Young people are right not to get out of bed for less than £40k
There have been lots of different explanations offered for why almost a million 16 to 24-year-olds are neither working, training nor studying. But as one expert told a House of Lords committee this week, there is a far simpler explanation: it is not worth the hassle of getting out of bed for less than £40,000.
If that is true, it would be easy to condemn them as idle and feckless. But they are also completely right. Until we fix a dysfunctional welfare and tax system it isn't going to change – because people won't bother to work unless it pays to do so.
It was the kind of hard truth that was not meant to be mentioned in polite society. Appearing before a House of Lords social mobility committee this week, Graham Cowley, who works with young people not in employment, education nor training – or 'Neets' – argued that lots of them 'don't want to work for anything less than 40 grand'.
While the Lords gasped in horror, he reminded them 'you may laugh, but that is the reality' – and he is completely right.
The UK faces a growing challenge that many young people are no longer bothered to either get a job or even to prepare themselves for one. According to the official figures, 595,000 16 to 24-year-olds are classed as 'inactive' while another 392,000 are 'looking for work', but perhaps not very actively since they don't seem to be having much success.
The shadow chancellor, Mel Stride, has suggested that they may be addicted to online pornography and video games, while the Liz Kendall, the Work and Pensions Secretary, has suggested that especially since Covid many of them find the concept of work 'too stressful'.
From coaching, to encouragement, to more stringent medical checks there are lots of different suggestions about ways of getting them out of the house and into a warehouse, factory or retailer to start their career.
The trouble is, it is hard to believe any of that will make any significant difference. It is hard to know what exactly Stride is going to do about online pornography, and Kendall can't turn back the clock and reverse lockdown – as desirable as that might be. In reality, there is a simpler solution.
Although it might come as a surprise to some of the people on the Lords committee, most people work just to make money. Many teenagers and 20-somethings have worked out for themselves that the UK's welfare and tax system has become so bloated and inefficient that getting a job hardly pays any more. They are just making a rational choice.
To start with, taxes are far too high, and they become even higher as you start to climb your way up the career ladder. According to the Centre for Policy Studies, the effective tax rate even for someone on the minimum wage has more than doubled in the last decade alone, rising from an effective 11pc in 2015 to more than 21pc now.
Even worse, if you study for a degree, the repayments on the loan you will have to take out to finance it kick in at far too low a level, and you will be charged a punitive rate of interest. On some plans you start repayments on just £25,000 a year, and you will be charged 7pc interest on the debt you have taken on. On almost any graduate job available, you will have to start repaying your loan, significantly increasing your effective tax rate.
Next, wages are not high enough. Wave after wave of mass immigration has driven down salaries, especially for the relatively low-skilled, entry-level jobs that are typically all that is on offer to teenagers and 20-somethings making their first steps into the workforce.
The average non-graduate salary is now £29,000 in the UK, up from £22,000 a decade ago, but once the cost of living and the extra taxes are taken into account it has gone down in real terms.
Even worse, while many Neets may imagine they will finally stir themselves to get out of bed in the unlikely event that someone offers them £40,000 a year to do so, they probably won't find that very worthwhile either.
As soon as they get a promotion or a bonus they will start paying tax at 40pc, and, given the Chancellor does not show much inclination to ever raise thresholds again, that will probably be the rate for someone on the living wage by the end of the decade.
If they climb further up the ladder, child benefit starts to be withdrawn, and as the personal allowance is tapered away their marginal tax rates soon climb to 60pc or more. Staying in bed will become more and more tempting.
It is a crazy system, and one that is dragging down the entire economy. There is no point in accusing the Neets of being lazy, or not bothering, of being addicted to the web, or lacking the spine of earlier generations.
It is insulting, it is not fair, and even if there was some element of truth to it, there is not much we can do about it anyway.
Instead, we need a wholescale reform of the tax and benefit system. If we have to cut spending to pay for it, then that is the only option.
An entire generation is making a perfectly rational decision that work does not pay enough to be worthwhile any more – and until that calculation changes there is very little prospect of the economy ever starting to recover.
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Fox News
21 minutes ago
- Fox News
Former Congressman George Santos delivers 'glamorous' farewell before going to prison: 'The curtain falls'
Former Rep. George Santos posted a theatrical farewell on social media Thursday night, just hours before he was to begin serving a federal prison sentence for fraud and identity theft. "Well, darlings… The curtain falls, the spotlight dims, and the rhinestones are packed," Santos wrote on X. "From the halls of Congress to the chaos of cable news what a ride it's been! Was it messy? Always. Glamorous? Occasionally. Honest? I tried… most days. To my supporters: You made this wild political cabaret worth it. To my critics: Thanks for the free press." The former New York congressman is expected to report to federal custody Friday to begin serving an 87-month sentence, just over seven years, after pleading guilty in 2024 to wire fraud and aggravated identity theft. Santos was assessed the maximum sentence in April by U.S. District Judge Joanna Seybert. He was also ordered to pay nearly $374,000 in restitution and forfeit more than $205,000 in fraud proceeds. His guilty plea followed a sweeping investigation into campaign finance fraud, donor identity theft and false COVID-era unemployment claims. "This prosecution speaks to the truth that my office is committed to aggressively rooting out public corruption," said U.S. Attorney John J. Durham, who called the sentence "judgment day" for Santos and justice for his victims. Nassau County District Attorney Anne T. Donnelly said Santos "traded in his integrity for designer clothes and a luxury lifestyle." Prosecutors shared how Santos and his campaign treasurer, Nancy Marks, doctored donor reports to qualify for national Republican party funding. They fabricated contributions from Santos' family and falsely reported a $500,000 loan from Santos, though he had under $8,000 in his accounts. He also stole credit card information from donors, including "victims he knew were elderly persons suffering from cognitive impairment or decline" and made unauthorized charges to fund both campaign and personal expenses, according to the DOJ. Santos also used a fake political fundraising company to solicit tens of thousands of dollars which he spent on "designer clothing." During the pandemic, Santos fraudulently claimed over $24,000 in unemployment benefits while employed at an investment firm. He also submitted false congressional financial disclosures to the House. Santos was elected in 2022 after flipping New York's 3rd District for the GOP. His résumé was easily debunked. He falsely claimed academic degrees, Wall Street jobs and family ties to the Holocaust and 9/11. He was expelled from Congress in December 2023 after a scathing ethics report, becoming just the sixth member ever removed from the People's House. Santos has remained publicly active after his sentencing, selling video messages on Cameo and making social media posts. His tweet concluded, "I may be leaving the stage (for now), but trust me legends never truly exit." Unless pardoned, Santos is expected to remain incarcerated until at least early 2032. He has reportedly appealed to President Donald Trump for clemency. The White House and Santos did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
TikTok Will ‘Go Dark' Soon if China Does Not Strike Deal, Commerce Secretary Says
Howard Lutnick says TikTok's algorithm must be sold for the popular app to remain active past Sept. 17 No more extensions. TikTok will 'go dark' if China does not cut a deal with the Trump administration that transfers control of the app's technology and algorithm, U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said on Thursday. More from TheWrap TikTok Will 'Go Dark' Soon if China Does Not Strike Deal, Commerce Secretary Says Trump Says It Is 'Not Do-able' for AI Companies to Pay for All Copyrighted Content Used in Training Models YouTube Ad Revenue Up 13% Year-Over-Year in 2nd Quarter of 2025, Hitting $9.8 Billion Oracle in Talks With Paramount-Skydance for $100 Million Cloud Deal | Report Lutnick was discussing the ongoing TikTok negotiation during an appearance on CNBC's 'Squawk on the Street.' TikTok's parent company, Beijing-based ByteDance, is currently facing a Sept. 17 deadline to offload the app's American operation or face being banned in the States. 'We've made the decision: you can't have Chinese control and have something on 100 million American phones. That's just not okay,' Lutnick said. He continued: 'So if it's in American control, and, you know, China can have a little piece, or ByteDance, the current owner, can keep a little piece. But basically, Americans will have control. Americans will own the technology, and Americans will control the algorithm.' His comments come after TikTok has received multiple extensions from the president to reach a deal on selling its U.S. app. TikTok was initially set to be banned on Jan. 19, after President Joe Biden signed a law last year requiring ByteDance to sell TikTok's American operation. The chief concern lawmakers had was that TikTok could act as a stealth spyware app for China's communist government, as ByteDance is required by Chinese law to hand over any user data the government asks for. President Trump, on his first day back in office on Jan. 20, gave TikTok a 75-day extension to make a deal, and the app's future in the U.S. has remained in limbo ever since. The president gave TikTok a second extension in April, and then another one last month, making Sept. 17 the latest deadline. In late June, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said President Trump's 'main goal' is making sure TikTok remains available in the U.S. — 'while protecting [Americans'] privacy and security.' TikTok has said it has 170 million American users. On Thursday, Lutnick said TikTok is 'not really' part of a larger trade deal being discussed with China. But he also said it is hard for the topic to not come up 'unofficially' during discussions with Chinese diplomats. You can watch part of Lutnick's CNBC appearance by clicking here. The post TikTok Will 'Go Dark' Soon if China Does Not Strike Deal, Commerce Secretary Says appeared first on TheWrap.


New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Trump's economic agenda leading to decades-high wage increases, capital expenditures and record tariffs revenue: Treasury
WASHINGTON — President Trump's handling of the economy has succeeded in bringing some of the biggest increases in a decade or more to tariffs revenue, blue-collar wages and capital investments, a senior Treasury official told The Post. Those 'ABCs' — described as 'America First' trade, a 'Blue-Collar Boom' and a 'Capital Expenditures Comeback' — are also rebutting Trump critics who claimed the president's tax-and-tariff agenda would upend the global economy, said Joe Lavorgna, who serves as counselor to Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. As the US agreed to another trade deal with Japan this month, Lavorgna pointed to Treasury revenue from tariffs topping $200 billion in fiscal year 2025 — a record — and approaching 'more than $300 billion' by the end of the calendar year. Blue-collar workers have also seen real wage growth of 1.7% since Trump took office, Bessent previously told Post columnist Miranda Devine on 'Pod Force One,' the highest level of any presidential administration since at least Richard Nixon. 'These are … the laborers, the backbone of the market,' Lavorgna added. 'They didn't graduate from fancy colleges — in most cases probably they didn't graduate from college at all — that are punching a time check when they come into work.' 4 President Trump's handling of the economy has succeeded in bringing some of the biggest increases in a decade or more to tariffs revenue, blue-collar wages and capital investments, a senior Treasury official told The Post. / MEGA In the first half of the year, he noted, capital expenditures surged 16.6% — the largest two-quarter gain since 1997, excluding the rebound coming out of the COVID-19 pandemic. Business equipment production also rose 11% (annualized) in the second quarter after jumping 23% in the first quarter of the calendar year. 'We think it's tied into the One Big Beautiful Bill,' Lavorgna claimed, pointing to provisions that allow businesses to write off production expenses and other investments. 4 Blue-collar workers have also seen real wage growth of 1.7% since Trump took office, Bessent previously told 'Pod Force One,' the highest level of any presidential administration since at least Richard Nixon. REUTERS Last week, Trump touted more than $100 billion in investments for the artificial intelligence and energy industries at a summit in Pittsburgh, one of several events that have spurred economic growth. Japan's trade deal also pencilled in $550 billion in US-based investments. 'If you have more capital, people can produce more,' he went on. 'You're raising productivity and lending standards, living standards … at the same time, people are taking on bigger paychecks … that reinforces the blue-collar boom.' 4 Lavorgna said the largest growth sectors domestically have been in communications equipment, computers and AI. Akarawut – The economic shifts are still keeping core inflation to around 2%, while the current consumer price index hit 2.7% over the past year, per the US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Some trade deals have yet to be inked that could affect those rates — including an anticipated deal with the European Union, which Trump recently threatened with up to 50% duties. Lavorgna said the largest growth sectors domestically have been in communications equipment, computers and AI. 4 Last week, Trump touted more than $100 billion in investments for the artificial intelligence and energy industries at a summit in Pittsburgh, one of several events that have spurred economic growth. Getty Images 'As these trade deals have come through and these other countries such as Japan have committed to making major capital investments in the US, it's clear that the tariffs have had their desired effect,' he said. 'We've got the revenues. We haven't had the inflation, and we're getting the capital commitments of reshoring here. So to me, it's a win-win-win.'