Man (24) fatally stabbed sister's housemate after night of drinking, court told
Valeriu Melnic (24) with an address at Calliaghstown Lower, Rathcoole, Co Dublin, is charged with murdering Ion Daghi (39) at The Close, Sallins Park, Sallins in Co Kildare on May 12th 2024.
Advertisement
Mr Melnic has pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to Mr Daghi's manslaughter.
The plea was not accepted by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) and a jury of eight men and four women have been sworn in to hear the trial.
In his opening address, Carl Hanahoe SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions, told the jury on Tuesday afternoon that Mr Melnic's sister resided with Mr Daghi at a property in Sallins Park, Co Kildare.
He said on the evening in question, the accused met up with a friend named Alexandru Beccieu and they had a beer together, purchased a bottle of whiskey and proceeded to Mr Daghi's house, arriving at 8pm.
Advertisement
Mr Hanahoe said there were a number of people present in the house, including Mr Daghi, his wife, his mother-in-law, some children and the accused's sister.
They had some food in the garden, drank the bottle of whiskey and proceeded to a pub where a second bottle of whiskey was purchased and consumed back at the house.
The group then went to a nightclub where they bought a third bottle of whiskey.
The two women present appeared to have had very little to drink, counsel said, so the alcohol was principally consumed by the three men.
Advertisement
Mr Hanahoe said some time around 3am a dispute appears to have arisen between Mr Melnic and Mr Daghi.
He said the dispute 'became physical' and also involved the accused man's friend, Mr Beccieu.
Mr Melnic and the deceased were separated, and Mr Beccieu went to look for car keys. When he returned, he saw the deceased on the ground and the accused man 'over him'.
It was 'quite clear a serious altercation had occurred,' Mr Hanahoe said.
Advertisement
The incident was broken up and Mr Melnic retreated into the kitchen while Mr Daghi 'momentarily remained in the garden'.
Mr Hanahoe said it is the prosecution case that the accused 'armed himself with a kitchen knife'. Mr Daghi then entered the kitchen and as he did so, Mr Melnic 'stabbed him once in the chest', the barrister said.
Counsel told the jury a pathologist will say Mr Daghi suffered a single stab wound to the left side of the chest and would have died 'relatively quickly'.
He said the gardaí were called at around 3.10am and examined the scene.
Mr Hanahoe told the jury that they are the judges of fact, and they must decide the case based on the evidence 'without sympathy or prejudice'.
The trial continues on Wednesday before Mr Justice David Keane and the jury.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Fraudster mum, 28, who faked pregnancy and stole £100,000 from her employers and boyfriend walks free from court
A mother-of-two who faked having cancer, being pregnant and stole nearly £100,000 from her employers has avoided jail. 'Selfish' Megan Reynolds, 28, racked up thousands on lavish gifts - including hotel stays, a five course dinner and clubbing in Amsterdam - using company cards before attempting to conceal them through fake invoices. She defrauded electrical machinery firm CSL Power Systems out of £78,000, who described her as a 'compulsive liar', between 2019 and 2021 before she was caught and dismissed by bosses, Maidstone Crown Court heard. But, just a month later she joined another firm, ATL Retail Limited, where she continued her behaviour - again fraudulently spending £18,500 of the company's cash on her own amenities. Her dishonest habits didn't stop there however, as the court also heard that Reynolds took out a finance agreement for over £1,000 using her boyfriend Callum Bishop's name and details without his consent. She also lied to Mr Bishop by telling him she was pregnant with a fake scan and faked having cancer to a family member to get time off work. Reynolds had initially denied the offences and a trial date was set for February this year but then, less than two weeks before she was due to take the stand, she changed her pleas to guilty. But she avoided prison after a judge decided that given her role as a mother to two small children and having not committed any further offences since being charged, it would be too harsh to put her behind bars. At her sentencing at Maidstone Crown Court on Friday, July 4, the court heard how Reynolds, of Fruit Fields Drive in Rainham, had pleaded guilty to three counts of fraud and a further three counts were ordered to lie on file. During her role at CSL Power Systems in Farningham, near Dartford, between November 6, 2019 and March 26, 2021, Reynolds undertook the book keeping and had access to the company credit cards and would assist colleges by making online purchases on their behalf. But instead, the court heard she was using the 11 company cards to make fraudulent transactions, and tried to conceal them using fake invoices. When an employee noticed a purchase did not have a matching receipt, she tasked Reynolds with reporting it to Barclaycard Bank - an action she did not take, instead providing 'fictional' updates to the company. But by February, 2021, when an employee found a bank statement for an EasyJet flight in her name, the police were called and discovered no fraud had been reported to the bank. That evening, while employees investigated, they found emails were being remotely deleted by Reynolds and she was told to stop. The prosecutor, Nick Sanders, explained how fraudulent payments included car insurance for her vehicle, bookings on and a five-course dinner, along with spending at a nightclub in Amsterdam. To cover her tracks, the court heard how an invoice for a spill kit, valued at £75.96 was used to cover-up a purchase of dog chews Reynolds had made. Meanwhile, an invoice for black frames actually matched the purchase of a 5-piece set of Tefal pans. The total amount of fraud at the company was £78,000, the court heard. But after being dismissed, within a month she was working at another firm in Sevenoaks, ATL Retail Limited, from April 26, 2021 until January 17, 2022. It was only through a chance meeting with someone from CSL that Reynolds' fraudulent past became knowledge to her new employer. ATL Retail Limited made Reynolds redundant and discovered a number of fraudulent transactions, totalling £18,500. But as well as deceiving the two businesses, the court heard how Reynolds had also been deceiving her former partner Callum Bishop from February 2019 until they split in October 2021. The night before he left he found a letter for a financial agreement from Creation Finance in his name for over £1,000 that he had never taken on. He rang the company and found out Reynolds' mobile number was linked to the loan. The prosecutor said: 'She abused her position of trust and was sophisticated in nature'. But Judge Julian Smith said: 'I do not think it is particularly sophisticated, more wounding and hurtful but not particularly sophisticated.' The court heard how the now 28-year-old, had been charged with six fraud offences, including two counts of fraud by abuse of position and four counts of fraud by false representation in 2023. Only three fraud offences, regarding CSL Power Systems, ATL Retail, and Callum Bishop were pursued by the Crown Prosecution Service and the other three charges were ordered to lie on file. The judge added: 'She had quite the network of dishonesty set up. £78,000 is a lot of money and certainly a lot of money whether it's personal or business. 'It's a very substantial impact and it is exploitative. She saw an opportunity and went after it again and again and again.' He said Reynolds was 'dishonest' and 'deceitful' and sought to enrich herself personally at others expense. 'She was given a fresh start and then did it again - straight away,' the judge added. Her defence solicitor, Lucy Kennedy, explained how the victim impact statements had caused Reynolds 'considerable distress' and that her actions were driven out of 'greed' and she is 'mortified'. Relaying Reynolds statements, the defence solicitor said: 'None of it was worth it. That is not me anymore. 'I am devastated that I have hurt them in such a way that they can't trust others in the way they used to and I am devastated that I have caused so much trauma to them.' The court heard Reynolds was 'petrified' to face her victims in the court room and has acknowledged she could be sent to prison, so had packed a small suitcase which she brought into the courtroom. The court heard how the 28-year-old now has a four-and-a-half month old baby who was born prematurely and is immunosuppressed while also being lactose-intolerant. And while the court heard that both baby's fathers are present in their children's lives, the judge considered the fact Reynolds was the 'principle' caregiver and was still breastfeeding her baby. Meanwhile, Ms Kennedy explained Reynolds' son, aged two, had undergone eye surgery for a squint and is due to have another surgery. While explaining that Reynolds' offence was a 'modern day fingers in the till' she then urged for a suspended sentence, keeping in mind her son, two, and her daughter, four-and-a-half months - adding 'that is not her anymore'. 'Keep the three of them together,' Reynolds solicitor said. In response, the prosecutor explained how Reynolds had often told lies in the past, such as pretending to a family member she had cancer to get time off work, telling Mr Bishop she was pregnant by providing a fake scan, and lying about her dog having cancer. While he said he did not doubt that Reynolds had children, the prosecutor referenced her perpetual lies to urge the judge to question information given by the mother-of-two. In his remarks, the judge said the three offences were examples of 'persistent dishonesty'. He said: 'Having faced the victims now, reflect on what it was about you to put your selfish wishes, superficial desires above everybody else. 'You were a fraudster. You were thieving,' he added. The judge handed the 28-year-old a suspended sentence of 24 months in prison for the first count, 15 months in prison for count two, and six months in prison for count three, all suspended for two years and to be served concurrently. She was given 15 rehabilitation activity requirement days and 200 hours unpaid work. Judge Julian Smith added: 'You are being given a chance today because of your two children. If you breach this order what you are telling the court is that you do not care.' A further hearing is set to organise a timetable of repayment for the money stolen. 'I do not expect to see you again. If I do, I am giving you a warning, do not let your children down,' the judge said. Following the conclusion of Friday's hearing her former employer CSL Power Systems recorded their disappointment at what they believe to be an unduly lenient sentence. 'As a company and on a personal level we are thoroughly disappointed with the sentencing ruling by the judge and feel it has sent out the wrong message in today's society,' a spokesperson for CSL Power Systems. 'Essentially you can steal 100K from honest businesses and walk away without ever seeing the inside of a cell as long as you have a well-timed pregnancy!' The company explained how the length of time between her crimes and sentencing has meant the victims had to wait four years for her to be brought to justice, while Reynolds had carried on with her life, in their view, 'without a care in the world'. The company claim Reynolds has never shown any remorse, or apologised for her actions. They described her as a 'compulsive liar', adding: 'We let Miss Reynolds into our lives, and after COVID she worked from offices in our home and we thought she was also a friend.'
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
A Mexican court sentences 10 men to 141 years each in a cartel-run recruitment ranch
A Mexican court on Tuesday sentenced 10 men to 141-year prison terms each for their involvement in a ranch in the western Mexican state of Jalisco that was used by a feared cartel to recruit members, kill and disappear victims. The discovery earlier this year of the Izaguirre ranch, used by the Jalisco New Generation Cartel for recruitment and training since 2021, had sparked alarm and fear across the region. The 10 men were arrested in September 2024 during an initial raid on the property. They were convicted on Monday in the disappearance and murder of three victims. On Tuesday, each was sentenced to 141 years and three months in prison, and ordered to pay 1.3 million pesos (about $65,000) in restitution to the victims' families, the local prosecutor's office said. Five other suspects detained in the case are still awaiting trial, including three municipal police officers, a CJNG operative who allegedly recruited new members, and José Murguía Santiago, the mayor of Teuchitlan, the municipality where the ranch is located. Murguía Santiago was arrested just days after Mexico's Attorney General Alejandro Gertz Manero revealed that since 2021, the Jalisco state Human Rights Commission had alerted Teuchitlan authorities about the ranch being operated by CJNG, but the warning was ignored for years. The case had sparked a major controversy after Guerrero Buscadores de Jalisco — a group that searches for missing persons — reported in March 5 the discovery of numerous charred human bones and hundreds of clothing items and shoes at the site. The shock brought back into the spotlight stark violence and rampant impunity in cartel-plagued parts of the Latin American nation and the tragedy of the investigations into Mexico's 130,000 missing people. Following that report, it emerged that Jalisco's state prosecutors had not moved forward with the investigation for several months after the initial raid on the ranch, when the National Guard intervened and arrested the 10 men. During that operation, one body and two of the men later detained were found on the ranch. Due to missteps and omissions by state authorities, the federal Attorney General's Office took over the case — but criticism persisted. At the end of April, Gertz Manero dismissed claims that cremation sites existed at 'Rancho Izaguirre,' fueling backlash from activists. The group Guerreros Buscadores de Jalisco responded, saying it had recovered '17 sets of charred human bone remains' from the site, which are now in the custody of forensics teams. ____
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Bad nanny's chilling note: Scam artist Samantha Cookes who conned vulnerable families wrote disturbing message about death of her baby daughter the day she was due to be adopted
Convicted scam artist Samantha Cookes wrote a disturbing message after the death of her infant daughter in 2008, a new documentary has revealed. Rebecca Fitzgerald, Lucy Hart, Lucy Fitzwilliams, and Sadie Harris are just some of the aliases used by Cookes, the jailed serial fraudster and fantasist with victims in the UK and Ireland. Her story is the subject of a BBC documentary that airs tonight, which seeks to untangle her web of lies over two episodes. But before she became the con artist known by many different names, she was a young mother whose first born - a daughter named Martha Isabel Cookes - tragically died in infancy, on the day she was due to be taken away for adoption. It appeared she never healed from her past as Cookes - who was in March sentenced to three years in prison for scamming the state of €60,000 in welfare benefits - penned a note denying she had any role in Martha's death. 'I stand shoulder to shoulder with the coroner that I did not murder my daughter,' Cookes, then 23, wrote in a diary that would be discovered by one of her victims who has shared her story in the documentary titled 'Bad Nanny'. The scamster was referring to the inquest that found her four-month-old daughter had died due to accidental suffocation. Cookes' declaration she did not 'murder' Martha stood out because at no point was there any such accusation against her. Cookes, who had at least five different identities, was living as a disability activist Carrie Jade Williams and posted a TikTok in 2022 that ultimately led to her downfall. 'I stand shoulder to shoulder with the coroner that I did not murder my daughter,' Cookes, then 23, wrote in a diary that would be discovered by one of her victims who has shared her story in the documentary titled 'Bad Nanny' The 'sickfluencer' who used the platform to share her experiences living with the terminal Huntington's Disease found herself in the spotlight after she claimed she was being sued for €450,000 by her 'ableist' Airbnb guests in a now-viral video. There was an outpouring of sympathy for the disability activist on social media - until the world learned the truth behind the video. 'Carrie' wasn't real and neither were the heartless Airbnb guests the internet was looking for. The video went onto expose Cookes as a notorious scam artist with a long history of conning vulnerable families out of thousands of pounds while posing as someone qualified to look after children. Before she became Carrie in 2022, Cookes was autism therapist Rebecca in 2017, au pair Lucy Hart in 2014, and a surrogate mother called Claudia in 2010. In 2008, however, she was still Samantha, 20-year-old whose daughter Martha Isabel Cookes died in infancy under mysterious circumstances. An inquest into the baby's death in 2009 revealed that Martha died due to 'accidental' suffocation when a V-shaped pillow wrapped around the baby's neck while her mother was sleeping. It was at this point Cookes made the statement later found by Layla, a mother-of-two living in Tullamore, who was one of her first victims. Layla hired 'Lucy Hart' to look after her two children after finding the fake profile on an au pair website in 2014. Speaking on the documentary, Layla revealed she didn't carry out any background checks on 'Lucy' and 'took her at face value' after they bonded over both being English women living in Ireland. 'She was Mary Poppins,' Layla said as her daughter Charlie, who also appeared in the documentary, described 'Lucy' as a 'big ball of fun'. Layla explained how 'Lucy' regaled them with stories about her life as she was always looking to orchestrate a 'wow' moment. The mother-of-two recalled 'Lucy' telling her was adopted and that her mother Jane Hart manufactured sandpaper for B&Q. Around the same time that Cookes entered their home as Lucy, the family were grappling with rising rent prices while looking for somewhere to live. 'Lucy', who claimed to be a Jehovah's Witness, said a church elder had offered to let them live in a more affordable home in the area. After packing up their home and handing in their notice with the landlord, the family prepared for a move to the new property. However, every time Layla asked 'Lucy' whether they could view their new house, 'there was always an excuse', she said. It would become clear as day 'Lucy' had conned them after she pretended to faint at a Tesco while they were en-route to view the house, as Layla said: 'Why didn't I pick up on this sooner? There is no house.' 'Lucy' disappeared pretty quickly after this incident, telling the family she was going on a 'writers retreat'. As Layla began clearing up 'Lucy's' room, she discovered the ominous note that made her blood run cold. 'I stand shoulder to shoulder with the coroner, and I did not murder my daughter,' it read. 'I pray she is at peace Speaking on the documentary through tears, Layla said: 'Who have we had looking after our children?' She continued: 'She never mentioned any children to me, that she has ever had any children, that's strange, very strange. 'As a parent leaving my children in her care, if I had known for one second that she had children things would have been a whole lot different. 'I would warn anyone about her, don't let her in your home, don't let her in.' Martha's father was one of Cookes' former boyfriends, who remained anonymous for the documentary as he opened up about their toxic relationship in 2007. They were both 18 years old when they started dating, but he claimed he ended the relationship when he began to spot Cookes's pattern of lying. However, she revealed she was pregnant with his child and began bombarding him with messages and calls. He said: 'Was it real, was it a tactic? That whole "being in a family" thing was a real wish for her, it was something she would have referred to. 'The whole period is not something I look on with much pride. My involvement in pregnancy was next to zero really. There was going to be an adoption.' In July 2008, Cookes gave birth to Martha but she tragically died on the same day she was to be given up for adoption. The father said: 'I found out that baby Martha had died from a local newspaper report. There had been this death on the day that Martha was going to be taken. Those details do raise questions for me.' In 2013, the circumstances into baby Martha's death were to be re-examined by the high court due to concerns over her death - however by this point, Cookes had been reported as a missing person to UK police after she fled to Ireland. The case was closed and Martha's 2009 accidental cause of death still stands today. In 2010, Cookes started a relationship with a man, whose identity is not being revealed to protect him and his family. The pair had a child. The same year, Cookes, then 23, offered her services as a surrogate on Facebook. After making contact with a couple about being their surrogate, she passed on the contact of a woman called Claudia, who had previously used her as a surrogate. Claudia gave the excited couple a glowing review of Samantha. Having never met her face-to-face, the couple gave Cookes £1,200 out of their savings to cover the cost of the insemination kit, legal fees and other expenses. Sadly the baby never came, and as both Cookes and Claudia avoided the couple's messages, they realised they had been duped. The police were contacted and a 23-year-old woman was arrested at her home in Shropshire. The case came to trial in 2011 and Cookes pleaded guilty to fraud. She received a suspended sentence of nine months in prison and a fine of £1,890 to be paid to the couple. But what the trial also revealed was that Cookes was Claudia - her first fake persona. Meanwhile in 2012, her second child was taken away from her due to welfare concerns. Social services requested a psychological assessment of Cookes and she was diagnosed with Pseudologia Fantastica. PF, also known as pathological lying or mythomania, is a mental disorder characterised by persistent, pervasive, and often compulsive lying. In 2013 she became pregnant with her third child with the same man. Determined not to lose custody of this unborn child, Cookes fled to Ireland in the winter of 2013 and delivered the baby in January 2014. However, a neighbour reported her to Irish social services and the child was taken into care. After appearing at Irish family court, the father was again given custody and the baby was transported back to the UK. By August 2014, she had lost custody of both her living children after Martha's death six years ago. A month later she had changed her name to Lucy Hart and was working for Layla as an au pair. In January 2015, she left Layla's home under the pretense of attending a writer's retreat after her lies were discovered. In 2016, Cookes moved to County Geery and became Lucy Fitzwilliam and in 2017, Rebecca Fitzgerald arrived in Fermoy. In 2019, she became disability activist Carrie Jade Williams, a prize-winning writer, autism guru and terminal illness sufferer who posted routinely about being diagnosed with Huntington's Disease. The fraudster went viral on TikTok in 2022 after claiming to havebeen sued by Airbnb guests because they couldn't stand to be around a disabled person, leaving millions outraged for her. The story even started the #thisworldcanbeaccessible trend. But the it was later revealed that the story was completely made up, and Carrie was outed on a podcast called Carrie Jade Does Not Exist, which is hosted by VICE journalist Kat Denkinson and comedian Sue Perkins. In 2024, she was discovered working as au pair Sadie Harris in rural Ireland for a family of six - having rebranded as a 'conservative Christian' who 'doesn't think women should wear trousers'. She is believed to have worked for family for six months before fleeing once their child's school alerted them to her true identity. In March 2025, Cookes was jailed in Ireland for deception and theft charges after she claimed thousands in welfare benefits for a terminal illness that turned out not to exist.
