logo
HC Junks PIL Against Lloyds' Iron Ore Expansion In Gadchiroli, Flags Petitioner's Bona Fides

HC Junks PIL Against Lloyds' Iron Ore Expansion In Gadchiroli, Flags Petitioner's Bona Fides

Time of India20-06-2025
1
2
3
4
Nagpur: The Nagpur bench of Bombay High Court recently dismissed two clubbed public interest litigations (PILs) challenging the expansion of iron ore mining by Lloyds Metals and Energy Limited in Gadchiroli.
The court pointed out that the petition was filed by a person with no stakes in the matter, lacked locus standi and was acting without bona fides.
A division bench of Justices Nitin Sambre and Abhay Mantri rejected the pleas filed by Samarjeet Chatterjee, resident of Raipur, Chhattisgarh, and co-petitioner Vishesh Bhatpalliwar from Gadchiroli. The bench stated there was no substantive connection between the petitioners and affected population.
It also noted no local resident or tribal community had objected to the environmental clearance (EC) and questioned the motive and timing of the PIL.
"Merely claiming to be a social servant does not give the petitioner the locus standi to filed a PIL as he has not shown any nexus with the cause of such people, who live almost 300km away from his place of residence and that too in another state (Chhattisgarh)," the bench noted.
The judges added the fact that the petitioner did not question the earlier public hearing, conducted at the district headquarters in 2005-06, and is now questioning the subsequent public hearing, sufficiently demonstrates he lacks bona fides in the matter of preferring the PIL.
The HC also observed that it failed to understand the petitioner's source of funds for carrying out the legal battle, especially if he has an annual income of Rs4-5 lakh.
The court noted that the petitioner claimed he gave up his profession as a mine contractor and travelled all the way to Maharashtra from Raipur in Chhattisgarh, where he is based. Aheri, where the plant is located, is more than 200 km from his place, said the court.
Chatterjee, a former mining contractor, challenged the environmental clearances (EC) granted to Lloyds Metals in two stages — from 3 metric tonnes per annum (MTPA) to 10 MTPA (2023) and then to 16 MTPA (2024).
He alleged violations of EIA norms, improper public hearing, and non-compliance with environmental regulations. He sought to quash the terms of reference and clearances issued in 2022 and 2023 on grounds of procedural lapse under office memorandums dated April 2022 and July 2021 SOPs.
However, the court noted the public hearing at the Gadchiroli district headquarters on October 27, 2022, was legally valid, widely publicised, and attended by a large number of local representatives and citizens.
It also cited the Maoist threat in the mining zones for not conducting the hearing at the actual site.
The bench acknowledged that Lloyds earlier operated without a fresh environment clearance post-2011, but later complied fully with the 2021 standard operating procedure, paid a ₹5.48 crore penalty, furnished a ₹26.64 crore bank guarantee. The environment clearance for 10 MTPA was then granted on February 24, 2023, followed by the terms of reference for 16 MTPA on November 26, 2024.
Calling such PILs "a tool for personal vendetta" and not a genuine public interest action, the court invoked Supreme Court rulings to underscore the need to curb misuse of PILs.
Lloyds, through counsel Raghav Bhandakkar, argued it created 2,000 jobs and contributed ₹2,000 crore in royalties to the District Mineral Fund, and 80% project execution was already complete. Finding no merit in the plea, the court refused to interfere with the environmental approvals and dismissed both PILs.
**Key Takeaways from HC Verdict**
- Petitioner had no local standing or public interest.
- Lloyds Metals paid ₹5.48 crore penalty for prior EC lapse.
- Environmental clearance for 10 MTPA upheld as per SOP
- Public hearing held as per guidelines, no irregularity found.
- 2,000 jobs and ₹2,000 crore royalty cited as development impact.
- Relied on SC rulings to warn against "luxury litigation."
- No locals objected to project
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Farmers get Rs 49,330-cr fertiliser subsidy till July 21
Farmers get Rs 49,330-cr fertiliser subsidy till July 21

Hans India

time39 minutes ago

  • Hans India

Farmers get Rs 49,330-cr fertiliser subsidy till July 21

New Delhi: The Centre has provided fertilisers subsidy of Rs49,330 crore till July 21 of this fiscal to ensure farmers get key nutrients at a reasonable a written reply to Lok Sabha on Friday, Minister of State of Chemicals and FertilisersAnupriya Patel informed that the total fertilizer subsidy provided by the government stood at Rs49,329.88 crore till July 21 of 2025-26 fiscal. Out of this, Rs30,940.82 crore subsidy was towards domestic urea, while Rs4,006.70 crore for imported urea. In 2022-23, the Centre's fertiliser subsidy stood at Rs2,54,798.88 crore. The subsidy declined to Rs1,95,420.51 crore in 2023-24 and Rs1,77,129.50 crore in 2024-25. 'Under 'DBT in Fertilizers' system, 100 per cent subsidy on various fertilizer grades is released to the fertilizer companies, on actual sales to the beneficiaries based on Aadhar authentication through POS devices installed at each retail shop,' Patel said. All farmers (including small, medium and large farmers) are being supplied fertilisers at subsidized rates, she added.

SC cancels Rs 295 crore land payout order over bizman's fake claim
SC cancels Rs 295 crore land payout order over bizman's fake claim

Time of India

time5 hours ago

  • Time of India

SC cancels Rs 295 crore land payout order over bizman's fake claim

Noida: The Supreme Court has struck down a Rs 295-crore compensation award to Hyderabad-based businessman Reddy Veeranna, ruling that the payment was secured through fraudulent claims and a deliberate suppression of facts regarding land ownership in Noida. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now A three-judge bench of Justices Surya Kant, Dipankar Datta, and Ujjal Bhuyan set aside both the Allahabad high court's 2021 order and its own 2022 ruling that had granted enhanced compensation to Veeranna for land acquired in Sector 18. "The impugned order of the High Court dated October 28, 2021 passed in WP (Civil) 2272/2019 [Reddy Veeranna v State of Uttar Pradesh & ors] stands set aside, since fraud has vitiated the entire proceedings. As a corollary to the above, the judgment and order dated May 5, 2022 in Reddy Veerana (supra) (which too was obtained by playing fraud) is declared to be a nullity and stands recalled in exercise of our inherent powers," the court said in its order. The case revolves around over five bighas in Chhalera Banger village, jointly purchased in 1997 by Veeranna, Vishnu Vardhan, and T Sudhakar for Rs 1 crore. In 2005, Noida Authority partially acquired this land and later leased it to DLF for Rs 173 crore. The Mall of India now stands there. While the three co-owners initially contested the Authority's acquisition together, Veeranna subsequently began claiming exclusive ownership. He obtained a compromise decree from a trial court in 2006 — using a revoked power of attorney — which became the basis for recording his name as the sole owner in govt records. In 2019, Veeranna approached the high court, seeking enhanced compensation without making his co-owners party to the case. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The high court awarded him compensation at Rs 1.1 lakh per sqm. The Supreme Court not just upheld the HC order, but also removed a 50% development charge that had been deducted, raising Veeranna's total entitlement to around 360 crore. The payout eventually settled at 295 crore following discussions with the Authority. The apex court had, however, clarified then that it was not deciding on ownership. Vardhan, who claimed he was not informed about these proceedings, approached the SC in 2023, filing multiple petitions to challenge Veeranna's claim. He asserted that Veeranna had repeatedly misled the HC and SC, relying on an invalid decree procured through manipulation and concealment. In its judgment, the apex court found that Veeranna had consistently identified himself as a joint owner with Vishnu and Sudhakar in earlier proceedings, but abruptly changed his stance in 2019. The bench held that he had suppressed critical facts, including Vishnu's pending civil suit challenging the 2006 decree. "We have no hesitation to hold that Veeranna Reddy tailored a situation to suit his convenience by not impleading Vishnu as a party with the sole intention of obtaining an order in respect of not only the quantum of compensation payable for acquisition of the subject land but also a declaration as to his entitlement thereto — all, behind Vishnu's back. An attempt by Reddy to steal a march over Vishnu is clearly discernible which, without reference to anything more, does border on fraud," the court observed. The case has now been remanded in the high court for a fresh hearing of ownership and compensation with all parties present, including Vishnu and Sudhakar. While Veeranna has retained the compensation amount, he has furnished property securities worth Rs 295 crore through his firm Manyata-Pristine. It will remain deposited with the SC. Given the "magnitude of fraud", the SC has requested the high court chief justice to personally hear the case and conclude it preferably by the end of this year.

Friendship always first: PM resets India-Maldives ties with defence, trade push
Friendship always first: PM resets India-Maldives ties with defence, trade push

India Today

time8 hours ago

  • India Today

Friendship always first: PM resets India-Maldives ties with defence, trade push

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on his two-day visit to the Maldives reaffirmed the historic and strategic depth of the bilateral relationship. 'The roots of our relations are older than history, and as deep as the ocean,' Modi said during his two-day visit to Modi held wide-ranging talks with Maldivian President Mohamed Muizzu to strengthen cooperation in key sectors including trade, defence, and maritime security. 'For us, it is always friendship first,' the Prime Minister declared, calling India the 'most trusted' friend of the Indian Ocean meeting marked a turnaround in bilateral ties, which had witnessed tensions after Muizzu came to power in November 2023 following his 'India Out' campaign. Modi, however, asserted that the India-Maldives friendship will always 'remain bright and clear' regardless of circumstances. India on Friday announced a Rs4,850 crore (USD 565 million) line of credit to the Maldives. 'This amount will be used for projects related to the development of infrastructure in the Maldives, in accordance with the priorities of the people of the country', the PM Secretary Vikram Misri said the pact signed during the visit would reduce the Maldives' annual debt repayment to India by 40 per cent. While China's growing assertiveness was not directly mentioned, Misri said India continues to work with the Maldives on issues that may 'impinge not just our security but the common security of the region.'PM Modi confirmed that both sides will soon finalise a bilateral investment treaty and that negotiations for a free trade agreement have already the visit,PM Modi and Muizzu jointly inaugurated several India-backed projects, including a new defence ministry building in Male, roads and drainage systems in Addu city, and 3,300 housing units in Hulhumale. PM Modi also handed over 72 vehicles and equipment to the Maldives National Defence the new defence ministry complex as a 'concrete building of trust,' PM Modi said it stands as a symbol of the 'strong partnership' between the two nations. 'India will continue to support the Maldives in the development of its defence capabilities. Peace, stability and prosperity in the Indian Ocean region is our common goal,' he the Maldives' role in India's strategic outreach, PM Modi said, 'The Maldives holds an important place in both India's Neighbourhood First policy and its MAHASAGAR (Mutual and Holistic Advancement for Security and Growth Across Regions) vision.'PM Modi also spotlighted India's swift and consistent support to the Maldives during times of crisis. 'India is also proud to be the most trusted friend of the Maldives. Be it a disaster or a pandemic, India has always stood by as a 'first responder',' he welcomed the progress made under the economic and maritime security vision unveiled during Muizzu's visit to New Delhi in October last year. 'Now it is becoming a reality. And as a result of that, our relations are touching new heights,' PM Prime Minister also noted the growing success of India's UPI (Unified Payments Interface) system in the Maldives. 'The speed with which UPI is being promoted in the Maldives will give a boost to both tourism and retail,' he Modi arrived in Male from London in the second and final leg of his two-nation tour. He received a warm welcome at Velena International Airport, with President Muizzu and top Maldivian ministers personally receiving him. Later, he was accorded a ceremonial welcome and a guard of honour at the Republic Square.- EndsMust Watch

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store