Noel Leeming 'perplexed' over misleading advertising charges
The Commerce Commission has filed criminal charges against retailer Noel Leeming over what it says is a misleading price matching promotion.
Noel Leeming is a subsidiary of The Warehouse Group.
"For over a decade Noel Leeming has prominently promoted their 'Price Promise,' which is their commitment to match any competitors' price. We believe their price promise claim was misleading and in breach of the Fair Trading Act," Commerce Commission deputy chair Anne Callinan said.
"We believe Noel Leeming's price promise had many limitations and conditions which weren't made obvious to customers and made any price matches difficult to obtain.
"Fine print should not contradict advertising claims or be used to conceal important information which could be critical to a person's decision to buy goods or services."
Noel Leeming chief operating officer Jason Bell said the company "firmly" maintained it had not committed an offence and would vigourously defend itself against multiple charges of misleading customers under the Fair Trading Act.
"We're perplexed by the Commission's claim that price matches were difficult to obtain, when over 250,000 Kiwis saved money with our Price Promise between 2019-2021," he said.
"Our terms and conditions are fair and presented just like other retailers, and when we can't price match, we often don't get the sale."
Callinan said Noel Leeming had previously been one of the regulators most complained about traders involving a range of issues raised by consumers.
The commission had also filed charges against Noel Leeming regarding promotions where the advertised product or price was different to what could be purchased.
Other charges against Noel Leeming involved incorrect or misleading information about consumers' rights under the Consumer Guarantees Act, when customers complained about faulty products.
"We expect big businesses to be clear and honest in their advertising," she said.
"Consumers should be able to trust the information they receive when they are buying goods and services."
The maximum penalty for a single breach of the Fair Trading Act was $600,000 for businesses.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
11 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Helius and Elysian to continue merger after Cannabis Clinic withdrawal
'I think these things happen when you're looking at mergers and going through that process, you get to learn more about how the entire structure would work, about each other's cultures and how we approach things, we understand more about each other's businesses as well,' Alzaher said. 'That's why we mutually agreed and reached the conclusion that it would be better for us to work independently.' Dr Waseem Alzaher, CEO and co-founder of the Cannabis Clinic, says it will be better for the businesses to work independently towards their shared goal. Alzaher said the proposal had been spoken about between the parties for about two months before the announcement to the public. After a further three weeks deep-diving on the proposal and deciding on how it would work, the decision was made for it not to proceed. Alzaher said the decision to communicate proactively about the proposal was because of Helius Therapeutics' shareholders and its responsibility to keep them involved, and he said he would do the process the same if given another opportunity. 'We're still open to partnerships, to collaboration, to investment, to coming together, so that one plus one equals 10. 'The bigger picture for us is revolutionising healthcare, how healthcare is delivered, the systems, the expectations, how it's centred around people. 'That's a big mission. Our big area audacious goal is to have a million long-term clients with us, and that's not going to happen overnight.' As for what didn't work between Cannabis Clinic and Helius Therapeutics, Alzaher said that their business cultures and visions were not necessarily aligned. He viewed Cannabis Clinic as a 'rebel' and a 'misfit' trying to disrupt the system, and said the business' time could be better spent helping more Kiwis instead. Alzaher said he could see the businesses working together in the future, although not in the 'foreseeable future'. 'With Helius they've got products that are New Zealand made and we're still distributing them. We see them as a strategic partner for us moving forward. 'They believe in what we're doing, we believe in what they're doing, and we're still talking to each other and on good terms.' Helius Health chairman Guy Haddleton previously said the industry long needed a reset. Photo / File Merger moves on Despite the mutual decision for Cannabis Clinic to pull out of the proposed merger, Helius Therapeutics and Elsyian Group/CannaPlus have confirmed a two-way merger will now take its place. Helius Therapeutics financial officer Bruce McEwen said the businesses expect to settle in August. 'What happens now – it's full steam ahead with the execution of the new strategy and the merger with CannaPlus," McEwen said. 'Whilst it's now a two not three-way merger and reduces overall scale, it doesn't change the direction or effectiveness of the strategy. It does however make it simpler, enabling us to move faster.' McEwen said Helius Therapeutics shareholders were firmly behind the strategy pivot to vertically integrate and the proposed two-party merger. He said Helius Therapeutics and Cannabis Clinic had a strong mutual respect for each other and continued to be key business partners. 'After careful consideration we mutually agreed not to proceed with the proposed merger between Helius Therapeutics and Cannabis Clinic. 'Whilst there is strong alignment around increasing access to medicinal cannabis and reducing the stigma, we agreed that was better achieved independently.' Helius Health chairman Guy Haddleton was unavailable for comment. Elysian executive chairwoman Eva Piëch said the fundamentals of the transaction remained intact. 'The transition to a two-party merger between Elysian and Helius is a deliberate and strategically focused decision. It enhances clarity, accelerates execution, and strengthens alignment – not only operationally, but philosophically,' Piëch said. 'This structure allows for faster execution, clearer governance and greater strategic clarity. Our infrastructure, patient network and digital platform remain core to the combined strategy.' Piëch said that as discussions matured with Cannabis Clinic, it became clear a three-party integration would introduce operational complexity and dilute strategic focus – without materially strengthening the core proposition. She said the two-party plan would preserve strategic coherence and allow the pair to integrate with speed, purpose and precision. 'This two-way merger creates a clean, tightly aligned platform – one that enables rapid integration, strategic coherence and a stronger foundation for long-term innovation and growth.' Tom Raynel is a multimedia business journalist for the Herald, covering small business, retail and tourism.
NZ Herald
13 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Watch: Fonterra boss points finger at international prices and supermarkets in butter meeting with Wills
When asked whether anything raised in the meeting would lead to lower prices, Willis said, 'All roads lead back to supermarket competition.' 'I continue to believe that is the most powerful lever the Government has on this issue. We will never be able to control global dairy prices, but we can influence the amount of competition in New Zealand's grocery sector,' Willis said. Willis said she had three main reflections on her conversation, the first was that 'the large proportion of the price of butter at the supermarket is dictated by global demand for butter'. 'There's a story to tell there: butter, which was once an unfashionable product, has gone into huge demand globally and that's reflected in the price people are willing to pay for it internationally,' she said. She had been told by Hurrell that when the global dairy price comes down, butter prices in New Zealand are expected to come down too. She added that high prices had a positive upside. 'It's worth noting that when the price is high that is hundreds of millions of dollars of export revenue coming into our country,' Willis said. The second issue raised was retailers. 'What Miles acknowledged, and what every New Zealander can see, is that supermarkets make choices about what margin they charge for butter. Now this is at the margin, it is a small proportion of the overall price that you pay, between 5% and 10% of the overall price shared between Fonterra and the retailer. 'What is clear is that different retailers make different decisions about what margins they charge,' Willis said. Willis, who once worked for Fonterra, revealed the fact she was meeting Hurrell last week. While the meeting was already scheduled, she let it be known she planned to raise the cost of butter with him. The third point raised by Hurrell was that the dairy giant was itself squeezing costs out of the system to ensure prices could be lower for shoppers. On Wednesday, she expressed regret that the significance of the meeting had spiralled out of proportion. 'I've been very surprised at the almost breathless excitement of the blow by blow of what happened in that meeting,' Willis said. It is not clear what, if anything, Fonterra could do to lower the cost of butter, given the main driver of the price Kiwis pay is the price our dairy fetches on the international commodities market. Willis praised the success of these exporters in Parliament on Wednesday, noting exporters, including dairy, are delivering an export-led economic recovery.
Techday NZ
14 hours ago
- Techday NZ
Skittles Cloudz launch dazzles Auckland commuters with colour
MARS has launched a new product, Skittles Cloudz, in New Zealand, accompanied by a digital campaign on the MetService website and a transformation at Britomart Station in Auckland. The new product introduces a "soft-format twist" on the established Skittles brand, offering consumers a chewy variant described as texturally distinct from the original sweets. MARS has promoted Skittles Cloudz with a multi-channel approach targeting commuters and online audiences during winter. Winter campaign As part of the campaign, Britomart Station, the busiest train hub in Auckland, underwent a visual makeover. This activation provided free samples to commuters and incorporated a "colour therapy experience" intended to counteract the effects of winter on mood. The visual elements drew inspiration from both colour and taste therapy, aiming to lift the spirits of Auckland rail users during the season's shortest days. The initiative also included a unique digital element: for a limited period, the MetService website displayed Skittles-themed weather updates. These updates presented typically straightforward weather information in a colourful, interactive format intended to stand out against the usual winter gloom. The campaign was designed to coincide with high rates of weather-checking during the colder months. According to MARS, this combination of visibility at physical locations and digital platforms is part of a broader strategy to reach consumers in both their daily commutes and online routines. Product launch details Skittles remains a popular choice among New Zealand consumers, with Kiwis purchasing more than one million bags of the original product last year. The launch of Skittles Cloudz marks the first new textural variant of the brand introduced in New Zealand since Skittles entered the market in 2003. The new product maintains the signature fruity flavours associated with Skittles while introducing a soft, bouncy texture. "Kiwis aren't just looking for new flavours, they want new textures too. The new product reflects growing demand for new sensory experiences in confectionery. It offers a soft, bouncy chew that's completely different to the original, but still delivers those familiar fruity notes that Skittles fans love." Shane Hammond from MARS highlighted the company's approach, stating, "Our takeover of Britomart Station was about more than just product, it's about creating a moment of brightness in people's everyday routine; connecting them with moments of everyday happiness." Consumer engagement The Britomart activation allowed Auckland commuters to be among the first in New Zealand to sample the new Skittles Cloudz. The digital takeover of MetService presented colourful weather updates which MARS described as designed to bring "an unexpected moment of cheer" for those checking forecasts during the winter months. Hammond emphasised the campaign's focus on well-being and small, positive sensory experiences: "We know that even small sensory experiences can make a difference to how people feel, especially during the darker months. If we can help bring a bit of joy and colour to someone's commute, then we've achieved something worthwhile." He continued, "At its core, this is a reminder that well-being doesn't have to be complicated. Sometimes a burst of colour, a familiar taste or a light-hearted moment can help lift someone's day, and that's a powerful thing during winter." MARS' campaign integrates physical and digital engagement, reflecting shifts in consumer expectations regarding brand interactions and the use of online platforms beyond conventional retail environments. The activation also demonstrates the use of behavioural insights, such as seasonal mood and weather-checking habits, in designing marketing campaigns that seek to create "micro-moments of joy" throughout consumers' daily routines. Follow us on: Share on:
