
How an NYC wine company helped take on Trump's tariffs and won, at least for a day
But Schwartz and his company VOS Selections are the lead plaintiffs in a legal battle against some of Donald Trump's tariffs, in a case which could have economic implications across the world.
"I didn't start my company with the idea of like I'm going to sue the president of the United States some day," Schwartz told CBC News. "That was not my goal in life. I just wanted to bring in really nice wine to sell to people that enjoyed them."
Yet Schwartz's company was instrumental in landing a serious legal blow against Trump's tariff policies on Wednesday, when a court ruled the administration had exceeded its right to impose some of those tariffs and had to stop collecting them.
Short-lived victory
The victory, however, was short lived when, a day later, a U.S. federal appeals court granted an emergency motion that would allow the administration to continue the tariffs, at least temporarily.
Schwartz seemed to take the reversal in stride.
"That's just part of the process. It's not like we thought we won the case after that decision [Wednesday] This process, we knew was going to be appealed," he said.
In February, Trump invoked the 1977 International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) to impose tariffs on Canada, Mexico and China, saying that the illegal flow of immigrants and drugs across the U.S. border amounted to a national emergency and that the three countries needed to do more to stop it.
Last month, Trump also cited the IEEPA when he imposed what he referred to as "reciprocal" tariffs which, he said, were needed to address the U.S. trade balance with other countries. He later suspended those tariffs for 90 days to give countries time to agree to reduce barriers to U.S. exports.
In its ruling Wednesday, a three-judge panel at the New York-based U.S. Court of International Trade, found that the president had exceeded his authority when he invoked that act.
The ruling came in a pair of lawsuits. One was filed by the nonpartisan Liberty Justice Center on behalf of five small U.S. businesses, including VOS Selections, which import goods from countries targeted by the tariffs. The other lawsuit was filed by 12 U.S. states.
Schwartz says when the first decision came down on Wednesday he wasn't exactly sure what it meant until a lawyer friend explained it to him.
"Then I was pretty elated, and I knew it was a really good thing for everybody, for us, for small businesses across the country, and for world trade, you know?" he said.
The tariffs are "really just a terrible, terrible impact on what we're trying to do here."
He celebrated in his Manhattan apartment with his wife, and of course a special bottle of wine, a vermentino from France.
His company, which he runs with his daughter Chloe, imports wines from 16 countries and distributes them to neighbouring states. Schwartz says he runs a family company that works with family operations and family farms in Europe and the U.S.
Asked to join the case
Schwartz says he didn't seek legal redress but found out through a family member that Ilya Somin, a constitutional law professor at George Mason University, was going to be bringing a case against the tariffs. Schwartz says he contacted Somin just to tell him about what was going on in his industry and that Somin was very interested to hear his story.
"Long story short, they asked me to join the case and then eventually asked me to be their lead plaintiff," he said. "That's really how it evolved. I'm a very unintentional plaintiff here. I didn't go out looking for this fight."
WATCH | Carney welcomes ruling blocking some Trump tariffs:
Carney welcomes U.S. court decision blocking some Trump tariffs
9 hours ago
Duration 11:51
Prime Minister Mark Carney says a U.S. court decision that struck down some of Donald Trump's tariffs shows that they were 'unlawful as well as unjustified.' A three-judge panel ruled the president overstepped his constitutional authority by using emergency powers to impose sweeping levies on global goods.
He says the first time he read the legal complaint, with his company's name on it, he laughed "kind of crazily."
"'VOS Selections versus Trump.' It was like a kind of dream," said Schwartz.
"It was 'Wow, this is amazing.'"
Meanwhile, Somin, the law professor, said in his blog on Thursday that the appeal court ruling was not an indefinite stay, but a temporary block while a decision is made over whether a more permanent stay, pending appeal, should be implemented.
If the case eventually makes its way to the Supreme Court, Somin told CBC News that his team is "guardedly optimistic" they will prevail.
He says he was not surprised by Wednesday's ruling. Somin says that, during oral arguments a couple of weeks ago, the judges seemed to make it pretty clear that they did not accept the administration's claim that the president "essentially has the power to impose any tariffs he wants on any country at any time for any reason, for as long as he wants, as long if he feels like it."
That, said Somin, is a "massive power grab."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
26 minutes ago
- CTV News
Sask. premier advises Canada not to retaliate against new tariffs
WATCH: As U.S. President Donald Trump calls for higher tariffs, Sask. Premier Moe says Canada should not retaliate. Wayne Mantyka has the details.


CTV News
26 minutes ago
- CTV News
Portage Place, Air Canada Window Park: construction at Portage and Carlton
CTV's Harrison Shin gives an update on the current progress of the Portage Place redevelopment. CTV's Harrison Shin gives an update on the current progress of the Portage Place redevelopment. A construction project in Winnipeg is set to change the downtown landscape. 'It is part of an over a billion-dollar injection into our downtown, and it's going to be transformative,' said Sean Kavanagh, senior director of strategic communications of True North Real Estate and Development (TNRED). The centre court, food court and skywalk at Portage Place were closed as of mid-July, while some of the existing retail stores will remain open. TNRED intends to build a new building called 'Healthcare Centre of Excellence,' featuring multiple health care services. 'MRI, CT, diagnostics, day surgery, clinics, Pan Am Clinic—it will be a whole host of health services that will be available,' Kavanagh explained. The plan also includes affordable housing with the Southern Chiefs' Organization, based on call to action #92 of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada. The housing tower is projected to have more than 200 units, with up to 40 per cent of the units rented out at affordable rates. Kavanagh said the construction's impact won't be too heavy. 'They're doing work at Air Canada Window Park next door, and the lane has been closed for a year anyway,' he said. 'Fortuitously, with the Transit Master Plan, the amount of busses actually coming down Portage Avenue has subsided substantially.' Air Canada Window Park was fenced off in September 2024 and demolished. Construction has been ongoing, and the city says it is on track to be done by late September this year. The redevelopment of Portage Place will unfold over the next three to four years, according to TNRED.


Globe and Mail
26 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Ford's Earnings Call: Record Revenues Amid Challenges
Ford Motor Company ((F)) has held its Q2 earnings call. Read on for the main highlights of the call. Elevate Your Investing Strategy: Take advantage of TipRanks Premium at 50% off! Unlock powerful investing tools, advanced data, and expert analyst insights to help you invest with confidence. The latest earnings call from Ford Motor Company presented a mixed sentiment, reflecting both commendable achievements and notable challenges. The company reported strong revenue performance and market share gains, alongside strategic improvements in cost efficiency and credit performance. However, it also faced significant challenges, including tariff headwinds, quality and recall issues, and pressure in the commercial vehicle market. Record Revenue Achievement Ford reported a record $50 billion in revenue for the second quarter, underscoring the strength of its product lineup. This milestone highlights the company's ability to leverage its diverse offerings to capture market demand effectively. Ford Pro Performance Ford Pro's revenue grew by 11% to nearly $19 billion, achieving a 12.3% EBIT margin. This growth was driven by a robust product lineup and disciplined pricing strategies, showcasing Ford's strategic focus on its professional segment. Market Share Gains Ford increased its market share in the U.S. by 1.7 points sequentially, marking the best sales quarter for trucks in 20 years. This gain reflects the company's competitive positioning and strong consumer demand for its truck offerings. Improved Cost Efficiency Ford achieved its fourth consecutive quarter of year-over-year cost improvement, excluding the impact of tariffs. This demonstrates Ford's commitment to operational efficiency and cost management. Positive Credit Performance Ford Credit delivered $645 million of EBT, up $300 million, supported by a strong financing margin and receivables growth. This performance underscores the strength of Ford's financial services arm. Strong Free Cash Flow Ford generated $2.8 billion in adjusted free cash flow, maintaining a strong balance sheet with $28 billion in cash. This financial strength provides Ford with flexibility to invest in future growth opportunities. Tariff Headwinds Ford expects tariffs to be a net headwind of about $2 billion for the year, impacting adjusted EBIT. This challenge highlights the external pressures affecting Ford's profitability. Recall and Quality Challenges Ford faced a record number of recalls, although many were software-related, which are less costly than mechanical recalls. This indicates ongoing quality control challenges that the company needs to address. Model e Margin Pressure Despite revenue growth, Model e faced margin pressure due to high fixed costs associated with EV production. This reflects the broader industry challenge of balancing growth and profitability in the electric vehicle market. Price Pressure in Commercial Vehicles Pricing pressure was noted in the commercial van segment, although full-size pickup pricing remained strong. This suggests competitive dynamics in certain segments of Ford's commercial vehicle offerings. Forward-Looking Guidance Ford updated its full-year guidance, expecting adjusted EBIT between $6.5 billion and $7.5 billion, with adjusted free cash flow forecasted at $3.5 billion to $4.5 billion, despite a net tariff headwind of approximately $2 billion. The company highlighted a record quarterly revenue of $50 billion, with adjusted EBIT at $2.1 billion. Ford Pro maintained strong performance, while Model e more than doubled its revenue, achieving significant margin improvement. Ford also emphasized ongoing cost improvements and a reduction in CO2 credit purchases. In summary, Ford's earnings call presented a balanced view of its current performance and future prospects. While the company celebrated record revenues and market share gains, it also acknowledged challenges such as tariff impacts and quality issues. The forward-looking guidance reflects Ford's strategic focus on sustaining growth and improving operational efficiency amidst external pressures.