De Lima slams Senate's return of VP Sara's impeachment case to House
Representative-elect Leila de Lima of ML Party-list denounced the move of the Senate sitting as an impeachment court to return to the House of Representatives the Articles of Impeachment against Vice President Sara Duterte.
'Harap-harapan na tayong niloloko. Sila ang nagtanong, sila rin ang sumagot. Walang due process. Walang hiya,' de Lima said in a statement.
(We are being duped right in front of us. They asked, but they are also the ones who answered. No due process. No shame.)
With 18 affirmative, five negative votes, and zero abstentions, the Senate, on Tuesday, voted to return to the lower chamber the Articles of Impeachment against the Vice President without dismissing or terminating them.
'Ano ito—korte o kulto? (What is this — a court or a cult?)' the former senator and incoming party-list said de Lima, who last month accepted invitations to join the prosecution panel of the House of Representatives in the impeachment trial of Duterte.
During a plenary session, Senator Ronald "Bato" dela Rosa made a motion seeking that the verified impeachment complaint against the Vice President be dismissed "in view of its constitutional infirmities and questions on the jurisdiction and authority of the 20th Congress."
Senate President Francis ''Chiz'' Escudero then ruled that the impeachment court should be convened first before acting on any motion to dismiss the impeachment complaint.
When the impeachment court was convened, senators debated on Dela Rosa's motion for hours.
Senator-judge Alan Peter Cayetano then moved to amend Dela Rosa's motion that the Articles of Impeachment be returned to the House of Representatives instead, without dismissing or terminating the case.
'There is no rule that allows this. No justice in shutting the door before the people can speak. No truth in a court that silences both sides,' de Lima said.
GMA News Online asked Escudero for comment but has yet to receive a reply as of posting time.
Escudero on Wednesday however said the House of Representatives has no option but to accept the Articles of Impeachment against Duterte, following the decision of the Senate, sitting as an impeachment court, to return the case back to the lower chamber.
The House of Representatives on Wednesday night certified that the impeachment of Duterte complied with the 1987 Constitution.
Escudero on Thursday however said the Senate has yet to receive any pleading from the House of Representatives regarding the impeachment of Duterte.
The ML Party-list representative-elect further said that the impeachment complaint should have been filed in a 'palengke' or a public market, saying 'pareho lang din—walang nangyaring hustisya… at least doon, may nagtitinda ng totoo (It's the same. There is no justice... At least [in the market], there are vendors who truthfully sell).'
'This is how impunity thrives: pakonti-konti, paisa-isang hakbang, hanggang sa mabaon sa kalokohan ang katotohanan (slowly, one step at a time, until the truth is buried under falsehood),' she said.
The incoming lawmaker then praised the senators who voted against remanding the Articles of Impeachment to the House.
'To Senators Risa Hontiveros, Koko Pimentel, Nancy Binay, Win Gatchalian, and Grace Poe: thank you for standing your ground,' de Lima said.
'This is not just a setback. It is a stain—on the Senate, on the law, on the very idea that accountability is still possible in this country,' she said.
'You had one job: to let the truth be heard. Instead, you chose silence dressed as procedure. Delay disguised as order. Cowardice in the costume of rules.
"Pero tandaan niyo ito: hindi kami tatahimik. At hindi lahat ng dinadaan sa teknikalidad ay nakakalimutan (But remember this: we will not be quiet. And not all that are processed via technicality will be forgotten),' she added.
De Lima further said the 'fight for truth continues—outside your halls, beyond your rules, and with the people who still believe that justice must prevail.'
The House of Representatives impeached Duterte on February 5, with over 200 lawmakers endorsing the complaint.
Duterte was accused of betrayal of public trust, culpable violation of the constitution, graft and corruption, and other high crimes.
The vice president earlier said the impeachment process is rooted in political retaliation, and referred to the impeachment trial as a "crucifixion." —KG, GMA Integrated News
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
GMA Network
an hour ago
- GMA Network
Joey Uy seeks TRO vs. Comelec ruling affirming Abante's win
Initial poll winner Luis 'Joey' Chua Uy on Monday asked the Supreme Court (SC) to issue a temporary restraining order (TRO) against the ruling of the Commission on Elections (Comelec) affirming Bienvenido 'Benny' Abante as Manila representative in the midterm polls. In his petition, Uy also asked the SC to issue a writ of preliminary injunction and a status quo ante order preserving the status of the parties and their respective positions. Uy's filing came after the Comelec En Banc junked his motion for reconsideration against its June 18 resolution that voided his certificate of candidacy. Comelec annulled Uy's proclamation, leaving Abante as the sole qualified candidate with the highest number of votes. The respondents are the Commission on Elections (Comelec) and Abante. GMA News Online asked Comelec for comment but has yet to receive a response as of posting time. Meanwhile, in a statement issued earlier, Abante welcomed the poll body's ruling, saying that in upholding the law, Comelec also upheld the truth. ['It] highlights the importance of protecting the integrity of our democratic institutions and ensuring that those who seek public office do so with honesty and transparency,' he said. 'Our constituents—the people of Manila—deserve no less. They deserve leaders who are open about who they are, faithful to the Constitution, and respectful of the sacred trust that comes with public service," he added. In a separate move, Uy also asked the House of Representatives Office of the Secretary General Reginald Velasco to include him in the list of House members for the 20th Congress, saying that he remains the legitimate Manila Sixth District congressional race winner pending his appeal before the Comelec. Uy cited Article 6, Section 7 of the Constitution which reads 'the members of the House of Representatives shall be elected for a term of three years which shall begin, unless otherwise provided by law, at noon on the 30th day of June next following their election.' Comelec earlier voided Uy's proclamation, allegedly because he is not a natural-born Filipino. 'We write on behalf of our client, Congressman Luis "Joey" C. Uy, duly elected Congressman of the Sixth District of Manila. At 12:00 noon today, Cong. Joey assumed the position of Member of the House of Representatives, in accordance with Section 7, Article VI of the 1987 Constitution,' Gialogo said. In addition, Uy's camp cited Section 13, Rule 18 of the Comelec Rules of Procedure which provides that a decision in special cases becomes final and executory only after five days from promulgation, unless the Supreme Court issues a Temporary Restraining Order. 'Congressman Joey's assumption of office is pursuant to his valid proclamation and oath of office, and stands despite the Resolution issued by the Commission on Elections en banc earlier this morning,' Gialogo said. 'Accordingly, we respectfully request your good office to include Cong. Joey in the Roll of Members of the House of Representatives and to receive his proposed bill for official filing and consideration,' he added. The lawyer also said Uy tried to file a House Bill on Monday, June 30 or which was supposed to be Day 1 of Uy's congressional tenure. However, the House personnel did not allow them to file the bill. Uy said he wanted to file a bill granting free flu vaccines for senior citizens. 'I want all the senior citizens to get their flu vaccines. As it is, the flu vaccines are only given while supply lasts,' he said.—LDF, GMA Integrated News
GMA Network
an hour ago
- GMA Network
Senators file priority bills in 20th Congress
Several senators on Monday have begun filing their priority bills and resolutions for the incoming 20th Congress. According to the Senate's bills and index section, Senator Loren Legarda was the first to file her 10 priority bills, topped by the One Tablet, One Student Act. Her other bills are as follows: Pangkabuhayan Act Unpaid Care Workers Equity and Empowerment Act Magna Carta of Waste Workers Living Wage Act Monthly Maintenance Medication Support Act for Senior Citizens Women and Children Protection Units Act Low Carbon Economy Act Complementarity in Education Act Blue Economy Act Next to file was Senate President Francis 'Chiz' Escudero, who included in his top ten bills is the act mandating government officials and employees to execute and submit a written permission to examine, inquire, or look into all their deposits and investments, thereby waiving the Bank Secrecy Law. Escudero also listed in his priority measures the act lowering the compulsory retirement age of teachers and non-teaching school personnel of the Department of Education (DepEd) from 65 to 60 years old. His other priority bills are: An act prohibiting any form of interference by national government agencies with the use of the national tax allotment and locally-generated revenues of local government units; To further strengthen local autonomy through a more rationalized system of decentralization; An act promoting business competitiveness by providing temporary tax relief to single proprietorships, cooperatives, partnerships or corporations classified as micro, small and medium enterprises An act promoting business growth and recovery by reducing the cost of business compliance for micro, small and medium enterprises; An act providing an increase and an automatic adjustment mechanism in the Personnel Economic Relief Allowance (PERA) granted to government employees; An act reinstituting mandatory credit allocation for micro, small and medium enterprises, imposing fines and penalties for noncompliance, and for other purposes; An act providing for the redevelopment of condominiums; An act establishing a tripartite council to address the problems of unemployment, underemployment, job-skills mismatch and technology-induced job displacement. Senate President Pro Tempore Jinggoy Ejercito Estrada came next, pushing for the promotion of safer communities and future-proof essential public services. Among his 20 legislative proposals is a measure that would guarantee a monthly stipend for all Filipino seniors—P1,000 for indigents, and P500 for non-indigents, to be increased after five years. He also sought for a measure granting senior citizens a 20% discount on travel tax. Estrada also filed the Disaster Food Bank and Stockpile Act, Department of Disaster Resilience Act, and the Rainwater Harvesting Facility Act, among others. Meanwhile, included in Senator Robin Padilla's 10 priority bills was an act expanding the grounds for dissolution of marriage, instituting divorce and setting the procedures thereof, providing protections to the parties to the marriage and its common children. He also filed measures seeking the medicalization of cannabis; the establishment of Muslim prayer rooms in all public offices and establishments; a P150 minimum wage increase for employees and workers in the private sector; and the prohibition of political dynasties. Senator Joel Villanueva, on the other hand, highlighted in his priority bills the Security of Tenure and End of Endo Act, which seeks to put a stop to the end-of-contract and labor-only contracting schemes. He also filed a bill on anti-online gambling which aims to ban all forms of online gambling in the country, among others. Topping the list of Senator Erwin Tulfo's priority measures was a resolution urging the Senate to review the Rice Tariffication Law, restoring the regulatory powers of National Food Authority. The first-termer senator also filed his version of the National Land Use Act which seeks to create a rational, holistic, and sustainable land use and physical planning mechanism. As a former secretary of the Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD), the younger Tulfo also proposed a bill that seeks to simplify the documentary requirements for accessing government financial assistance or ayuda. Senator Bong Go also filed his top 10 bills in the 20th Congress which included magna carta for barangays, across-the-board wage hike, establishment of Department of Disaster Resilience, and provision of expanded tertiary education subsidy. Returning senator Vicente 'Tito' Sotto III also filed 10 landmark bills aimed at strengthening government accountability, social welfare, public safety, and institutional reform. Among these were the People's Freedom of Information Act of 2025, Anti-False Content and Fake News Act, 14th Month Pay Law, Maternal Surname for Legitimate Children Act, and Rightsizing the National Government Act. For his part, Senator Bam Aquino filed 10 education-related measures, including proposals to bridge the education-to-employment gap and strengthen the implementation of the Tertiary Education Subsidy (TES) under the Free College Law. Aquino will also push for the School-to-Employment Program (STEP) Act which seeks to establish job placement offices in all public senior high schools, state universities and colleges, and local universities and colleges. He also filed the E-Textbook Para sa Lahat Act, which intends to improve access to textbooks for teachers and learners by requiring all DepEd-approved textbooks for basic education to be made available in digital format, free of charge, through official platforms or other authorized channels. —RF, GMA Integrated News
GMA Network
3 hours ago
- GMA Network
Hontiveros urges Chiz to conduct oath taking of new senator-judges
Senator Risa Hontiveros on Monday called on Senate President Francis 'Chiz' Escudero to already preside over the oath taking of the new senators in the 20th Congress who will serve as judges in the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte. At a press conference, Hontiveros explained that since the impeachment court is still in session now, Escudero, as the presiding officer, may call on the senators who won in the 2025 midterm elections anytime starting noon of June 30 to take their oath as senator-judges. 'Paalala, any time 12:01 p.m. onwards of today, pwede na at sana ipanumpa na ni presiding officer 'yung labindalawa pang bagong mga senador. Dahil by 12:01 p.m. today, 20th Congress na and therefore sila'y magiging senator-judges na ng Senate impeachment trial court,' she said. (Just a reminder, any time today 12:01 p.m. onwards, they can already take their oath and I hope the presiding officer will preside over that. Because by 12:01 p.m. today, it's already the 20th Congress and therefore they will be senator-judges of the Senate impeachment trial court.) 'The Senate impeachment rules say 'as they arrive.' So pwedeng one by one sila, two by two or 12, it doesn't matter, sila po ay senador na ng 20th Congress by June 30, 12:01 p.m. At dahil in session ang impeachment trial court at any time, sana mas maaga, panumpain na sila ni presiding officer. Sana wala ng ano pa mang delay or aberya between now and the 29th [July],' she added. (The Senate impeachment rules say 'as they arrive.' So they take their oath one by one, two by two or as a 12, it doesn't matter, they are already senators of the 20th congress by June 30, 12:01 p.m. And since the impeachment trial court is in session, the presiding officer can preside over that. I hope there won't be any delays between now and July 29.) GMA News Online has reached out to Escudero but he has yet to reply as of posting time. 20th Congress The 20th Congress is set to convene its first session day on July 28, on the fourth State of the Nation Address (SONA) of President Ferdinand 'Bongbong' Marcos Jr. The Senate impeachment court convened on June 10, with the trial proper expected to begin in the 20th Congress. Hontiveros further said that the impeachment court should proceed with the trial and not entertain any motion to dismiss Duterte's case. This was in reaction to Escudero's statement last Wednesday that the Senate impeachment court may vote on the motion to dismiss the impeachment complaint against Duterte if a senator-judge makes such a submission. 'Para sa amin, mga senator-judges, ibang understanding ko sa tungkulin namin, it is to conduct a trial,' Hontiveros said. (For us senators-judges, I understand that it is our duty to conduct a trial.) 'Para makaboto kami eventually na convict ba, acquit ba, kailangan naming madinig ang mga ebidensya sa bawat Article of Impeachment,' she added. (We need to hear the evidence in each Article of Impeachment, so that we can eventually vote whether to convict or acquit her.) The senator stressed that moving to dismiss the case or convict Duterte right away would not be fair to the prosecution, the impeachable official, and the public. 'So hindi po ako sumasang-ayon na karapatan namin bilang Senate impeachment trial court pagbotohan at pagdesisyunan na ni wala pang isang unang minuto ng trial 'yung motion to dismiss na nakapaloob sa ngayon sa formal answer ad cautelam. Kailangan umupo kami bilang senator-judges, i-kondukta ang trial, at saka lamang mag-desisyon at bumoto kung convict ba o acquit ba,' she said. (So I do not agree that it is our right as the Senate impeachment trial court to vote and decide on the motion to dismiss it. We must sit as senator-judges, conduct the trial, and then decide and vote whether to convict or acquit.) — RSJ, GMA Integrated News
