US appeals court overturns Bored Ape maker's $8.8 mln win in NFT trademark case
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said that Yuga had not yet proven, opens new tab that Ripps and Cahen's tokens — which they called satirical works of appropriation art — would confuse NFT buyers, sending the case back to California federal court for a trial on Yuga's trademark infringement and cybersquatting claims.
Ripps in a statement said the decision "underscores that appropriation is a vital tool for artists to hold powerful entities to account." Yuga called the decision "a win for the industry" that "validates the fight we took on and confirms that BAYC is a strong and recognizable brand."
Yuga accused Ripps and Cahen in a 2022 lawsuit of making millions of dollars from selling counterfeits of its Bored Ape tokens under the pretense of satire. Ripps and Cahen said that their versions of the tokens lampoon allegedly racist and anti-Semitic imagery in Yuga's NFTs and branding.
Yuga denied the allegations and said that Ripps was "spreading ridiculous conspiracy theories online and using them to sell knockoff NFTs."
U.S. District Judge John Walter ruled for Yuga before trial in 2023 and said that Ripps and Cahen's tokens were likely to create confusion in the NFT market. He awarded Yuga $1.5 million in damages, which later ballooned to more than $8.8 million with attorneys' fees and other costs.
The 9th Circuit overturned Walter's decision on Wednesday and said a trial was necessary to determine whether the fake tokens infringed Yuga's trademarks.
The appeals court agreed with Walter, however, that Ripps and Cahen were not immune from Yuga's claims based on First Amendment protections for works of art.
The case is Yuga Labs Inc v. Ripps, 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 24-879.
For Yuga: Todd Gregorian of Fenwick & West
For Ripps and Cahen: Louis Tompros of Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale & Dorr
Read more:
Bored Ape NFT maker Yuga Labs sues artist, claiming he copied tokens
US judge sides with Yuga Labs in Bored Ape NFT trademark lawsuit
Artist owes $1.5 mln in damages for fake Bored Ape NFTs, judge says
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
a few seconds ago
- Daily Mail
Travis Kelce unveils slick new haircut at Chiefs training camp as he ditches long locks ahead of new season
Travis Kelce has freshened up his look while in training camp with the Kansas City Chiefs after ditching his long locks for a fade. The 35-year-old, who is getting ready for his 13th season in the NFL, was sporting a slick new haircut when he emerged for practice with his teammates on Sunday. Kelce is back in football mode after enjoying some downtime in the offseason with girlfriend Taylor Swift, who he will not see for the next three weeks while in camp. Earlier this week he finally went Instagram official with Swift after posting her on his account for the very first time as part of an offseason photo dump. The superstar couple look smitten in a number of the pictures, which show them posing together in a warm setting, clowning around in the snow, skating on an ice rink and out with friends. One of the pictures even sparked engagement rumors after eagle-eyed Swifties spotted that Travis has an image of him and Taylor as the lock screen on his phone. In a photo that shows them out for dinner together, Kelce's phone is lying on the table with his loved-up screensaver clearly visible. And Swift's die-hard legion of fans pointed out how their beloved singer appeared to be holding both hands up to the camera with a ring on her finger. Yet according to TMZ , the pop megastar is actually wearing Kelce's three Super Bowl rings in the picture he saved as his phone background. Unfortunately for Swifties, it is believed that Travis has not yet popped the question to Taylor just yet. After his offseason adventures with Swift, Kelce was back on the practice field on Tuesday as the Chiefs began their preparations for the new NFL season. Up until August 13, the team will be based at Missouri Western State University in St Joseph - around an hour north Arrowhead Stadium. There, Kelce and the other 89 players on the roster will stay in dorms on campus for the duration of camp. That means three weeks without seeing their partners and families. For Travis, that means three weeks without seeing his girlfriend. Kelce and Swift enjoyed a more low-key offseason together than last year, with the pair only making a handful of public appearances since the Chiefs' Super Bowl defeat to the Philadelphia Eagles in February. The most noteworthy of the lot came when Taylor made a surprise cameo at her man's 'Tight End University' event in Nashville last month, where she took to the stage and performed her famous 'Shake It Off' song.
The Sun
a few seconds ago
- The Sun
I've splashed £1million to get the world's smallest waist -all my organs moved around because of it but I'm not done yet
A WOMAN has revealed that she has spent over £1 million trying to get the world's smallest waist. Aleira Avendano, 33 has spent two decades cinching her waist down to just 18 inches, 16 inches smaller than the average British woman's. 2 2 The Florida-based yoga instructor has achieved her tiny waist by wearing a corset, and is determined to beat the current record held by 86-year-old Cathie Jung, whose waist is just 15 inches. Aleira's controversial methods have caused her internal organs to "shift and adjust" to new spots. However, despite the dangers, Aleira, who is originally from Venezuela, isn't ready to quit. "I find it challenging when it comes to buying clothes, as nothing fits," she told NeedToKnow. "My sizes are unique, and I have naturally wide hips." "I have to have clothes custom-made for me. It's been a major investment – enhancements, treatments and healthy food. "A huge commitment. Honestly, my body should be insured." As well as spending £1 million on her waist whittling mission, Aleira has also spent £471,000 on cosmetic surgeries, including seven boob jobs, four nose jobs and veneers. Aleira previously claimed that all woman "should have plastic surgery to be truly beautiful." And despite the health risks, Aleira has encouraged others to try and get a waist like hers. The 45-second trick to get a snatched waist that Love Island star swears by At the start of her waist cinching journey, Aleira wore a corset six hours a day, but she has now ramped this up to 23 hours. Wearing a corset comes with a myriad of issues, such as breathing difficulties, organ compression and muscle atrophy. The model has now launched her own brand of shapewear, to help people achieve her "one of a kind look". "My shapewear line will change many lives" she said. What are the dangers of wearing corsets? Wearing corsets, a fashion practice that dates back centuries, can pose significant medical risks despite their aesthetic appeal. One of the primary concerns is the potential for internal organ damage. Corsets, especially when tightly laced, can compress the ribs and exert pressure on internal organs such as the liver, stomach, and intestines. This compression can lead to displacement and deformation of these organs, potentially causing digestive issues, reduced lung capacity, and impaired circulation. Breathing difficulties are another serious risk associated with corset use. The constriction of the rib cage can limit the expansion of the lungs, leading to shallow breathing and decreased oxygen intake. Over time, this can result in respiratory problems and reduced stamina. In extreme cases, prolonged use of tightly laced corsets can lead to conditions like atelectasis, where parts of the lungs collapse due to inadequate ventilation. Additionally, corsets can affect the musculoskeletal system. The constant pressure and altered posture imposed by a corset can weaken core muscles, leading to muscle atrophy and decreased strength. This can result in long-term back pain and poor posture once the corset is removed. There is also a risk of nerve compression, which can lead to numbness, tingling, and in severe cases, nerve damage. While modern corsets are often designed to be less restrictive than their historical counterparts, the potential health risks remain. It is essential for individuals to be aware of these risks and to use corsets sparingly and with caution. Consulting with medical professionals before incorporating corsets into regular wear can help mitigate some of these risks and ensure that any adverse effects are promptly addressed. "It's a gentle product with incredible results, created by me and inspired by the story of my own body." Aleria added: "I don't miss my old figure at all. "People react in different ways. "Some follow me, some feel nervous, and others admire me or see my body as something crazy." She added that men "can't get enough" of her "exotic" figure.
Daily Mail
a few seconds ago
- Daily Mail
Chrishell Stause weds G-Flip for the FOURTH TIME during Medieval ceremony atop LA 'castle'
Selling Sunset star Chrishell Stause and partner G-Flip renewed their vows, yet again, during their fourth annual wedding ceremony held atop a castle in Los Angeles on Saturday. The Medieval-themed nuptials appeared to be held at the 3,800-square-foot, five-bedroom Mulholland Castle, which can be rented for $18K/month - according to Zillow. Celebrity hairstylist Chris Appleton Instastoried snaps of the Kentucky-born 44-year-old wearing her off-the-shoulder corseted bridal gown and the Australian 31-year-old dressed in a regal red prince costume. 'By royal decree, we request the honor of your noble presence to witness the wedding ceremony of Lord Flipo & Lady Stause,' the bride and groom's invite read. 'Lord Flipo & Lady Stause bid thee join in revelry and royal delight. Medieval, renaissance, regal, and festive attire encouraged. RSVP with haste!' 'Lady Stause' even dyed her own vow scroll with a tea bag and crafted her own bouquet. Chrishell (born Terrina) and G Flip (born Georgia Flipo) secretly tied the knot in Las Vegas, NV in July 2022 without obtaining a marriage license before renewing their vows in Palm Springs, CA in July 2023. Stause and the non-binary rocker - who uses they/them pronouns - renewed their vows for a third time in Melbourne, Australia in July 2024. 'We promised we're going to [renew our vows] every year,' the Daytime Emmy nominee explained to E! News in 2023. 'But just every year, something around the same time, spontaneous, fun, get everybody together and every single year, just celebrate.' On social media, Instagram users were less than thrilled about the couple's attention-getting wedding obsession including @jessicazamprognoo_ who commented: 'Why Chrishell? Why?' Instagram user @bighag007 simply wrote: 'Cringey.' 'In need of attention and trying to be relevant,' Instagram user @cjmrip noted. 'Imagine cosplaying at your own wedding,' Instagram user @blondambitionoo7 wrote. 'Didn't Adrianne Curry already do this?' 'Lady Stause' even dyed her own vow scroll with a tea bag and crafted her own bouquet Instagram user @vittoriac4 commented: 'Oh Chriselle, Chriselle, Chriselle.' 'Performative nonsense,' Instagram user @ruchami955 scoffed. The inseparable pair were dating other people - The Oppenheim Group president Jason Oppenheim and The Bachelorette Australia #7 Brooke Blurton - when the met at a Halloween party in 2021, but they didn't start dating until five months later. G Flip then enlisted Chrishell to be the sultry vixen in their music video for Get Me Outta Here video in 2022. 'I adore you and cherish every second in your presence,' the Disco Cowgirl singer gushed on Instagram last week. 'You're my best friend and the most beautiful partner and wife I could ever dream of. I hope you have a beautiful birthday today and every day my angel - you're a hot lil muffin that lights up the world. You're wusband.' The inseparable pair were dating other people - The Oppenheim Group president Jason Oppenheim (L) and The Bachelorette Australia #7 Brooke Blurton (R) - when the met at a Halloween party in 2021, but they didn't start dating until five months later The Disco Cowgirl singer gushed on Instagram last week: 'I adore you and cherish every second in your presence. You're my best friend and the most beautiful partner and wife I could ever dream of' On June 19, Stause revealed she was 'back on the IVF hell train' and warned it might be her 'last attempt' before they explore 'other alternatives' for children. The Traitors #3 contestant was previously married to This Is Us alum Justin Hartley, but their bitter divorce was finalized in 2021 after nearly two years of wedded bliss. Chrishell has been hard at work filming the ninth season of Adam DiVello's reality show Selling Sunset as well as the fourth season of spin-off Selling the OC, which premieres October 29 on Netflix. G Flip is next scheduled to perform at Montréal Pride on August 8 at 5pm, which will be held on the TD Canada stage in Quebec's Olympic Park Esplanade. On September 5, the Big Ol' Hammer singer will release their third studio album Dream Ride.
