Pakistan's crackdown on black market dollar trade pushes deals online
Many unlicensed exchange shops have been shut since July 22, when the military spy agency summoned representatives of the sector to explain the U.S. dollar's rising cost in the open market. Soon after, raids were carried out by the Federal Investigation Agency, which tackles financial crime and smuggling.
Since the crackdown began, the rupee has rebounded from a sharp fall against the dollar earlier in July. In the open market, it firmed from 288.6 per dollar on July 19 to about 286 in recent sessions.
But traders and bankers say the trade continues, suggesting the crackdown's effects could be short-lived.
The black market operates outside official channels and includes unlicensed dealers, personal networks, and digital peer-to-peer exchanges, with customers seeking to skip tax declarations, avoid burdensome paperwork and bypass limits on official currency purchases.
In Peshawar, a city near the Afghan border long known for black market currency deals, many shops in the historic Chowk Yadgar district remain shuttered, though some traders were still operating discreetly in back-alley booths.
'The trade didn't stop. It just moved,' said Ahmad, a dealer whose family has been in the business for generations. 'Now it's on WhatsApp. If you know someone, the dollars come to your house.'
'The big players have shifted to safer locations and kept going,' said another trader, Gul. Both traders asked not to give their full names.
Rupee gains against US dollar amid reported crackdown
Even retail buyers are bypassing the formal foreign exchange market. Hassan, a manager at a multinational firm in Karachi, said stricter documentation drove him to an informal forex chat.
'Everyone there is a buyer or seller. No middleman, no commission. Sometimes it's physical cash, sometimes bank transfers, sometimes crypto,' he said.
Stricter FX discipline
On Monday, Pakistan's central bank called in bank treasury heads to address pressure on the rupee. Two bankers said they were told to stop buying dollars from exchange companies at above-official rates on the grounds it was skewing the market.
Banks were asked to rely on their own inflows from exports and remittances, but both sources have slowed. Exporters are delaying bringing money home, betting the rupee will weaken. Remittances are also tapering off as banks reduce incentives once offered to attract overseas inflows.
Authorities also pressed banks to keep the gap between the interbank rate and the open market rate narrow, a condition of Pakistan's $7 billion IMF deal meant to discourage speculation.
'These meetings have been happening for years, but this one was more pointed,' one banker said, speaking on condition of anonymity.
The central bank is expected to cut rates on Wednesday, easing inflation but risking pressure on the rupee.?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Quetta chamber highlights obstacles to trade with Iran, Afghanistan
ISLAMABAD: Despite importing hundreds of items from Iran, Pakistan exports only 10 items to the neighbouring country, exposing a stark imbalance in bilateral trade that has drawn concern from the Quetta Chamber of Commerce. The Chamber representatives, on Thursday, informed the Senate Standing Committee on Finance at length about the major challenges being faced by local businessmen in carrying out trade activities through the Pakistan-Iran and the Pakistan-Afghanistan border areas. It is learnt that the issues were raised by the Quetta Chamber of Commerce and Industry during a joint session of the Senate Standing Committees on Finance and Trade with the office-bearers and members of the Chamber. Businessmen voice concerns over trade challenges at Iran, Afghanistan borders On the occasion, the President of the Chamber, Muhammad Ayub Mariani, Senior Vice President Haji Akhtar Kakar, Vice President Engineer Mir Wais Khan, and others stated that not only have they conveyed the obstacles in bilateral trade with Iran and Afghanistan to the higher authorities, but they have also held dialogues with Afghan and Iranian officials in this regard. President of the Chamber Mariani, Senior Vice President Kakar, and Vice President Mir Wais Khan informed the participants that due to the requirement of the EIF form, bilateral trade has come to a halt, and Pakistani cargo trucks are being held in Iran unnecessarily for 15 to 20 days. They also mentioned that Pakistan exports only 10 items to Iran, while hundreds of items are imported from Iran. Complaints were also made about the increase in attestation and visa fees. They also discussed the Joint Economic Forum and Joint Border Trade Committee with Iran, lamenting that unfortunately, the recommendations of the Economic Forum and Joint Border Committee have not been implemented by either country. They demanded the inclusion of officials from the federal ministries of Commerce and Finance, as well as the prime minister's representatives, in the merging of the Economic Forum and Joint Border Trade Committee, so that matters can reach a logical conclusion. They expressed reservations about the reopening and then closure of the Badini border, the reopening of Qamaruddin Karez border, inactivity of border markets, and other issues, and presented suggestions. They stated that if cold storage and LPG terminals and other issues at Chaman and Taftan borders are resolved, trade volume with neighboring countries can be significantly increased. On this occasion, Chairman Saleem Mandviwalla said that for the past six months, they had been receiving complaints in Islamabad regarding Pakistan-Iran and Pakistan-Afghanistan bilateral trade issues. Therefore, they decided to come here and listen to the stakeholders. The provincial government was also taken into confidence in this regard. Some issues will be resolved here on the spot, while others will be conveyed to higher authorities. We want to address the complaints and concerns we have heard. We have come to end the sense of deprivation and backwardness in Balochistan. If we cannot solve these problems collectively, it would be a failure of the federation. He said that they have discussed border issues here and will visit Chaman and Taftan next time to assess the situation. He mentioned that the Iranian Consul General gave them a list of issues, and Balochistan's business community also shared their problems. These will be presented to the Iranian president and the high-level delegation accompanying him. He clarified that borders are not closed — only smuggling has been curbed. If full freedom is given, then sugar and other goods will become more expensive. He added that Iranian petrol is entering under a token system, but not through tankers. In response to a question, he stated that global economic sanctions on Iran are the main obstacle to the pipeline project. Whenever steps are taken in this regard, Pakistan also receives threats of sanctions. However, this project should be completed as it has no military or war-related objectives—it is purely for the welfare of the general public. Talks on this matter are still ongoing. Our job is not to restrict trade but to facilitate it. Chairperson of the Senate Standing Committee on Commerce, Anusha Rahman, has said that barter and border trade with the neighbouring brotherly Islamic country Iran should be conducted on a free and equal basis. After consultation with stakeholders regarding the obstacles and difficulties in bilateral trade, the recommendations have been finalised. She stated that they want a separate SRO for barter trade with Iran so that hurdles in trade with Iran can be eliminated. She directed the chairman of TDAP to ensure support for the Chamber of Commerce and Industry members and officials regarding online trade. She reiterated that border and barter trade with Iran and Pakistan should be on an equal basis. She directed TDAP officials to allocate funds for cold storage, LPG terminals, and other facilities at the borders. She also stated that the opening of the Chaman border is scheduled for September, and they will definitely participate in it. The Consul General of Iran in Quetta, Ali Reza Razaei, said that Iran is always ready to hold discussions to resolve the difficulties faced in bilateral trade relations with Pakistan. He stated that Iran wants to trade with Pakistan through land, sea, and air routes, and the lack of cooperation in this regard is disappointing. 'We are not here to compete with each other, but to highlight bilateral trade issues,' he said. 'The doors of the Iranian Consulate are always open for traders.' The session was also attended by Senator Manzoor Khan Kakar, Senator Bilal Khan Mandokhail, Senator Jan Muhammad Buledi, Iran's Consul General Ali Reza Rezaei, Additional Secretary Commerce, Chairman TDAP, Chief Collector Customs, and other officials. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Sugar crisis
EDITORIAL: Public Accounts Committee (PAC) under the chairmanship of Junaid Akbar, a Pakistan Tehrik-i-Insaaf loyalist, has sought records of sugar mill owners and exporters to determine the cause behind the escalation in the price of sugar in the domestic market – a recurring cause reminiscent of the boom-bust cycle in the country's balance of payment position that has compelled successive administrations to periodically seek an International Monetary Fund (IMF) loan. The country is currently on the harshest-ever upfront programme – the twenty-fourth in our history, average three years per programme. The root of the recurring problem is as follows: the growers are seen lined-up with their cane outside mills which are, on occasion, not immediately accepted by the mill owners due to reasons ranging from a deliberate delay in the start of crushing due to price disputes, capacity limitations of mills and the middlemen (aarthis) exploiting farmers. Once the cane is accepted after negotiating the price downward, the mill owners begin crushing. The Sugar Advisory Board (SAB), headed by the Minister for Food Security and Research, with provincial cane commissioners and representatives from the politically powerful Pakistan Sugar Mills Association (with 80 plus members) reviews the sugar stocks to determine scarcity and or surplus. The SAB recommends exports to Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) of the Cabinet, the highest economic policymaking forum, only if there is an assurance that there are surplus stocks — an assurance that has been given time and again through data fudging — exports would in no way impact on domestic prices. In several years, allowing exports have been accompanied by a subsidy paid at the taxpayers' expense on the plea that the international price of sugar is lower than the cost to the mill owners. Mid-October 2024, Musaddiq Mailk as Sugar Monitoring Committee chair was replaced with Ishaq Dar who allowed export of 0.500 million metric tons (MT) of sugar, in addition to the already approved 0.140 million MT, based on the following data: 2.054 million MT of sugar was available with 5.465 MT consumed domestically in ten months, 0.900 million MT was projected to be used in the next two months premised on the September data (which was 0.450 million MT – a quantity that was set aside). Failure to allow legal exports, it was argued, would lead to smuggling of sugar across the Afghan border. That this argument backed by trumped-up data was flawed, as in previous years, is evident, given the subsequent rise in domestic prices reaching a high of 210 rupees per kg in Islamabad this week past prompting the Minister for Food Security to publicly propose deregulating the sugar industry as well as lifting a long-standing ban on new sugar mill licences. Would these proposed measures assist in resolving the issue for all times to come? The answer sadly is not positive because it presupposes that sugar operates in the open market where there are too many buyers and sellers to be able to influence market price. This is not the case in Pakistan where most items which are operating in open market conditions in other countries have managed to establish associations duly registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan that allows them to operate in the market as oligopolists (few buyers who collude to set prices) and through their pervasive influence in the country's politics to get approval for exports and export subsidies. In addition, lifting the ban on issuing sugar mill licences, a ban that was violated by the ruling Sharif family during a previous administration, would in all probability allow for even more of a concentration of mills in the hands of a few. This, in turn, may exacerbate the situation. To conclude, the prevalence of associations for products that operate in open market conditions in other countries must be revisited and the Competition Commission of Pakistan strengthened to take up the challenge of powerful influential groups. In addition, the government also needs to revisit sugar as a large-scale manufacturing sector with a weightage of 3.43 in the calculation of large scale manufacturing sector that provides justification for government support. And finally, there is a need to update and delink the data from those whose interest it is to manipulate it. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
14 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Businessmen voice concerns over trade challenges at Iran, Afghanistan borders
ISLAMABAD: The representatives of Quetta Chamber of Commerce informed the Senate Standing Committee on Finance at length about the major challenges being faced by local businessmen in carrying out trade activities through the Pakistan-Iran and the Pakistan-Afghanistan border areas, a statement said. The businessmen also highlighted that despite importing hundreds of items from Iran, Pakistan exports only 10 items to the neighbouring country, exposing a stark imbalance in bilateral trade, the statement added. As per the details, Quetta chamber president Muhammad Ayub Mariani, senior vice president Haji Akhtar Kakar, vice president engineer Mir Wais Khan, and others stated that not only had they conveyed the obstacles in bilateral trade with Iran and Afghanistan to the higher authorities, but also held dialogues with Afghan and Iranian officials in that regard. Govt bars pilgrims from traveling to Iran, Iraq by road this Arbaeen The participants were informed that due to the requirement of the Electronic Import Form (EIF) form, bilateral trade had come to a halt, and Pakistani cargo trucks were being held in Iran unnecessarily for 15 to 20 days. Complaints were also made about the increase in attestation and visa fees. They also discussed the Joint Economic Forum and Joint Border Trade Committee with Iran, lamenting that the recommendations of the Economic Forum and Joint Border Committee had not been implemented by either country. The businessmen demanded the inclusion of officials from the federal ministries of Commerce and Finance, as well as the prime minister's representatives, in the merging of the Economic Forum and Joint Border Trade Committee, so that matters could reach a logical conclusion. They expressed reservations about the reopening and then closure of the Badini border, the reopening of Qamaruddin Karez border, inactivity of border markets, and other issues, and presented suggestions. The businessmen stated that if cold storage and LPG terminals and other issues at Chaman and Taftan borders were resolved, trade volume with neighboring countries could be significantly increased. On the occasion, committee chairman Saleem Mandviwalla said for the past six months, they had been receiving complaints in Islamabad regarding Pakistan-Iran and Pakistan-Afghanistan bilateral trade issues. Cross-border trade: FBR issues PSW (Evidence of Identity) Regulations Some issues would be resolved on the spot, while others would be conveyed to higher authorities, he added. Mandviwalla said mentioned that the Iranian Consul General had given them a list of issues, and Balochistan's business community also shared their problems. They would be presented to the Iranian president and the high-level delegation accompanying him, he added. Iran President Dr Masoud Pezeshkian is due to visit Pakistan on August 2 (Saturday) for a two-day trip.
