Wimbledon chiefs release statement after technology cock-up left players fuming
Wimbledon issued a grovelling apology for an embarrassing failure in their new Electronic Line Calling (ELC) system. But not before Russian Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova accused the German umpire of being 'scared' to make a decision against 'local' Sonay Kartal.
For the first time this year human line judges have been replaced by automated line calling at SW19. But 'human error' still exists as a worker failed to switch on the system for three crucial points at 4-4 in the first set of the fourth-round tie.
Kartal's backhand was clearly long on game point but there was no call - and official Nico Helmerth ordered the point to be replayed instead of giving the point to the Russian.
Pavlyuchenkova's serve was broken and at the next changeover she complained: 'They stole a game from me. Because she is local, they can say whatever.'
Nearly six hours after the incident, a spokesperson for the All England Club said: 'It is now clear that the live ELC system, which was working optimally, was deactivated in error on part of the server's side of the court for one game by those operating the system. We have apologised to the players involved. We continue to have full confidence in the accuracy of the ball tracking technology.'
But Jack Draper and Emma Raducanu have both slammed the accuracy of the ELC. And former world No.11 Pavlyuchenkova, who went on to win 7-6 6-4, said: 'It was very confusing in the beginning because the ball looked very long to me. I just also thought the chair umpire could take initiative. That's why he's sitting in the chair.
"Otherwise, I think soon let's just play without them, right, and then we're going to have everything automatic. He also saw it out, he told me after the match. I think he felt bad a little bit.
'He probably was scared to take such a big decision. They're very good at giving fines, though, and code violations. This they don't miss because every time any little thing, they are just right there on it. Yeah, I would prefer they looked at the lines and call in the errors, mistakes better.
'I think we losing a little bit of the charm of actually having human being, ballboys. Like during Covid, we didn't have ballboys. It just becomes a little bit weird and, like, robot sort of orientated.'
She also called for changes in the system. 'It's such a big match, big event,' the Russian added. 'So much invested into this, we should probably have better,. I think we should have a VAR system like in football so then it's clear for everybody instead of just guessing.'
Asked if she thought her backhand was out on the controversial point, Kartal said: "It's unfortunate for me. I'm quite short, so where the net tape is, a lot of the time I lose my vision. That kind of covers the baseline. From where I was, I couldn't see.'
After her first appearance on Centre Court, Kartal has the consolation of overtaking Emma Raducanu to become the new British No.2 and banking £240,000.
'I wish that is the amount I took in my pocket, but obviously I've got a lot of stuff to pay before I take home anything,' she said. 'This week I've proved to myself that I can go deep into slams, I can beat some of the best players on tour.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Djokovic names two Wimbledon 'favourites' after learning quarter-final opponent
Novak Djokovic insists he is not the favourite to win Wimbledon despite others suggesting he is - instead highlighting defending champion Carlos Alcaraz as the ones to watch out for Novak Djokovic has cooled suggestions he is the man to beat at Wimbledon - instead citing defending champion Carlos Alcaraz as one of two "favourites" to claim the top prize at SW19. The former World No.1 has lost the last two finals at the All England Club, both of them to the Spaniard. Djokovic is again into the last eight after seeing off Alex de Minaur on Sunday, despite losing the first set, but has backed some of his rivals to be ahead of him in the pecking order. Djokovic sees Alcaraz and three-time Grand Slam champion Jannik Sinner as the two men to beat. They just played out an epic in the French Open final with Alcaraz winning in five sets, but the level of tennis left everyone stunned and they sit as the top two seeded players. Despite that the veteran 38-year-old has been cited by his former coach Goran Ivanisevic as the one they all need to watch out for in London. He claimed Djokovic was "the best grass-court player" - which is backed up by his seven championships - but the sixth seed insists others are ahead of him. The Serbian said: "I love Goran, and I'm happy he loves me back, but I don't think I'm a favourite against these guys at the moment. I think they are, both of them. "But I do probably have my best chance here against them here, yeah. If it comes down to me facing one of them or two of them, which I hope so, it means I would proceed to the final and then yeah, I'll obviously look for my best game to win. I do think have a chance. There's no doubt about it. I think my results on grass even in the previous years are a testament to my confidence on this surface. "I've been playing some really good tennis this year. So I feel good about myself. I feel confident. I feel motivated to go all the way. Let's see what happens." Djokovic hasn't won a Grand Slam since he won the US Open in 2023. Last year marked only the second time in 14 years where he didn't win one. It means he's looking to end what is, by his high standards, a hefty drought as he eyes more history. The Serbian will face Flavio Cobolli in the next round but his last four opponent is likely to be Sinner. Only recent at Roland Garros did Sinner beat Djokovic handsomely in the semi-finals. The Italian though survived a scare when he was handed a walkover in a match against Gregor Dimitrov in which he was two sets behind on Sunday. Alcaraz meanwhile has dropped four sets in his four matches so far. Quarter-Final Matches Jannik Sinner vs Ben Shelton Flavio Cobolli vs Novak Djokovic Taylor Fritz vs Karen Khachanov
South Wales Argus
an hour ago
- South Wales Argus
Wimbledon briefing: Monday recap, day nine order of play and ‘nightmare' Norrie
The quarter-finals begin on Tuesday, with women's world number one Aryna Sabalenka opening play on Centre Court before Britain's last remaining singles hope Cameron Norrie tackles defending men's champion Carlos Alcaraz. Here, the PA news agency looks back at Monday's action and previews day nine of the Championships. Djokovic wakes up to down De Minaur Novak Djokovic had to overcome a shaky start (Mike Egerton/PA) Novak Djokovic recovered from his worst first set at Wimbledon to battle past Alex De Minaur in four sets and reach a 16th quarter-final in SW19. The seven-time champion made 16 unforced errors, including four double faults, and dropped serve three times as he lost the first set 6-1. Bu the Serbian remains on a semi-final collision course with Jannik Sinner, who appeared to be heading for an early exit before Grigor Dimitrov suffered a heartbreaking injury. The 34-year-old Bulgarian was two sets up and playing some inspired tennis when, at 2-2 in the third set, he clutched his chest after serving an ace and was forced to retire injured. World number one Sinner, who helped Dimitrov pack his rackets away and carried his bag off court, said: 'I don't take this as a win at all. This is just a very unfortunate moment to witness for all of us.' In the zone Mirra Andreeva did not immediately realise she had won (John Walton/PA) Mirra Andreeva was so focused on continually winning the next point that she did not realise she had won. The 18-year-old Russian swatted aside Emma Navarro in straight sets to reach her first Wimbledon quarter-final. But, in front of her hero Roger Federer, she was oblivious to the fact the umpire was announcing her as the winner. 'I kept telling myself I'm not the one who is up on the score, I am the one who is down,' she explained. 'That helped me to stay focused and in the end I completely forgot the score. 'I'm happy that I did it because I think I would have been three times more nervous on a match point.' AI here to stay Umpire Nico Helwerth on the phone after the line-calling technology failed on Centre Court (Adam Davy/PA) Wimbledon bosses are 'deeply disappointed' by Sunday's electronic line calling failure but insist it will not happen again. All England Club chief executive Sally Bolton said: 'We did a full review of all of our systems and processes to check all of those kinds of things and to make sure that, both historically and moving forward, we have made the appropriate changes that we needed to make. So we're absolutely confident in the system.' Organisers later clarified the changes that have been made, with a spokesman saying: 'Following our review, we have removed the ability for Hawk-Eye operators to manually deactivate the ball tracking. This error cannot now be repeated.' Match of the day Cameron Norrie takes on the defending Wimbledon champion in the quarter-finals (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Cameron Norrie faces the ultimate Wimbledon challenge as he aims to dethrone defending champion Carlos Alcaraz. The British number three is through to the quarter-finals for the first time since he reached the last four in 2022, which was the last time Spanish superstar Alcaraz lost a match in SW19. Since then Norrie has dropped from eight in the world to a low of 91 while Alcaraz, 22, has won two Wimbledons, two French Opens and a US Open. But Alcaraz is taking nothing for granted, insisting facing Norrie on home soil is 'almost a nightmare'. Order of play Centre Court (from 1.30pm) Aryna Sabalenka (1) v Laura Siegemund Cameron Norrie v Carlos Alcaraz (2) Court One (from 1pm) Taylor Fritz (5) v Karen Khachanov (17) Amanda Anisimova (13) v Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova Weather watch Sunny with highs of 25C, according to the Met Office.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Wimbledon is a test case. It must be possible to build in Britain
For two weeks of the year, the eyes of the sporting world are focused on a corner of south-west London as tennis stars battle it out for the ultimate accolade of Wimbledon champion. Today the quarter-finals begin, with British player Cameron Norrie matched against the No 2 seed Carlos Alcaraz. Eight miles away at the Royal Courts of Justice another monumental tussle is unfolding over plans by the All England Lawn Tennis Club (AELTC) to expand its territory from the cramped site it currently occupies. The plans are opposed by residents close to the ground, but have been approved by Merton Borough Council and the Greater London Authority. That should have been the end of the matter but a judicial review against approval has been brought by complainants. They maintain that a new 8,000-seater stadium and practice courts will affect the vistas across the Capability Brown-designed park, although the development will be mainly on an old golf course bought by the AELTC. The site is designated Metropolitan Open Land and afforded the same protection as green belt. The club needs to show 'very special circumstances' to override this and can do so by dint of the 'special and unique cultural, sporting and socio-economic interest' of the peerless championships. The facilities at Wimbledon have fallen behind those at the three other grand slam venues and the AELTC has been meticulous in drawing up its plans over many years. If approval is now to be overturned by the courts the chances of getting anything built in this country will recede further.
