Was the Antikythera Mechanism just a janky toy? New study of its triangular teeth offers a clue.
The mysterious Antikythera Mechanism may not have been a cryptic celestial measuring device, but just a toy prone to constant jamming. And the secret to its true purpose, according to new research, is its triangle-shaped teeth.
Discovered in a shipwreck in 1901, the Antikythera Mechanism has remained an enigma for more than a century. Several years ago, CT scans suggested that the 2,000-year-old device was an astronomical tool.
Consisting of a hand crank, many interlocking gears and various indicators, the Mechanism could seemingly perform many tasks. These include giving the date according to the Egyptian and Greek calendars, displaying the positions of the sun, moon and planets within the zodiac, and predicting future lunar and solar eclipses.
But was celestial measurement really the purpose of this fascinating device? Was it meant to be a powerful computer, or a simple toy? And was it a one-off, made for a wealthy patron, or just one example of a mass-produced tool?
For decades, researchers have attempted to understand how accurate the Mechanism is, as that would help resolve its intended purpose. If it wasn't very accurate, for example, then it might have been a toy or an educational model. But if it was incredibly precise, it might have been used by court astrologers to make forecasts and horoscopes.
Related: Antikythera mechanism, world's oldest computer, followed Greek lunar calendar
Unfortunately, the Antikythera Mechanism spent more than two millennia buried at the bottom of the sea, and an unknown amount of time functioning before that. Its gears are highly corroded, and many parts are missing.
In the new study, submitted April 1 to the preprint server arXiv, Argentinian scientists created a computer simulation that replicated the Antikythera Mechanism's movements. This simulation incorporated errors from the imprecise nature of its manufacture, where the gears didn't have exact spacing between them.
Crucially, unlike previous efforts to recreate the Mechanism, the researchers also included an accurate model of the Mechanism's triangle-shaped gear teeth, which affect how well gears interlock with one another, and how well the indicators point to the intended astronomical target.
From this model, the researchers found that the Mechanism wasn't very useful at all. It could only be cranked to about four months into the future before it inevitably jammed, or its gears simply disengaged. The user would then have had to reset everything to get it going again — similar to trying to fix a modern printer. Considering that the indicators marking the date cover an entire year, this jamming problem seems unfortunate.
One possibility is that the Antikythera Mechanism was a fancy toy that was never intended to be fully accurate, or that it came with an instruction manual that required users to reset it after a few turns — much like a mechanical watch whose mainspring must be occasionally adjusted by hand.
But given the obvious craftmanship that went into creating such a complex device, the researchers don't believe that the Mechanism was just a janky toy. After all, if it was never intended to be accurate, detailed or forward-looking, why bother putting in all that hard work in the first place?
RELATED STORIES
—1,600-year-old Roman padlock with spring mechanism discovered in Germany — and it's tiny
—Phaistos Disk: 3,000-year-old inscriptions from Crete that have never been deciphered
—32 haunting shipwrecks from the ancient world
Another possibility, which the researchers think is more likely, is that current measurements of the gears and teeth are off. CT scans can only provide a certain level of resolution, and two thousand years of corrosion may have warped or distorted the components far beyond their original state. The Mechanism's original creators may have made it precise enough to avoid jamming and still provide reliable predictions for years into the future.
Either way, the Antikythera Mechanism represents the apex of ancient engineering expertise. And despite modern technology and tools such as CT scans, its ultimate purpose may stay forever mysterious.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
14 hours ago
- Yahoo
James Webb telescope discovers tentacled 'jellyfish' galaxy swimming through deep space
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. Astronomers have discovered what seems to be a new "jellyfish" galaxy about 12 billion light-years away from Earth using high-resolution imaging from the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). The galaxy appears to have tentacle-like trails of gas and stars jutting off from one side, likely making it a jellyfish galaxy — a class of galaxies that drip tendrils of star-forming material as they swim through space. Though more analysis is needed to confirm whether the newfound galaxy truly falls into this category, all signs so far indicate that it does. Ian Roberts, an astronomer at Waterloo University, found the unique galaxy while sifting through images taken by JWST. His team's research is available to read on the preprint server arXiv, but has not yet been peer reviewed. "The fact that an interesting galaxy such as this one could be found in such a cursory way suggested that there would be real value in doing a truly systematic search for these sorts of objects," Roberts told Live Science in an email. Jellyfish galaxies develop their tentacles as they undergo a phenomenon called ram pressure stripping, which happens when a galaxy moves through the dense medium between other closeby galaxies within a galaxy cluster. This movement eventually pushes some gas and stars out of the roaming galaxy, leaving them to trail behind. These tentacles sometimes trigger a large number of stars to form. Though astronomers don't believe this kind of pressure stripping to be rare in nearby space, the jellyfish stage is short on the cosmic timescale, so it's unusual to capture these aquatic forms before they disappear, Roberts said. Related: 'Previously unimaginable': James Webb telescope breaks its own record again, discovering farthest known galaxy in the universe Farther out in the universe, though, where JWST observed this new jellyfish galaxy, "we really have no idea" how common they are, Roberts said. Jellyfish galaxies provide a way to study galaxy evolution and star formation. Some galaxies in dense environments form many fewer new stars than others, and understanding the reasons why is fundamental to our understanding of how galaxies change over time. Stars are also affected by ram pressure stripping. Though a surge of new stars may form in the trail behind a jellyfish galaxy, the loss of gas in the center of the galaxy could prevent formation there, according to Roberts. RELATED STORIES —James Webb telescope spots tiny galaxies that may have transformed the universe —Mysterious 'rogue' objects discovered by James Webb telescope may not actually exist, new simulations hint —James Webb telescope discovers its first planet — a Saturn-size 'shepherd' still glowing red hot from its formation While ram pressure stripping is the best explanation for the new observations, there may be other possible reasons that the galaxy looks the way it does, and they can't yet be ruled out. The jelly's appendages could be an illusion; parts of the image that show the tentacles were taken using a method that creates blurring, introducing some uncertainty, Roberts said. With the limited existing data about jellyfish galaxies, it's not clear to astronomers whether a jellyfish galaxy so far out in space is rare or not. "We don't know the answer yet, but the more galaxies like this that are discovered the more clues that we get," Roberts said. The research team is hoping to sharpen their image by gathering data from other telescopes, which would allow them to determine whether or not what they've observed is indeed a jellyfish galaxy.
Boston Globe
14 hours ago
- Boston Globe
What 4,000-year-old DNA revealed about how ancient societies interacted
'This finding was quite interesting because we actually know from archaeology that the Egyptian and the eastern-Persian cultures influenced each other for millennia,' Adeline Morez Jacobs, lead author of the new study, said in a media briefing. They shared domesticated animal farming practices and writing systems, for instance. But we now know that 'below the network of ideas was a complex network of people moving and intermixing with the local population,' said Jacobs, a researcher at Liverpool John Moores University and the Francis Crick Institute. Advertisement While artifacts have provided a general understanding of Egyptian life, genetic analysis has been scarce. One big issue has been heat degrading many DNA samples. Due to poor DNA preservation, only three ancient Egyptian individuals have had their genomes partially sequenced. Those samples were also more recent, dating more than 1,000 years after this one. Now, with improved technology, scientists were able to analyze the full genome of a man buried in Nuwayrat village, about 165 miles south of Cairo, who was excavated more than 100 years ago and then housed at the World Museum Liverpool. Researchers were able to glean details about life for someone outside of royalty - although a laborer, the man had the more elaborate burial of someone in a higher social class, which probably helped preserve the DNA. Advertisement 'It's only over the past 10 to 15 years … we've really learned how to take really minute samples from ancient skeletons [to] maximize our chance of retrieving DNA,' Linus Girdland-Flink, a coauthor and archaeogeneticist at the University of Aberdeen, said in the briefing. The remains were found in a pottery vessel placed inside a rock-cut tomb (before widespread artificial mummification), which probably kept the DNA unusually well-preserved at a stable temperature. The team analyzed his dental tissue, which locks the teeth into the jaw, a location that is particularly good at preserving DNA. Radiocarbon dating indicated he probably lived between 2855 and 2570 BC - during an interesting shift in Egyptian history. Upper and Lower Egypt were united a few centuries earlier, followed by a major leap in centralized rule and architecture. The beginning of this golden age of innovation, known as the Old Kingdom, marked notable pyramid construction, including the first step-pyramid complex of King Djoser and the Great Pyramid of Giza. 'This genome allows us, for the first time, to get insights into the genetic ancestry of an ancient Egyptian individual from the Old Kingdom period,' Jacobs said. The researchers took seven DNA extracts from the man, two of which were preserved well enough to be fully sequenced. They analyzed and compared those samples to a library of 3,233 present-day and 805 ancient individuals. Advertisement The team found 80 percent of the genome was linked to individuals in North Africa, suggesting mainly an emergence from the local population, Jacobs said. The remaining 20 percent of his ancestry could be traced to people in the eastern Fertile Crescent, particularly Mesopotamia (roughly modern-day Iraq). The findings provide 'genetic evidence that people moved into Egypt and mixed with local populations at this time, which was previously only visible in archaeological [artifacts],' according to a news release from the Francis Crick Institute. The study focused only on one man, and scientists acknowledged more individual genome sequences would need to be analyzed for a complete picture of Egyptian ancestry at that time DNA analysis even further back - before the introduction of agriculture in Egypt - could help pinpoint when the ancestry began spreading beyond the local population, said Harald Ringbauer, a population geneticist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, who was not involved in the study. 'That would help resolve whether the Levantine-like ancestry component spread with the adoption of farming - or has deeper roots in North East Africa,' Ringbauer said in an email. Still, the man who is the focus of the study is intriguing on his own. Analyzing the skeleton, the researchers could tell he lived to a relatively old age for that time - potentially in his mid-60s. That would be the equivalent of someone living into their 80s today, said coauthor Joel Irish. Features on his skull and pelvis indicated arthritis and a high degree of osteoporosis in his bones. From the back of his skull and vertebrae, the researchers determined that he looked down and leaned forward a lot in his lifetime. Muscle markings on his arms and shoulders show that he was holding his arms in front of him for long periods of time, along with evidence of squatting on his ankles - probably placing him as a potter. Advertisement But his burial would be unusual for a potter. This manner - in the rock-cut tomb and a large pottery vessel - is typically reserved for someone in the upper class. 'That's interesting because it's also at odds with the fact that he had an incredibly hard physical life,' Irish, a dental anthropologist at Liverpool John Moores University, said in the briefing. Other researchers said the findings were a significant step forward in ancient-DNA analysis and our understanding of Egyptian history. For instance, royal dynasties were shown to have rather limited gene pools because of their high inbreeding, said Yehia Gad, emeritus professor of molecular genetics at National Research Center in Egypt, who was not involved in the research.
New York Post
17 hours ago
- New York Post
Ancient DNA shows genetic link between Egypt and Mesopotamia: ‘Highly significant'
WASHINGTON — Ancient DNA has revealed a genetic link between the cultures of ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia, according to research published Wednesday in the journal Nature. Researchers sequenced whole genomes from the teeth of a remarkably well-preserved skeleton found in a sealed funeral pot in an Egyptian tomb site dating to between 4,495 and 4,880 years ago. Four-fifths of the genome showed links to North Africa and the region around Egypt. Advertisement 4 A facial reconstruction of a man radiocarbon dated to around 2855–2570 cal BCE found in Nuwayrat, Egypt. AP 4 A pottery vessel in which the remains of a man was discovered. AP But a fifth of the genome showed links to the area in the Middle East between the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers, known as the Fertile Crescent, where Mesopotamian civilization flourished. 'The finding is highly significant' because it 'is the first direct evidence of what has been hinted at' in prior work,' said Daniel Antoine, curator of Egypt and Sudan at the British Museum. Advertisement Earlier archeological evidence has shown trade links between Egypt and Mesopotamia, as well as similarities in pottery-making techniques and pictorial writing systems. While resemblances in dental structures suggested possible ancestral links, the new study clarifies the genetic ties. The Nile River is 'likely to have acted as an ancient superhighway, facilitating the movement of not only cultures and ideas, but people,' said Antoine, who was not involved in the study. Advertisement The skeleton was found in an Egyptian tomb complex at the archaeological site of Nuwayrat, inside a chamber carved out from a rocky hillside. 4 Earlier archeological evidence has shown trade links between Egypt and Mesopotamia, as well as similarities in pottery-making techniques and pictorial writing systems. AP An analysis of wear and tear on the skeleton — and the presence of arthritis in specific joints — indicates the man was likely in his 60s and may have worked as a potter, said co-author and bio-archaeologist Joel Irish of Liverpool John Moores University. The man lived just before or near the start of ancient Egypt's Old Kingdom, when Upper and Lower Egypt were unified as one state, leading to a period of relative political stability and cultural innovation — including the construction of the Giza pyramids. Advertisement 'This is the time that centralized power allowed the formation of ancient Egypt as we know it,' said co-author Linus Girdland-Flink, a paleogeneticist at the University of Aberdeen. 4 Rock-cut tombs in Nuwayrat, Egypt where all of the items were found. AP At approximately the same time, Sumerian city-states took root in Mesopotamia and cuneiform emerged as a writing system. Researchers said analysis of other ancient DNA samples is needed to obtain a clearer picture of the extent and timing of movements between the two cultural centers. The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Science and Educational Media Group and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
