Vancouver short-term rental data at stake in ongoing freedom of information dispute
Rezel filed two requests with the city under the Freedom of Information and the Protection of Privacy Act in 2019, seeking records about Airbnb and other short-term rental operators in Vancouver, including names, addresses and business licence numbers.
The city refused and Airbnb opposed the release, leading to years of legal wrangling involving B.C.'s Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner, and the province's Supreme and Appeal Courts.
ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW
An adjudicator with the privacy office ruled in 2021 that the city wasn't allowed to 'refuse access' to business licence numbers and addresses of short-term rentals, but Airbnb and the city went to court claiming the office was obligated to notify 20,000 short-term rental operators to give them a chance to weigh in on the dispute.
An adjudicator's decision released Wednesday says the commissioner's office is not required to contact the thousands of owners, finding it 'would not be a fair, timely or efficient administration' of the act, and both the city and company could have raised the issue 'as early as possible but failed to do so.'
Rezel says the information he's seeking is likely out of date now, but he plans to continue fighting for access, over the dispute that has evolved from access to housing data to a 'battle for public transparency' and corporate interests versus a citizen's right to access public information.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 8, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
25-07-2025
- Winnipeg Free Press
Maui panel passes bill to curb vacation rentals and boost housing supply after Lahaina wildfire
HONOLULU (AP) — Lawmakers on Maui passed legislation Thursday aimed at eliminating a large percentage of the Hawaiian island's vacation rentals to address a housing shortage exacerbated by the wildfire that destroyed most of Lahaina two years ago. It's the latest action by a top global tourist destination to push back against the infiltration of vacationers into residential neighborhoods and tourism overwhelming their communities. In May, Spain ordered Airbnb to block more than 65,000 holiday listings on its platform for having violated rules. Last month, thousands of protesters in European cities like Barcelona and Venice, Italy, marched against the ills of overtourism. The Maui County Council's housing committee voted 6-3 to pass the bill, which would close a loophole that has allowed owners of condos in apartment zones to rent their units for days or weeks at a time instead of a minimum of 180 days. The mandate would take effect in the West Maui district that includes Lahaina in 2028. The rest of the county would have until 2030 to comply. The council still needs to vote on the bill, but the committee's result is a strong indication of the final outcome because all nine council members sit on the housing panel. The mayor is expected to sign the bill, which he proposed. 'Bill 9 is a critical first step in restoring our commitment to prioritize housing for local residents — and securing a future where our keiki can live, grow, and thrive in the place they call home,' Maui Mayor Richard Bissen said in a statement, using the Hawaiian word for children. Vacation rentals take up one-fifth of Maui's housing Vacation rentals currently account for 21% of all housing in the county, which has a population of about 165,000 people. An analysis by University of Hawaii economists predicted the measure would add 6,127 units to Maui's long-term housing stock, increasing supply by 13%. Opponents questioned whether local residents could afford the condos in question, noting that many of the buildings they are in are aging and their units come with high mortgages, insurance payments, maintenance and special assessment costs. Alicia Humiston said her condo is in a hotel zone so it won't be affected. But she predicted the measure will will hurt housekeepers, plumbers, electricians and other small business owners who help maintain vacation rentals. 'It's not what's best for the the community,' said Humiston, who is president of the Rentals by Owner Awareness Association. Bissen proposed the legislation last year after wildfire survivors and activists camped out on a beach popular with tourists to demand change. Mayor says tourism will continue but must not 'hollow out our neighborhoods' The University of Hawaii study said because only about 600 new housing units are built in the county each year, converting the vacation rentals would be equivalent to a decade's worth of new housing development. Condo prices would drop 20-40%, the study estimated. The report also predicted one-quarter of Maui County's visitor accommodations would disappear and visitor spending would sink 15%. It estimated gross domestic product would contract by 4%. The mayor said such economic analysis failed to tell a full story, noting families are torn apart when high housing costs drive out relatives and that cultural knowledge disappears when generations leave Maui. The mayor told the council the bill was one part of a broader housing strategy that would include building new housing, investing in infrastructure and stopping illegally operated vacation rentals. He said there were limits to how much new housing could be built because of constraints on water supplies and sewer infrastructure. Tourism would continue on Maui but must do so in a way 'that doesn't hollow out our neighborhoods,' the mayor said. The mayor's staff told council members that visitor spending would decline with the measure but most of the drop would be on lodging. Because 94% of those who own vacation rentals in apartment zones don't live on Maui, they said much of this income already flows off-island. They predicted the county budget could withstand an estimated $61 million decline in annual tax revenue resulting from the measure.
National Post
02-07-2025
- National Post
Anyone can now rent Michael Jordan's former mansion, but cash is king
Article content Fans of Air Jordan can check out Airbnb Jordan, but it'll come with at a high cost. Article content NBA great Michael Jordan's former mansion in Highland Park, Ill., is now available for rent on Airbnb, for at least $100,000 along with a seven-night minimum stay, per the U.K. Daily Mail. Article content Article content The rental lists seven bedrooms and 17.5 bathrooms. It costs $105,514 for a stay from Aug. 2-9 (about $15,000 per day) and increases to $120,920 from Aug. 29-Sept. 5 (about $17,000 a day). Article content 'Live like a legend at 2700 Point Ln!' the description for 'Champions Point Legendary Listing' posted by John reads. 'This estate was built with privacy, security, and luxury in mind – a private oasis on 7.39 acres surrounded by mature pines, fenced and gated.' Article content Photos of the property highlight the pool, living room, full kitchen and dining area, seven bedrooms, 15 full bathrooms and five half-bathrooms. Article content 'Enjoy putting on your professional grade putting green, fishing in your private pond stocked with bass and bluegill, and swimming in your zero-entry infinity edge pool!' the listing reads. Article content The 62-year-old Jordan sold the 56,000-foot property last year after listing it for more than a decade. Article content Article content He lived at the property during his time with the Bulls, a team he helped win six titles with in the 1990s. Article content Article content Jordan originally valued the property at $29 million after listing it on the market in 2012. The asking price was lowered to just under $15 million in 2015. Article content John Cooper, of Lincoln, Neb., bought the property last year for $9.5 million, scoring it for less than one-third of the original asking price. Article content 'I remember seeing the home for sale and thinking how cool it would be for the person that buys the home,' Cooper, a general partner at Han Capital, told the Lincoln Journal Star last year. Article content Cooper said at the time he did not plan to live at the property and would have 'exciting plans' to announce in January. Article content 'I am still considering many different uses for the property,' Cooper said to NBC News in a statement. 'Some great uses require zoning relief, but in the meantime, short-term rentals are a permitted use to bring exposure to the property and generate some revenue.' Article content
National Observer
27-06-2025
- National Observer
Trade talks between Canada and US end over digital tax, Trump says
Prime Minister Mark Carney says he did not speak Friday with Donald Trump before the U.S. president announced a sudden end to trade negotiations in response to Ottawa's plans to push ahead with a digital services tax at the end of the month. On his platform Truth Social, Trump wrote that he was "terminating all discussions on trade with Canada" because of the tax, set to apply this Monday to major American online companies such as Amazon, Google and Airbnb. Trump wrote Friday afternoon that Washington will notify Canada about new tariff rates required "to do business with the United States" within the next week. An hour later, Carney told reporters he had not spoken with Trump that day. "We'll continue to conduct these complex negotiations in the best interests of Canadians," the prime minister said. Trump called the proposed tax a "direct and blatant attack on our country." Carney has been negotiating in private with Trump and said earlier this month the two governments are pursuing a deal to end the president's stop-and-go tariff war. At the G7 summit in Alberta, Carney and Trump agreed to work on reaching a deal by mid-July. Prime Minister Mark Carney says he did not speak Friday with Donald Trump before the U.S. president announced a sudden end to trade negotiations in response to Ottawa's plans to push ahead with a digital services tax at the end of the month. The digital services tax is a three per cent levy on revenue from Canadian users of digital services such as Amazon, Google, Meta, Uber and Airbnb. It takes effect on June 30 but is retroactive for three years. The initial bill facing American companies is expected to be close to $2 billion. The United Kingdom kept a similar tax in a trade deal with the U.S. that was signed last week at the G7 summit in Alberta. Trump said similar measures by the European Union would be part of the broader trade talks the U.S. is having with the bloc. In the Oval Office, Trump said Canadians are great people but their government has unfair policies. "Canada has been a very difficult country to deal with over the years," he told reporters. Trump added that Ottawa has less leverage than Washington. "Economically we have such power over Canada. I'd rather not use it, but they did something with our tech companies," he said. "It's not gonna work out well for Canada. They were foolish to do it. And so I said we're going to stop all negotiations with Canada right now, until they straighten out their act." Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre did not weigh in on whether Canada should scrap the digital sales tax. Instead, he suggested Canada should cut its own domestic taxes and levies to unleash more economic growth. "Disappointed that trade talks have halted. Hopefully they resume quickly. As always, Conservatives are ready to help get a good deal for Canada. We must put Canada First," Poilievre wrote on the platform X. In a written statement, NDP trade critic Heather McPherson said Canada should invest in employment insurance and sustainable jobs to protect workers from Trump's whims. "Appeasement doesn't work. Betting on having a unique relationship with Trump doesn't work. Negotiations in secret doesn't work. Standing up for Canadian jobs and communities does," she wrote. In a post on the platform X, Bloc Québécois Leader Yves-François Blanchet blamed Carney for Canada's failure to get the tariffs lifted and suggested he has been distracted by legislation to fast-track the approval of major projects like oil pipelines. The Canadian Chamber of Commerce has urged Ottawa for months to scrap the tax, citing increased costs and the risk of U.S. retaliation. "Negotiations go through peaks and valleys. With deadlines approaching, some last-minute surprises should be expected," chamber head Candace Laing said in an email. "The tone and tenor of talks has improved in recent months, and we hope to see progress continue. We respect that Team Canada is conducting these negotiations at the table, and we need to give them the space to navigate.' The Canadian Press has asked the office of Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne for comment but has not yet received a response. The Business Council of Canada has called on Ottawa to suspend the tax. 'Canada should put forward an immediate proposal to eliminate the DST in exchange for an elimination of tariffs from the United States,' wrote the group's CEO Goldy Hyder, adding Trump's decision is the 'unfortunate development' the group had warned about. Earlier this month, 21 members of the U.S. Congress wrote to Trump saying the digital services tax could inspire other "discriminatory cash grabs" that largely target American companies. But on Thursday, congressional Republicans agreed to remove a so-called "revenge tax" provision from Trump's major tax cut bill, in response to a request from Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. That provision would have allowed Washington to impose taxes on companies and investments from countries charging what it called "unfair foreign taxes" on American firms.
