Judge tosses defamation case brought by Ohio doctor who was acquitted of killing patients
Franklin County Judge Stephen McIntosh issued his directed verdict against former doctor William Husel, whose attorneys accused Michigan-based Trinity Health and Mount Carmel Health System in Columbus of orchestrating a campaign to destroy his reputation.
Husel was seeking more than $18 million from the health care companies.
His attorney, David Vermillion, said in a statement that Husel's legal team was disappointed that McIntosh would prevent the jury from making a decision in the case after weeks of evidence and testimony had been presented. He said issuing the directed verdict, a procedural move requested by the hospital, 'effectively silences the voices of those who came seeking justice.'
'This is not the outcome that any reasonable person expected, nor is it one that reflects the strength of the evidence presented," he said. 'We are evaluating all legal options, including appeal. This case has always been about more than one courtroom or one ruling. It is about truth, accountability, and the right of every individual to defend their name against false and damaging accusations.'
Mount Carmel issued a statement that said simply, 'We are pleased with the judge's decision.'
Mount Carmel Health System fired the doctor in 2018 after it concluded he had ordered excessive painkillers for about three dozen patients who died over several years.
He initially was charged with murder in 25 deaths in one of the biggest cases of its kind ever brought against a U.S. health care professional. Eleven counts were dismissed before trial.
Husel, now 49, maintained he was trying to help patients deal with their pain, sometimes in the last moments of their life, not speed up their deaths. Despite being found not guilty by a jury on murder charges in 2022, he permanently surrendered his medical license.
He filed multiple lawsuits against his former employer, accusing Trinity Health and Mount Carmel of defamation and malicious prosecution.
As part of the defamation lawsuit filed in 2019, Husel's attorneys said Trinity Health repeatedly spread lies and false information to convince the public and law enforcement that Husel was a killer, even though health system officials knew that was not true.
'Obviously, these false allegations destroyed Dr. Husel's life,' the lawsuit said. Husel gave up his medical license because his lawyers said that he knew the damage to his reputation would prevent him from working as a doctor.
In court documents filed two years ago, Husel said he had been unable to find work and was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder and depression.
Trinity Health had asked a judge to toss the lawsuit, but a Franklin County judge ruled there was enough reason to move forward.
Husel, who worked in the intensive care unit, was charged in cases that involved the use of at least 500 micrograms of the powerful painkiller fentanyl. Prosecutors said ordering such dosages for nonsurgical situations indicated an intent to end lives.
His colleagues who administered the medications at Mount Carmel West Hospital in Columbus weren't criminally charged, but the hospital said it fired 23 nurses, pharmacists and managers after its internal investigation and referred various employees to their respective state boards for disciplinary action.
The hospital reached settlements in multiple cases involving relatives of the patients who died.
___
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Hunger strike at Alligator Alcatraz reaches Day 9 as inmate protests conditions
A detainee at the Florida immigration detention center known as Alligator Alcatraz has been on hunger strike for at least nine days, the latest in a string of detainees to allege being mistreated at the prison in the Everglades. 'Since my life no longer belongs to me, it's up to them to decide whether I live or die,' detainee Pedro Lorenzo Concepción, 44, told El País from inside the facility. State officials run the Florida detention camp, housing migrants in a series of hastily assembled tents and chain link enclosures on a converted airstrip as they await federal immigration court and potential deportation by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The Independent has contacted the Florida Division of Emergency Management, one of the state agencies overseeing the facility, for comment. Concepción, who came to the U.S. from Cuba in 2006 but lost his permanent resident status after going to prison, has been in detention since being arrested on July 8 after a check-in at a Florida Immigration and Customs Enforcement office, according to his family. The Independent has contacted ICE for comment. On July 22, he went on hunger strike and has collapsed multiple times inside Alligator Alcatraz. During the strike, he was taken to Miami's Kendall Hospital, according to his family, where he said he sat in handcuffs as doctors tried to get him to eat, but he refused. 'I don't want food, I refuse any treatment,' reads a document he signed about his protest, obtained by El País. 'I didn't even ask to be taken to the hospital, because I'm fighting for my family and all Cubans, and I belong where my people are, in prison, suffering the same hardship they are.' The Independent has contacted Kendall Hospital for comment. Concepción's wife said she's worried he could be deported back to Cuba without her or the couple's two children. 'In a minute, your life falls apart,' she told the paper. 'It's been 19 years of being together.' Concepción, who said he was shackled and left on a floor at Alligator Alcatraz for more than 10 hours upon his arrival, is not the only one to complain of alleged poor conditions at the facility, which federal officials say they plan to support with millions in reimbursement funds and use as a model for future detention centers. Other inmates say they have faced poor sanitation and other brutal conditions inside the facility, which sits in the middle of a sweltering swamp. 'They only brought a meal once a day and it has maggots,' Leamsy 'La Figura' Izquierdo, a Cuban artist who was housed at the facility, told CBS News. 'They never take of the lights for 24 hours. The mosquitoes are as big as elephants.' The facility is facing lawsuits on environmental and civil rights grounds, with lawyers accusing officials of largely barring them from being able to speak with detainees. Earlier this month, Florida news outlets found that among those held at Alligator Alcatraz, only about one-third had a past criminal record, despite officials touting the prison as being designed to hold the worst of the worst.
Daily Mail
8 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Look INSTANTLY refreshed with $21 off the eye serum that delivers Botox-level results at home: 'The best eye product I've ever tried'
Daily Mail journalists select and curate the products that feature on our site. If you make a purchase via links on this page we will earn commission - learn more Imagine treating the puffiness and fine lines under your eyes and actually seeing a visible difference right away. That stunning result is the reason hundreds of shoppers are in a frenzy over the NU:YU Eye Revive CRYO Serum. Carefully formulated to meet the unique needs of women over 40, the treatment is inspired by the power of cryotherapy. This invigorating solution literally chills out your skin, offering targeted cold therapy to refresh and invigorate. Even better, you can now get $21 off when you enter our exclusive code DAILYMAIL21 at checkout. NU:YU Eye Revive CRYO Serum Inspired by cryotherapy, this innovative undereye serum is formulated to treat puffiness instantly while reducing fine lines over time. It's clinically proven to deliver visible results thanks to its potent HEXCELL complex, which effectively targets six signs of aging to leave your skin looking plump and youthful. Right now, you can save $21 — and with a 60-day money-back guarantee, you can try it risk-free. There is no better time to give your skin routine a reboot! Enter code DAILYMAIL21 at checkout to take advantage of this exclusive deal. Save $21 Shop The serum is truly innovative, delivering similar cooling sensations to reduce puffiness immediately. Circulation also increases, giving even the most tired eyes an instant reboot. That's exactly what you want on those bleary-eyed mornings that see you looking a bit worse for wear despite your best efforts. When no amount of concealer can do the job, this instantly revitalizes your skin like a little pocket-sized magician. Impressively, the serum's benefits are progressive. In addition to its quick de-puffing and hydrating action, it generously plumps the thin, delicate under-eye skin. By the second week, the area begins to look fuller and healthier. Within a month, NU:YU's formula firms the skin to reverse the effects of time and exhaustion. By the eighth week, fine lines are smoothed away to reveal a youthful and radiant appearance. It's well worth the commitment — and it's all down to a cocktail of ingredients that are clinically proven to deliver visible results. The hero agent in the serum is HEXCELL, designed to target your skin's needs at the cellular level and deliver at least six incredible results: enhanced volume, softer skin, a radiant finish, fewer lines, increased elasticity, and an overall renewed appearance. The applicator is a cooling ZAMAK metal tip, which gently soothes the skin. The refreshing wand is a key part of the process, adding a lovely spa-like feel to your treatment. And the evidence is truly astonishing. A whopping 100 percent of users felt their skin was instantly smoother, while 98 percent were more confident in their skin's appearance, and 90 percent said its texture improved significantly with regular use. The photo evidence and reviews reveal all, with users taking to the NU:YU website to share their outstanding experiences with the product. 'This serum does it all,' raved one customer. 'Puffiness, fine lines, crow's feet… WOW! Plus the metal wand feels incredible on my tired eyes in the morning. Without a doubt the best eye product I've ever tried.' 'I feel like a movie star every time I use this,' shared another thrilled user. 'I love the cold wand to massage my eyes. My eyes just look so much more refreshed like when I was younger.' A third agreed, writing: 'SO surprised by the instant effect you get from it as soon as the serum and wand touch your skin. It's cooling. My eyes feel so refreshed from using it!' You could not ask for more, especially if you're looking for an effective way to transform your undereye area. Pick up the NU:YU Eye Revive CRYO Serum and save $21 today — while enjoying a 60-day money-back guarantee.
The Independent
34 minutes ago
- The Independent
An Ohio couple welcomes a baby boy from a nearly 31-year-old frozen embryo
A baby boy born last week to an Ohio couple developed from an embryo that had been frozen for more than 30 years in what is believed to be the longest storage time before a birth. In what's known as embryo adoption, Linda and Tim Pierce used a handful of embryos donated in 1994 in pursuit of having a child after fighting infertility for years. Their son was born Saturday from an embryo that had been in storage for 11,148 days, which the Pierces' doctor says sets a record. It's a concept that has been around since the 1990s but is gaining attraction as some fertility clinics and advocates, often Christian-centered, oppose discarding leftover embryos because of their belief that life begins at or around conception and that all embryos deserve to be treated like children who need a home. 'I felt all along that these three little hopes, these little embryos, deserved to live just like my daughter did,' said Linda Archerd, 62, who donated her embryos to the Pierces. Just about 2% of births in the U.S. are the result of in vitro fertilization, and an even smaller fraction involve donated embryos. However, medical experts estimate about 1.5 million frozen embryos are currently being stored throughout the country, with many of those in limbo as parents wrestle with what to do with their leftover embryos created in IVF labs. Further complicating the topic is a 2024 Alabama Supreme Court decision that said that frozen embryos have the legal status of children. State leaders have since devised a temporary solution shielding clinics from liability stemming from that ruling, though questions linger about remaining embryos. Archerd says she turned to IVF in 1994. Back then, the ability to freeze, thaw and transfer embryos was making key progress and opening the door for hopeful parents to create more embryos and increase their chances of a successful transfer. She wound up with four embryos and initially hoped to use them all. But after the birth of her daughter, Archerd and her husband divorced, disrupting her timeline for having more children. As the years turned into decades, Archerd said she was wracked with guilt about what to do with the embryos as storage fees continued to rise. Eventually, she found Snowflakes, a division of Nightlight Christian Adoptions, which offers open adoptions to donors that allows people like Archerd. She was also able to set preferences for what families would adopt her embryos. 'I wanted to be a part of this baby's life,' she said. 'And I wanted to know the adopting parents.' The process was tricky, requiring Archerd to contact her initial fertility doctor in Oregon and dig through paper records to get the proper documentation for the donation. The embryos then had to be shipped from Oregon to the Pierces' doctor in Tennessee. The clinic, Rejoice Fertility in Knoxville, refuses to discard frozen embryos and has become known for handling embryos stored in outdated and older containers. Of the three donated embryos the Pierces received from Archerd, one didn't make the thaw. Two were transferred to Lindsey Pierce's womb, but just one successfully implanted. According to Dr. John David Gordon, the transfer of the nearly 31-year-old embryo marks the longest-frozen embryo to result in a live birth. He would know, Gordon says his clinic assisted in the previous record, when Lydia and Timothy Ridgeway were born from embryos frozen for 30 years, or 10,905 days. 'I think that these stories catch the imagination,' Gordon said. 'But I think they also provide a little bit of a cautionary tale to say: Why are these embryos sitting in storage? You know, why do we have this problem?' In a statement, Lindsey and Tim Pierce said the clinic's support was just what they needed. 'We didn't go into this thinking about records — we just wanted to have a baby,' Lindsey Pierce said. For Archerd, the donation process has been an emotional roller coaster. Relief that her embryos finally found a home, sadness it couldn't be with her and a little anxiety about what the future holds next, with possibly meeting the Pierces and the baby in person. 'I'm hoping that they're going to send pictures,' she said, noting that the parents have already sent several after the birth. 'I'd love to meet them some day. That would be a dream come true to meet — meet them and the baby.'
