the theme of health and demographic change, the Minister spoke of India facing a 'bi-phasic challenge' -- a rising number of elderly citizens due to increased life expectancy, alongside a youthful population. He explained: 'While more than 70% of India is under 40, the elderly population is also growing rapidly. In 1947, the average life span was 50-55 years; today it is nearing 80,' the release added. Jitendra Singh noted the dual burden of disease, as India simultaneously tackles both communicable and non-communicable illnesses, particularly in the post-COVID era. To address this, he stressed mass screening, early detection, and prevention, calling for greater public-private partnerships and optimal use of technologies like AI, telemedicine, and machine learning, the release added. Highlighting India's recent global achievements, Jitendra Singh proudly stated that India has emerged as a global leader in preventive and precision healthcare. He noted that India developed the world's first DNA vaccine for COVID-19 and an HPV vaccine to help prevent cervical cancer. Further, India successfully conducted its first gene therapy trial for haemophilia, with the results published in the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine, the release added. The Minister also announced the launch of Nafithromycin, the country's first indigenously developed antibiotic molecule, marking a significant milestone in India's pharmaceutical innovation landscape. He attributed these successes to early-stage collaboration with private industry, stating 'These achievements were possible because of seamless integration of public and private sectors from the outset.' Touching upon the need for integrated institutions, Jitendra Singh revealed that IIT Kanpur and IISc Bengaluru are planning to establish medical schools within their campuses. He also lauded India's affordable healthcare models like Ayushman Bharat and institutions like Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute in Trivandrum, which integrates research, manufacturing, and clinical care, the release added. In the context of cancer care, Jitendra Singh emphasized India's move toward targeted radiation therapy and highlighted Tata Memorial Centre as a pioneer in 100% digital and cashless hospital systems. He also shed light on India's hygiene innovations during massive public gatherings like Kumbh Mela, where radiation-based faecal sludge treatment plants (FSTPs)ensured sanitation for over 40 crore pilgrims without health hazards. On climate-related health resilience, Jitendra Singh mentioned the recently launched Mission Mausam, focusing on early warning systems for health-related impacts of climate disasters. Concluding his address, Jitendra Singh underscored the need for a transformative approach to India's healthcare future. He called for wider synergy across sectors, emphasizing the importance of collaboration between academia, research institutions, industry, and government. He also advocated for early-stage integration of the private sector in both research and healthcare delivery to ensure sustainability and scalability. Furthermore, he urged institutional innovation, citing proposals by premier institutes like IIT Kanpur and IISc Bengaluru to establish medical schools within their campuses -- a step he believes will foster interdisciplinary excellence and create a new model of holistic education and healthcare, the release added. 'Let us not hand over everything to the technocrats. A bit of the doctor must remain. We must carry forward both the science and the soul of medicine,' he said. (ANI)
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
Four of 6 new Covid cases in state from city
Mumbai: Maharashtra recorded six Covid-19 cases on the new cases, four are from Mumbai and two from the limits of the Pune Municipal Corporation, an official statement said. The state's tally of the viral infections so far in this calendar year is now 2,488, the health department said. No death has been reported due to coronavirus in the state since Friday, it said. The health department said it has conducted 29,317 Covid-19 tests across the state since January 1, adding that 2,332 patients have recovered from the coronavirus infection till date. Meanwhile, Mumbai has reported 990 cases, including 549 in June, so far this year. A total of 37 patients have succumbed to the virus in the state since Jan 1. pti
