Extradition hearing starts for Indonesian businessman said to have bribed officials
Extradition hearing starts for Indonesian businessman said to have bribed officials
SINGAPORE – A court hearing is taking place here that will determine whether an Indonesian businessman in a high-profile corruption case will be extradited to his home country.
The hearing on June 23 regarding Paulus Tannos, also known as Tjhin Thian Po, is Singapore's first such proceeding under its extradition treaty with Indonesia.
Tannos has been implicated in a major graft scandal involving the Indonesian government's issuing of electronic ID card – known as e-KTP – allegedly causing state losses of about 2.3 trillion rupiah (S$187 million).
The Indonesian fugitive, who is believed to have been living in Singapore since 2017, faces one charge of corruption under Indonesia law which is punishable with a maximum sentence of life imprisonment.
The crux of the hearing is to determine whethe r there is enough evidence to support the corruption charge Tannos is facing, so he can be sent back to Indonesia.
In extradition hearings, the State does not have to prove the fugitive's guilt or secure a conviction. It only has to show that there is enough evidence for the fugitive to face trial if his acts had taken place in Singapore.
Delivering the State's opening statement, Deputy Solicitor-General Vincent Leow said the State would rely on evidence submitted by Indonesian authorities.
Tannos was the president and director of technology company PT Sandipala Arthaputra, which was a member of the PNRI Consortium – a grouping of companies that won the e-KTP tender in 2011.
DSG Leow said under the alleged corruption scheme, the consortium paid 'commitment fees' to officials of the Ministry of Home Affairs of Indonesia (MOHA), which was responsible for the e-KTP tender.
Bribes were also allegedly given to members of the House of Representatives of Indonesia, otherwise known as DPR-RI, who appropriated and allocated the government's budget for the project.
The gratification amounted to 10 per cent of the total project value, split equally amongst MOHA officials and DPR-RI.
According to Indonesian authorities, Tannos eventually paid US$530,000 to a MOHA officer and approximately US$3,799,842 to former Indonesian politician Setya Novanto through the latter's associate.
'The Indonesian authorities' position is that the payment of these 'commitment fees' resulted in the manipulation of the decision-making process regarding the e-KTP project and tender, and that the PNRI Consortium won the tender through unlawful methods,' said DSG Leow.
Chief Special Investigator Alvin Tang of the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) – the State's only witness – took the stand to give evidence on how he arrested Tannos and brought him to the State Courts.
Meanwhile, Tannos' defence lawyer Bachoo Mohan Singh argued that there were about 100 pages in the formal extradition request that were added after the stipulated deadline, and should hence be thrown out.
Tannos' other defence lawyer, Mr Suang Wijaya, also objected to the admission of documents prepared by Indonesian authorities as he said they were not 'duly authenticated'.
For example, an English document said to be the translation of Tannos' arrest warrant did not have a stamp with official authorisation, said Mr Wijaya.
The hearing continues till June 25.
Tannos has reportedly been on Indonesia's fugitive list since Oct 19, 2021. He was arrested on Jan 17 by CPIB, and Indonesia put in a formal extradition request on Feb 24.
The extradition treaty between Singapore and Indonesia took effect on March 21, 2024.
It grants extradition for a list of offences, including corruption, money laundering and bribery, and can be retrospectively applied to crimes committed up to 18 years ago.
Christine Tan is a journalist at The Straits Times reporting on crime, justice and social issues in Singapore.
Join ST's WhatsApp Channel and get the latest news and must-reads.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
36 minutes ago
- Straits Times
US, China to resume tariff talks in effort to extend truce by 90 days
Find out what's new on ST website and app. US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Chinese Vice-Premier He Lifeng will lead tariff talks on July 28, in Stockholm. STOCKHOLM – Senior US and Chinese negotiators will meet in Stockholm on July 28 to tackle longstanding economic disputes at the centre of the countries' trade war, aiming to extend a truce keeping sharply higher tariffs at bay. The South China Morning Post reported on July 27 that the two sides are expected to agree to extend the truce by three more months. China is facing an Aug 12 deadline to reach a durable tariff agreement with President Donald Trump's administration, after Beijing and Washington reached a preliminary deal in June to end weeks of escalating tit-for-tat tariffs. Without an agreement, global supply chains could face renewed turmoil from duties exceeding 100 per cent. The Stockholm talks, led by US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Chinese Vice-Premier He Lifeng, take place a day after European Union chief Ursula von der Leyen meets Mr Trump at his golf course in Scotland to try to clinch a deal that would likely see a 15 per cent baseline tariff on most EU goods. Trade analysts on both sides of the Pacific say the discussions in the Swedish capital are unlikely to produce any breakthroughs but could prevent further escalation and help create conditions for Mr Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping to meet later in 2025. Previous US-China trade talks in Geneva and London in May and June focused on bringing US and Chinese retaliatory tariffs down from triple-digit levels and restoring the flow of rare earth minerals halted by China and Nvidia H20 AI chips and other goods halted by the United States. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Sewage shaft failure linked to sinkhole; PUB calling safety time-out on similar works islandwide Singapore Tanjong Katong Road sinkhole did not happen overnight: Experts Singapore Workers used nylon rope to rescue driver of car that fell into Tanjong Katong Road sinkhole Asia Singapore-only car washes will get business licences revoked, says Johor govt World Food airdropped into Gaza as Israel opens aid routes Sport Arsenal beat Newcastle in five-goal thriller to bring Singapore Festival of Football to a close Singapore Benchmark barrier: Six of her homeschooled kids had to retake the PSLE Asia S'porean trainee doctor in Melbourne arrested for allegedly filming colleagues in toilets since 2021 So far, the talks have not delved into broader economic issues. These include US complaints that China's state-led, export-driven model is flooding world markets with cheap goods, and Beijing's complaints that US national security export controls on tech goods seek to stunt Chinese growth. 'Stockholm will be the first meaningful round of US-China trade talks,' said Mr Bo Zhengyuan, Shanghai-based partner at China consultancy firm Plenum. Deals, deals, deals Mr Trump has been successful in pressuring some other trading partners, including Japan, Vietnam and the Philippines , into deals accepting higher US tariffs of 15 to 20 per cent. He said there was a 50-50 chance that the US and the 27-member European Union could also reach a framework trade pact, adding that Brussels wanted to 'make a deal very badly'. Two of Mr Trump's top trade officials, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, will attend the Scotland talks and then travel to Stockholm. Analysts say the US-China negotiations are far more complex and will require more time. China's grip on the global market for rare earth minerals and magnets, used in everything from military hardware to car windshield wiper motors, has proved to be an effective leverage point on US industries. Trump-Xi meeting? In the background of the talks is speculation about a possible meeting between Mr Trump and Mr Xi in late October. Mr Trump has said he will decide soon whether to visit China in a landmark trip to address trade and security tensions. A new flare-up of tariffs and export controls would likely derail any plans for a meeting with Mr Xi. 'The Stockholm meeting is an opportunity to start laying the groundwork for a Trump visit to China,' said Ms Wendy Cutler, vice-president at the Asia Society Policy Institute. Mr Bessent has already said he wants to work out an extension of the Aug 12 deadline to prevent tariffs snapping back to 145 per cent on the US side and 125 per cent on the Chinese side. Still, China will likely request a reduction of multi-layered US tariffs totaling 55 per cent on most goods and further easing of US high-tech export controls, analysts said. Beijing has argued that such purchases would help reduce the US trade deficit with China, which reached US$295.5 billion (S$379 billion) in 2024. China is currently facing a 20 per cent tariff related to the US fentanyl crisis, a 10 per cent reciprocal tariff, and 25 per cent duties on most industrial goods imposed during Mr Trump's first term. Mr Bessent has also said he would discuss with Mr He the need for China to rebalance its economy away from exports toward domestic consumer demand. The shift would require China to put an end to a protracted property crisis and boost social safety nets to encourage household spending. Mr Michael Froman, a former US trade representative during former president Barack Obama's administration, said such a shift has been a goal of US policymakers for two decades. 'Can we effectively use tariffs to get China to fundamentally change their economic strategy? That remains to be seen,' said Mr Froman, now president of the Council on Foreign Relations think-tank. REUTERS
Business Times
3 hours ago
- Business Times
Trump, EU's von der Leyen to meet to clinch trade deal
[GLASGOW] European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen is set to meet US President Donald Trump on Sunday (Jul 27) to clinch a trade deal for Europe that would likely see a 15 per cent baseline tariff on most EU goods, but end months of uncertainty for EU companies. US and EU negotiators huddled in final talks on tariffs facing crucial sectors like cars, steel, aluminium and pharmaceuticals before the meeting, which is expected at 1530 GMT on Trump's golf course in Turnberry, western Scotland. US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick flew to Scotland on Saturday and EU Trade Commissioner Maros Sefcovic arrived on Sunday morning. Lutnick told 'Fox News Sunday' that the EU needed to open its markets for more US exports to convince Trump to reduce a threatened 30 per cent tariff rate that is due to kick in on Aug 1. 'The question is, do they offer President Trump a good enough deal that is worth it for him to step off of the 30 per cent tariffs that he set,' Lutnick said, adding that the EU clearly wanted – and needed – to reach an agreement. A separate US administration official was upbeat that a deal was possible. 'We're cautiously optimistic that there will be a deal reached,' the official said, speaking on condition of anonymity. 'But it's not over till it's over.' BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up The EU deal would be a huge prize, given that the US and EU are each other's largest trading partners by far and account for a third of global trade. Ambassadors of EU governments, on a weekend trip to Greenland organised by the Danish presidency of the EU, held a teleconference with EU Commission officials on Sunday to agree on the amount of leeway von der Leyen would have. In case there is no deal and the US imposes 30 per cent tariffs from Aug 1, the EU has prepared counter-tariffs on 93 billion euros (S$140 billion) of US goods. EU diplomats have said a deal would likely include a broad 15 per cent tariff on EU goods imported into the US, mirroring the US-Japan trade deal, along with a 50 per cent tariff on European steel and aluminium for which there could be export quotas. EU officials are hopeful that a 15 per cent baseline tariff would also apply to cars, replacing the current 27.5 per cent auto tariff. Possible exemptions Some expect the 27-nation bloc may be able to secure exemptions from the 15 per cent baseline tariff for its aerospace industry and for spirits, though probably not for wine. The EU could also pledge to buy more liquefied natural gas from the US, a long-standing offer, and boost investment in the US. Trump told reporters there was 'not a lot' of wiggle room on the 50 per cent tariffs that the US has on steel and aluminium imports, adding, 'because if I do it for one, I have to do it for all.' The US president, in Scotland for a few days of golfing and bilateral meetings, told reporters upon his arrival on Friday evening that von der Leyen was a highly respected leader and he was looking forward to meeting with her. He said there was a 50-50 chance that the two sides could reach a framework trade pact, adding that Brussels wanted to 'make a deal very badly'. The EU now faces US tariffs on more than 70 per cent of its exports, with 50 per cent on steel and aluminium, an extra 25 per cent on cars and car parts on top of the existing 2.5 per cent and a 10 per cent levy on most other EU goods. EU officials have said a 'no-deal' tariff rate of 30 per cent would wipe out whole chunks of transatlantic commerce. A 15 per cent tariff on most EU goods would remove uncertainty but would be seen by many in Europe as a poor outcome compared to the initial European ambition of a zero-for-zero tariff deal on all industrial goods. Seeking to learn from Japan, which secured a 15 per cent baseline tariff with the US in a deal earlier this week, EU negotiators spoke to their Japanese counterparts in preparation for Sunday's meeting. For Trump, aiming to reorder the global economy and reduce decades-old US trade deficits, a deal with the EU would be the biggest trade agreement, surpassing the US$550 billion deal with Japan. So far, he has reeled in agreements with Britain, Japan, Indonesia and Vietnam, although his administration has failed to deliver on a promise of '90 deals in 90 days.' REUTERS
Straits Times
9 hours ago
- Straits Times
Indonesia rushing to complete trade deals with Europe, Canada as a hedge against looming US tariff
Find out what's new on ST website and app. With the US tariff looming, Indonesia, under President Prabowo Subianto, is negotiating with other countries and groupings as alternative markets for its exports. JAKARTA – Indonesia is rushing to complete several trade deals to diversify its export market as a hedge against the impending tariff from the United States, in a move welcomed by industry players. A top Indonesian official said South-east Asia's largest economy is seeking zero per cent tariff from trade deals with the European Union, which has 27 member countries. It is also seeking a separate agreement with the Eurasian Economic Union, said Mr Susiwijono Moegiarso, the most senior bureaucrat at Indonesia's Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs. The members of the Eurasian grouping are Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Armenia. Indonesia is, additionally, accelerating to ratify a December 2024 comprehensive economic partnership agreement (Cepa) with Canada, he told a panel discussion in Jakarta on July 22, organised by Bank UOB Indonesia. 'We are rushing now to complete trade deals as part of our effort to expand markets,' Mr Susiwijono said, when asked by The Straits Times during the panel discussion. 'In the past two weeks, we have been travelling to a number of countries... and we have achieved concrete results,' he had said at the session. 'Palm oil, coffee bean, aroma essence (fragrance) are among the sectors that would most benefit from wider access to the European markets,' said Mr Edwin Kadir, Bank UOB Indonesia's executive director, when asked by ST on the impact of the Indonesia-EU deal. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Car that fell into Tanjong Katong Road South sinkhole removed; road remains closed for repairs Singapore Workers used nylon rope to rescue driver of car that fell into Tanjong Katong Road sinkhole Asia Thai-Cambodia border shelling continues despite Trump's ceasefire call Singapore PAP has to retain its position for S'pore to keep doing well: SM Lee Asia S'porean trainee doctor in Melbourne arrested for allegedly filming colleagues in toilets since 2021 Singapore HSA will not trace vape users who throw away e-vaporisers in disposal bins at 23 CCs Singapore Mum at 15: More teens in Singapore gave birth in 2024 Business Already owning 5 properties, woman wanted elderly dad's 4 homes The US has set a 19 per cent tariff on most goods from Indonesia under a new agreement. Certain goods, including processed nickel, coffee beans and others that are not produced by the US, may get a lower rate. The 19 per cent rate, decided on July 15, is significantly lower than the 32 per cent announced by the Trump administration in April. The US tariff is set to take effect on Aug 1. Mr Susiwijono said that the expected deal with the EU will take effect in 2026. Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen had expressed their shared commitment in Brussels on July 13 to concluding the negotiations of the Indonesia-European Union Cepa, or IEU Cepa, a pact that has been under negotiation for the past 10 years. Technical teams have put the deal under a 'legal scrubbing process' before a slated agreement signing by both leaders in September, said Mr Susiwijono, referring to the pact's final review and refinement. 'This IEU Cepa would be a game-changer for Indonesia. Imagine our exports of Nike, Adidas shoes to Europe, compared with the same products from Vietnam, which has a free trade deal with the EU, hence a zero per cent tariff,' he said. With no trade deal, shoes shipped to Europe from Indonesia have a 20 per cent tariff rate. International brands such as Nike and Adidas outsource production to independent suppliers which manufacture shoes based on provided specifications that include design, materials and quality standards. 'It has been years that our shoe manufacturers have to compete with Vietnam with this tariff gap burden,' said Mr Susiwijono. Indonesia remains the world's top exporter of palm oil, accounting for about half of global demand. The EU, historically Indonesia's main export market, continued to import Indonesian palm oil in 2024 despite a decline in that year amid stricter sustainability standards being applied. Indonesia and Eurasian countries have an in-principle agreement on a free trade deal, even as Jakarta is seeking a quicker ratification process with Ottawa on their trade deal. The current No.1 destination for Indonesian exports is China, which accounts for about 23 per cent of total exports in dollar value in 2024, led by coal, palm oil and nickel, according to Indonesia's statistics agency (BPS). The total exports to China were valued at US$65.84 billion (S$84.21 billion) in 2024. Indonesia's second-biggest export market is the US, with about 9.3 per cent of total exports in 2024, valued at US$28.18 billion, comprising mostly apparel, footwear, machinery and electrical goods. This is followed by Japan (8.51 per cent, mostly industrial goods and mineral fuels); India (8 per cent, led by coal, palm oil and rubber); and Singapore 5 per cent (mostly re-exported goods). The EU market accounted for US$21.47 billion (S$27.52 billion) in 2024, or 7.4 per cent, of Indonesia's total exports in 2024, according to BPS. The Netherlands and Germany are the top two European importers of Indonesian goods, including chemical products, vegetable oil, cocoa beans, footwear and electrical equipment. Indonesia, meanwhile, imports vehicles, pharmaceuticals, electronic and medical instruments, among others, from the EU. Mrs Shinta Kamdani, chairwoman of Apindo, the Indonesian employers' association, said the business sector has been looking forward to seeing the completion of the IEU Cepa deal, and it has been involved in the negotiation for the last decade. A Cepa does not just give market access but is also about capacity-building and cooperation, Mrs Shinta said in a July 23 panel discussion organised by the Jakarta Foreign Correspondent Club. She said that as European buyers have high standards for imported products, the two parties need to work closely to reach a common ground. 'It is not only about signing an agreement, but how we can utilise the agreement,' Mrs Shinta said, pointing to Indonesia's separate Cepa with Australia, which has been working well. 'A good example is with the Australians. We work very closely with our government, set up a task force on trade and investment, and the Australian government is supporting us,' she added. The Indonesia-Australia Cepa came into effect on July 5, 2020, after the parliaments of both countries ratified the deal following the official signing on March 4, 2019. Mr Fithra Hastiadi, senior adviser to the Presidential Communication Office, concurs with Mrs Shinta about the EU's high standards for goods, adding that Indonesia's wider access to the market would help the country gain easier access to other markets. 'It creates a positive signalling effect, which in turn will help Indonesia enter other markets,' Mr Fithra said.
