&w=3840&q=100)
'None of them are really doctors': Liver Doc takes on Vidit Gujrathi on X
What started as a heartfelt tribute — a family selfie captioned 'Happy Doctor's Day to my entire family' — quickly spiralled into controversy. When a user asked about his family's medical background, Vidit replied that his father is an Ayurvedic migraine specialist, his wife holds an MD in homeopathy, his mother practices cosmetology, and his sister is a physiotherapist.
But the Liver Doc wasted no time in firing back, bluntly declaring, 'I'm sorry, but none of them are really doctors,' dismissing the qualifications as unscientific or pseudoscientific. The remark drew backlash — and Vidit, usually reserved, hit back sharply: 'Stay in your lane and try being useful.'
The digital clash has since stirred debate across the platform, pitting advocates of traditional medicine against voices from modern science, with Gujrathi's post becoming the unexpected battleground.
A user replied to Vidit, saying 'you are an influential figure, so you have the responsibility not to spread misinformation. Doctor's day on July 1st is celebrated for Doctors of medical science. Not homeopaths, not ayurvedics or any other professions that have nothing to do with medicine. So educate yourself and be responsible instead of feeling personally attacked by someone for just pointing out that they are not indeed real doctors.'
For the past five years, Dr. Cyriac Abby Philips — a hepatologist and clinical researcher from Kerala — has been on a mission: treating patients harmed by the misuse of alternative medicines. Since 2019, he's taken that fight online, using his Twitter handle @theliverdr to launch sharp, data-driven takedowns of Ayurveda, Homeopathy, Siddha, and Unani systems.
His posts often go viral, earning him both praise from science advocates and criticism from supporters of traditional medicine — making him one of the most polarising voices in India's healthcare debate.
Hot battle: Modern medicine Vs Ayurveda
The clash between modern medicine and traditional systems like Ayurveda has been brewing for years — and this latest exchange has only poured fuel on the fire. As his back-and-forth with Vidit Gujrathi escalated, Dr. Cyriac Abby Philips doubled down on his stance, writing on X: 'Your statement on Doctors' Day claiming an Ayurveda practitioner, homeopath, cosmetologist and physiotherapist were doctors is wrong, and I stand by my words.'
'Doctors' Day in India marks both the birth and death anniversary of Dr. Bidhan Chandra Roy, one of India's most revered physicians and a key figure in shaping the healthcare system,' he added.
'Ayurveda, Homeopathy, Cosmetology or Physiotherapy are not realistic clinical medicine or and their practitioners are not clinical physicians.'
Supporters of modern medicine quickly rallied behind him. One user praised his boldness: 'Salute to you, Doctor, for fearlessly exposing the fraudulent practices carried out in the name of medicine. Your courage and integrity are a true service to humanity.'
One more went, 'I have the deepest respect and awe for ppl who are good at chess bcoz I'm not. But sorry, Ayurveda Homoeopathy etc are quackery and dangerous. People are often healed there because many illnesses are self limiting & also due to placebo effect.'
The defenders of Ayurveda didn't hold back either. One user confronted the Liver Doc, saying 'Though I respect your contribution to society but who are you talking negative about Ayurveda ? This is not so mature of you Doctor. There is a whole government department called AYUSH propagating Ayurveda. The Ayurveda industry is a 20 billion USD market . Ayurveda was born 5000 years ago.
The user continued, 'There is Hindu god called Dhawantri of Ayurveda. Doctors basically are called healers. So anybody helping in healing gets that badge. I don't know about other branches but Ayurveda, Homeopathy & physiotherapy are definitely healers.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
13 minutes ago
- News18
Spermatorrhoea: Harmless or Harmful? Explaining Nightfall Without Shame
Last Updated: Understanding and managing spermatorrhoea requires a compassionate and informed approach, emphasising self-care and open communication Sex may permeate our popular culture, but conversations about it are still associated with stigma and shame in Indian households. As a result, most individuals dealing with sexual health issues or trying to find information about sex often resort to unverified online sources or follow the unscientific advice of their friends. To address the widespread misinformation about sex, is running this weekly sex column, titled 'Let's Talk Sex'. We hope to initiate conversations about sex through this column and address sexual health issues with scientific insight and nuance. In this article, we will explain all aspects of spermatorrhoea, enabling you to distinguish between myths and reality. In a world where health topics are increasingly discussed openly, it is imperative to address concerns that often linger in the shadows, such as spermatorrhoea, commonly known as nightfall. By shedding light on this subject without stigma, you are encouraged to embrace a more informed and confident perspective, acknowledging that nightfall is a normal part of human biology and development. Spermatorrhoea, commonly referred to as 'nightfall," is a natural physiological phenomenon predominantly observed in adolescent males and young adults. It involves the involuntary ejaculation of semen during sleep, often linked to erotic dreams or fantasies. This occurrence is a normal part of male puberty, a period marked by significant hormonal changes and sexual maturation. Despite its prevalence, the topic of nightfall is frequently shrouded in misconceptions and shame, making it essential to shed light on its nature and implications. At its core, spermatorrhoea is a result of the body's reproductive system functioning as it should. During puberty, the testes ramp up the production of testosterone, the hormone responsible for many male characteristics, including the maturation of sperm. As the body adjusts to this surge in hormones, nightfall becomes a mechanism for relieving the reproductive system of excess sperm. It's akin to a pressure-release valve, ensuring the sperm production process doesn't reach an overflow. COMMON CAUSES OF SPERMATORRHOEA Hormonal Imbalances: Spermatorrhoea, often referred to as nightfall, can be influenced by various factors, one of which is hormonal imbalances. Testosterone and other hormones play a crucial role in regulating sexual health. When these hormones are disrupted, whether due to puberty, stress, or medical conditions, they can lead to more frequent episodes of nightfall. It's essential to understand that hormonal fluctuations are a natural part of development, yet they can sometimes indicate underlying health issues if experienced excessively. Psychological Factors: Another significant contributor to spermatorrhoea is the realm of psychological influences. Stress and anxiety are common culprits, as they can elevate levels of physical arousal and lead to involuntary emissions during sleep. Moreover, psychological factors such as sexual fantasies or guilt associated with sexual thoughts can exacerbate the frequency of nocturnal emissions. By acknowledging these influences, individuals can better approach their mental well-being, potentially reducing the occurrence of nightfall. Lifestyle and Dietary Habits: Lifestyle choices and dietary habits can also impact the frequency of spermatorrhoea. A diet low in essential nutrients like zinc and magnesium, combined with sedentary lifestyles, can affect hormonal balance and increase the likelihood of nightfall. Additionally, excessive consumption of stimulating substances such as caffeine and alcohol might lead to more frequent nocturnal emissions. By adopting a balanced diet and engaging in regular physical activity, one can foster a healthier body and potentially mitigate the intensity or frequency of spermatorrhoea. Lack of Sexual Activity: Lastly, a decrease in regular sexual activity can lead to an increase in spermatorrhoea incidents. The body naturally seeks to expel excess semen when ejaculation does not occur through regular means. Understanding this can help normalize the conversation around nocturnal emissions and encourage a healthier, more informed perspective on sexual health. IS SPERMATORRHOEA HARMLESS OR HARMFUL? While spermatorrhoea is generally considered to be a benign occurrence and part of normal male physiology, it can sometimes cause concern or embarrassment for those experiencing it. From a medical standpoint, nightfall is not inherently harmful. It does not lead to physical health problems and is not indicative of any underlying medical condition. However, if excessive, it might be an indicator of heightened sexual tension or anxiety, which could benefit from attention and management. The psychological impact of spermatorrhoea should not be underestimated. Cultural and societal attitudes can often imbue this natural process with unwarranted shame or anxiety. Emphasising a supportive and educational approach is essential to dismantle these negative perceptions. Encouraging open conversations about nightfall can help individuals understand that it is a normal bodily function, reducing the stigma associated with it. In conclusion, spermatorrhoea is a largely harmless phenomenon that plays a role in the body's natural functioning. Promoting awareness and dispelling myths can pave the way for acceptance and understanding, ensuring that individuals experiencing nightfall do so without shame or undue concern. Embracing a positive, informed perspective on spermatorrhoea fosters a healthier, more supportive environment for everyone. EFFECTIVE WAYS TO MANAGE SPERMATORRHOEA Lifestyle Adjustments: Managing spermatorrhoea often starts with subtle lifestyle changes. A balanced diet, regular exercise, and adequate sleep can significantly affect the frequency and intensity of nocturnal emissions. Foods rich in vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants can bolster overall health and stabilize hormones. Regular physical activity not only helps in maintaining a healthy body weight but also promotes better sleep patterns, which can reduce the occurrences of nightfall. Stress Management: Stress and anxiety can exacerbate the frequency of spermatorrhoea. Engaging in relaxation techniques such as meditation, deep-breathing exercises, and yoga can help in alleviating stress. These practices not only calm the mind but also enhance self-awareness, helping individuals understand and control their bodily responses more effectively. Medical Consultation: If spermatorrhoea becomes a source of distress or significantly affects daily life, consulting with a healthcare professional is advisable. A doctor can provide personalized advice and, if necessary, recommend treatments or therapies to manage symptoms. It's important to approach this conversation without shame, as healthcare providers are equipped to help with such concerns. Understanding and managing spermatorrhoea requires a compassionate and informed approach, emphasising self-care and open communication. By approaching the topic without stigma, you empower yourself and others to engage in open, informed discussions that can dispel myths and reduce unwarranted anxiety. Encouraging dialogue with healthcare professionals further demystifies the subject, ensuring that any underlying concerns are properly addressed. Ultimately, embracing a perspective rooted in knowledge and acceptance not only enhances personal well-being but also fosters a broader cultural shift towards more open conversations about sexual health. About the Author Prof (Dr) Saransh Jain First Published:
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Delhi govt to launch 4-tier mental health programme for children, workers and seniors
New Delhi: The Delhi government is set to launch a dedicated mental health programme focused on children, the working class and senior citizens, through a four-tier model offering teleconsultation, counselling, OPD care and a referral system. In a bid to tackle the rising cases of stress and anxiety across age groups, a comprehensive mental health programme under the AYUSH intervention will help people of all ages, Delhi Health Minister Pankaj Singh said He said that the initiative -- aimed at promoting holistic well-being -- will focus on three key population groups: children, the working class and senior citizens. The service will be anonymous, accessible and rooted in traditional systems of medicine including Ayurveda, Homoeopathy and Unani, he said, adding that this will be the first focused mental health initiative under Ayush and it will support people at every stage -- from a phone call to a consultation, and even hospital-level care if needed. Many people hesitate to speak about mental stress. Through this platform, they can reach out anonymously and seek help without fear or stigma, the minister said. The programme will operate through a four-level structure starting from telephonic consultations, moving to mental health counselling , followed by OPD services at Ayush hospitals and a final referral stage in case specialised psychiatric intervention is needed. The programme is especially significant at a time when stress is increasingly being reported among school children, with some showing early signs of aggression and anxiety. Also, working professionals are burdened with high-pressure targets and a lack of work-life balance. Women who juggle home and workplace responsibilities will also be covered within this group. The elderly, too, face isolation and other age-related mental health challenges. Under the plan, people can call a dedicated helpline and book a time slot to speak with a counsellor. If the counsellor feels that in-person help is required, the case will be referred to OPDs at Ayush hospitals. There are currently four such teaching hospitals in Delhi -- Karol Bagh, Defence Colony, Najafgarh and Nanak Pura. If further care is necessary, the final level will involve referral to allopathic or psychiatric facilities based on Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs). Functioning under the Delhi government's health framework, the AYUSH systems comprise Ayurveda, Yoga and Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha, and Homoeopathy. PTI
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Metrowater says it can't remove forever chemicals from lakes
Chennai: In an ongoing case before the National Green Tribunal (NGT), Chennai's lakes have come under scrutiny for contamination by 'forever chemicals'— toxic compounds linked to cancer and liver damage. Metrowater said the city's current treatment infrastructure cannot remove these chemicals, scientifically known as per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS). In an affidavit, the board said that PFAS enter water bodies through everyday items — especially fast food wrappers, instant noodle cups, and baking paper — whose chemical coatings break down in landfills. The resulting leachate seeps into groundwater and lakes, contaminating urban water systems. While these substances are known for their non-stick, oil-resistant properties, their extreme chemical stability also makes them nearly impossible to break down through conventional treatment. You Can Also Check: Chennai AQI | Weather in Chennai | Bank Holidays in Chennai | Public Holidays in Chennai Metrowater said that its plants meet Indian drinking water standards under IS:10500, but added that these norms do not cover PFAS. More importantly, they said that during treatment, certain PFAS precursors may convert into detectable PFAS forms, raising levels in treated water higher than the raw input. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 새로 나온 '실비보험' 최적가 비교가입! "月 보험료 낮추고, 보장은 든든하게"... 굿리치 [등록번호:제2006038313호] 가입하기 Undo Globally, advanced economies have begun investing in high-end solutions such as plasma reactors and advanced oxidation systems to degrade PFAS, but Metrowater said such technologies are expensive and still unproven at scale. Laboratory results often don't translate to real-world success, where wastewater is filled with organic matter and other compounds that interfere with treatment. Detection itself is a hurdle. PFAS and their precursors require specialized equipment such as high-resolution mass spectrometry, which is costly and not widely available in India. Without clear regulations or national guidelines, utilities like Metrowater are operating in a scientific vacuum. Instead of downstream fixes, the board called for preventive measures — stopping PFAS at the source. That means controlling industrial and packaging uses before they enter the waste stream.
