Residential Tenancies Board's new ICT system €5.2m over budget
The online tenancy registration system was initially budgeted at €3.3m, and came into use in November 2021, but it reached an overall cost of €8.5m, bringing it over budget by 157%.
After the RTB360 system went live, the RTB noted in its annual report that the cost had reached €7.3m but stated that "no further costs are expected for this phase".
However, the commencement of annual tenancy registration in April 2022 saw "significant performance failures" arise for users and further development was required through 2023, with the operation issues resolved towards the end of the year.
Initially, the associated costs for the further development work was estimated at just over €1.1m.
Temporary pause
As a result of these system failures, a temporary pause in the automatic charging of late fees was introduced in November 2022 and remained in place until March 1, 2024.
During 2023, the RTB refunded €1.67m in late fees, while the data on fees refunded in 2024 has not been published.
In the 2023 annual report, it is also noted that the original scope for the system included system requirements for handling disputes and enforcement, which were not included.
The RTB has since "adopted a new approach" to deliver a dispute-resolution system using the ServiceNow platform, with a pilot beginning testing last month.
The first phase of this new system will be delivered within one year and has cost less than €1m to date, according to an RTB spokesperson.
In light of the drastic cost overrun and delay in delivery, the RTB board commissioned an independent external review of the RTB360 project.
A spokesperson told the Irish Examiner that it had "received legal advice that currently prevents us from sharing this report" but said recommendations from the review have been implemented.
Rory Hearne questioned whether State agencies require more support for ICT projects. Picture: PA
Social Democrats TD Rory Hearne submitted a parliamentary question to housing minister James Browne regarding RTB360 but was told the minister has "no official responsibility to Dáil Éireann for this matter".
As the RTB is a State body, Mr Hearne said Mr Browne should be taking responsibility to respond, just as other ministers must when it comes to State agencies being held accountable.
The issues raised by RTB360 and other ICT projects which have resulted in significant overspend beg the question as to whether State agencies require more support and resources when such projects are being undertaken, Mr Hearne added.
Read More
50th anniversary of Seamus Heaney's landmark collection on Troubles to be marked
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Twelve times more properties available for short-term lets than for renters, new figures show
There are 12 times more 'entire' properties available for rent on short-term letting platforms than there are available for long-term living, new figures show. Nearly 22,000 properties advertised on short-term letting websites are offering tourists, holidaymakers, and those heading to concerts and events the opportunity to rent 'entire' houses or properties. This compares to just 1,800 properties or fewer that were available for hard-pressed renters countrywide on Tourism Minister Peter Burke confirmed 34,000 short-term lets were advertised across four platforms in May — up from 33,000 in April. He said 'approximately 64% of these properties are advertised as 'entire' houses and apartments' — about 21,760 properties. In Dublin, some 3,850 (55%) of 7,010 properties available for short-term let offered the entire property. In response to a parliamentary question from Social Democrats housing spokesperson Rory Hearne, Mr Burke said as there was no register, there was 'no way of knowing whether these are people's principal private residences or otherwise'. He also noted there was an annual 10% increase in the short-term letting sector. The number of properties available for renters across the country on has differed over the last week. On Wednesday, there were 1,800 properties countrywide. This dropped to 1,688 properties on Thursday. By Friday, this had fallen further to 1,669, and decreased further to 1,633 on Monday. There were 868 properties for rent on Daft in Dublin on Friday. This fell to 838 on Monday. In May, the same month as the short-term letting data was captured, there were 15,747 people classified as homeless. This included 4,844 children. There were 2,273 families in emergency accommodation. The latest homelessness figures for June rose to 15,915, including 4,958 children and 2,230 families. Mr Hearne told the Irish Examiner the number of properties available shows the 'real negative impact of short-term lets on the housing disaster'. 'There are twice as many entire properties being let as short-term lets (21,760) as the number of households who are homeless (2,320 families and 7,060 individuals),' he said. That we could house everyone in homelessness twice over in the number of full homes being let short-term is a shocking indictment of the Government's housing failures. 'The increasing impact of short-term lets is a result of a rampant lack of regulation and enforcement, resulting from a policy failure on the part of the Government. 'These houses did not just spring up on the market like mushrooms. They were allowed to by policy and a lack of enforcement.' A short-term let is when a property is rented out for periods not exceeding 15 days. Currently, people must apply for planning permission to rent out their principal private residence for less than 14 days at a time. This is not required if the owner rents out the property for fewer than 90 days a year. If the property is not their principal private residence, the 90-day exemption does not apply, and planning permission is needed for the property to become a short-term let. In April, Mr Burke secured Cabinet approval to progress the general scheme of the new Short-Term Letting and Tourism Bill. However, it will not go through the full legislative process in the Oireachtas until later this year. The proposed legislation will introduce a register for all short-term lets from May 2026, with Fáilte Ireland put in charge of implementing and managing the register. Hosts offering accommodation for periods up to 21 nights will be obliged to register and hold a valid registration number. This must be displayed when advertising their property. The legislation will restrict short-term lets in towns with populations of more than 10,000 people. However, people in these towns will still be allowed to rent out their primary residences for up to 90 days. The bill will also introduce sanctions for hosts who do not have a registration number. An administrative financial sanction procedure will also be introduced for platforms that do not comply with their obligations.
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Which TDs and Senators live in rented homes? Why so few? Does it matter?
With as few as eight of Ireland's national politicians living in private rental accommodation, the proportion of TDs and Senators who are renting is significantly lower than among the population as a whole. The plight of renters in Ireland is one of the issues at the forefront of the debate over the housing crisis . The opposition has attacked successive governments for not stemming spiralling rents, which have exceeded an average of €2,000 per month around the country for the first time in 2025. The current Coalition has announced reforms aimed at boosting private investment to build more housing in the hope that this will bring down rents. READ MORE At the same time it is seeking to strengthen tenant protections with a new national system of rent controls and better security of tenure. Just five TDs and three Senators confirmed they are renters in response to a survey carried out by The Irish Times in recent weeks. The TDs are Sinn Féin housing spokesman Eoin Ó Broin , Fine Gael 's Barry Ward and Kiera Keogh , along with Sinéad Gibney and Eoin Hayes of the Social Democrats . The Senators who confirmed they are renting are Laura Harmon of the Labour Party and Anne Rabbitte and Shane Curley of Fianna Fáil . Some others, such as Minister for Housing James Browne and Social Democrats housing spokesman Rory Hearne , own their own homes but confirmed they had been renters for several years. In addition to being renters, both Ward and Gibney are landlords, with one property each. They are two of about 30 landlords among TDs and Senators who indicated they have residential properties in Dáil and Seanad register-of-interests declarations. It would seem that landlords outnumber renters by some distance among the politicians in Leinster House. The eight politicians who rent represent 11 per cent – little more than one in 10 – of the 74 Oireachtas members who responded to the survey. The remainder of the 234 Oireachtas members did not answer the survey, so the precise proportion of renters in Leinster House has not necessarily been revealed. The eight confirmed renters represents just 3 per cent of the overall number of TDs and Senators. Whether the true proportion of renters in Leinster House is closer to 11 per cent or 3 per cent, it is still well below the rate of people living in rental accommodation in Ireland. The proportion of tenants in the private rental sector in the population generally is about one in five or 20 per cent. So, what are the reasons for the low number of renters in Leinster House? For one thing, the age profile in Leinster House tends to be older than the general population – by about 10 years at the start of the last Dáil, when the average age of TDs was 48.5. Ó Broin says younger people are more likely to rent. He also cites those with a modest income; renters where the head of household was born outside of Ireland; and people who owned a home but now rent as a result of relationship breakdown or mortgage distress, as other groups among tenants in the private rental sector. 'In some senses the Oireachtas isn't representative of the population as a whole so its tenure breakdown probably isn't representative either,' says Ó Broin, who notes that people in the Oireachtas 'have significantly higher incomes'. He also says 'any politician who's doing their constituency work properly will engage with large numbers of people in different types of housing situations [including renters]' while adding: 'of course the more representative your parliament is of people's real life experiences, I think, the better.' [ David McWilliams: An answer to Ireland's housing crisis is right behind us Opens in new window ] Ó Broin, now 53, has been renting since he was 18 and has been living in his current home in Clondalkin for 15 years. He has greater security of tenure than many renters. His landlord is the Church of Ireland and the deeds of the property he lives in stipulate that it must not be sold. He is aware that other renters are less secure. 'I deal with lots of cases of people in their 50s and 60s who are renting and when circumstances change they're in very precarious situations.' He is critical of Government efforts to grow the private rental sector, saying 'renting is volatile by its very nature' and, even with rent pressure zones , rents have risen faster than any income increases for most tenants in recent years. Will he ever seek to buy? 'You wouldn't get a mortgage at my age but also the insecurity of the employment [as a TD] is the other thing,' Ó Broin says. 'Buying a house isn't on my radar.' Harmon, who is based in Cork, says she does hope to buy in the coming years but knows she is fortunate to have a tenancy where she is comfortable to be living. 'I do hope to own my own home one day,' she says, but it is 'going to take me a couple of years before I'll be in a position to even look at that'. 'I know that a lot of people are even struggling to find somewhere to rent and somewhere they can afford,' says Harmon, who is a board member of housing charity Threshold She stood in the last general election on a platform of a 'generation who are locked out of the housing market' and says three of her sisters have left the country over the cost of living . 'They didn't see home ownership in their future,' she says. 'A lot of renters do aspire to home ownership but unfortunately that dream is being taken away from them because of the absolute enormity of the cost of homes in this country.' Ward and Gibney fall into a category that can perhaps best be described as accidental landlords. Ward, a TD for Dún Laoghaire, says he was lucky enough to have been able to buy a property in Dublin city before the economic crash and it was his home. However, once he was elected to the Oireachtas, he felt he needed to be living in his constituency and he also got married and started a family. 'It wasn't feasible to live in a one-bedroom apartment outside the constituency any more so we rent out of necessity.' He also says that when he moved out of his property it was in negative equity and he couldn't sell it 'without saddling myself with a significant additional debt'. He rents out the apartment. Ward, who also hopes to buy a house in the future, says his own experience of renting has been positive but that 'doesn't mean that I'm not aware of people who've had very negative experiences renting'. He says he knows this from meeting constituents who may have 'unscrupulous' landlords or be in 'dire financial circumstances' and facing rent increases – an issue he says the Government is seeking to address. [ Lorcan Sirr: How much do landlords in Ireland really earn? You might be surprised Opens in new window ] He also says: 'I think the discussion around landlords in the Dáil can sometimes suggest to people that TDs and Senators are out of touch when in fact nothing could be farther form the truth'. 'We are all in daily contact with people with different circumstances ... so we are very much aware of the pressures that people face around the country and around our constituencies in particular.' Gibney, as TD for Dublin-Rathdown, also owns a property but says: 'When I met and married my now husband our home was no longer appropriate for our blended family and so we now rent and I now rent out my home.' One politician who is neither a homeowner nor a renter is Labour's Eoghan Kenny , the youngest TD in the Dáil, who lives with his grandmother in Mallow, Co Cork. The 25-year-old is not alone among people his age, with almost 70 per cent of them living at home. The Cork North-Central TD says there's a couple of reasons he's living there. 'Number one – it's my home. I've lived there all my life'. But another reason is a 'lack of housing supply' and available rental accommodation in the town. 'I want to live in Mallow where my home base is and where my constituency office is. The only possible way I could live there is by living at home with my grandmother.'
Irish Examiner
2 days ago
- Irish Examiner
‘We need Pride more than ever now': Solidarity and celebration at Cork Pride parade
The Pride movement is needed now more than ever, the 2025 Cork Pride parade heard amid mounting concerns that hard-won rights are being eroded. Organisers of the Cork LGBT+ Pride Festival issued the rallying call on Sunday as an estimated 5,000 people marched in or watched the colourful parade, and its giant rainbow flag, wind its way through the city to the Party at the Port — the climax of the week-long Pride festival, which had as its theme, 'A fearless future'. Damian O'Halloran, vice chair of Cork Pride, said the theme is not just a statement — it's a rhetorical question. 'Can we really have a fearless future, when around the world we are watching the hard-won rights of our communities being stripped away?' he asked. Cork City Council staff and friends at the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. 'So today, we gather not just in celebration, but in solidarity. We gather to say: We will not be silent. We will not be afraid. And we will not be erased.' He praised those previous campaigning generations, and those who marched on Sunday. 'Because showing up is an act of courage. And in doing so, you're helping shape what a fearless future truly looks like,' he said. Speaking to the Irish Examiner after the parade, Mr O'Halloran said progress has been made but added: 'A lot of bullies now have a voice, they are standing up because they are not afraid anymore and when you see leaders across the globe demonstrating rhetoric like that, people aren't afraid anymore to say what they want because there is no sanction. "It's about policy, and that starts with the leadership of the country.' Lisa Lynch, Linda O'Mahony, and Kelly and Aisling O'Sullivan from Glanmire enjoying the Party at the Port on Kennedy Quay after the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. Denise Boyle, chair of Cork Pride, said the community has to keep marching. 'My message to young people here today is to be happy with who you are, and know that there is lots of support out there for you — don't struggle by yourself,' she said. Diarmuid Scully, a member of UCC's LGBT staff network, said that homophobia thrived in the past by dividing people, and making them afraid. Staff from Apple and their families at the 2025 Cork Pride Parade at the Grand Parade, Cork City, on Sunday. 'This sends out a massive signal to people that there is a community here, young and old, and that they are not on their own,' he said. 'There is a very cold wind blowing outside of Ireland. I think it will reach here in some form or another. Social media is the real terrifying thing because it allows 24-hour bullying. Lord Mayor Fergal Dennehy and Lady Mayoress Karen Brennan leading the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. 'The fact that the Pride slogan this year is 'a fearless future' tells its own story, and the theme of Pride in Belfast last week was 'never going back'. 'If you have to have slogans like that, it tells you there is something to fight against but that we will win against it.' Minister of State Jerry Buttimer, who came out as Fine Gael's first gay TD in 2012, said the community, and country has come a long way, with a new generation of people marching, but that people cannot be complacent. 'It's about holding the rights we have and ensuring that people are free to be who they are,' he said. Margarita O'Regan and Emma Clifford walking their dogs at the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. Eimear McNally, 18, who is part of that new generation, said showing support for the rights won by the campaigners of the past, and keeping that support 'strong and present', is very important — especially today. 'People can be afraid to show real solidarity with tough causes right now and this is a day where everyone can express what they want to,' she said. Eurovision Fanclub president Frank Dermody at the 2025 Cork Pride Parade on Sunday. Nick Murphy, a member of the inclusive GAA club Na Laochra Aeracha, said the rise of homophobia is inevitable, given the rise of the far right across the world, and the echo chambers that exist on social media. 'This is why Pride needs to be. As long as people think like that, Pride will always be necessary,' he said. Claire Flynn, of Mammies for Trans Rights, said their group was founded because of concerning rhetoric from some places. 'We didn't want our children standing up and being front and centre, because we were afraid for their safety, so we said, as parents, we can stand up in front of them until it's safe enough for them to stand up,' she said.
