Julianne Nicholson Was ‘Paradise' Creator Dan Fogelman's Only Choice for His ‘Complicated' Villain
Ahead, 'Paradise' creator Dan Fogelman explains why Julianne Nicholson, this season's IndieWire Honors Performance Award winner, was so worth the wait (and the white lies) it took to get her 'transcendent' work in the series.
More from IndieWire
Natasha Lyonne: The Maverick Behind the Madness
'Stick' Review: Owen Wilson's Golf Comedy Takes Too Many Shortcuts Trying to Be 'Ted Lasso'
It's summer of 2024. We are shooting Episode 2 of my new [Hulu] series, 'Paradise.' While a lot of my mental energy has been devoted to the pilot, I'm equally focused on the second episode… an episode that expands our world and tells the backstory of our complicated 'villain' — Samantha Redmond, AKA Sinatra.
I have come to set today — a rarity for me. Because today Julianne Nicholson is doing her big therapy scene — a monologue where she processes the loss of a child and her failed attempts to move forward — and I want to see it live. There are some things you just need to see in person.
Julianne begins her monologue. The directors — knowing what's about to happen before it happens — have chosen to start on her and shoot the scene in one shot. No editing. Just let her go. And, so, the scene begins.
I am standing in the back room, watching on the rear monitors. Julianne launches in. It is transcendent. And to no one, or maybe everyone, I simply say, 'Oh, my God.'
And with that, as I'm inclined to do in many of my screenplays, I FLASHBACK.
It's a year earlier now. I've been an admirer of Julianne's from a distance for years, and I've been obsessed with the idea of her as Sinatra from go. We've Zoomed, connected, and agreed to take this journey together. I'm so excited. And then I get a phone call… there's been a hiccup. Julianne has been filming another project, a project that still has time left to go, and their dates conflict with ours. They conflict in a way that makes shooting with her impossible.
'Dan,' I'm told, 'You're going to have to move on and cast someone else.'
A decade of running TV shows has taught me to roll with the punches. A location falls apart, you change the location. An actor can't get their head around a speech, you change the words. But having Julianne in my show — in this part — and then losing her? I can't roll with that.
There's a multiple week overlap between projects. I would have to push our project multiple weeks to accommodate Julianne's schedule. At a very late date. It would cost the show, and the studio that employs me, a LOT of money. I worry I'll never be able to convince anyone to push, not for one actor in an ensemble, no matter how great they are. And so…
I lie. I tell everyone I need more time to prep the show (which I kind of do), and that we are rushing into production before we were ready (also a partial truth). But the real truth: we could shoot now. Just not with Julianne.
And I don't want to shoot without Julianne.
BACK TO PRESENT
Julianne only needs two takes at the monologue. We will wind up using her first take in the show. It is one of the most extraordinary single pieces of acting I've ever witnessed — a broken woman, a mother who has lost a child, grasping at anything she can hold on to as she tries to survive for her remaining child. It's so raw, and so real… one of those performances where the lines blur between reality and art. You can hear a pin drop on stage. Everyone knows they are witnessing 'special.'
I have a five-year-old. We're entering the 'not good to lie' portion of his development. But the white lie I told that allowed Julianne to play Sinatra is one of those few lies I'll be proud of for the rest of my life. She's a woman at the very top of her craft, who is kind and generous to boot.
Working with Julianne Nicholson is, indeed, Paradise.
Best of IndieWire
The Best Thrillers Streaming on Netflix in June, from 'Vertigo' and 'Rear Window' to 'Emily the Criminal'
All 12 Wes Anderson Movies, Ranked, from 'Bottle Rocket' to 'The Phoenician Scheme'
Nightmare Film Shoots: The 38 Most Grueling Films Ever Made, from 'Deliverance' to 'The Wages of Fear'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
30 minutes ago
- Forbes
Here's When ‘King Of The Hill' And ‘Beavis And Butt-Head' Return And Where To Watch
Beavis and Butt-Head Everything old is new again. Nowhere is this more true than the world of animation. Mike Judge has two animated series returning after many years: King Of The Hill returns after fifteen years – 'Return of the dang ol' king,' as Boomhauer says in the trailer, with Hank and Peggy Hill and friends reuniting in a much-changed Arlen, TX. The new season makes its way to Hulu with ten new episodes on August 4th. It features Hank Hill's return to Arlen after taking a propane (and propane accessories) job in Saudi Arabia. The world they return to has changed in startling ways, including fruity beer and 'all-gender bathrooms' and Uber drivers desperate for 5-star reviews. One month later, Judge's other famous animated series Beavis and Butt-Head lands on Comedy Central for the third season of its revival series (the first two can be streamed on Paramount+). A trailer for the new season, which features our titular characters in various stages of life and health, was released Thursday morning: I was more of a King Of The Hill guy than a Beavis and Butt-Head guy – other kids ruined it by doing their annoying voices all the time at school – but both these trailers made me chuckle. 'One gold bar will do!' You kind of got what you asked for, Metallica. Beavis and Butt-Head lands on Comedy Central on September 3rd. Creator Mike Judge will reprise his roles in both series, as Hank Hill, Beavis, Butt-Head and many of the other characters.
Forbes
3 hours ago
- Forbes
Netflix Is Deleting ‘Happy Gilmore' A Week After ‘Happy Gilmore 2' Releases
Happy Gilmore 2 If you want an example of streaming licensing weirdness, look no further than what's about to happen on Netflix. The service has made a big deal about managing to make a sequel to Happy Gilmore nearly 30 years after the release of the Adam Sandler classic. But Netflix is removing the original movie just a week after it airs. Happy Gilmore 2 is out this Friday, July 25. Happy Gilmore 1, which has climbed to #3 on Netflix ahead of the sequel's release, is being removed from Netflix, along with a wider slate of movies, on August 1. Yes, movies and shows come and go, but this is an especially bizarre example, where if you want a Happy Gilmore refresher and don't want to hop streaming services, you have a week to do so. Happy Gilmore will still be airing on Hulu or Peacock, but not Netflix, going forward. It certainly seems like Netflix should have tried to get this sequel out much sooner, but production may have been pushed to its limit to get it out by now, I suppose. Still, rather poor planning on their end. Happy Gilmore 2 is bringing back other core cast members besides Sandler like Julie Bowen, Ben Stiller and Christopher McDonald. As its most prominent new cast member, it has the red-hot Margaret Qualley, fresh off her high-profile turn in The Substance. Unfortunately, a larger role was written for Carl Weathers, Sandler's mentor in the first film, before he passed away in February 2024. As for what exactly is going on in this 30-years-later sequel, here's the synopsis: Happy Gilmore is one of those classic comedies that critics deemed just okay at the time (a 63% score) and fans loved (an 85% score with 250,000 reviews in on Rotten Tomatoes). It's widely regarded as one of Sandler's best, and it's certainly surprising to see him return to the role after he's branched into much different films like Uncut Gems. He's found success on Netflix before with Murder Mystery 1 and 2 opposite Jennifer Aniston, widely watched comedies. So, hurry up and watch Happy Gilmore if you perhaps have not done so in the last 29 years. You have a week, or really, you have a day if you want to watch it before the actual premiere of the movie tomorrow. Follow me on Twitter, YouTube, Bluesky and Instagram. Pick up my sci-fi novels the Herokiller series and The Earthborn Trilogy
Chicago Tribune
5 hours ago
- Chicago Tribune
‘Washington Black' review: Escaping enslavement becomes a rip-roaring adventure
What does 'somewhere safe' mean when a bounty hunter is on your trail? In the Hulu adventure series 'Washington Black,' that location has been Halifax, Nova Scotia — at least temporarily — for the title character who, as a boy, escaped enslavement on a sugar plantation in early 19th century Barbados. Now a young adult (Ernest Kingsley Jr.), he goes by Jack Crawford to evade detection. Wash, as he was known in a former life, has been living for an indeterminate period of time as a free man in Halifax among other free Black people, including the warmly protective Medwin (Sterling K. Brown, also a producer here), who affectionately calls Wash 'island boy' and says things like 'Are we dreamin' or are we drinkin'?' before clinking glasses, and then: 'If the white folks don't kill ya, this'll definitely do the job,' he says of whatever they're swilling. He is also not afraid to get his hands dirty. This is good news for Wash, since that aforementioned bounty hunter means business. An accomplished artist and scientist who dreams of building a flying machine, Wash's interests and prodigious talents are conspicuous enough that his attempts to disappear haven't fully succeeded, forcing him into hiding. There's also the beautiful young blonde woman Wash spotted days earlier at the docks. As she disembarked from a ship, he stared, both enraptured but also clocking that she's biracial, something the white population of Halifax has failed to grasp. That's how her (white) father wants it, but she has no intention of living a lie or denying the memory of her deceased mother. Her insistence is why they left London to start over in Halifax, as her father keeps reminding her: 'You are a child of England, a child of empire, and that is the skin you must inhabit for us both.' The tenuousness of her and Wash's circumstances complicates the sweetness of their tentative romance. They have both been living double lives and have a unique understanding of one another as a result. That's the 1837 narrative. The other begins eight years earlier in Barbados, and it is Wash's origin story told in flashback. A repellent plantation owner rides out to the sugarcane fields to ward off any thoughts of suicide as a means of escape from their living nightmare: 'Killing yourself is a crime against me as surely as if you stole my horse and slit his throat.' This cruel man has a brother, whose arrival changes the course of Wash's life. A high-spirited inventor and abolitionist named Titch (Tom Ellis), he recognizes the child's curiosity and talent and takes the preteen (played by Eddie Karanja) under his wing. Soon enough, the pair are fleeing the sugarcane fields and Titch's nasty family dysfunction in a blimp-shaped 'cloutcutter' of the man's own devising. They don't get far before crashing into the masts of a pirate ship, and so Wash's journey — a grand, Jules Verne-esque tale both thrilling and fought with danger — begins. Based on the 2018 novel of the same name by Esi Edugyan, the eight-episode series is adapted by show creator Selwyn Seyfu Hinds and has a throwback quality to it, with a sweeping orchestral score that sets the tone. Wash's story can be deeply harrowing in parts (Nat Turner, played by Jamie Hector, makes a brief appearance and he is deadly serious about how precarious everyone's safety is), but it is also filled with dreamy and audacious escapades that see Wash deep sea diving and becoming mesmerized by the vast unknowableness of ocean life under the water. Is a novel, which engages the imagination differently than a screen adaptation, better equipped to toggle between these competing tones? Perhaps. More pressing, for me, was the question of who Wash is, in terms of his personality. As written and performed, we don't get much sense of what his own particular internal monologue might be, and this becomes underscored in any scene he shares with Brown's Medwin, who is such a clearly defined presence by comparison. Brown's an actor working on a different level than most, and he's very effective in his few appearances. I wish the show had outlined a bit more about the lives of Black people in Fairfax. They are free but vulnerable, and that nuance comes through most clearly when Medwin walks into a watering hole patronized by white men. The place goes quiet and he takes a seat at the bar. The man next to him says, 'I wouldn't expect your kind to be welcome in a place like this,' to which Medwin replies evenly: 'No, not usually. But most of the boys in here still need me and mine to make life easier for 'em down on the docks, so' — he takes a short but meaningful pause — 'we agree to disagree.' 'Washington Black' — 2.5 stars (out of 4) Where to watch: Hulu
