Pakistan's Defence Minister Admits ‘Hybrid Rule', Says Army Too Holds Power In Civil-Military Setup
This marks the second time in a week that Asif, currently serving in Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif's cabinet, has acknowledged the presence of a hybrid arrangement.
Pakistan's Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, a senior leader of the ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) and a close aide of former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, has openly stated that the country is operating under a 'hybrid model" of governance in which the military holds a fair share of power.
This marks the second time in a week that Asif, currently serving in Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif's cabinet, has acknowledged the presence of a hybrid arrangement. Analysts have long criticised this setup as a 'fixed government to serve subsidiary interests," rather than a genuine power-sharing model.
Asif's remarks came during an interview with Arab News aired on Friday evening and are being widely interpreted as confirmation that the Sharifs' PML-N is functioning with the endorsement of Pakistan's powerful military establishment.
Describing the hybrid civil-military structure as a shared arrangement, Asif said: 'This is a hybrid model. It's not an ideal democratic government. So, this hybrid arrangement, I think it is doing wonders. This system is a practical necessity until Pakistan is out of the woods as far as economic and governance problems are concerned."
He further argued that if such a model had been implemented in the 1990s, when Nawaz Sharif was twice elected prime minister, Pakistan might have avoided prolonged friction between civilian and military leadership. 'The confrontation between the military establishment and the political government would retard the progress of democracy," he added.
The defence minister's statement has reignited debate over the PML-N's political trajectory and its now-contradictory past slogan of 'vote ko izzat do" (give respect to the ballot). Critics argue that Asif's frank admission cements the perception that the PML-N has aligned itself firmly under the military's umbrella, abandoning its previous anti-establishment stance.
Former Prime Minister Imran Khan, a long-time rival of the Sharifs, has repeatedly claimed that the general elections held on February 8 were the 'Mother of All Rigging" and accused the PML-N and its coalition partner—the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) led by Bilawal Bhutto Zardari—of being 'mandate thieves."
Following Asif's admission, political observers say the future of Pakistan's democratic institutions remains precarious. 'This (Trump-Munir) meeting has lifted the thin, see-through veneer of 'elected'. What the world has known for quite a while is now in the open… where is the centre of power in Pakistan and who is in control of real state powers? The political allies (military) in power have presented themselves as the 'government' now," remarked political analyst Dr Rasul Bakhsh Rais, reported news agency PTI.
He further noted: 'Khawaja Asif and others now have to seek some legitimacy to praise the merits of the hybrid model, which actually doesn't mean a mixed but a fixed government to serve subsidiary interests."
Dr Rais described the current political system as the third iteration of a hybrid regime since Imran Khan's ouster in 2022. Unlike previous periods under General Ziaul Haq and General Pervez Musharraf, both of whom built new political alliances, this time, he said, major parties like the PML-N and PPP have willingly assumed the role of 'political facade."
He concluded that the military's orchestration of electoral victories for the PML-N and PPP has reduced them to mere appendages of the establishment. 'Now, the priority of the Sharifs and Zardaris as well as the military establishment is to neutralise the third force — Imran Khan's PTI — which is perceived as a danger for all of them," he said.
Senior journalist Matiullah Jan also weighed in with sharp criticism on X: 'What a fall from grace for a politician. This defence minister takes oath to defend the constitution which makes no mention of the so-called hybrid form of government." He added, 'The fact is that this system is not even a hybrid system but a pure and simple dictatorship with political pygmies at the heels of affairs."
Location :
New Delhi, India, India
First Published:
June 21, 2025, 21:38 IST
News world Pakistan's Defence Minister Admits 'Hybrid Rule', Says Army Too Holds Power In Civil-Military Setup
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
41 minutes ago
- Business Standard
IDF claims to have killed Hamas mastermind behind October 2023 attack
The Israel Defense Forces has announced that they eliminated Hakham Muhammad Issa Al-Issa--one of the founders of Hamas' military wing. The IDF in a late Saturday night post said that Issa was one of the masterminds of the October 7, 2023 attack. In a post on X, the IDF said, "ELIMINATED: eliminated Hakham Muhammad Issa Al-Issa--one of the founders of Hamas' military wing. Issa led Hamas' force build-up, training, and planned the October 7 massacre. As Head of Combat Support, he advanced aerial & naval attacks against Israelis. The IDF & ISA will continue to locate and eliminate all terrorists involved in the October 7 massacre." ???? ELIMINATED: eliminated Hakham Muhammad Issa Al-Issa—one of the founders of Hamas' military wing. Issa led Hamas' force build-up, training, and planned the October 7 massacre. As Head of Combat Support, he advanced aerial & naval attacks against Israelis. The IDF & ISA will… — Israel Defense Forces (@IDF) June 28, 2025 Meanwhile, as per Al Jazeera, Israel continued its attacks across the Gaza Strip, including an attack that killed at least 20 people, including nine children, in Gaza City's Tuffah neighbourhood. Meanwhile, US President Donald Trump said he believes a ceasefire in Gaza between Israel and Hamas could be reached within a week. Trump came out with the surprise comment while speaking to reporters on Friday, saying he was hopeful after speaking to some of the people involved in trying to get a truce. "I think it's close. I just spoke to some of the people involved," Trump said, as per Al Jazeera. "We think within the next week we're going to get a ceasefire," the president said, without revealing who he had been in contact with, as per Al Jazeera. There is an understanding, according to many reports, that Netanyahu would have to agree to some sort of ceasefire in exchange for normalisation deals with Arab states, which the Trump administration has promoted. Hamas, on the other hand, requires that Israel stop its war on Gaza and for the Israeli military to withdraw from areas it seized in Gaza after breaking the last ceasefire in March. Trump's ceasefire prediction comes at a time of mounting killings by Israeli forces in Gaza and growing international condemnation of Israel's war amid the latest revelation that soldiers said they were ordered to shoot unarmed Palestinian civilians seeking humanitarian aid in the territory, as per Al Jazeera.
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
an hour ago
- First Post
'Let Bibi go': Trump reiterates support for Netanyahu, calls corruption trial a 'political witch hunt'
Trump has again defended Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, calling the corruption charges against him a 'political witch hunt' and demanding an end to his trial. read more US President Donald Trump has once again expressed support for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who is facing an ongoing corruption trial. Posting on Truth Social on Sunday, Trump described the charges against the Israeli prime minister as 'a political witch hunt.' Trump also criticised prosecutors for what he called a 'terrible trial' against Netanyahu, saying, 'Let Bibi go.' Notably, 'Bibi' is Netanyahu's nickname. 'He is a war hero and a prime minister who did a fabulous job working with the United States to achieve great success in eliminating the dangerous nuclear threat in Iran,' Trump wrote on his social media platform, Truth Social. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'How is it possible that the prime minister of Israel can be forced to sit in a courtroom all day long, over NOTHING (cigars, Bugs Bunny doll, etc.)? It is a POLITICAL WITCH HUNT, very similar to the witch hunt that I was forced to endure. 'This travesty of 'justice' will interfere with both Iran and Hamas negotiations. In other words, it is INSANITY, what the out-of-control prosecutors are doing to Bibi Netanyahu. 'The United States of America spends billions of dollars a year—far more than on any other nation—protecting and supporting Israel. We are not going to stand for this. 'We just had a great victory with Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu at the helm—and this greatly tarnishes our victory. LET BIBI GO, HE'S GOT A BIG JOB TO DO!' Trump added. This isn't the first time Trump has spoken out against Netanyahu's trial. Last week, he made similar comments after a ceasefire was announced between Israel and Iran. What are the charges against Netanyahu? Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu faces several corruption charges, first filed in 2019, including bribery, fraud, and breach of trust. If found guilty, he could face up to 10 years in prison. Case 1000: Netanyahu and his wife, Sara, are accused of accepting lavish gifts worth about $192,000 from businessmen in exchange for political favours. Case 2000: Netanyahu is accused of breach of trust for allegedly striking a deal with newspaper owner Arnon Moses for favourable coverage to weaken his political rival, Israel Hayom. Case 4000: Netanyahu is accused of granting regulatory and financial benefits to the Israeli telecom company Bezeq in exchange for positive coverage of him and his wife on a news website controlled by the company's former chairman. Netanyahu denies all the charges and insists the allegations are part of a 'witch hunt' against him.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Elon Musk renews criticism of Trump's ‘big beautiful bill' as it faces key Senate vote
Elon Musk on Saturday (June 28, 2025) doubled down on his distaste for U.S. President Donald Trump's sprawling tax and spending cuts bill, arguing the legislation that Republican senators are scrambling to pass would kill jobs and bog down burgeoning industries. 'The latest Senate draft bill will destroy millions of jobs in America and cause immense strategic harm to our country,' Mr. Musk wrote on X on Saturday as the Senate was scheduled to call a vote to open debate on the nearly 1,000-page bill. 'It gives handouts to industries of the past while severely damaging industries of the future.' The Tesla and SpaceX CEO, whose birthday is also Saturday, later posted that the bill would be 'political suicide for the Republican Party". The criticisms reopen a recent fiery conflict between the former head of the Department of Government Efficiency and the administration he recently left. They also represent yet another headache for Republican Senate leaders who have spent the weekend working overtime to get the legislation through their chamber so it can pass by Mr. Trump's Fourth of July deadline. Mr. Musk previously made his opinions about Mr. Trump's 'big, beautiful bill' clear. Days after he left the federal government last month with a laudatory celebration in the Oval Office, he blasted the bill as 'pork-filled' and a 'disgusting abomination". 'Shame on those who voted for it: you know you did wrong. You know it,' he wrote on X earlier this month. In another post, the wealthy GOP donor who recently forecasted that he'd step back from political donations threatened to fire lawmakers who 'betrayed the American people". When Mr. Trump clapped back to say he was disappointed with Mr. Musk, back-and-forth fighting erupted and quickly escalated. Mr. Musk suggested without evidence that Mr. Trump, who spent the first part of the year as one of his closest allies, was mentioned in files related to sex abuser Jeffrey Epstein. Mr. Musk ultimately tried to make nice with the administration, saying he regretted some of his posts that 'went too far". Mr. Trump responded in kind in an interview with The New York Post, saying, 'Things like that happen. I don't blame him for anything.' It's unclear how Mr. Musk's latest broadsides will influence the fragile peace he and the president had enjoyed in recent weeks. The White House didn't immediately respond to a request for comment. Mr. Musk has spent recent weeks focused on his businesses, and his political influence has waned since he left the administration. Still, the wealthy businessman poured hundreds of millions of dollars into Mr. Trump's campaign in 2024, demonstrating the impact his money can have if he's passionate enough about an issue or candidate to restart his political spending.
