
HC Junks PIL Against Lloyds' Iron Ore Expansion In Gadchiroli, Flags Petitioner's Bona Fides
2
3
4
Nagpur: The Nagpur bench of Bombay High Court recently dismissed two clubbed public interest litigations (PILs) challenging the expansion of iron ore mining by Lloyds Metals and Energy Limited in Gadchiroli.
The court pointed out that the petition was filed by a person with no stakes in the matter, lacked locus standi and was acting without bona fides.
A division bench of Justices Nitin Sambre and Abhay Mantri rejected the pleas filed by Samarjeet Chatterjee, resident of Raipur, Chhattisgarh, and co-petitioner Vishesh Bhatpalliwar from Gadchiroli. The bench stated there was no substantive connection between the petitioners and affected population.
It also noted no local resident or tribal community had objected to the environmental clearance (EC) and questioned the motive and timing of the PIL.
"Merely claiming to be a social servant does not give the petitioner the locus standi to filed a PIL as he has not shown any nexus with the cause of such people, who live almost 300km away from his place of residence and that too in another state (Chhattisgarh)," the bench noted.
The judges added the fact that the petitioner did not question the earlier public hearing, conducted at the district headquarters in 2005-06, and is now questioning the subsequent public hearing, sufficiently demonstrates he lacks bona fides in the matter of preferring the PIL.
The HC also observed that it failed to understand the petitioner's source of funds for carrying out the legal battle, especially if he has an annual income of Rs4-5 lakh.
The court noted that the petitioner claimed he gave up his profession as a mine contractor and travelled all the way to Maharashtra from Raipur in Chhattisgarh, where he is based. Aheri, where the plant is located, is more than 200 km from his place, said the court.
Chatterjee, a former mining contractor, challenged the environmental clearances (EC) granted to Lloyds Metals in two stages — from 3 metric tonnes per annum (MTPA) to 10 MTPA (2023) and then to 16 MTPA (2024).
He alleged violations of EIA norms, improper public hearing, and non-compliance with environmental regulations. He sought to quash the terms of reference and clearances issued in 2022 and 2023 on grounds of procedural lapse under office memorandums dated April 2022 and July 2021 SOPs.
However, the court noted the public hearing at the Gadchiroli district headquarters on October 27, 2022, was legally valid, widely publicised, and attended by a large number of local representatives and citizens.
It also cited the Maoist threat in the mining zones for not conducting the hearing at the actual site.
The bench acknowledged that Lloyds earlier operated without a fresh environment clearance post-2011, but later complied fully with the 2021 standard operating procedure, paid a ₹5.48 crore penalty, furnished a ₹26.64 crore bank guarantee. The environment clearance for 10 MTPA was then granted on February 24, 2023, followed by the terms of reference for 16 MTPA on November 26, 2024.
Calling such PILs "a tool for personal vendetta" and not a genuine public interest action, the court invoked Supreme Court rulings to underscore the need to curb misuse of PILs.
Lloyds, through counsel Raghav Bhandakkar, argued it created 2,000 jobs and contributed ₹2,000 crore in royalties to the District Mineral Fund, and 80% project execution was already complete. Finding no merit in the plea, the court refused to interfere with the environmental approvals and dismissed both PILs.
**Key Takeaways from HC Verdict**
- Petitioner had no local standing or public interest.
- Lloyds Metals paid ₹5.48 crore penalty for prior EC lapse.
- Environmental clearance for 10 MTPA upheld as per SOP
- Public hearing held as per guidelines, no irregularity found.
- 2,000 jobs and ₹2,000 crore royalty cited as development impact.
- Relied on SC rulings to warn against "luxury litigation."
- No locals objected to project
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Online shopping scam: Kerala HC directs transfer of provisionally attached amount to interest-bearing treasury deposit
Kochi: High court has directed the competent authority under the BUDS Act to ensure that the provisionally attached amount, exceeding Rs 200 crore and lying in various bank accounts in connection with the scam-hit High Rich Online Shopee case, is transferred to an interest-bearing treasury deposit within two weeks. The bench of Justice P Gopinath issued the order on Monday in a petition filed by High Rich Online Shoppe Pvt Ltd and its directors, K D Dasan and his wife K S Sreena, challenging the actions taken under the Banning of Unregulated Deposit Schemes Act, 2019 (BUDS Act). The directive was issued after considering the fact that the amounts on deposit admittedly exceed Rs 200 crore, and that it would be in the interest of the depositors for the funds to earn interest rather than remain idle in current accounts across various banks. HC further directed that the details of the treasury deposit, including the applicable rate of interest, be duly intimated to it by the competent authority immediately after the transfer and deposit of the amount. Accordingly, the matter was adjourned to Aug 13. Previously, a crime had been registered at the Cherpu police station in Thrissur under the BUDS Act against the petitioners, based on a private complaint in a financial fraud case. The complainant alleged that High Rich was engaged in multi-level marketing, thereby conducting a money chain business. Similar cases were also registered against the petitioners at the Ernakulam, Sulthan Bathery and Kannur police stations. In 2023, the additional chief secretary (home), acting as the competent authority under the Act, provisionally attached the assets.


Time of India
12 hours ago
- Time of India
Bombay HC dismisses review plea and allows Motilal Nagar Redevelopment in Goregaon West
MUMBAI: Bombay high court on Friday dismissed a review plea and paved the way for the redevelopment of 141 acres of MHADA land in Goregaon West, called Motilal Nagar. MHADA recently appointed Adani Realty as the consultant and Development Agency (CDA) for the project. It is touted as the city's largest housing project. Motilal Nagar Vikas Samiti, a residents' group, filed the review petition seeking recall and quashing of the HC ruling dated March 6, 2025, by Chief Justice Alok Aradhe and Justice Bharati Dangre. The residents sought, as interim relief, a stay on MHADA and the developer awarded the contract from going ahead. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai By its March judgment, the HC allowed MHADA's 2021 application to ensure redevelopment gets done via private developers' bids and disposed of public interest litigation filed in 2013 seeking action against rampant illegal construction on the land. The society's three main contentions were that firstly, as a society, they can and ought to be allowed to self-develop the premises under the govt policy. Secondly, the society of residents can, under rule 33 (5) (2) of the Development Control and Promotion Regulations (DCPR), appoint a developer of their choice. Thirdly, any development undertaken by such society, with MHADA NOC, by appointing a developer, requires 51 percent consent of the members. The housing authority, through its senior counsel, said no new points were being raised and that the HC, after considering all aspects, recognised MHADA's rights under the law as the owner of the property to redevelop the premises through private developments by inviting bids. The counsel also contended that the society, in an affidavit, earlier said it wanted MHADA to do the development itself. Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority (MHADA) said it floated bids and appointed Adani Realty as the CDA. The review plea before the same division bench challenged the appointment of the developer. The HC said a reasoned order will be made available later. By Friday's development in court, Motilal Nagar I, II, III redevelopment projects can proceed, said a MHADA lawyer. In 2018, MHADA said the estimated project cost was Rs 21,000 crore. The developer will bear all costs, including costs for transit and rehabilitation of eligible tenements, shops, slum dwellers, and other amenities. In 2013, Manjula Veeran and Tekchand Khanchandani filed two PILs before the HC seeking directions to MHADA and Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to demolish the 'rampant unauthorised horizontal and vertical constructions'' at Motilal Nagar I, II, and III, Goregaon West, MHADA Colony, Mumbai. The colony originally housed 400 tenants, mostly row houses. In 2013, HC directed MHADA as the landowner to carry out a survey based on which to decide on the course of action. MHADA found over 3,600 unauthorised constructions, which it then sought to include in the redevelopment plan. The HC in March 2025 accepted the housing authority's stand to ensure rehabilitation through a bidding process. What MHADA envisages in its plan for Motilal Nagar Rehabilitation for both existing and commercial users. Building markets, shopping centres, offices, houses and workplaces, mixed-use buildings, cultural centres, clubs, public halls, recreational centres, schools, community centres, shelters for women and children, shelters for the old, healthcare and medical centres, hostels, and residential buildings for sale. In December 2021, TOI reported that only three construction firms, Adani, L&T, and Naman Developers , submitted bids to redevelop Motilal Nagar, touted as the city's largest housing project.


Hans India
13 hours ago
- Hans India
Gitam honours over 1,500 students
Visakhapatnam: Honouringover 1,500 students, who secured placements in leading multinational companies (MNCs) and admissions in prestigious universities abroad, GITAM Deemed to be University celebrated 'Achievers Day' as a prelude to the 16th graduation ceremony scheduled on July 26 (Saturday). Students, drawn from diverse disciplines including engineering, pharmacy, science, architecture, law, management, and humanities, celebrated their transition from learners to professionals. GITAM career guidance center director Vamsi Krishna Somayajula highlighted the remarkable placement achievements for the academic year 2024–25. He informed that several corporate giants visited the campus for mass hiring drives and students secured the highest package of Rs.34 LPA and average package of Rs.5 LPA, while a few others bagged international employment-linked opportunities with Porsche,' he shared. AT&T India HR director Lt. Col. Pragathi Kumar Achanta, who attended as chief guest, motivated the young achievers to embrace lifelong learning. The institution's Vice-Chancellor Prof. Errol D'Souza congratulated the students and encouraged them to engage in regular self-assessment. Parents and students actively participated in the event, sharing emotional anecdotes and celebrating their collective journey.