Inside a fired fitness trainer's legal fight against Fisher Island
The big picture: The island community — accessible only by boat or helicopter — is one of the wealthiest ZIP codes in America and a source of palace intrigue, legal fights and celebrity gossip.
Driving the news: Shebah Carfagna, who says she was the only Black woman working as a trainer on Fisher Island, alleges in a lawsuit filed last year that the club "terminated her because she is a black woman who objected to her mistreatment."
District Judge Rodolfo A. Ruiz II in January dismissed two counts from the suit and sent another to arbitration.
A fourth count — alleging the club's actions "demonstrate an intent to discriminate against Carfagna on the basis of her race" — remains pending.
Carfagna, who worked on Fisher Island for 14 years through her Panache Fitness brand, alleges that the club:
Directed clients away from her and her life partner, a Black man who also works on Fisher Island as a trainer.
Prevented her from teaching certain classes she was certified to teach.
Withheld payments owed to her and harassed and intimidated her.
The other side: Fisher Island Club issued a statement to Axios denying the allegations and saying it ended its business relationship with Panache Fitness "for legitimate business reasons."
"The Club is disappointed that last year Ms. Carfagna filed a lawsuit alleging that this decision was unlawful," the club said.
"However, the Club is committed to continue to address such allegations through the appropriate legal channels as the allegations are unfounded and without merit."
The club ended its contract with Panache Fitness in April 2024, alleging that Carfagna offered virtual fitness classes without club approval and that trainers and guests had complained about her, according to Carfagna's lawsuit.
In her lawsuit, filed last June but not previously reported, Carfagna argues her firing was retaliation for raising concerns about a "hostile" work environment.
The club's reasons for firing her were "entirely contrived," her lawsuit says.
Zoom in: The club allowed white trainers to hold virtual classes, the lawsuit says.
The wife of a Fisher Island board member attended Carfagna's virtual classes and emailed the club to ask that Carfagna be hired back, the suit says. (In a legal filing, Fisher Island attorneys did not dispute this.)
Carfagna said the club's complaints were inconsistent with her "impeccable" reputation and said many other club members sent emails to management opposing her firing.
What they're saying: Carfagna's attorney, Jonathan Minsker, tells Axios that Fisher Island Club's actions are "both shameful and illegal."
"Ms. Carfagna did not want this fight, and she did not ask for it, but she will not be bullied," he said in a statement. "She intends to fully vindicate her rights and hopefully prevent the Club's management from doing this to others."
What's next: Fisher Island this month filed a motion asking the judge to rule in its favor on the lawsuit's sole remaining count, which would end the suit.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
3 minutes ago
- Axios
Death row inmate with heart implant reported pain as he was executed
Tennessee death row inmate Byron Black moaned and said he was in pain during his execution, according to reporters who witnessed the lethal injection Tuesday morning. Black's attorney said his distress was evidence he was "tortured." Black's legal team had argued his heart implant could create unconstitutional pain during the execution. At one point, Black told his spiritual adviser, who was with him, it was "hurting so bad," according to witness accounts. Prison officials took Black into the execution chamber at Riverbend Maximum Security Institution shortly after 10am. He was declared dead at 10:43am. Multiple media witnesses said Black appeared to be in more distress than inmate Oscar Franklin Smith, who was put to death by lethal injection earlier this year. The big picture: Black's attorneys asked multiple courts to delay the execution so doctors could deactivate a medical device implanted last year to keep his heart beating normally. The lawyers said the device could deliver painful repeated shocks in an attempt to restore Black's heartbeat. They argued that would amount to cruel and unusual punishment that violated the U.S. Constitution. They had also fought to stop the execution because of Black's intellectual disability. Prosecutors agreed the new state standards would make Black ineligible for the death penalty if he were tried today. Black, 69, was sentenced to death for the 1988 shooting deaths of his girlfriend Angela Clay and her two young daughters, 9-year-old Latoya and 6-year-old Lakeisha. The Clay family, which provided a statement after the execution, said "a load and burden that has been lifted off our hearts." "This is closure for my family," Clark's sister wrote in the statement. "My sister and her two daughters can finally rest in peace." What she's saying: Federal public defender Kelley Henry, who represented Black, said the state had "heartlessly and intentionally traumatized a second family today. A family that matters. A family that is devastated."
Indianapolis Star
an hour ago
- Indianapolis Star
Westfield residents asked to lock doors, stay inside as police search for armed man
This story will update. Westfield residents between 191st Street to 196th Street and U.S. 31 to Flippins Road are asked to lock their doors and stay inside as police search the area for an armed man who fled from a car chase on foot. The suspect is described as a Black man with dreadlocks wearing a dark blue or black hoodie or sweatshirt. Police have formed a perimeter around the area. Publicly available flight data shows an Indiana State Police helicopter circling near the intersection of East 191st Street and U.S. 31. Anybody who sees suspicious activity is asked to call 911 or the Hamilton County Sheriff's Department at (317) 773-1282. The circumstances leading up to the police chase have not been made available at the time of publication. The Westfield Police Department characterized the situation as "an active investigation."
Axios
2 hours ago
- Axios
Developer pulls plans for Heritage Square rezoning in Durham
A Chicago developer proposing a new life sciences campus near downtown Durham has pulled its rezoning application from the City Council at the 11th hour. Why it matters: The plans from Chicago-based Sterling Bay envisioned a mixed-use life sciences campus on the site of the Heritage Square shopping center on the edge of the Hayti neighborhood and across the Durham Freeway from downtown. The shopping center currently sits vacant, but was once home to a grocery store, some smaller shops and restaurants. Driving the news: The developer's plans, which were set to be heard at Monday night's Durham City Council meeting, were facing pushback from residents of Hayti, a historically Black neighborhood that has faced rising costs in recent years. Many of those residents expressed concern at the City Council meeting that a project of that size will cause property valuations across the neighborhood to soar even more, the News & Observer reported. Before the council could vote, however, Sterling Bay withdrew its application, a move that surprised the council and the dozens of people in the audience. The council ultimately voted to approve the withdrawal 5-2. Zoom in: A Sterling Bay spokesperson told Axios the company is disappointed that the project will not proceed, and noted that it's worked for the past three years to speak with residents in the neighborhood about the project. The company said it proposed $2.3 million in contributions to the local community as part of its rezoning, including scholarship money for N.C. Central University and Durham Technical Community College, a contribution to the Hayti Promise Community Development Corporation, affordable retail space and several other measures. "While the initiative will not move forward, we remain proud of the collaborative efforts that shaped it," the spokesperson said in a statement. What's next: The withdrawal means that Sterling Bay could resubmit another rezoning in six months or potentially build without it. Sterling Bay only filed the rezoning after discovering issues with the bedrock that made building underground parking more expensive and required taller buildings. The company had bought the 10-acre property for $62 million in 2022, according to county records. Sterling Bay said it was "exploring new steps" but declined to comment further on what might become of the property. Between the lines: The pulling of the rezoning also comes at a time when financing for office and lab buildings is much harder to come by.
