Banks warn lending disclosure regulations threaten financial system
But amendment to the CCCFA's disclosure settings could interfere with legal action being taken against ASB and ANZ.
Photo:
RNZ
Banks warn consumer lending disclosure regulations could threaten the stability of the financial system and are calling for changes.
A report by the Reserve Bank - shared with government cabinet ministers last October - estimates disclosure breaches under the consumer lending law could have a $12.9 billion impact on the financial system.
The costs could potentially be greater depending on the outcome of Commerce Commission investigation into possible disclosure breaches that happened between 2015 and 2019.
The Bankers Association chief executive Roger Beaumont said banks would like to see changes made to the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act (CCCFA) to
limit liability when mistakes were made in disclosures
.
"Between 2015 and 2019 any lender who even made a small mistake in the information provided to customers, like getting their phone number wrong, could, on one interpretation, be required to repay all the interest and fees paid until the error was corrected," Beaumont said.
"That consequence would be totally out of proportion with the technical legal breach, especially if there was no harm to the consumer."
However, an amendment to the CCCFA's disclosure settings
could interfere with legal action
being taken against ASB and ANZ by around 170,000 customers, over past disclosure failures.
The RBNZ's report indicates it could take a couple of years before those cases were heard, which made it difficult to estimate the potential risk to financial stability.
"The potential lead time before any adverse findings means that there is time for impacted entities to plan how they would respond," the RBNZ said.
Beaumont said the ongoing risk should be dealt with now.
"At a time of economic recovery and global uncertainty, the last thing New Zealand needs is the risk of this scenario playing out.
"It shows why the law is bad and needs to be fixed," he said.
"It's important to remember that the proposed law change does not stop consumers or regulators taking action against lenders for information disclosure breaches. Nor does it stop any cases currently before the courts."
The CCCFA is a controversial piece of legislation which had been reviewed and amended several times since it was first introduced in the mid-70s.
A tightening up of disclosure rules in 2021 led to unintended consequences, with mainstream lenders becoming far more cautious and denying loans to people and businesses with previously good credit records.
Those concerns resulted in further amendments to the CCCFA in 2024, which gave banks more flexibility and discretion in making loans.
Further amendments to the CCCFA were in the works, with a bill introduced to Parliament last month, setting out additional changes to disclosure rules.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
You can DIY your KiwiSaver, but should you?
Photo: RNZ More KiwiSaver schemes allow investors to choose their own investments - but should you do it? This week, Sharesies expanded its 'self select' KiwiSaver option to include US shares and exchange-traded funds. Members can now add more than 150 New Zealand and US investments to their KiwiSaver portfolios, alongside 'base funds'. Up to half a KiwiSaver member's plan can be allocated to their own investment picks, with a maximum of 5 percent in each pick. To varying degrees, Craigs Investment Partners, NZ Funds, Nikko, InvestNow, Kernel and KiwiWRAP also allow investors to select where their money goes. Sharesies super and funds general manager Matt McPherson said investors said they wanted more connection and control over what was available. "People who want to take some of the control, but not all of it are who we're building for." He said about 40 percent of Sharesies KiwiSaver members had some of their own picks and about 10 percent of their contributions going into those. He said the most popular self-select pick was the S&P500. "What people like about that is that it's very low cost and it's very passive." Investments in big global brands were also proving popular, such as Microsoft, Apple and Amazon. Each stock was in its own pie fund for Sharesies investors to simplify tax considerations. Genesis Advice financial adviser Edward Glennie said it was sensible for KiwiSaver schemes to have limits on how much choice investors could have, "If you're allowed to put 100 percent on one particular stock, that might compromise your returns, particular if you're unadvised." He said he would work with clients through KiwiWRAP to help them set up a suitable portfolio. Self-select options could sometimes have higher costs, but he said that was probably the direction the market was headed. It also allowed people to get away from the 'one manager' model that had been dominant since the scheme launched 18 years ago. "I think the market is gradually opening up." Data director Greg Bunkall said it was difficult to anticipate most individuals outperforming fund managers with their own picks. "In Australia, studies comparing self-managed superannuation fund (SMSF) portfolios with APRA-regulated funds present mixed results, with superior returns observed among SMSFs that possess substantial balances and leverage the expertise of financial advisors in their decision-making processes." McPherson said the option would not be the right thing for all investors. "Fund managers do great work of finding undervalued companies and investing in them, so that's why the product is built around this idea of, if you want to, you can do a bit of it, as opposed to having to take on all the responsibility." McPherson said Sharesies' model was more like the self-directed options seen in Australian, than full self-management. Kernel Wealth founder Dean Anderson said members could "mix and match" from Kernel's 21 funds. "We've found overall investors are very informed, with fund selection often reflecting an investor's age and life stage. Of course, Kernel isn't a default provider, so investors have typically made an educated decision to move to us and have realised the benefits of being engaged with their KiwiSaver. "Consistently outperforming the market over time is incredibly challenging, but KiwiSaver members, who customise their plans, often have a specific purpose in mind. Some may want 100 percent of their KiwiSaver invested in global shares, others might prioritise values by choosing ESG-centric funds or they could be aiming to diversify away from other assets they own, selecting funds that balance their overall wealth. "As investors approach the time to access their KiwiSaver, the self-select function becomes even more valuable. They might start to bucket their assets-moving funds for the first few years of retirement spending into a cash fund, while keeping another bucket in higher-growth assets to support their financial needs 10, 20 or even 30 years down the line. "This flexibility is incredibly useful, rather than being forced to only be in one strategy."
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
Invercargill mayor Nobby Clark criticises own council of being too risk averse
Invercargill Mayor Nobby Clark says his council should take more risks. Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER Invercargill mayor Nobby Clark has hit out at his own council, saying its aversion to risk has resulted in an "eye watering" consultants bill. His comments follow the organisation revealing it spent more than $7.3 million on consultants in less than three years between July 2022 and December 2024. Clark said the council's low tolerance for risk meant elected members didn't "run against" advice from management, and management used consultants to "justify" the advice they gave elected members. "For me, personally, I think the risk should be higher. We should take more risk," Clark said. "Because at the end of the day, you've got to balance it out against the cost of these consultants, which are eye watering amounts." Clark said the only way to change the situation was to tell staff not to spend large amounts on advice, and for councillors to accept the risk. "And if we get it wrong, we get it wrong." Invercargill City Council was approached for comment but did not respond in time for publication. The numbers were made public on the back of a LGOIMA request from the Taxpayers' Union, which released the data on Friday. It showed $2.58 million was spent on consultants for the 12 months to June 2023, $3.23 million was spent for the 12 months to June 2024, and $1.52 million was spent for the six months to December 2024. The document showed more than 160 companies were used during the two-and-a-half-year period. Deloitte topped the spending with more than $424,000 for work on reviewing rates, contract compliance, internal audit support, and risk and assurance support. Stantec was next with a figure of more than $396,000 for support with the Bluff wastewater consent. LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Teenagers who gain work experience at school more likely to be employed by age 20
Gateway supported short-term, work-based placements while Trades Academies provided learning in trades-related. (File photo) Photo: Supplied/ UCOL Teenagers who gain trade and workplace experience at school are more likely to get a qualification and complete apprenticeships, a report finds. A Ministry of Education report said students who participated in the Gateway and Trades Academy programmes were also more likely to be in substantial employment by the age of 20 than other students with similar characteristics. The report considered the cohorts that participated in the programmes in 2014 and in 2018 and compared their education and employment outcomes with similar students who did not participate. It said Gateway was set up in 2001 and supported short-term, work-based placements while Trades Academies had provided learning in trades-related fields since 2010. "Both programmes increased the likelihood of students staying in education at age 17 and achieving a Level 2 or higher qualification by age 18. "These effects were consistent across genders and ethnic groups," the report said. "Men in both programmes were more likely to enrol in and complete apprenticeships, though rates remained lower for Māori and Pacific men. Women's apprenticeship participation remained low. "Both programmes reduced the likelihood of being in limited employment and increased students being in substantial employment, particularly for men. "Gateway had a stronger effect than Trades Academies in reducing limited employment for women, especially Māori and Pacific women." The report said 87-90 percent of Gateway and Trades Academy students had a level two qualification by the age of 18, compared with 78-79 percent for similar students who had done neither programme. It said 10-12 percent had completed an apprenticeship by age 24, compared with six percent for similar students. About a quarter of the group of similar students were in limited employment when they were 18, compared to 16-19 percent for the cohorts that had participated in the programmes. By age 20, 46-53 percent of the Trades Academy and Gateway cohorts were in substantial employment, compared with 35-38 percent for the group that had done neither programme. The report said the programmes appeared to have "a protective role for educational participation and achievement during the pandemic". Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
