
Special care changes needed as costs push patients away
About 1.9 million Australians are delaying or skipping critical medical care due to exorbitant fees for specialist doctors, a report by public policy think tank the Grattan Institute has found.
Some private specialist doctors charge patients two to three times more than the rate Medicare sets for those services, the report found.
It said patients of one specialist forked out an average of $300 per year in 2023 - up 73 per cent since 2010.
Average out-of-pocket costs for extreme-fee-charging specialists in 2023 reached $671 for psychiatry services and more than $350 for endocrinology, cardiology, paediatrics, immunology and neurology services.
The high costs leave critical health care out of reach for millions, causing patients in poorer pockets of Australia to wait months or years for urgent appointments, and leading to missed diagnoses, avoidable pain and added pressure on hospitals.
About four in 10 Australians visited a specialist in 2023/24.
About two-thirds across all specialties are private appointments, with patients receiving a Medicare rebate and paying a gap fee.
Grattan's Health Program director Peter Breadon said the system was broken from start to end.
"Everywhere, from how the system is planned and how training is funded through to how we target public investment and integrate the system between primary care and specialist care, it all really needs a lot of change," he told AAP.
Grattan's recommendations include scrapping Medicare subsidies to specialists who charge excessive fees and publicly naming them.
"Hopefully it would discourage those specialists who are charging really unreasonable fees, but this is a problem that needs many solutions," Mr Breadon said.
The report also recommends governments provide one million extra specialist appointment services every year in areas that receive the least care, a system in which GPs can get written advice from other specialists, modernise public specialist clinics, and allocate $160 million to expand specialist training for undersupplied specialties and rural training.
Australian Medical Association President Danielle McMullen said public hospital underinvestment and lagging Medicare rebates made it harder for patients.
"The risks of delaying medical care are that the health problem gets worse," she said, adding it also puts pressure on GPs and hospitals in public and private clinics.
The doctors' association supports most of Grattan's recommendations, but said removing Medicare funding from specialists who charged excessive fees was not practical.
As governments negotiate the National Health Reform agreement, Dr McMullen urged leaders to sort out longer-term funding for public hospitals and develop a health workforce data tracker to show where investment was needed.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler said private health insurers and specialists needed to do more to protect patients from exorbitant bills.
He said the Albanese government would upgrade the Medical Costs Finder, which helps patients find the best value for specialist medical advice, and was committed to working with stakeholders to improve cost transparency.
High specialist medical costs cause almost two million Australians to delay or skip appointments, but a report suggests stripping public funding to doctors charging excessive fees could be part of the remedy.
About 1.9 million Australians are delaying or skipping critical medical care due to exorbitant fees for specialist doctors, a report by public policy think tank the Grattan Institute has found.
Some private specialist doctors charge patients two to three times more than the rate Medicare sets for those services, the report found.
It said patients of one specialist forked out an average of $300 per year in 2023 - up 73 per cent since 2010.
Average out-of-pocket costs for extreme-fee-charging specialists in 2023 reached $671 for psychiatry services and more than $350 for endocrinology, cardiology, paediatrics, immunology and neurology services.
The high costs leave critical health care out of reach for millions, causing patients in poorer pockets of Australia to wait months or years for urgent appointments, and leading to missed diagnoses, avoidable pain and added pressure on hospitals.
About four in 10 Australians visited a specialist in 2023/24.
About two-thirds across all specialties are private appointments, with patients receiving a Medicare rebate and paying a gap fee.
Grattan's Health Program director Peter Breadon said the system was broken from start to end.
"Everywhere, from how the system is planned and how training is funded through to how we target public investment and integrate the system between primary care and specialist care, it all really needs a lot of change," he told AAP.
Grattan's recommendations include scrapping Medicare subsidies to specialists who charge excessive fees and publicly naming them.
"Hopefully it would discourage those specialists who are charging really unreasonable fees, but this is a problem that needs many solutions," Mr Breadon said.
The report also recommends governments provide one million extra specialist appointment services every year in areas that receive the least care, a system in which GPs can get written advice from other specialists, modernise public specialist clinics, and allocate $160 million to expand specialist training for undersupplied specialties and rural training.
Australian Medical Association President Danielle McMullen said public hospital underinvestment and lagging Medicare rebates made it harder for patients.
"The risks of delaying medical care are that the health problem gets worse," she said, adding it also puts pressure on GPs and hospitals in public and private clinics.
The doctors' association supports most of Grattan's recommendations, but said removing Medicare funding from specialists who charged excessive fees was not practical.
As governments negotiate the National Health Reform agreement, Dr McMullen urged leaders to sort out longer-term funding for public hospitals and develop a health workforce data tracker to show where investment was needed.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler said private health insurers and specialists needed to do more to protect patients from exorbitant bills.
He said the Albanese government would upgrade the Medical Costs Finder, which helps patients find the best value for specialist medical advice, and was committed to working with stakeholders to improve cost transparency.
High specialist medical costs cause almost two million Australians to delay or skip appointments, but a report suggests stripping public funding to doctors charging excessive fees could be part of the remedy.
About 1.9 million Australians are delaying or skipping critical medical care due to exorbitant fees for specialist doctors, a report by public policy think tank the Grattan Institute has found.
Some private specialist doctors charge patients two to three times more than the rate Medicare sets for those services, the report found.
It said patients of one specialist forked out an average of $300 per year in 2023 - up 73 per cent since 2010.
Average out-of-pocket costs for extreme-fee-charging specialists in 2023 reached $671 for psychiatry services and more than $350 for endocrinology, cardiology, paediatrics, immunology and neurology services.
The high costs leave critical health care out of reach for millions, causing patients in poorer pockets of Australia to wait months or years for urgent appointments, and leading to missed diagnoses, avoidable pain and added pressure on hospitals.
About four in 10 Australians visited a specialist in 2023/24.
About two-thirds across all specialties are private appointments, with patients receiving a Medicare rebate and paying a gap fee.
Grattan's Health Program director Peter Breadon said the system was broken from start to end.
"Everywhere, from how the system is planned and how training is funded through to how we target public investment and integrate the system between primary care and specialist care, it all really needs a lot of change," he told AAP.
Grattan's recommendations include scrapping Medicare subsidies to specialists who charge excessive fees and publicly naming them.
"Hopefully it would discourage those specialists who are charging really unreasonable fees, but this is a problem that needs many solutions," Mr Breadon said.
The report also recommends governments provide one million extra specialist appointment services every year in areas that receive the least care, a system in which GPs can get written advice from other specialists, modernise public specialist clinics, and allocate $160 million to expand specialist training for undersupplied specialties and rural training.
Australian Medical Association President Danielle McMullen said public hospital underinvestment and lagging Medicare rebates made it harder for patients.
"The risks of delaying medical care are that the health problem gets worse," she said, adding it also puts pressure on GPs and hospitals in public and private clinics.
The doctors' association supports most of Grattan's recommendations, but said removing Medicare funding from specialists who charged excessive fees was not practical.
As governments negotiate the National Health Reform agreement, Dr McMullen urged leaders to sort out longer-term funding for public hospitals and develop a health workforce data tracker to show where investment was needed.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler said private health insurers and specialists needed to do more to protect patients from exorbitant bills.
He said the Albanese government would upgrade the Medical Costs Finder, which helps patients find the best value for specialist medical advice, and was committed to working with stakeholders to improve cost transparency.
High specialist medical costs cause almost two million Australians to delay or skip appointments, but a report suggests stripping public funding to doctors charging excessive fees could be part of the remedy.
About 1.9 million Australians are delaying or skipping critical medical care due to exorbitant fees for specialist doctors, a report by public policy think tank the Grattan Institute has found.
Some private specialist doctors charge patients two to three times more than the rate Medicare sets for those services, the report found.
It said patients of one specialist forked out an average of $300 per year in 2023 - up 73 per cent since 2010.
Average out-of-pocket costs for extreme-fee-charging specialists in 2023 reached $671 for psychiatry services and more than $350 for endocrinology, cardiology, paediatrics, immunology and neurology services.
The high costs leave critical health care out of reach for millions, causing patients in poorer pockets of Australia to wait months or years for urgent appointments, and leading to missed diagnoses, avoidable pain and added pressure on hospitals.
About four in 10 Australians visited a specialist in 2023/24.
About two-thirds across all specialties are private appointments, with patients receiving a Medicare rebate and paying a gap fee.
Grattan's Health Program director Peter Breadon said the system was broken from start to end.
"Everywhere, from how the system is planned and how training is funded through to how we target public investment and integrate the system between primary care and specialist care, it all really needs a lot of change," he told AAP.
Grattan's recommendations include scrapping Medicare subsidies to specialists who charge excessive fees and publicly naming them.
"Hopefully it would discourage those specialists who are charging really unreasonable fees, but this is a problem that needs many solutions," Mr Breadon said.
The report also recommends governments provide one million extra specialist appointment services every year in areas that receive the least care, a system in which GPs can get written advice from other specialists, modernise public specialist clinics, and allocate $160 million to expand specialist training for undersupplied specialties and rural training.
Australian Medical Association President Danielle McMullen said public hospital underinvestment and lagging Medicare rebates made it harder for patients.
"The risks of delaying medical care are that the health problem gets worse," she said, adding it also puts pressure on GPs and hospitals in public and private clinics.
The doctors' association supports most of Grattan's recommendations, but said removing Medicare funding from specialists who charged excessive fees was not practical.
As governments negotiate the National Health Reform agreement, Dr McMullen urged leaders to sort out longer-term funding for public hospitals and develop a health workforce data tracker to show where investment was needed.
Federal Health Minister Mark Butler said private health insurers and specialists needed to do more to protect patients from exorbitant bills.
He said the Albanese government would upgrade the Medical Costs Finder, which helps patients find the best value for specialist medical advice, and was committed to working with stakeholders to improve cost transparency.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Advertiser
8 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Understanding your stroke risk and what you can do about It
This is branded content for the Health Care Consumers' Association and is funded by the Australian Government. The impact of stroke can be serious and sometimes life-threatening. If you have atrial fibrillation (AF), your risk of having a stroke can be up to five times higher. This is because an irregular heartbeat can lead to blood clots that may travel to your brain. AF affects over 500,000 Australians and plays a role in nearly one in 10 deaths. Getting checked and managing AF early can help lower your risk of stroke. What is atrial fibrillation? AF is a condition where your heart beats irregularly. With a normal heartbeat, blood pumps through all four chambers of the heart smoothly. In atrial fibrillation, the upper chambers of the heart beat quickly and out of rhythm with the lower chambers of the heart. This means that blood does not move through the heart as it is supposed to. When this happens, it can cause blood to pool in the heart and form a 'blood clot. And if a clot breaks away from the heart and travels to the brain, it can cause a stroke. Signs of stroke include: If you have AF, you may get: Some people may not experience any symptoms at all To find out if you have AF, a doctor or nurse will check your pulse. If it feels irregular, they may send you for more tests. How can you treat atrial fibrillation? If you have AF, your healthcare professional will work with you to manage your condition. One treatment they might recommend is an anticoagulant medicine. Anticoagulants are a type of medicine that helps prevent blood clots. They don't treat the irregular heartbeat directly, but they make it harder for your blood to form a clot. This helps lower your risk of having a stroke from AF. Other treatments are needed to help with symptoms caused by AF. Risks and benefits of taking anticoagulant medicine Anticoagulants can sometimes cause bruising or bleeding, but they lower your risk of stroke, which can be more serious. The benefit of taking them is greater than the risk of bleeding. Although rare, if you notice serious bruising or bleeding while taking anticoagulants, go straight to a hospital or call 000 and ask for an ambulance. With the right treatment and regular care, including taking anticoagulants safely and as prescribed, most people with AF can continue to live well. Why are anticoagulants important for managing atrial fibrillation? People with AF have a higher risk of stroke. A stroke can cause serious damage to the brain with long-lasting effects. Taking anticoagulants can help lower your risk of stroke. Your healthcare professional will talk with you about your options and help you understand how to take your anticoagulant medicine safely. They can also answer any questions you may have. The Anticoagulants Care Plan is a helpful guide. It has more information and tips on how to talk with your health professional about taking your anticoagulant medicine safely. If you have any questions or concerns about how this information relates to your own health, speak with your doctor or healthcare provider for advice that's right for you. This is branded content for the Health Care Consumers' Association and is funded by the Australian Government. The impact of stroke can be serious and sometimes life-threatening. If you have atrial fibrillation (AF), your risk of having a stroke can be up to five times higher. This is because an irregular heartbeat can lead to blood clots that may travel to your brain. AF affects over 500,000 Australians and plays a role in nearly one in 10 deaths. Getting checked and managing AF early can help lower your risk of stroke. What is atrial fibrillation? AF is a condition where your heart beats irregularly. With a normal heartbeat, blood pumps through all four chambers of the heart smoothly. In atrial fibrillation, the upper chambers of the heart beat quickly and out of rhythm with the lower chambers of the heart. This means that blood does not move through the heart as it is supposed to. When this happens, it can cause blood to pool in the heart and form a 'blood clot. And if a clot breaks away from the heart and travels to the brain, it can cause a stroke. Signs of stroke include: If you have AF, you may get: Some people may not experience any symptoms at all To find out if you have AF, a doctor or nurse will check your pulse. If it feels irregular, they may send you for more tests. How can you treat atrial fibrillation? If you have AF, your healthcare professional will work with you to manage your condition. One treatment they might recommend is an anticoagulant medicine. Anticoagulants are a type of medicine that helps prevent blood clots. They don't treat the irregular heartbeat directly, but they make it harder for your blood to form a clot. This helps lower your risk of having a stroke from AF. Other treatments are needed to help with symptoms caused by AF. Risks and benefits of taking anticoagulant medicine Anticoagulants can sometimes cause bruising or bleeding, but they lower your risk of stroke, which can be more serious. The benefit of taking them is greater than the risk of bleeding. Although rare, if you notice serious bruising or bleeding while taking anticoagulants, go straight to a hospital or call 000 and ask for an ambulance. With the right treatment and regular care, including taking anticoagulants safely and as prescribed, most people with AF can continue to live well. Why are anticoagulants important for managing atrial fibrillation? People with AF have a higher risk of stroke. A stroke can cause serious damage to the brain with long-lasting effects. Taking anticoagulants can help lower your risk of stroke. Your healthcare professional will talk with you about your options and help you understand how to take your anticoagulant medicine safely. They can also answer any questions you may have. The Anticoagulants Care Plan is a helpful guide. It has more information and tips on how to talk with your health professional about taking your anticoagulant medicine safely. If you have any questions or concerns about how this information relates to your own health, speak with your doctor or healthcare provider for advice that's right for you. This is branded content for the Health Care Consumers' Association and is funded by the Australian Government. The impact of stroke can be serious and sometimes life-threatening. If you have atrial fibrillation (AF), your risk of having a stroke can be up to five times higher. This is because an irregular heartbeat can lead to blood clots that may travel to your brain. AF affects over 500,000 Australians and plays a role in nearly one in 10 deaths. Getting checked and managing AF early can help lower your risk of stroke. What is atrial fibrillation? AF is a condition where your heart beats irregularly. With a normal heartbeat, blood pumps through all four chambers of the heart smoothly. In atrial fibrillation, the upper chambers of the heart beat quickly and out of rhythm with the lower chambers of the heart. This means that blood does not move through the heart as it is supposed to. When this happens, it can cause blood to pool in the heart and form a 'blood clot. And if a clot breaks away from the heart and travels to the brain, it can cause a stroke. Signs of stroke include: If you have AF, you may get: Some people may not experience any symptoms at all To find out if you have AF, a doctor or nurse will check your pulse. If it feels irregular, they may send you for more tests. How can you treat atrial fibrillation? If you have AF, your healthcare professional will work with you to manage your condition. One treatment they might recommend is an anticoagulant medicine. Anticoagulants are a type of medicine that helps prevent blood clots. They don't treat the irregular heartbeat directly, but they make it harder for your blood to form a clot. This helps lower your risk of having a stroke from AF. Other treatments are needed to help with symptoms caused by AF. Risks and benefits of taking anticoagulant medicine Anticoagulants can sometimes cause bruising or bleeding, but they lower your risk of stroke, which can be more serious. The benefit of taking them is greater than the risk of bleeding. Although rare, if you notice serious bruising or bleeding while taking anticoagulants, go straight to a hospital or call 000 and ask for an ambulance. With the right treatment and regular care, including taking anticoagulants safely and as prescribed, most people with AF can continue to live well. Why are anticoagulants important for managing atrial fibrillation? People with AF have a higher risk of stroke. A stroke can cause serious damage to the brain with long-lasting effects. Taking anticoagulants can help lower your risk of stroke. Your healthcare professional will talk with you about your options and help you understand how to take your anticoagulant medicine safely. They can also answer any questions you may have. The Anticoagulants Care Plan is a helpful guide. It has more information and tips on how to talk with your health professional about taking your anticoagulant medicine safely. If you have any questions or concerns about how this information relates to your own health, speak with your doctor or healthcare provider for advice that's right for you.


West Australian
9 hours ago
- West Australian
Private healthcare giant Ramsay shuts psychology clinics
The country's biggest private hospital company will shut the majority of its psychology clinics in a matter of months. Ramsay Health Care notified staff of the closure of 17 of its 20 clinics earlier this month. The three remaining clinics are in the Newcastle suburb of Charlestown, in Perth's northern suburbs, and in Cairns. 'We understand this change might be unsettling and we are working closely with our psychologists to ensure every client is supported and has continuity of care, whether through our existing and expanded Telehealth service or with another trusted provider, depending on what is clinically appropriate,' a spokesperson said. 'This change is part of Ramsay's broader strategy to strengthen how we deliver high-quality, accessible and connected care across hospital, home and virtual settings.' Only Ramsay's community-based psychology clinics are closing, not its hospital mental health services or inpatient and day programs. Federal Greens leader Larissa Waters said half of Australians who needed mental health support already could not get it. 'The waiting lists are huge, and so it's devastating to see that a private healthcare operator is going to close down yet more facilities, and where are those people going to go?' she said. 'Health care shouldn't be for profit, and it shouldn't be how much money you've got on your credit card to enable you to get the health care that you need. 'So it's a real shame that profit seems to be driving this outcome that will have a real impact.' Ramsay Health is listed on the Australian sharemarket and valued at $8.9bn. The company's share price is down 16 per cent over the past 12 months. In August, Ramsay Health Care reported a nearly triple full-year profit of $888.7m, up from $298.1m the year before. The large return was mostly due to the sale of Ramsay's stake in Ramsay Sime Darby, which owns hospitals in Malaysia and Indonesia. The financial results gave shareholders an 80 cent dividend per share across the financial year. 'The government should be providing healthcare services as a universal right of all Australians, and it shouldn't be whether or not a private company's profit margin is going to work to determine the outcomes for Australians' access to mental health care,' Ms Waters said. The 17 clinics are being shut progressively until the final one closes the doors permanently by the end of August. Four Melbourne clinics are being shut, three in Sydney will close, two in Perth will shut, and single clinics on the Sunshine Coast, Ipswich, the Gold Coast, NSW's Central Coast and Wollongong will close. 'After careful consideration, we are transitioning Ramsay Psychology to a more flexible and sustainable model, which includes the progressive closure of 17 clinics by the end of August,' the Ramsay spokesperson said. 'Three clinics, in Cairns (QLD), Charlestown (NSW) and Joondalup (WA), will remain open to support local needs, maintain key partnerships and pilot more integrated models of care. 'Ramsay Health Care is reshaping how it delivers community-based mental health support to better meet the evolving needs of clients and clinicians.' The National Mental Health Commission's National Report Card was also released on Thursday, the same day as news of the Ramsay closures broke. Health commission chief executive David McGrath said fewer and fewer people could afford mental health care. 'We have also seen a steady rise in financial stress and in the proportion of people in Australia delaying mental health care due to cost in the last four years,' Mr McGrath said in the report. 'Disappointingly, many social factors impacting mental health are not showing improvement (e.g. loneliness and experiences of discrimination) and positive experiences of mental health care have remained stable.' People were feeling less secluded than in the previous year, the commission found, and more people were getting help now than in 2007. 'However, there is no question there is a long way to go – our younger generations continue to report heightened psychological distress and financial stress and have a much higher prevalence of mental health challenges relative to the rest of the population,' Mr McGrath said.


Perth Now
9 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘Devastating': Private health giant shuts clinics
The country's biggest private hospital company will shut the majority of its psychology clinics in a matter of months. Ramsay Health Care notified staff of the closure of 17 of its 20 clinics earlier this month. The three remaining clinics are in the Newcastle suburb of Charlestown, in Perth's northern suburbs, and in Cairns. 'We understand this change might be unsettling and we are working closely with our psychologists to ensure every client is supported and has continuity of care, whether through our existing and expanded Telehealth service or with another trusted provider, depending on what is clinically appropriate,' a spokesperson said. 'This change is part of Ramsay's broader strategy to strengthen how we deliver high-quality, accessible and connected care across hospital, home and virtual settings.' Ramsay Health Care is a major player in Australia's private healthcare industry. Jason Edwards / NewsWire Credit: News Corp Australia Only Ramsay's community-based psychology clinics are closing, not its hospital mental health services or inpatient and day programs. Federal Greens leader Larissa Waters said half of Australians who needed mental health support already could not get it. 'The waiting lists are huge, and so it's devastating to see that a private healthcare operator is going to close down yet more facilities, and where are those people going to go?' she said. 'Health care shouldn't be for profit, and it shouldn't be how much money you've got on your credit card to enable you to get the health care that you need. 'So it's a real shame that profit seems to be driving this outcome that will have a real impact.' Ramsay Health is listed on the Australian sharemarket and valued at $8.9bn. The company's share price is down 16 per cent over the past 12 months. Erina on the NSW Central Coast is one of the clinics to close. Google Credit: Supplied In August, Ramsay Health Care reported a nearly triple full-year profit of $888.7m, up from $298.1m the year before. The large return was mostly due to the sale of Ramsay's stake in Ramsay Sime Darby, which owns hospitals in Malaysia and Indonesia. The financial results gave shareholders an 80 cent dividend per share across the financial year. 'The government should be providing healthcare services as a universal right of all Australians, and it shouldn't be whether or not a private company's profit margin is going to work to determine the outcomes for Australians' access to mental health care,' Ms Waters said. The 17 clinics are being shut progressively until the final one closes the doors permanently by the end of August. Ramsay Health Care's share price has tumbled over the past year. NewsWire / Gaye Gerard Credit: News Corp Australia Four Melbourne clinics are being shut, three in Sydney will close, two in Perth will shut, and single clinics on the Sunshine Coast, Ipswich, the Gold Coast, NSW's Central Coast and Wollongong will close. 'After careful consideration, we are transitioning Ramsay Psychology to a more flexible and sustainable model, which includes the progressive closure of 17 clinics by the end of August,' the Ramsay spokesperson said. 'Three clinics, in Cairns (QLD), Charlestown (NSW) and Joondalup (WA), will remain open to support local needs, maintain key partnerships and pilot more integrated models of care. 'Ramsay Health Care is reshaping how it delivers community-based mental health support to better meet the evolving needs of clients and clinicians.' The National Mental Health Commission's National Report Card was also released on Thursday, the same day as news of the Ramsay closures broke. Health commission chief executive David McGrath said fewer and fewer people could afford mental health care. 'We have also seen a steady rise in financial stress and in the proportion of people in Australia delaying mental health care due to cost in the last four years,' Mr McGrath said in the report. 'Disappointingly, many social factors impacting mental health are not showing improvement (e.g. loneliness and experiences of discrimination) and positive experiences of mental health care have remained stable.' People were feeling less secluded than in the previous year, the commission found, and more people were getting help now than in 2007. 'However, there is no question there is a long way to go – our younger generations continue to report heightened psychological distress and financial stress and have a much higher prevalence of mental health challenges relative to the rest of the population,' Mr McGrath said.