
HC Junks PIL Against Lloyds' Iron Ore Expansion In Gadchiroli, Flags Petitioner's Bona Fides
2
3
4
Nagpur: The Nagpur bench of Bombay High Court recently dismissed two clubbed public interest litigations (PILs) challenging the expansion of iron ore mining by Lloyds Metals and Energy Limited in Gadchiroli.
The court pointed out that the petition was filed by a person with no stakes in the matter, lacked locus standi and was acting without bona fides.
A division bench of Justices Nitin Sambre and Abhay Mantri rejected the pleas filed by Samarjeet Chatterjee, resident of Raipur, Chhattisgarh, and co-petitioner Vishesh Bhatpalliwar from Gadchiroli. The bench stated there was no substantive connection between the petitioners and affected population.
It also noted no local resident or tribal community had objected to the environmental clearance (EC) and questioned the motive and timing of the PIL.
"Merely claiming to be a social servant does not give the petitioner the locus standi to filed a PIL as he has not shown any nexus with the cause of such people, who live almost 300km away from his place of residence and that too in another state (Chhattisgarh)," the bench noted.
The judges added the fact that the petitioner did not question the earlier public hearing, conducted at the district headquarters in 2005-06, and is now questioning the subsequent public hearing, sufficiently demonstrates he lacks bona fides in the matter of preferring the PIL.
The HC also observed that it failed to understand the petitioner's source of funds for carrying out the legal battle, especially if he has an annual income of Rs4-5 lakh.
The court noted that the petitioner claimed he gave up his profession as a mine contractor and travelled all the way to Maharashtra from Raipur in Chhattisgarh, where he is based. Aheri, where the plant is located, is more than 200 km from his place, said the court.
Chatterjee, a former mining contractor, challenged the environmental clearances (EC) granted to Lloyds Metals in two stages — from 3 metric tonnes per annum (MTPA) to 10 MTPA (2023) and then to 16 MTPA (2024).
He alleged violations of EIA norms, improper public hearing, and non-compliance with environmental regulations. He sought to quash the terms of reference and clearances issued in 2022 and 2023 on grounds of procedural lapse under office memorandums dated April 2022 and July 2021 SOPs.
However, the court noted the public hearing at the Gadchiroli district headquarters on October 27, 2022, was legally valid, widely publicised, and attended by a large number of local representatives and citizens.
It also cited the Maoist threat in the mining zones for not conducting the hearing at the actual site.
The bench acknowledged that Lloyds earlier operated without a fresh environment clearance post-2011, but later complied fully with the 2021 standard operating procedure, paid a ₹5.48 crore penalty, furnished a ₹26.64 crore bank guarantee. The environment clearance for 10 MTPA was then granted on February 24, 2023, followed by the terms of reference for 16 MTPA on November 26, 2024.
Calling such PILs "a tool for personal vendetta" and not a genuine public interest action, the court invoked Supreme Court rulings to underscore the need to curb misuse of PILs.
Lloyds, through counsel Raghav Bhandakkar, argued it created 2,000 jobs and contributed ₹2,000 crore in royalties to the District Mineral Fund, and 80% project execution was already complete. Finding no merit in the plea, the court refused to interfere with the environmental approvals and dismissed both PILs.
**Key Takeaways from HC Verdict**
- Petitioner had no local standing or public interest.
- Lloyds Metals paid ₹5.48 crore penalty for prior EC lapse.
- Environmental clearance for 10 MTPA upheld as per SOP
- Public hearing held as per guidelines, no irregularity found.
- 2,000 jobs and ₹2,000 crore royalty cited as development impact.
- Relied on SC rulings to warn against "luxury litigation."
- No locals objected to project
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
HC lifts stay, MIAL can pick Turkiye co arm's replacement
Mumbai: In a relief for Mumbai International Airport Limited (MIAL), Bombay HC on Wednesday lifted its interim stay on finalising tenders to replace an Indian subsidiary of Celebi, a Turkiye-based airport ground handling services major. Citing national security concerns, Bureau of Civil Aviation Safety (BCAS) had in May revoked Celebi's clearance amid backlash over Turkiye's support for Pakistan during hostilities. The firm moved HC seeking suspension and annulment of the security clearance's cancellation. A similar plea was moved in Delhi HC, which ruled against the firm. In May, HC restrained Adani-led MIAL from making a final decision on bids invited that month to replace Celebi's Indian arm for ground and bridge handling services. The relief continued till Wednesday. The lifting of the stay has paved the way for MIAL to proceed with finalising new ground service handlers. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai After hearing senior counsel Vikram Nankani for MIAL and Chetan Kapadia for Celebi, HC observed that with Delhi HC upholding the revocation, preventing MIAL from finalising Celebi's replacement would no longer be tenable. The firm worked for nearly a decade and said its equipment was on the ground. Justice Somasekhar Sundaresan dismissed Celebi's arbitration plea and said claims, if any, can be pursued separately. The firm filed two petitions for two contracts to also challenge the consequential termination. The revocation order meant airlines that had given ground handling contracts to Celebi would face flight delays. Ground handling companies carry out security-sensitive jobs like loading and unloading of bags, cargo, cleaning aircraft, fuelling and passenger check-in. Govt worked with airport operators and appointed ground handling companies on an interim basis. At Mumbai airport, for instance, Indo Thai Airport Services—a certified ground handler operating at nine airports across India —was appointed within 24 hours of the BCAS order.


Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Global outreach for investment: Govt to hold roadshows in run-up to UP GIS, GBC-5
The Yogi Adityanath government has undertaken a new outreach drive to attract fresh investments, and a comprehensive strategy, including national and international roadshows, has been worked out to boost investor engagement ahead of the Uttar Pradesh Global Investors Summit (UP GIS) scheduled for February 2026, according to an official release. The Yogi Adityanath government is set to organise the fifth Groundbreaking Ceremony (GBC-5) in November 2025. (File Photo) The state government is also set to organise the fifth Groundbreaking Ceremony (GBC-5) in November 2025, with an initial investment target of over ₹5 lakh crore. This target may be increased to ₹10 lakh crore as the event approaches. The initiative to hold another GIS comes following the success of Uttar Pradesh Global Investors Summit-2023 that attracted investment proposals worth over ₹35 lakh crore, the release said. As part of this initiative, international roadshows will be held in Singapore, Japan, South Korea, the UAE, Qatar and Canada during September-October this year, aligning with the China+1 strategy. To ensure strong domestic participation, roadshows will also be organised across major Indian cities from December 2025 to early January 2026. The U.P. government has implemented 16,478 projects worth ₹12.10 lakh crore through previous GBCs. Of these, 8,363 projects worth ₹4.33 lakh crore have already commenced commercial operations, while another 8,115 projects worth ₹7.76 lakh crore are nearing operational rollout. Invest UP has identified emerging areas under the new outreach policy, officials said. The state government has notified Global Capability Centre (GCC) Policy, while Footwear and Leather Products Policy will be notified soon. Additionally, drafts of the Sustainable Aviation Fuel and Private Investment Promotion policies have been prepared. These policies will include provisions such as the Quick Investment Promotion Scheme, exemption limit for expansion/diversification and conversion of MSMEs to large enterprises, officials said. The outreach plan aims to make U.P. a global investment destination through direct dialogue with investors, promotion of new policies, and active participation in international and national forums. To ensure the success of the new outreach plan, the government is holding an hour-long investor roundtable meeting every 15 days. Various meetings are also held every week to update the strategy based on investor feedback and generate new leads in collaboration with the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA), the release said.


News18
4 hours ago
- News18
Important cases heard by Delhi High Court on July 23
Agency: PTI Last Updated: Important cases heard by the Delhi High Court on Wednesday, July 23: * NewsClick case: Delhi HC grants pre-arrest bail to Prabir Purkayastha. * Create awareness about one-stop centres among people: Delhi HC tells govt. * HC asks ED to respond to Aslam Wani's plea to quash money laundering case. * Delhi HC seeks govt's response on plea against 'unauthorised construction'. * HC awards Rs 5 lakh costs to Veerji Malai Chaap restaurant in trademark infringement suit. PTI UK SKV UK MNK MNK Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.