Former Clare hurler Niall Gilligan found not guilty of assaulting 12-year-old boy
|
12 mins ago
A JURY HAS found former All-Star and Clare All-Ireland winning hurler, Niall Gilligan not guilty of assaulting a then 12-year-old boy with a stick almost two years ago.
At Ennis Circuit Court today, the jury of seven men and five women delivered a majority 'not guilty' verdict against the charge that Gilligan (48) of Rossroe, Kilmurry, Sixmilebridge had assaulted causing harm of the boy with a stick at the Jamaica Inn Hostel, Sixmilebridge on 5 October 2023.
Gilligan sat impassively in the court as the court registrar read out the 'not guilty' majority verdicts in the case concerning the assault causing harm charge and producing a stick under Section 11 of the Firearms and Offensive Weapons Act at the same location on the same date.
Two women in the Gilligan family group seated at the back of the court to support Mr Gilligan wept as the 'not guilty' verdicts were called out while the parents of the then 12 year old sitting on the opposite side of the court left the courtroom shortly after the verdicts were announced.
The jury delivered their majority 'not guilty' verdict after five hours and three minutes of deliberations and returned to the court 48 minutes after Judge Francis Comerford directed shortly after midday today that they could deliver a majority 11-1 or 10-2 verdict.
Shortly before 1pm, the foreman replied 'yes' when asked by the court registrar had at least 10 of the jury reached a verdict in the case.
The jury reached their verdicts after five days of evidence, closing speech by lawyers from both sides and the judge's charge in the case.
Judge Comerford thanked the jury 'for the careful deliberations you have taken'.
Gilligan spoke briefly with his legal team of solicitor, Daragh Hassett and Patrick Whyms BL in the body of the court before leaving the courtroom.
A farmer and auctioneer in Sixmilebridge, Gilligan was not on legal aid for the case and will have to pay his legal bill from the six-day long trial from his own resources.
In his closing speech to the jury, counsel for Gilligan, Whyms said on the evening at the Jamaica Inn hostel, Gilligan 'didn't know that he was dealing with a child and did not create this situation'.
Advertisement
Whyms said that Gilligan 'was at the end of his tether' by the vandalism being done to a vacant property he was trying to sell.
Putting forward the defence of reasonable force against the charge of assault causing harm, Whyms said that Gilligan was at the Jamaica Inn hostel on the night of 5 October 'in the dark and believed that he was under siege'.
He said: 'Believing himself under threat and needing to protect himself and his property, Niall Gilligan needs to make an instant decision and so we are here.'
Whyms said: 'And Mr Gilligan, a family man who has young children and no previous convictions gives a clear story which has't changed and an entirely credible, fulsome account of what happened.'
Whyms said to the jury: 'Did Niall Gilligan use such force as was reasonable in the circumstances as he believed them to be and if he did then no offence was committed.'
In his prepared statement at Shannon Garda Station in February 2024 on the alleged assault, Whyms said that Gilligan 'has given a perfectly plausible account in an otherwise impeccably accurate description of what occurred which placed the boys inside the building when he met them'.
On the medical evidence, Whyms said: 'Nobody wants to see a child being injured and it would be much better if that didn't happen and the boy was injured in this case.'
He said: 'There doesn't seem to be much room for argument that he was injured from the actions of Niall Gilligan.'
Whyms said that a displaced fracture of a finger on the boy's left hand 'is the only fracture in this case'.
He said: 'There is an un-displaced fracture of a finger – that is not a good thing to happen but that it is what happened'
He said: 'There were injuries and there were sustained in the incident but by and large, most were cleared up in the week and the last one was pretty well cleared up in two weeks.'
Whyms said that the injuries 'don't look nice on the photographs – there is no getting away from that and injuries that are photographed immediately after don't look nice'.
Whyms said that the injuries sustained by the boy 'are clearly regrettable'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Sallins train robbery: Man (75) seeks to have wrongful conviction declared miscarriage of justice
A judge has said 'every effort should be made' to progress matters in an application by a man who is attempting to have his wrongful conviction more than 45 years ago for the Sallins train robbery declared a miscarriage of justice. The mail train robbery took place on March 31st, 1976 when the Cork-to-Dublin train was robbed near Sallins in Co Kildare and an estimated £200,000 stolen. Osgur Breatnach (75) was one of five members of the Irish Republican Socialist Party who were subsequently arrested. Mr Breatnach was found guilty and sentenced to 12 years by the Special Criminal Court but his conviction was quashed in May 1980 after the Court of Criminal Appeal ruled that his confession had been obtained under 'oppression'. READ MORE He is now seeking to have his wrongful conviction declared a miscarriage of justice. Mr Breatnach's case was raised briefly on Friday during a case management list at the Court of Appeal where barrister Miceál O'Connor told the court he appears for Mr Breatnach instructed by KRW law. Mr Justice Edwards, presiding, said he had read the paperwork, which clearly raised 'serious issues'. He said it was a matter for the State to reply to Mr Breatnach's affidavit and noted that as 'very significant issues are raised' a considerable amount of time would be required to allow the DPP time to respond. The judge said he would put the matter back for three months and adjourned the case to October 24th. A State solicitor asked for 'a little longer' given the court's upcoming long vacation. Mr O'Connor said he believed three months was sufficient. 'We can see where we are at that stage,' he added. Mr Justice Edwards refused the request, saying: 'I'm not closing the door to more time, but I think every effort should be made to try and progress the matter in the next three months.' Following today's hearing, Mr Breatnach's solicitor Kevin Winters of KRW Law confirmed the company has filed an application to the Court of Appeal under section 9 of The Criminal Procedure Act 1993 certifying that a newly discovered fact or facts point to a miscarriage of justice which led to Mr Breathnach's wrongful robbery conviction on December 13th, 1978. 'We're delighted the court has requested immediate expedition of this application,' Mr Winters said.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Fire at Conor McGregor's pub: Gardaí investigate alleged ‘incident of criminal damage'
Gardaí say investigations are ongoing into a suspected 'incident of criminal damage' at Conor McGregor 's Black Forge Inn pub in Dublin 12. A small fire broke out at the front of the building in Crumlin in the early hours of this morning. McGregor bought the premises in 2020 for €2 million and later spent €1 million in renovations. It was the target of a suspected petrol bombing in 2022 , in which the bomb failed to detonate and caused no damage to the premises. READ MORE A worker at the Black Forge Inn told The Irish Times that the premises remains open and said that it was understood that the fire was the result of 'an electrical fault'. McGregor said on social media 'the pub is open for business today, folks. You wouldn't get through it with a rocket launcher. There's not a bother on her, she's spotless'. A Garda spokesperson said gardaí attended the scene around 3am this morning. 'The fire was extinguished by Dublin Fire Brigade,' they said, and 'no injuries have been reported'. 'The scene is currently preserved and a technical examination will be conducted in due course,' the Garda spokesperson said. A spokesperson for Dublin Fire Brigade said they were 'called at 3.08am to reports of a fire'. 'Fire fighters from Dolphin's Barn were mobilised to the address and on arrival found a small fire at the front of the building'. 'Using a high-pressure hose reel, one fire engine dealt with the incident and no injuries were reported. The scene was handed over to gardaí,' they said.
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Thirty two children from the West Bank watched the All-Ireland in Jordan. This wasn't the plan
The cheering coming from a hotel room in Amman last Sunday sprang from an astonishing source. Gathered in front of a big screen, 32 Palestinian children from the West Bank were watching the All-Ireland final on the GAAGO streaming service. Some were sporting Tipperary jerseys, a gift from a donor. After the final whistle, one of the boys produced a length of string and fashioned it into a clothes line over the bath upon which he hung his precious Gaelic jersey to dry after washing it. Such resourcefulness is second nature to a child who has lived all his life in a refugee camp; as have his parents and his grandparents. The children – avid hurlers and camogie players aged from nine to 16 – should have been in Ireland, but they and 14 adult mentors were refused visas by the Department of Justice . 'But Ireland loves us,' they responded, confused, when the tour organisers, GAA Palestine, told them their visit to 152 waiting host families had to be cancelled . When Mohammed cannot come to the mountain, the mountain must come to Mohammed. A group of volunteers flew from Ireland to Jordan last Friday to give the children an alternative holiday there. One teenager failed to make it across the border from the West Bank because his requisite school certificate had burned to ashes when the Israel Defense Forces attacked his camp. On the day the other 32 left their homes in Ramallah and the Tulkarm, Jenin and Am'ari camps, soldiers shot a 13-year-old boy dead. Amr Ali Qabha had unwittingly walked down a road in Jenin where soldiers were present during violent raids by Israeli settlers. When he rounded a bend and saw them, Amr turned to go back. They shot him seven times – in the neck, abdomen, back, groin and right thigh. As he lay dying, the soldiers prevented an ambulance from going to his aid. READ MORE 'But Ireland loves us,' the children said. That is true, the GAA Palestine volunteers reassured them and showed them videos on their phones of last Saturday's solidarity protests when tens of thousands of people took to the streets of this country. These children need tender loving care. They've lost parents. They have family members in prisons, in detention with no charges. They are refugees all their lives. They are repeatedly displaced. They see the crops being burned, the sheep being killed. They need to be able to spend time without a gun in their face — Volunteer Claire Liddy 'Let them come,' the marchers had chanted. 'They say that for us?' wondered the children. They are not the only ones who are confused by the contradiction between Ireland's policy of solidarity on the Occupied Territories and how it treats the victim-occupants. The Government, admirably, has withstood orchestrated international opprobrium for its decision to officially recognise Palestinian statehood, which culminated in Israel shutting its embassy in Dublin. The Occupied Territories Bill currently before the Oireachtas has elicited accusations of anti-Semitism and warnings of ruination for the Irish economy. The US ambassador to Israel, Mike Huckabee , a Southern Baptist pastor and former Fox News talkshow host, dredged the muck of drunken-Paddies stereotypes, unapologetic for his own racism. [ Heartbreak as Palestinian GAA players are refused visas to visit Ireland Opens in new window ] To its credit, the Oireachtas appears resolved to outlaw trade with illegal Israeli settlers in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. Injecting steel into that resolve is the knowledge that since last January and up until last week, according to United Nations agency OCHA , 162 Palestinians have been killed in the West Bank and East Jerusalem. At least 32 of the dead were children. The killings and illegal seizures of Palestinian homes and farms, with the assistance of Israeli soldiers, have been a fact of life throughout the lives of the children watching Tipperary beat Cork last Sunday. As it becomes ever more obvious that Israel is trying to kill as many Gazans as it can while it still can with complicit way-leave by the US, Germany and the EU, Micheál Martin's condemnations have become more forthright and fearless. Yet Ireland's defence of Palestinians' freedom is a strange kind of love. GAA Palestine applied in February for the summer tour visas. It was only at the eleventh hour this month that the Department of Justice notified the organisation the visas were being refused, citing a failure to produce sufficient documents. Stephen Redmond, GAA Palestine's chairman who is currently in Jordan, countered that all required documentations had been submitted; in fact, more than ever before for past tours. One West Bank group having to abandon its plans might be presumed a glitch or merely the pedantry of some stickler officials in the department's visa section, but two suggests a pattern. The Lajee Centre in the West Bank town of Bethlehem has had to postpone its planned tour to Ireland by 40 musicians and dancers this month after failing to obtain timely decisions on their visa applications. It would have been the third visit organised by the cultural centre. The hurt, confusion, upheaval and disappointment caused by these aborted tours can but be imagined. [ Exhausted and imprisoned: how life in the West Bank is getting worse for Palestinians Opens in new window ] 'These children need tender loving care,' volunteer Claire Liddy told me on the phone from the Jordanian side of the Dead Sea on Tuesday, during an outing with the young Palestinian hurlers. 'They've lost parents. They have family members in prisons, in detention with no charges. They live in camps. They are refugees all their lives. They are repeatedly displaced; some twice since May alone. They see the crops being burned [by Israeli settlers], the sheep being killed. They need to be able to spend time without a gun in their face.' Ireland's stringent admission policy for Palestinians also strikes a contrast with how it has treated Ukrainians, who do not require a visitor's visa. Within months of the Russian invasion in February 2022, this country was, rightly, accommodating 42,000 Ukrainian war refugees. Meanwhile, 208 Palestinians have been refused short-stay visas since Israel began its killing rampage in Gaza in October 2023 , according to data published by While there is a distinction to be made between a campaign of all-out war and a prolonged campaign of violent and illegal annexation, the ultimate consequences are the same for those on the receiving end. The common factor between what Israel is doing in Gaza and in the West Bank is an international crime called ethnic cleansing. The methods may differ – aerial bombardment, mass killings and man-made famine in Gaza; systemic discrimination, forced displacement and murders in the West Bank – but they belong to the same grand plan to colonise the Palestinian territories.
