A message to the major parties: Embrace reform or end up like the Romans
With both parties having announced their flagship policies, it appears that Australia today is following the path of the late Roman Empire: tired, overextended and ruled by an elite political class more interested in voter appeasement than real reform.
The ancient Roman poet Juvenal called it panem et circenses, or 'bread and circuses' – a strategy of appeasing the public with necessities and entertainment to distract them from the real issues and maintain social order while selling future generations up the river.
My home state of Victoria now resembles the Roman province of Britannia in its final years— overburdened with debt, mismanaged by its rulers. But the parallels with ancient Rome are not just rhetorical.
As Professor Frederik Vervaet of the University of Melbourne explains, 'the fall of the Roman Republic could easily have been avoided if the senatorial aristocracy had supported moderate reformers instead of brutally repressing them'.
Vervaet calls it 'reform aversion', the conscious refusal on the part of powerful segments of the senate to embrace undesirable reforms, however pressing the need or justified the cause.
'The aristocracy's reform aversion put the Roman republic on the road to authoritarianism,' he writes in his recent essay How Republics Die.
If our politicians think tinkering around the edges instead of engaging in meaningful reform is enough, well – et tu, delulu.
'Roman politics became marked by escalating polarisation and a rise in factionalism, with the ensuing political deadlocks causing interest groups to divide and lose faith in the traditional political process.'
We see this occurring today, with voters abandoning major parties in favour of more extreme minor parties.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
3 days ago
- ABC News
Australian minister touches down in Solomon Islands amid contest for influence
On the program today Australian Minister for the Pacific, Pat Conroy sets out to reinforce Canberra's ties with Honiara. Papua New Guinea's government announces it will transfer its shares in Panguna Mine back to Bougainville. Fears disinformation around conflicts in the Middle East will create tensions in the Pacific. New Zealand's Foreign Minister calls for a ceasefire in the Middle East. Researchers from Germany and Indonesia identifying seven new species of freshwater crayfish. And the Vice Chancellor of the Solomon Islands National University gives a lecture at the University of Melbourne.
Sky News AU
20-06-2025
- Sky News AU
Australian universities' drop in global rankings is Donald Trump's fault, according to The Guardian
The 2026 QS World University Rankings released on Thursday revealed 25 out of Australia's 36 universities had experienced a substantial fall and equated to the third biggest drop in the world. In The Guardian's article covering the drop, "attacks from Donald Trump" were one of the leading reasons for the slip in standards. "Dozens of Australia's top universities have dropped in a global ranking amid a 'turbulent year' for higher education, as attacks from Donald Trump's second administration exacerbated years of disruption for the embattled sector", The Guardian claimed in the article's opening sentence. The rankings reflected growing competition in the region with institutions across Asia climbing up the charts, including in Hong Kong, Thailand, Malaysia, Taiwan and Vietnam. The University of Melbourne, the country's top higher education institution fell six spots to 19th in the world, with the University of NSW falling to 20th down one and the University of Sydney plummeting from 20th to 25th position. In its coverage of the slump, The Guardian listed 'attacks from Donald Trump's second administration', referring to the US President's crackdown on funding to Australian universities as a prime reason for the poor result. Despite the article detailing a range of local policy issues that have contributed towards Australia's poor performance in the global ranking, The Guardian chose to attack the US President in the opening line of its article. "At least seven Australian universities have had research programs temporarily suspended by the Trump administration this year, while a dozen universities were sent a questionnaire asking to confirm whether they aligned with US government interests," The Guardian wrote. "The chief executive of the Go8, Vicki Thomson, said the results came against a backdrop of global uncertainty and 'mixed messaging' from Australia's largest research partner, the US." Although the US government provides Australian universities with a considerable amount of funding, the federal government's caps on international students and declining government funding of the higher education industry have substantially impacted the operational capabilities of the nation's top tertiary institutions. The Albanese government in mid-2024 announced its plan to cap international student enrolments in 2025 at 270,000 students, with publicly funded universities allocated 145,000 new international student commencements. The federal government also implemented stricter visa and financial requirements for international students, increasing visa fees from $710 to $1,600 dollars in July 2024 with graduate visa restrictions also imposed on international students over 35. The Group of Eight – a coalition of Australia's top universities slammed the move and said at the time the decision had 'significantly damaged the global reputation of Australia's international education sector' and would result in up to $1 billion less revenue for their member universities in 2025. Universities reliant on international enrolments were hit hard by the move, with Macquarie University implementing sweeping course cuts and staff layoffs in late May to bring about short-term savings due to the sudden drop in tuition fees. Macquarie University's proposed cuts will impact 42 FTE (full-time equivalent) roles in arts and 33 in science and engineering, eliminating popular majors like music, politics and archaeology saving $15 million amid declining enrolment rates. QS chief executive Jessica Turner said international education was worth an estimated $51 billion in Australia in 2023-24, and that Australia faced mounting competition from multiple Asia-Pacific countries. 'Emerging markets such as Hong Kong SAR, Malaysia, and the UAE are making impressive strides and steadily closing the gap with more established study destinations,' Ms Turner said speaking to the Sydney Morning Herald. Director of Western Civilisation Program at the Institute of Public Affairs Dr Bella d'Abrera said that campus safety, governance, a rise in antisemitism and free speech concerns were also directly impacting the performance rankings of Australian universities. "It's hardly surprising that Australian universities are slipping down the league tables, they are no longer places of higher learning but have become ideological training camps where free speech is dead, dissent is punished, and students are forced to toe the activist line or risk academic penalties,' Dr d'Abrera said. "Free speech in Australian universities is not just under threat—it's extinct. And until we stop rewarding mediocrity and punishing independent thought, our universities will continue to slide into irrelevance.'
The Age
19-06-2025
- The Age
Iran ruler's iron grip has lasted almost four decades. Who is the man Israel wants to kill?
Khomeini abolished the monarchy in favour of an Islamic republic system he had devised and was soon embroiled in hostilities with the US. The era of the ayatollahs (high-ranking Shiite Muslim religious scholars) began. For years, Khamenei served as Iran's president under Khomeini, until the first supreme leader's death in 1989. Khamenei was then appointed leader, a role in which he has served for nearly four decades. 'That was somewhat controversial at the time because the Iranian Constitution stipulated the education requirements that the supreme leader needed to be a top Islamic scholar,' said Dara Conduit, a University of Melbourne research fellow specialising in Iran and the Middle East. How much control does he wield? Because Khamenei was appointed controversially, he was viewed as weak and lacking credibility at the beginning of his rule. But, said Conduit, he shed that label and has become immensely powerful. Loading Khamenei holds ultimate authority over all branches of government, the military and the judiciary. While elected officials manage day-to-day affairs, no major policy – especially one involving the United States – proceeds without his explicit approval. Iran's hardline Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and the paramilitary Basij answer directly to Khamenei. He exercises control of the Setad, the clandestine state-owned financial enterprise worth tens of billions of dollars. How has he remained in power? His leadership style has blended ideological rigidity with strategic pragmatism. He is deeply sceptical of the West, particularly the US, which he accuses of seeking regime change. Yet he has shown a willingness to bend when the survival of the Islamic republic is at stake. In 2013, Khamenei first mentioned the concept of 'heroic flexibility', which permits tactical compromises to advance his goals. His cautious endorsement of Iran's 2015 nuclear deal with six countries, including the US, was an example of this. Loading He has maintained his concrete grip on power despite disdain from many of his own citizens, according to the Group for Analysing and Measuring Attitudes in Iran, a Dutch independent research group. When Iran president Ebrahim Raisi died in a helicopter crash last year, many Iranians celebrated. And when Israel attacked Tehran last week, some locals partied, chanting 'death to Khamenei'. But he has quelled internal protests by deploying his Revolutionary Guard, notably against the huge 2009 Green Movement protests regarding the disputed re-election of president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Then in 2022, Khamenei arrested, imprisoned and sometimes executed protesters enraged by the death of young Iranian-Kurdish woman Mahsa Amini.
