MSD sanctions double, impact on employment unclear
Data released to RNZ after an Official Information Act request shows that there were 3015 times that a client was sanctioned, then recomplied with their obligations and then left the benefit to work.
There were 210 times when a client was sanctioned and then left for work, then recomplied with their obligations. That could include people who found work and then ended up back on the benefit.
Graham Allpress, group general manager of client service delivery, said sanctions and obligations were one part of a broader picture that could contribute to a jobseeker finding work.
He said MSD could not provide data about sanctions that led to someone re-engaging and then finding work because it could not link the sanction and the person finding a job.
'People get jobs because they apply for them, and because they take steps to become ready for work.
'We use sanctions as a last resort if someone is not meeting their obligations, to encourage them to engage with us and get back on track by re-complying their obligations.
'In 2024, 92.8% of sanctions were lifted after the client re-complied with their obligations and got back on track. That is the purpose we use them for.
'If someone gets a benefit and they have work obligations, one of the main things they agree to do is regularly apply for suitable jobs. By meeting their obligations, they maximise their own opportunity to get a job and 'exit to work'.
'We are engaging with more jobseekers more frequently through proactive appointments and Kōrero Mahi seminars. Our support for jobseekers includes training, work assessments or work experience, and help with CVs and applying for jobs.'
In 2018, the then-Labour Government produced a paper on the effects of work-related sanctions.
'Real barriers'
It said that regimes less severe than New Zealand's were effective in increasing movement from benefits to work. But evidence from the UK and US was that very harsh sanctions could have adverse effects that drove people away from employment.
Isaac Gunson, spokesperson for the Child Poverty Action Group, said it was unlikely that so many more people had started missing appointments.
'What seems more likely is that MSD has become quicker to cut people off, despite the very real barriers many face in attending.
'These are people doing their best in tough circumstances. They may not have access to childcare, a working phone, or may simply be confused by the system.
'Pushing people off income support doesn't make the job market fairer or more accessible. It just assumes success is possible while unemployment rises and support systems become harder to navigate.'
Economist Shamubeel Eaqub said there should be clearer ways to determine whether sanctions were having the effect intended.
'How can we be confident they are doing their job?
'I have no problem with them pulling these levers if they're effective. If they're creating a better outcome then of course we should be doing it. But we shouldn't just punish people.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Kinleith pulp and paper mill falls silent
Kinleith pulp and paper mill was opened 71 years ago by Prime Minister Sidney Holland. Photo: Libby Kirkby-McLeod The Kinleith pulp and paper mill in South Waikato was opened by Prime Minister Sidney Holland in 1954. On Monday, 71 years later, the last functional paper-making machine falls silent , with the loss of about 150 jobs. A RNZ documentary about the mill shortly after it opened captured the mood of a booming town, a valuable export industry and cutting-edge technology. Seven decades later, and after many cuts and retrenchments, South Waikato Mayor Gary Petley described the mood in town. "A fair amount of uncertainty, a little bit of angst, because of what has happened, and I think more of a realisation there's not a lot they can do about it," he said. Petley once worked at the mill and he still had two sons employed there. He described the mill in its heyday as a local industry that enabled intergenerational wealth and opportunity. "If your grandfather worked there or your father worked there, there was every probability that the sons or daughters would follow." It led to a vibrant community in Tokoroa. "One of the biggest things for me is the richness of the culture side of things, with all the different races of people, who came here to build Tokoroa and make Tokoroa what it is." You heard this even in the RNZ documentary from the 1950s - there were interviews with mill staff from Canada and Poland. Not that Tokoroa ever wanted to be known just as a mill town. Erica Rowe worked at the South Waikato News in the 1950s and told Rex Sayers that, although locals knew the mill was responsible for most of its growth, they did not want to feel that, without the mill, the town would be non-existent. Tokoroa Mayor Gary Petley once worked in at the mill and still has two sons working there. Photo: Libby Kirkby-McLeod / RNZ That sentiment was echoed today by the owner of local station Cruise Radio, Johnny Dryden. "You need to be mindful now that the mill's not the only large employer in Tokoroa or in the nearby vicinity of Tokoroa," he said. For his part, Dryden felt positive about the town's future. "It's a great area to bring a family up, where you can go and pick your kids up from school, and go and do things in the community." There was no doubt that the end of paper manufacturing would hit some hard. E Tu mill union delegate Ian Farall said everyone was disappointed paper production was finishing. "The fact is this is the last bastion for making paper in New Zealand," he said. "There is no other producer of what we do in New Zealand, so it's not like I can go down the road and get a job." He said working at the mill had enabled him to live a good life and he worried for younger workers who had lost their jobs, knowing several who had given up on New Zealand and moved to Australia. "[It's] not good for those people who have young families and have got no job, and have a mortgage locally and everything like that - that will be a tough time for people." South Waikato Investment Fund Trust (SWIFT) chief executive Clive Somerville said the end of paper production at Kinleith marked the close of an era, one that shaped the South Waikato's identity for generations. Ian Farall: "It's not like I can go down the road and get a job." Photo: Libby Kirkby-McLeod "There's definitely a sense of loss and uncertainty around town, but also deep pride in who we are." However, he said the community was built on primary industry and hard work, and that heart was still strong. "Despite global and national headwinds, there's real momentum here - residential and commercial development is underway. "Project Phoenix is backing displaced workers, and agencies like MSD are stepping up alongside community groups and employers." OJI Fibre Solutions chief executive Jon Ryder said the mill continued with pulp-only production. "Our priority has always been to minimise job losses through redeployments, and to run a thorough and fair process," he said. "Through these efforts and a voluntary redundancy programme, we managed to redeploy more than 30 people within the business and keep the number of compulsory redundancies to less than half of the total." The mill was still in a transition phase for some operations staff and currently reviewing support role requirements, so the final number of job losses was not yet known. "However, we can confirm around 150 employees will depart OjiFS on 30 June." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Newsroom
2 hours ago
- Newsroom
Regaining trust in a world of disinformation
There's been a lot of discussion over the past several years on the lack of public trust in institutions, and the levels of disinformation. The issues are increasingly concerning media organisations as they watch the levels of trust in their work slide. And while the latest figures show that slide may have been arrested, that's a bit like saying the floodwaters have stopped rising – there's still a flood to clean up. RNZ head of podcasts, Tim Watkin, is one media executive tasked with some serious research to work out how to restore trust in journalism. He spent three months at the University of Glasgow's philosophy department and today on The Detail he shares what he's learnt, and what he's telling RNZ's top brass needs to be done. 'If we actually can't trust the information around us, then it is potentially at least society-threatening, democracy-threatening, if not species-damaging,' he says. 'This is really important stuff. So I think we have to fix this. We have to wrestle with it, we have to make it a priority.' But this isn't the first era historically where trust in news outlets has been poor. Watkin says while we are stretching our trust muscles so thin these days, living our lives online and more disconnected from face-to-face transactions, journalism has been in this place before – and has won back trust. 'A hundred years ago … the propaganda out of World War I really had the public sceptical about what they could believe. 'That was the yellow press era, the rise of the tabloids in the UK and the US … [people were] just making stuff up, crazy stories.' Like this one. 'Through the late 1800s in particular and early 1900s, there was a real problem with trust in media. Journalism has often been unreliable, for most of its time in existence. But in the 20th century, journalism really buckled down and earnt trust. If you go back 50 years, the trust stats were way higher than they are now.' Watkin tells The Detail about the importance of a discipline of objectivity to show people journalists can take themselves out of the story to avoid bias; and the pressures that have tempted the media to push the boundaries between facts and opinion. Richard Sutherland is a media executive who's worked in several big New Zealand newsrooms and is currently back at RNZ. But later this year he's going to Estonia, to do an MA in disinformation and societal resilience. 'There's a lot of disinformation out there, and what are you going to do? Shrug your hands up and go 'There's no point fighting back against it' … or do you go, 'We've got to work out how to deal with this',' he says. But why Estonia? Well, it's a western-facing country with an English-language course in combating disinformation, which is of special interest to the nation. Sutherland says Estonia is an interesting case study in rebuilding a country from the ground up, having done so after the break-up of the Soviet Union. There was recognition in 2007 that Russia was flooding the place with disinformation, and as a result a decision was made to teach school children media literacy from a very early age. New Zealand, he suggests, perhaps doesn't see this issue through the same urgent lens, having been isolated by geography for years from war or real sectarian violence. But he says while 100 years ago that may have given us a degree of protection, it doesn't any more. 'The internet means the bad actor can be sitting 12,000 miles away and still have an impact on you. 'These guys know what it's like when things are bad, they don't want to go back. 'In the 1940s there was a great mass deportation of people from Estonia and the other Baltic states. Tens of thousands of people were shipped off to Siberia and most of them never came back. So every family now has a story about a great uncle or a grandmother or a grandfather shipped off by the Russians to Siberia and never returned. 'So when you have that kind of theme running through your national story, it focuses your mind on, 'Well, we did that once. We didn't like it. And we're not going back.'' Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here. You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
The Detail: Kiwi journos tackling issue of distrust in NZ media
Media executive Richard Sutherland and RNZ head of podcasts Tim Watkin. Photo: Davina Zimmer There's been a lot of discussion over recent years on the lack of public trust in institutions and the levels of disinformation. The issues increasingly concern media organisations, as they watch the levels of trust in their work slide. While the latest figures show that slide may have been arrested , that's a bit like saying the floodwaters have stopped rising - there's still a flood to clean up. RNZ head of podcasts Tim Watkin is one media executive tasked with serious research to work out how to restore trust in journalism. He spent three months at the University of Glasgow's philosophy department and, on The Detail , shares what he's learnt and what he's telling RNZ's top brass needs to be done. "If we actually can't trust the information around us, then it is potentially at least society-threatening, democracy-threatening, if not species-damaging," he says. "This is really important stuff, so I think we have to fix this. We have to wrestle with it, we have to make it a priority." This isn't the first era historically where trust in news outlets has been poor. Watkin says, while we are stretching our trust muscles so thin these days, living our lives online and more disconnected from face-to-face transactions, journalism has been in this place before - and has won back trust. "A hundred years ago... the propaganda out of World War I really had the public sceptical about what they could believe. "That was the yellow press era, the rise of the tabloids in the UK and the US... [people were] just making stuff up, crazy stories." Like this one . "Through the late 1800s in particular and early 1900s, there was a real problem with trust in media. Journalism has often been unreliable, for most of its time in existence, but in the 20th century, journalism really buckled down and earnt trust. "If you go back 50 years, the trust stats were way higher than they are now." Watkin tells The Detail about the importance of a discipline of objectivity to show people journalists can take themselves out of the story to avoid bias - and the pressures that have tempted the media to push the boundaries between facts and opinion. Richard Sutherland is a media executive who's worked in several big New Zealand newsrooms - he's currently back at RNZ, but later this year, he will travel to Estonia to do an MA in Disinformation and Societal Resilience. "There's a lot of disinformation out there and what are you going to do?" he says. "Shrug your hands up and go, 'There's no point fighting back against it', or do you go, 'We've got to work out how do deal with this'.". Why Estonia? Well, it's a western-facing country with an English-language course in combating disinformation, which is of special interest to the nation. Sutherland says Estonia is an interesting case study in rebuilding a country from the ground up, after the break-up of the Soviet Union. There was a recognition in 2007 that Russia was flooding the place with disinformation and, as a result, a decision was made to teach school children media literacy from a very early age. New Zealand, he suggests, perhaps doesn't see this issue through the same urgent lens, after being isolated by geography for years from war tearing down our cities or real sectarian violence. He says, while 100 years ago, that may have given us a degree of protection, it doesn't any more. "The internet means the bad actor can be sitting 12,000 miles away and still have an impact on you. These guys know what it's like when things are bad, they don't want to go back. "In the 1940s, there was a great mass deportation of people from Estonia and the other Baltic states. Tens of thousands of people were shipped off to Siberia and most of them never came back, so every family now has a story about a great uncle or a grandmother or a grandfather shipped off by the Russians to Siberia, and never returned. "When you have that kind of theme running through your national story, it focuses your mind on, 'Well, we did that once, we didn't like it and we're not going back'. "The disinformation piece the Estonians are working on is very much based on that." Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter .
