
Highland beaver release blocked after Kate Forbes stepped in
Emails released under Freedom of Information law disclose why the wildlife agency, NatureScot, postponed a long-awaited plan to move beavers into Loch Beinn A' Mheadhoin in Glen Affric.
Forbes, the National Farmers Union in Scotland (NFUS) and local landowners privately piled pressure on the agency to derail a beaver licence application by the Government's Forestry and Land Scotland.
The tree-felling, dam-building, semi-aquatic mammals were due to start being released in spring 2025. But NatureScot announced in April that it would 'take the summer' for more consultations because there was 'considerable concern about the proposal among the local community and its representatives'.
Campaigners have condemned the delay as 'ministerial appeasement of the NFUS at the expense of Scotland's nature'. They dubbed the revelations 'beavergate', saying they raised 'urgent questions about behind-the-scenes lobbying and hidden voices'.
Forbes, however, defended her role as a local MSP relaying concerns of constituents to 'relevant public bodies'. Her status as Deputy First Minister was 'immaterial to progressing constituency casework', she said.
NatureScot accepted the delay could cause 'frustration', and promised a 'short and focused' engagement on 'specific impacts'. The planned release was 'contentious' and there was 'ministerial interest', it said.
Beavers were hunted to extinction in Scotland in the 16th century. They were accidentally or illegally released in Tayside before 2006, and are now thought to number more than 2000 along the Tay and the Forth.
READ MORE: Archaeologist may have found William Wallace's Battle of Stirling Bridge camp
In 2019, the Tayside beavers were given legal protection by the Scottish Government. But farmers and landowners, who feared the damage they could cause by flooding, were licensed to shoot 352 of them between 2019 and 2022.
In 2021, Green MSP Lorna Slater, then biodiversity minister, announced a change of policy aimed at allowing beavers to be moved to other parts of Scotland instead of being shot. Authorised releases have since taken place at Loch Lomond and in the Cairngorms.
In March 2022 Slater asked Forestry and Land Scotland (FLS) to identify land it owned suitable for reintroducing beavers. Working with the rewilding campaign group, Trees for Life, FLS developed a proposal to release up to four beaver families on land it owns in Glen Affric, above the Beinn A' Mheadhoin dam.
The Ferret reported in October 2023 that FLS had postponed applying for a beaver release licence following opposition from landowners, backed by Forbes. It wasn't until January 2025, after two years of consultations, that FLS finally submitted its full licence application to NatureScot.
What happened next has now been revealed by more than 80 pages of emails released by NatureScot in response to a freedom of information request by The Ferret.
Local farmers and land managers, whose names have been redacted, wrote a series of angry letters, urging NatureScot to reject the licence application.
They expressed alarm about the damage that beavers might do to riverbanks and salmon spawning areas. They complained that beavers had already been illegally released downstream at Strathglass, and criticised the consultations as biased.
Forbes wrote to NatureScot in January, also saying that constituents were worried that beaver dams could harm salmon spawning beds. She asked for the matter to be investigated.
NatureScot told NFUS it didn't 'normally' seek comments on licence applications, but was 'happy' to receive them from farmers. On February 28, 2025, NFUS wrote to NatureScot expressing 'serious concerns', calling for a 'pause' and requesting a meeting.
The letter argued that, if released, beavers would quickly move downstream from Glen Affric to a 'high conflict area of productive agricultural land'. It criticised Trees for Life and FLS for 'poor' and 'inflammatory' responses to farmers' concerns.
'Pausing the processing of this application, or even better postponing it for, say, a year, will show a willingness by NatureScot to address the genuine concerns of those most likely to be impacted,' NFUS argued.
'Our members have engaged with their local parliamentarian Kate Forbes MSP, Deputy First Minister, who is in discussion with Mairi Gougeon MSP, Minister for Rural Affairs, Land Reform and Islands, and has advised that the Scottish Government will be looking into the matter.'
After receiving the letter from NFUS, one senior NatureScot official told a colleague that it would be assessed. 'The case is considered novel and contentious so when we have completed, we will pass by ministers, who will take an interest,' the official wrote.
NFUS chased up its letter and its demands on March 12 and again on March 31. NatureScot announced the decision to delay the Glen Affric beaver application on April 2, prompting accusations of a 'great beaver betrayal' from campaigners.
Trees for Life called on NatureScot to explain its actions. 'This growing beavergate controversy raises urgent questions around the behind-the-scenes lobbying and hidden voices seeking to block Scotland's nature recovery,' chief executive Steve Micklewright told The Ferret.
'Exactly what part has Kate Forbes played in this sorry saga? Is she willing to meet and engage positively with rewilding organisations, or should we give up asking?'
Micklewright argued that the issue went beyond the multiple benefits of bringing beavers back to Glen Affric.
'It goes to the heart of why the Scottish Government keeps hitting the pause button on restoring biodiversity, and whether NatureScot can show the leadership to fulfil its purpose,' he said.
'NatureScot now needs to show it can lead on nature recovery with vision and integrity – including by standing up to high-powered anti-nature lobbying. And all of our government ministers need to show that they fully support NatureScot in that.'
According to the Scottish Wild Beaver Group, which campaigns to protect beavers, it was 'really disheartening' to see Forbes use her influence to halt a beaver licensing process which had been conducted with 'high community consultation standards'.
The group's James Nairne said: 'It seems to mark yet another example of ministerial appeasement of the NFUS at the expense of Scotland's nature, and raises serious questions about how committed this government is to Scotland's beaver strategy and the Scottish biodiversity strategy more generally.'
Malcolm Wield, a former forest manager who has lived close to Strathglass since 1993, claimed that a lot of local people were 'excited' at the idea of having beavers in the area. 'Even if many often feel the need to keep their heads down, their views have to count too,' he said.
'Undemocratic intervention by the Deputy First Minister on such an important issue is unfair and demonstrates total disregard for the breadth of views here, not to mention biodiversity.'
Forbes stressed her role as a constituency MSP for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch.
'I am obligated to relay constituency concerns and queries to the relevant public bodies and I'm proud to work hard on behalf of my constituents,' she told The Ferret.
'When multiple local residents in Glen Affric expressed concerns about the introduction of beavers at drop-in surgeries, I raised those in my constituency capacity with the relevant public bodies.
'This is consistent with the approach I would take on any issue, from healthcare to wildlife.'
She added: 'My status as Deputy First Minister is immaterial to progressing constituency casework, and any suggestion to the contrary puts my constituents at a disadvantage.'
NatureScot insisted it was 'absolutely committed' to expanding the beaver population across Scotland for the benefit of biodiversity.
'We understand that there may be frustration around the timeframe for this licensing decision,' said a spokesperson.
'This short and focused engagement will be on the specific impacts on land and fisheries managers and the mitigation and management available to them.'
NatureScot pointed out that Scottish ministers could modify or revoke beaver licensing decisions, and it had to keep them briefed on 'any novel or contentious issues'.
NatureScot's delay was backed by the Scottish Government.
'Given the concerns from the local community, it is only right that NatureScot take the time to undertake further engagement with land and fisheries managers,' said a spokesperson.
READ MORE: Europe's first museum of contemporary Palestinian art opens in Edinburgh
'The Scottish Government supports the targeted reintroduction of beaver populations where appropriate.
'We want to make sure that where translocations take place, measures are put in place to ensure rural people and beavers are able to thrive.'
Forestry and Land Scotland described the delay to releasing beavers in Glen Affric as 'disappointing' but said it could appreciate NatureScot's position. Consultations were extensive and allowed everyone in the local community to have their say, it argued.
'The consultation process and other inputs helped us to identify where the majority opinion lay. It also helped us to develop appropriate and adequate mitigations to address the concerns raised by those who were not in favour of beaver reintroductions,' said north region planning manager, Euan Wiseman.
The National Farmers Union in Scotland said its members were committed to helping nature restoration.
'Local farmers and crofters highlighted concerns in relation to the Glen Affric beaver release to their MSP representative,' confirmed a spokesperson.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scottish Sun
42 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Donald Trump slams Nicola Sturgeon as ‘terrible' in swipe at ex-First Minister
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DONALD Trump yesterday hit out at Nicola Sturgeon and blasted her time as First Minister - just days after praising John Swinney. The US President said he did not 'have a lot of respect' for the former SNP leader who was in charge during his first presidency between 2016 and 2020. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 3 President Donald Trump speaks with reporters aboard Air Force One after leaving Aberdeen Credit: AP 3 Donald Trump waves as he boards Air Force One at RAF Lossiemouth Credit: Getty 3 The ex-First Minister had criticised Mr Trump when he was elected President for the first time Credit: PA The ex-First Minister had criticised Mr Trump when he was elected President for the first time in 2016, labelling his comments and behaviour 'abhorrent'. Speaking to journalists on Air Force One about his discussion with Mr Swinney, he said: 'I didn't have a lot of respect for the woman that preceded him. 'I thought she was terrible as a first minister of Scotland. But I think John is doing a very good job as first minister.' Despite senior Scottish Government sources insisting the discussion between Mr Swinney and Mr Trump had included whisky tariffs and had increased the chance of an exception to punishing extra trade costs, Mr Trump said the two 'did not really discuss' the issue. Find out what's really going on Register now for our free weekly politics newsletter for an insightful and irreverent look at the (sometimes excruciating) world of Scottish Politics. Every Thursday our hotshot politics team goes behind the headlines to bring you a rundown of key events - plus insights and gossip from the corridors of power, including a 'Plonker' and 'Star' of the Week. Sign up now and make sure you don't miss a beat. The politicians would hate that. SIGN UP FOR FREE NOW Ms Sturgeon responded on her Instagram account: 'Feeling was mutual, Donnie. 'Forever proud to represent all the things that offend your view of the world.' A source close to Ms Sturgeon hit back and said: 'Trump's lack of respect for women is hardly news. Donald Trump's Secret Service probes major security breach on Scotland visit after attempt to smuggle person onto plane 'That said, the feeling was entirely mutual'. The former SNP leader stepped down as First Minister and party chief unexpectedly in February 2023. She was replaced by Humza Yousaf who resigned in April 2024 after collapsing his power-sharing agreement with the Scottish Greens. He was succeeded by Mr Swinney in May last year.


The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Small increase in university students from poorest areas
The Scottish Government hopes to have 20 percent of students coming from the most deprived 20 percent of the population by 2030, with an interim target of 18 percent by 2026. In order to achieve the final target, a total increase of 3.3 percentage points will be required over the next six years; however, over the past six years, the recorded increase has been just 1.1 percentage points, and the total increase since 2014 stands at just 3 percentage points. The latest Report on Widening Access also reveals that the number of full-time, first-degree university entrants with experience of the care system continues to increase: it now stands at 1.9 percent, which is higher than the overall percentage of under-18s thought to be looked after by local authorities. Scottish Liberal Democrat education spokesperson Willie Rennie MSP says that the figures show the Scottish Government is guilty of 'breaking yet another promise to close the attainment gap between students from the most and least deprived areas.' He said: 'When it comes to the attainment gap, the SNP can only offer broken promises and missed targets. 'Universities have done a lot of work in trying to widen access, but they can only do so much. Ultimately, the SNP's failure to close the attainment gap at a school level undermines that good work because it is leaving lots of young people from deprived backgrounds without the support they need to get into university. 'In schools, there are lots of issues that need addressed, from behaviour challenges to teachers stuck on supply lists and fundamental problems with the curriculum. But all of these have gotten worsen on the SNP's watch.' Graeme Dey MSP, the [[Scottish Government]] Minister for Higher and Further Education Graeme Dey, welcomed publication of the latest data: 'These figures show that the number of people from deprived areas in Scotland studying full time for their first degree in 2023-24 was the second highest on record. 'The number of Scots, from the most deprived areas, entering university on full-time first degree courses is up 37% since this government established the Commission on Widening Access, while we have also seen record numbers of Scots from deprived areas accepted to study in 2024, increasing by 11% since 2023. 'The findings today are a testament to the great work being done by both our universities and colleges to improve access, with an increase to 20.8% of all full-time entrants to undergraduate HE courses, including colleges, coming from the most deprived areas. 'However, there is more to do to meet the goal of 20% of all entrants being from the 20% most deprived communities by 2030. I will continue to work constructively with the sector to create more opportunities for people from the poorest backgrounds to go to university and gain qualifications which will help in our mission to eradicate child poverty. 'Our continued pledge to keep tuition fees free is also ensuring that access to higher education is based on the ability to learn and not the ability to pay.'


STV News
an hour ago
- STV News
Donald Trump brands Nicola Sturgeon a 'terrible first minister'
Donald Trump branded Nicola Sturgeon a 'terrible first minister' as he made his way back to Washington following a working holiday in Scotland. The US President spoke to reporters aboard Air Force One after departing the country on Tuesday evening, adding he 'didn't have a lot of respect' for the former first minister of Scotland. 'I have a lot of respect for [current First Minister John Swinney],' Trump said. 'And I didn't have a lot of respect for the woman that preceded him. I thought she was terrible as first minister of Scotland. I think [Swinney] is doing a very good job.' A source close to Sturgeon said: 'Trump's lack of respect for women is hardly news. That said, the feeling was entirely mutual.' Trump was in Scotland for a five-day working holiday over the weekend. He landed at Prestwick Airport on Friday evening, and played multiple rounds of golf at his two Scottish golf resorts in Ayrshire and Aberdeenshire during his trip. After meeting with the Prime Minister and First Minister, Trump cut the ribbon on the 18-hole course at Trump International Golf Links on the Menie Estate on Tuesday. Sturgeon stood down as first minister in 2023. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country