Final cost of INM High Court inspection was €5.82m
The costs include fees paid to Irish barrister Sean Gillane SC and UK solicitor Robert Fleck, who as inspectors investigated a series of claims including that Leslie Buckley, as INM's then chairman, acted improperly in ways to benefit businessman Denis O'Brien, who was then a 29.9pc shareholder in INM.
Concerns raised at the time the report was published suggesting the final cost to taxpayers might multiply proved wide of the mark, according to Ian Drennan, CEO of the Corporate Enforcement Authority (CEA).
He was writing in the introduction to the agency's annual report for last year which was published on July 2nd.
'In the immediate aftermath of the publication of the Inspectors' Report, it was suggested in media commentary that the Inspection might ultimately cost the State in excess of €40m. The actual cost of the Inspection was €5.82m and no additional expenditures or liabilities that might increase that amount in any meaningful way have eventuated since that time,' he wrote.
The CEA took the decision not to bring any enforcement action against any of the people who's actions at the then stock market listed INM had been subject to the inspection.
However, in his report, Ian Drennan said that would not mean his agency is less likely to seek a similar process in future in relation to another company where it believed its powers of investigation fell short of what was required to investigate potential corporate wrongdoing.
'Should circumstances arise in the future in which the CEA were to take the view that an application to the High Court for the appointment of Inspectors was warranted, the CEA would not hesitate to do so,' he wrote.
The final inspectors report included important lessons on the standards of governance expected by the law, he said.
The six-year investigation by High Court inspectors into allegations of wrongdoing at Independent News and Media (INM) ultimately found its former chairman. Leslie Buckley, did pass confidential information to Denis O'Brien in a way that was not compliant with the company's policies and the terms of a memorandum he signed in 2016 but that he did not break company law.
The probe was launched after allegations made by INM's then former CEO Robert Pitt, and Ryan Preston, its chief finance officer, about Mr Buckley's conduct as INM chairman.
The inspectors' report made some criticisms of Mr Buckley's conduct but did not uphold the allegations that he broke company law or had tried to use INM resources to benefit Mr O'Brien to the detriment of INM's other shareholders.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Irish Examiner view: Free bets escalate gambling problems
Readers who are annoyed by gambling company advertisements that offer free bets to customers are on to something, to judge by a new report from the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI). The ESRI says that people at risk of problem gambling are more susceptible to the inducements offered by gambling companies, such as free bets and money-back guarantees, and that those people experience significantly more harm from their exposure to them. The ESRI's Diarmaid Ó Ceallaigh said: 'Our findings imply that gambling offers aren't merely marketing tools, but pose a real risk of financial harm, particularly among vulnerable groups.' Mr Ó Ceallaigh's assessment of those gambling offers will resonate with many members of the public. The free bets and various guarantees are clearly aimed at drawing in customers and, as he says, can be seen as marketing tools. That does not stop them from being dangerous in and of themselves, however. The ESRI's research showed that offering such inducements caused participants in its study to spend 10% more and almost halved the number of people opting not to bet, a significant increase in both participants and betting amounts. It is worth pointing out that the study was funded by the Gambling Regulatory Authority of Ireland (GRAI), which was established earlier this year to oversee the industry, and not before time. Last March, its chief executive, Anne Marie Caulfield, told this newspaper that the extent of problem gambling in Ireland was '10 times higher than had been previously thought", so clearly action is needed. Presumably, the gambling industry itself will work to solve this problem. Those advertisements mentioned above routinely carry warnings that people should 'gamble responsibly', after all. If those warnings are to be taken seriously, then it means the industry should row in to support the GRAI in its efforts. Apprentice pay rates must rise Last week, we were informed of the labour shortfall in the Irish economy, and the building sector specifically. Alan Barrett of the ESRI said getting housing completions up to about 50,000 a year would require about 40,000 additional construction employees, though he added that '80,000 additional employees' might be needed to complete the National Development Plan, according to research by the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council. One of the challenges in recruiting so many workers was spelled out by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions this week when it called for apprentices to be paid the minimum wage. New pay rates for apprentices are due to come into effect at the end of July, but they start at €7.66 per hour. It is only in the third year of an apprenticeship that pay exceeds the current national minimum wage of €13.50 per hour. It is difficult to believe that apprentices are expected to survive on €7.66 per hour, but that revelation makes it easy to understand why we have labour shortages. What's your view on this issue? You can tell us here It is not clear how we can be serious about encouraging people to take up the building trades when apprentices can expect to be paid half the minimum wage. An Ictu spokesperson added that employers in the sector agree that apprentice pay rates should start with the minimum wage as a baseline, but those employers also claimed legislation is required because they would be at a competitive disadvantage if they applied those higher pay rates unilaterally. There may be some substance to the suggestion that paying higher rates would eat into profits. There is less substance to claims to be in favour of the minimum wage if you need the law to force you to pay that rate. It might be helpful to hear from some large-scale developers on this issue. Many of them are swift to articulate their concerns about various challenges, so it would be good to hear some of them back the Ictu call for apprentices to be paid the minimum wage — for everyone's benefit. McGregor's court system experience Cianan Brennan of this parish reported earlier this week on a Court of Appeal hearing which was held in the Hugh Kennedy Court within the Four Courts complex. The choice of such a relatively small facility was a surprise, he noted, because the matter at hand was of considerable public interest. The Court of Appeal is to refer Conor McGregor's withdrawal of his application to the DPP for criminal investigation. File picture: PA The court was supposed to hear new information gathered by Conor McGregor regarding Nikita Hand: readers will be aware that Ms Hand won her case against Mr McGregor last November, when she was awarded nearly €250,000 in damages after the High Court jury in a civil rape case found Mr McGregor had assaulted Ms Hand in December 2018. However, no new information emerged. Just before the hearing was due to start, Mr McGregor's lawyers told the Court of Appeal they would be withdrawing the new claims. The court duly allowed the application to be withdrawn, but Ms Hand's senior counsel later said his client was owed an apology, adding that the matter should be referred to the Director of Public Prosecutions. Before the close of business that day, we learned that the Court of Appeal is to refer Mr McGregor's withdrawal of his application to the DPP for criminal investigation. Difficult though it is to believe, Mr McGregor recently aspired to become President of Ireland. The duties of the President include signing legislation into law and referring bills to the Supreme Court. He is certainly becoming more and more familiar with the workings of the Irish court system. Read More Irish Examiner view: Water fixes will come at a delayed cost
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Prison service hiring hundreds to address overcrowding crisis
A recruitment campaign is underway to hire 300 new prison officers in full-time positions. The new officers will help address staffing shortfalls amid an overcrowding crisis among the prison population, which recently exceeded 5,000 in a system with bed capacity for over 4,600. The Irish Penal Reform Trust (IPRT) has claimed that overcrowding in prisons has been persistent since 2023 leading to unacceptable, degrading and dehumanising conditions across Irish prisons. The highest level of overcrowding is at Limerick's Women's Prison, which is currently 48% over capacity. Eighty-three women are in custody there, but the prison has a bed capacity of just 56. As of Thursday, 3 July, 5,477 people are in prison custody, equating to the prison estate being at 118% capacity. The IRPT said many prisoners are forced to sleep on mattresses on the floor, which is said to increase tensions in ''inhumane and degrading conditions'' The Irish Prison Service's capital budget for 2025 is €53 million, which officials say is being used to create additional spaces. Capacity increases in prison system Over recent years, capacity has been increased by in excess of 300 spaces. "This year's campaign is a vital part of a much wider investment in our prison systems.'' said Minister for Justice, Home Affairs and Migration Jim O'Callaghan. ''Prison officers are at the heart of our justice system and have the potential to positively impact the lives of some of Ireland's most vulnerable people, as well as Irish society as a whole," he added. The Irish prison service has encouraged anyone looking for a varied and fulfilling career to apply. ''The Government is committed to ensuring that all prison officers are empowered and equipped to lead rewarding careers that make a real difference," said Minister O'Callaghan. Virtual prison tour launched A virtual prison tour through an Irish Prison Service location has also been launched. The interactive web-based virtual tool, believed to be the first of its kind, guides visitors or incoming prisoners on what to expect when visiting a prison location The Director General of the Irish Prison Service said the latest recruitment campaign will run until 1 August, 2025. ''The incredible work of prison officers is complex and often hidden from public view, but our annual competition and the launch of the virtual tour allow us the opportunity to let the public see the team work and the integrity, potential, safety and support that prison officers not only offer to prisoners, but to their colleagues as well.'' said Director General of the Irish Prison Service Caron McCaffrey. Eligible candidates will undergo a comprehensive selection process, including written assessments, physical fitness tests, interviews, and background checks. Successful candidates will receive extensive training to equip them with the skills required for the role. The 2024 recruitment campaign attracted more than 1500 applicants and 271 prison officers joining the Irish Prison Service.
RTÉ News
4 hours ago
- RTÉ News
US multinationals to increase employee numbers in Ireland over next year
60% of US multinationals that are members of the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland plan to increase employee numbers here over the next year. The findings of a new survey carried out by the American Chamber also show that a further 32.5% of US companies say they will maintain their current workforce levels. Ahead of an event in Dublin today to celebrate US Independence Day, AmCham surveyed its members current views on Ireland as a destination for growth and further investment. The companies included in the survey, which was carried out in the last week, represent around 52,000 of the employees within US multinationals across the country. 9 in 10 survey respondents say their corporate headquarters have a positive view of Ireland as an investment location, while 68% already have plans to invest in Ireland over the next 5 years. However, almost a third point to housing as the most important challenge to overcome for their company to invest and expand here. Just over a quarter, 26%, say cost competitiveness is the most important challenge, while 10.5% say skills shortage is the number one challenge. Other challenges include delays and complexity of the planning process, supply chain disruption, and the need to enhance R&D tax incentives. The CEO of the American Chamber says Ireland is "a strategic hub for innovation and global decision-makers in major American corporations". Paul Sweetman says almost 7.5% of Ireland's entire population is employed, directly or indirectly, by US multinationals. "On the flip side, Ireland is the 6th largest source of FDI into the US and Irish companies are employing almost as many people in the US as US companies are employing in Ireland." "It truly is a genuine two-way economic relationship," according to Mr Sweetman. He says while the geopolitical backdrop of trade, tariffs and uncertainty are "unquestionably causing challenges for our members," he says AmCham sees "a real and emerging optimism that the business community is ready to get moving through accelerating innovative projects and strategic investments". "The single biggest factor that will impact Ireland's long-term growth will be our own national competitiveness, a factor wholly within our control."
