‘My purpose was to survive': Bradford man accused of murder tells jury
The Bradford, Ont. man accused of murder in the stabbing of a Good Samaritan three years ago completed his testimony saying he did not attack the man prior to killing him.
Brandon Aaron, 23, denied repeated suggestions by the Crown he was the aggressor when violence broke out between Aaron and David Goddard, 59, whom police described as a hero who stepped in to help Aaron's former girlfriend after she'd been assaulted by Aaron along Holland Street West September 4, 2022.
Aaron was on the witness stand Thursday and Friday, where he disagreed with Crown Attorney Elizabeth Stokes who suggested Aaron became enraged when Good Samaritan David Goddard intervened, and Aaron stabbed Goddard 20 times along the side of the road.
David Goddard
Cameron David Goddard, 59, is identified as the victim of a homicide on Sept. 4, 2022, in Bradford, Ont. (Supplied)
The court heard Goddard bled profusely and died on scene.
'In order to inflict that damage, you stabbed him as hard as you could,' said Stokes.
'I stabbed him as hard as I needed to' replied Aaron 'My purpose was to survive.'
The Crown suggested Aaron, already with a knife in hand, got angry when Goddard told him to leave the young woman alone and walk the other way after the young woman, whose identity is protected by a publication ban as she was 17 at the time, asked Goddard to walk her home.
Aaron testified he was attacked by Goddard, who pushed, punched and choked him after he was knocked on his back on the grass.
'You didn't stab him because you were being choked,' the Crown suggested to Aaron, 'You stabbed him because he got between you and your girlfriend,' she said.
Brandon Aaron,
Brandon Aaron, 23, is accused of murder in the death of a man police described as a Good Samaritan who intervened when investigators said Aaron was assaulting the young woman in the early morning hours of September 4, 2022. (Court Exhibit)
'He upset you by trying to take her away from you and when he stepped up to you, you went to stab him,' she told Aaron.
'I did not attack him' Aaron responded.
The accused said he could not remember the sequence of events or how many times he stabbed Goddard after telling the court he was on his back, reached for his knife from his side bag and stabbed the stranger to break free.
The Crown called Aaron's version of events 'impossible' and told Aaron he was aware of how seriously he had wounded the man.
'You do remember exactly where you stabbed him and you're claiming not to remember because it's very bad for you,' said Stokes.
Aaron testified seeing Goddard standing upright despite being stabbed several times before he left the scene and walked home through a field to avoid being seen.
'Because you knew that you had stabbed that person over and over,' the Crown told Aaron. 'And that person was probably dead.'
Aaron denied becoming increasingly angry with his girlfriend or Goddard when he stepped in. Aaron testified he simply wanted to ensure she got home safely that night.
Brandon Aaron
Brandon Aaron, 23, denied repeated suggestions by the Crown he was the aggressor when violence broke out between Aaron and David Goddard, 59, whom police described as a hero who stepped in to help Aaron's former girlfriend after she'd been assaulted by Aaron along Holland Street West September 4, 2022.
'I don't know how she got hurt,' he told the court. He remembered she had hurt her wrist or arm but was not clear on what the injury was or how it happened. Instead, Aaron told the jury he was the one assaulted by his girlfriend with a flashlight she had borrowed from a nearby gas station to help her find her missing cell phone she believed Aaron lost earlier that night.
Both Aaron and his former girlfriend said they were intoxicated after a night out drinking and partying.
Hours after the incident police interviewed the young woman. She told investigators Aaron dragged her by her hair and struck her repeatedly with the flashlight, breaking her forearm. She changed her story during trial when she testified she broke her forearm picking herself up off the ground during an argument with Aaron. She had previously told police Aaron held a knife to her throat and threatened to kill her.
Aaron admitted to changing his clothes when he got home. He then conceded he sent several text messages on Instagram to the young woman reciting a version of events that included Aaron telling her he was going to tell police 'It was self defense.'
'I'm going to be gone for a very long time,' one message read. 'I don't care that you told on me.'
Aaron was convicted of violating his court-imposed non-communication order with his former girlfriend. He admitted to calling and emailing her for months.
The young woman's mother described the relationship between her daughter and Aaron as 'toxic' and 'abusive.'
The jury is expected to begin deliberations on Thursday following instructions from Justice Jill Cameron.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
20 minutes ago
- CTV News
Missing Alberta mom spotted on Vancouver Island, police say
Ashley Bartley, 30, and her four-year-old daughter Marlie Myers have been missing since July 12, police say. (Cochrane RCMP) Police in Cochrane, Alta., say a mother and daughter missing from their jurisdiction may be on Vancouver Island. Ashley Bartley and her four-year-old daughter Marlie Myers were last seen in Cochrane on July 12, and police said in a news release earlier this week that the pair may be in the Vancouver area. In an update Wednesday, Cochrane RCMP said their investigation had revealed that Bartley was seen in Courtenay, B.C., on July 18. The 30-year-old mother was seen at an ATM in the Vancouver Island city, police said, adding that she is believed to be travelling with a man in a dark grey 2017 Chevrolet Silverado with Alberta licence plate CTK 2944. The truck is pulling a white 2006 Arctic Fox trailer with B.C. plate WPW65H, police said. Mounties have previously said 'there is concern' for the well-being of Bartley and Myers. They described the mother as 5′4″ tall and 130 pounds. She has long, brown hair and brown eyes and was last seen wearing a white T-shirt, shorts and black flip flops, according to police. The daughter is three feet tall and weighs 40 to 45 pounds. She has curly, dirty-blond hair and brown eyes, and was last seen wearing pink pants, a shirt and crocs. Anyone with information on their whereabouts is asked to call Cochrane RCMP at 403-851-8000 or their local police. Tips can also be provided anonymously via Crime Stoppers.
CBC
21 minutes ago
- CBC
Edmonton piano, violin teacher charged with sexual offences against 9-year-old student
Social Sharing An Edmonton man who taught private music lessons has been charged with sexual assault and sexual interference against one of his young students. Peter Burandt, 68, was arrested this week, with police saying Wednesday that a nine-year-old girl reported he sexually assaulted her on several occasions during piano lessons in his home. The alleged incidents took place between February 2024 and June 2025, according to court information. The Edmonton Police Service said Burandt has been teaching music lessons for two decades. Investigators believe there could be more alleged victims, and are asking anyone who may have information to contact police. Burandt was previously publicly listed as a teacher at a south-side business that offers private music lessons, but on Wednesday afternoon, his profile on the school website was removed. The owner of the school told CBC News that Burandt hasn't worked there for approximately seven years. He has been released under conditions that include no contact or communication with anyone younger than 16, according to police. Burandt is set to appear in court next month. Several teachers or coaches have been charged with sexual offences involving children in recent months. That includes a former Edmonton Catholic Schools teacher facing child pornography offences who police believe has fled the country. Zebra Child & Youth Advocacy Centre CEO Emmy Stuebing said cases of alleged abuse by someone in a position of authority over children tend to raise broader public concerns. "When these situations arise, I know they can be scary for parents, but they can use it as a bit of a tool to help reinforce the flow of conversation and the opportunity to talk, to check in with your kids," she said. "Let them know that as a parent or a safe caregiver, you're there to talk. And if someone is making them feel uncomfortable, or is hurting them, to talk to you." Stuebing said it's important for adults to report concerns to authorities if a child discloses abuse. "If we don't … we can't help with the services and support."
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Honduran man gets life with parole in brutal murder of common-law spouse
A Honduran immigrant received a life sentence in court on Tuesday in the brutal killing of his common-law spouse, Shermaine Carling. The incident took place on Sept. 29, 2022. 41-year-old David Espinoza Montes had already pled guilty to second-degree murder in the stabbing death of Carling, who was 33 years old at the time. Justice Joseph Perfetto considered a joint submission on sentencing and agreed to a period of parole ineligibility of 12 years, starting from the date of the offence. 'I'm happy for the family that there's finality in this matter and my thoughts and prayers go out to them,' said assistant Crown attorney, Nicole Stortini. Espinoza Montes, who has no prior record, sat quietly in the courtroom as Justice Perfetto shared the sentence in his over an hour-long hearing. The judge shared with the court how the brutal attack saw Espinoza Montes stab Carling 48 times with a knife and a pair of scissors in a friend's house. Justice Perfetto characterized the incident as an act of intimate partner violence after Espinoza Montes became jealous and acted in a fit of rage. 'His Honour gave incredibly detailed reasons,' said Jayme Lesperance, assistant Crown attorney. 'It was very thorough. It followed all the jurisprudence that (Stortini) argued in front of him.' Justice Perfetto noted he carefully considered the victim impact statements. 'Which in my view speaks to the devastation of Mr. Espinoza Montes' offending,' he said. He took into account the statement from Carling's sister, who wrote how simple tasks are hard to undertake and that both of Carling's children have withdrawn from school because of the emotional anguish. He read a passage from the statement as Espinoza Montes listened. 'Losing her is such a betrayal at the hands of someone who she trusted has shattered our sense of safety and left an ache that seems impossible to heal. No words can fully express how empty our hearts feel without her,' he said. The emotional loss is coupled with the financial loss as Carling sent money home to the Philippines to care for her two children and family. 'We have been talking to the family,' Stortini said. 'Victim Services has also been engaging with the family a lot as well. They want to move forward in this matter, and they are still grieving.' Justice Perfetto said Espinoza Montes had applied for refugee status after his work visa expired and, at the time of the offence, was subject to immigration hearings. He pointed out neither the Crown nor defence discussed immigration status in their joint submission. 'I've got no idea what's going to happen with immigration,' Lesperance said. 'That's entirely out of the scope of our work. What the parole group chooses to do based on their algorithm and assessment is entirely up to them.' Justice Perfetto closed the hearing by addressing Carling's family, who joined through Zoom, saying, 'I hope as time passes you find healing and peace.'
