
Officials to assess use of innovations by Rassie Erasmus against Italy
The Springboks' 45-0 victory on Saturday in Gqeberha featured two unorthodox tactics that were widely shared and debated: the kick-off strategy — which guaranteed an early scrum and was criticised by the away team's head coach — and a lineout formation to set up a maul in open play.
When the refereeing team meet this week to discuss their performance — as they do after every Test — they will assess their interpretation of the opening move of the game, which could have ramifications for future rulings.
André Esterhuizen, the Springboks centre, ran ahead of Manie Libbok at kick-off and the fly half dinked the ball straight to his team-mate, ensuring it would not travel the requisite ten metres and the match would begin with a scrum. South Africa then conceded a free kick at the set-piece. 'We wanted to get the scrum badly to get into the game early on,' Erasmus said. 'We make a lot of little plans that sometimes don't pay off, that people don't know of.'
Gonzalo Quesada expressed his surprise over the manoeuvre. 'I didn't take it very well, they can beat us without needing to do this kind of tactic,' the Italy head coach said. 'These last couple of weeks, we've been extremely respectful, coming here with a lot of humility — the land of the world champions and deserved double world champions.
'We know that when they prepared this game, they decided to dominate us and show us why they are the first team in the world.
'I was surprised because I don't know if it was something we did or said that created that first moment. They didn't need to do that to beat us.'
Quesada had more praise for the Springboks' second innovation. Later in the game, South African forwards lifted a team-mate in the middle of the field to receive a pass from the scrum half, manufacturing a driving maul in open play. Law 9.26 states: 'In open play, any player may lift or support a team-mate.' The tactic has previously been used by Paul Roos Gymnasium's age-group sides.
Regarding the kick-off tactic, one can interpret the existing laws in two ways. Law 12.5 states: 'When the ball is kicked: team-mates of the kicker must be behind the ball.' The first offence was that Esterhuizen was in front of the ball, therefore a scrum was awarded in accordance with the listed sanction. Law 12.6 adds that 'the ball must reach the 10-metre line', for which the sanction is either a scrum or a retaken kick-off, decided by the opposing team. Esterhuizen's role prevented that choice. There is no firm provision in law 12 that 'an offside player must not interfere with play', though that phrase exists in law 10, which governs offside and onside in open play rather than at kick-offs and restarts.
However, Andrew Brace could have penalised South Africa under foul play under two edicts that, in effect, give officials the latitude to punish whatever they deem to be unfair. Law 9.27 states: 'A player must not do anything that is against the spirit of good sportsmanship.' More pertinently for this incident, law 9.7 stipulates that 'a player must not intentionally infringe any law of the game'. If South Africa had discussed the tactic beforehand with Brace, it could easily be viewed as a deliberate infringement, with a penalty awarded to Italy.
As with the in-field lineout, the Springboks do not have sole ownership of the deliberately mistaken restart. Immediate scrums used to be a feature of the wild days of French club rugby, when fly halves would deliberately kick the ball straight out to ensure an early confrontation on the halfway line.
Supporters of Erasmus again have cause to celebrate the innovations of the world champions, and to revel in those who cry foul. South Africa's use of the 'bomb squad' in a 7:1 split of forwards to backs on the bench has intensified calls in some quarters to limit the impact of replacements. Less controversially, in the 2023 World Cup quarter-final, Damian Willemse took the unusual move of calling for a scrum from a mark in his own 22, in another show of Springbok brain and brawn.
Novel tactics and the use of loopholes often bring about changes to the laws of the game, such as Italy's no-ruck 'fox' tactic against England in 2017 and the so-called 'Dupont law', which was recently altered to ensure players had to make more effort to return to an onside position during a kick chase.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
The Lions are 13/2 to score in the first 10 minutes of each half against Australia - and that's just one of many RequestABets
The Britsh & Irish Lions are aiming to wrap up their series against Australia on Saturday morning with a test to spare. Andy Farrell's men were dominant in the first Test as they stormed to a 27-19 win in Brisbane - a scoreline which did not reflect the gulf in class and physicality. The Lions don't expect an easy match, though, and they have not been helped by the withdrawal of Welshman Garry Ringrose. Sky Bet are offering a broad range of RequestABets for the clash, with a handful listed below. For the Lions to score at least one try in each half, you'll find a price of 4/11. For both teams to score at least two tries and for the Lions to win, Sky Bet are giving odds of 5/4. If you fancy Farrell's side to score a try in the first 10 minutes of each half, there's an offering of 13/2. And at 200/1, the most unlikely of all, Sky Bet have listed the outcome of at least six tries for each team. Sky Bet selected RequestABets for Australia vs the British & Irish Lions: Lions to score at least one try in each half - 4/1 Both teams to score at least two tries and for the Lions to win - 5/4 Lions to score a try in the first 10 minutes of each half - 13/2 Both teams to score at least six tries each - 200/1


The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Erling Haaland's girlfriend Isabel Haugseng treated to ultra-rare £330,000 handbag as couple enjoy break in Rome
ERLING HAALAND treated his stunning girlfriend Isabel Haugseng Johansen to an incredible £330,000 handbag. The Manchester City star has been relaxing with his partner in Italy over the last few weeks and they recently enjoyed a trip to Rome. 6 6 6 6 Isabel, 21, has taken to Instagram to share snaps from their trip and the brunette beauty wowed in a long orange dress in her latest post. But her designer handbag got the attention of followers as she clutched the luxurious diamond encrusted holdall. The Daily Ma il report that it is an ultra-rare Hermes Birkin 25 Himalaya Niloticus Crocodile. They claim that it is worth an eye-watering £330,000. And the handbag can only be purchased at auction from authentic Hermes reseller Madison Avenue Couture. Isabel is all smiles in the photos posted on social media as she stands next to Haaland, 25, and his brother Astor and his girlfriend. The Norwegian stunner is also seen giggling on a step and posing while looking out over a picturesque lake. Isabel is a footballer herself and is said to have met Haaland while they were both in the youth academy of club Bryne. The couple have one child, who was born back in December. Becoming parents has not slowed down their jet-setting lifestyle and they also visited Ibiza earlier this summer. Man City star Erling Haaland's girlfriend Isabel frolics in water in a bikini as pair relax on holiday Their travels have helped Isabel grow in popularity on Instagram after only launching her account in November. She now boasts a whopping 108,000 followers. Haaland is due back on the pitch on August 9 when City face Palmero in a pre-season friendly. The club's Premier League campaign kicks-off the following weekend against Wolves. 6 6


BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Catalans to face Wigan in Paris during 2026 season
Catalans Dragons will meet Wigan Warriors in Paris in 2026 to mark the 20th anniversary of the French club's debut in Super two teams will play at the Stade Jean-Bouin, home of rugby union outfit Stade Francais, on 6 June next match will also mark the 30th anniversary of Super League, which kicked off on March 29, 1996, when Paris St Germain met Sheffield Eagles at the Charlety Dragons president Bernard Guasch said: "It is a great honour to celebrate the 30th anniversary of the Super League in Paris, where it all began in 1996. "It will mark the return of professional rugby league to our capital and I have no doubt it will be an emotional occasion, both for French and English fans."Warriors chief executive Kris Radlinski added: "It's a great honour to take our wonderful sport back to Paris. "This June will mark 30 years since I had the privilege of playing in the Wigan side that narrowly defeated Paris Saint-Germain in what was a historic occasion. Now, to return with our club to this iconic city to face Catalans Dragons is another landmark moment."The match will also be Catalans' first match relocation since they faced Wigan at Barcelona's Camp Nou in 2019, a game which broke the Super League attendance record with a gate of 31,555.