Young people are right not to get out of bed for less than £40k
There have been lots of different explanations offered for why almost a million 16 to 24-year-olds are neither working, training nor studying. But as one expert told a House of Lords committee this week, there is a far simpler explanation: it is not worth the hassle of getting out of bed for less than £40,000.
If that is true, it would be easy to condemn them as idle and feckless. But they are also completely right. Until we fix a dysfunctional welfare and tax system it isn't going to change – because people won't bother to work unless it pays to do so.
It was the kind of hard truth that was not meant to be mentioned in polite society. Appearing before a House of Lords social mobility committee this week, Graham Cowley, who works with young people not in employment, education nor training – or 'Neets' – argued that lots of them 'don't want to work for anything less than 40 grand'.
While the Lords gasped in horror, he reminded them 'you may laugh, but that is the reality' – and he is completely right.
The UK faces a growing challenge that many young people are no longer bothered to either get a job or even to prepare themselves for one. According to the official figures, 595,000 16 to 24-year-olds are classed as 'inactive' while another 392,000 are 'looking for work', but perhaps not very actively since they don't seem to be having much success.
The shadow chancellor, Mel Stride, has suggested that they may be addicted to online pornography and video games, while the Liz Kendall, the Work and Pensions Secretary, has suggested that especially since Covid many of them find the concept of work 'too stressful'.
From coaching, to encouragement, to more stringent medical checks there are lots of different suggestions about ways of getting them out of the house and into a warehouse, factory or retailer to start their career.
The trouble is, it is hard to believe any of that will make any significant difference. It is hard to know what exactly Stride is going to do about online pornography, and Kendall can't turn back the clock and reverse lockdown – as desirable as that might be. In reality, there is a simpler solution.
Although it might come as a surprise to some of the people on the Lords committee, most people work just to make money. Many teenagers and 20-somethings have worked out for themselves that the UK's welfare and tax system has become so bloated and inefficient that getting a job hardly pays any more. They are just making a rational choice.
To start with, taxes are far too high, and they become even higher as you start to climb your way up the career ladder. According to the Centre for Policy Studies, the effective tax rate even for someone on the minimum wage has more than doubled in the last decade alone, rising from an effective 11pc in 2015 to more than 21pc now.
Even worse, if you study for a degree, the repayments on the loan you will have to take out to finance it kick in at far too low a level, and you will be charged a punitive rate of interest. On some plans you start repayments on just £25,000 a year, and you will be charged 7pc interest on the debt you have taken on. On almost any graduate job available, you will have to start repaying your loan, significantly increasing your effective tax rate.
Next, wages are not high enough. Wave after wave of mass immigration has driven down salaries, especially for the relatively low-skilled, entry-level jobs that are typically all that is on offer to teenagers and 20-somethings making their first steps into the workforce.
The average non-graduate salary is now £29,000 in the UK, up from £22,000 a decade ago, but once the cost of living and the extra taxes are taken into account it has gone down in real terms.
Even worse, while many Neets may imagine they will finally stir themselves to get out of bed in the unlikely event that someone offers them £40,000 a year to do so, they probably won't find that very worthwhile either.
As soon as they get a promotion or a bonus they will start paying tax at 40pc, and, given the Chancellor does not show much inclination to ever raise thresholds again, that will probably be the rate for someone on the living wage by the end of the decade.
If they climb further up the ladder, child benefit starts to be withdrawn, and as the personal allowance is tapered away their marginal tax rates soon climb to 60pc or more. Staying in bed will become more and more tempting.
It is a crazy system, and one that is dragging down the entire economy. There is no point in accusing the Neets of being lazy, or not bothering, of being addicted to the web, or lacking the spine of earlier generations.
It is insulting, it is not fair, and even if there was some element of truth to it, there is not much we can do about it anyway.
Instead, we need a wholescale reform of the tax and benefit system. If we have to cut spending to pay for it, then that is the only option.
An entire generation is making a perfectly rational decision that work does not pay enough to be worthwhile any more – and until that calculation changes there is very little prospect of the economy ever starting to recover.
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New York Post
4 hours ago
- New York Post
Shuttered Albany restaurant popular with NY elite, politicians to reopen as members-only social club
An Albany restaurant that used to feature a clientele list teeming with some of the most powerful politicians in New York is set to reopen as a private members' dining club in late 2025. The La Serre restaurant closed in 2020 after it was unable to bounce back from the COVID-19 lockdown, with much of its business at the time relying on large gatherings like banquets and receptions, founder Anne Trimble told the Times Union. The French-based restaurant originally opened in 1977 and quickly became a favorite among New York's political elite on both sides of the aisle during its run, including former Govs. Hugh Carey, Mario Cuomo, George Pataki and Andrew Cuomo. Advertisement Albany's La Serre restaurant will be taken over by an exclusive politician nightclub. Albany Times Union via Getty Ima Now, Mayor Eric Adams' spokesman Todd Shapiro is looking to revamp the historic mainstay alongside Greg Caggiano and Todd Miller of the law firm Miller & Caggiano. 'This is going to be the most important political and social venue north of Manhattan. We're bringing back the old-school power — but with a modern twist: young, trendsetting, high-end, and unapologetically political,' Shapiro said. Advertisement Their vision centers around elevating the old restaurant's history by making it a hotspot for 'high-level networking, private events, and political strategy' while filling the space of a much-needed 'contemporary social anchor,' according to a press release. They plan to make it highly selective, primarily limiting membership to public leaders, media influencers, creatives and civic entrepreneurs, according to the release. La Serre closed in 2020 after it was unable to recover from the COVID-19 lockdown. Albany Times Union via Getty Ima The restaurant will also include a secluded 'War Room' — which shares its name with another restaurant owned by Shapiro — that will be reserved for politicians' off-the-record meetings. Advertisement The new and improved La Serre will include a rooftop terrace and renovated interior, likely shifting away from the upscale, green leather-laden atmosphere of the old restaurant and gravitating towards something more 'clubby,' per the release. Trimble founded the restaurant alongside her late husband, Geoffrey, who passed away in 2005. She managed the restaurant with her son, John, up through its closure, the Times Union reported.


New York Post
9 hours ago
- New York Post
Trump ‘really likes' TikTok— but admin warns Chinese ownership not acceptable as dead deadline looms
President Trump likes TikTok but the Chinese-owned short video app, used by some 170 million Americans, has to move to US ownership, Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick said on Sunday. 'The President really likes TikTok, and he said it over and over again, because, you know, it was a good way to communicate with young people,' Lutnick said in an interview on Fox News Sunday with Shannon Bream. 'But let's face it, you can't have the Chinese have an app on 100 million American phones, that is just not okay. So, it's got to move to American ownership, it's got to move to American technology, American algorithms,' he said. 'I know the President is positive towards TikTok, if it can move into American hands.' Advertisement 3 Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said Sunday that President Trump likes TikTok because 'it was a good way to communicate with young people.: FOX NEWS Lutnick's comments follow his warning last week that TikTok will have to stop operating in the U.S. if China does not approve a deal for the app. He told CNBC on Thursday that US must control the algorithm that makes the social media platform work. Advertisement TikTok parent ByteDance has a Sept. 17 deadline to divest the platform's US assets. Last month, President Trump extended by 90 days to Sept. 17, a deadline for China-based ByteDance to divest the US assets of TikTok. Trump's action took place despite a 2024 law that mandated a sale or shutdown by Jan. 19 of this year if there had not been significant progress. 3 President Trump has set a Sept. 17 deadline for Chinese firm ByteDance to divest TikTok's US assets. Getty Images 'China can have a little piece or ByteDance, the current owner, can keep a little piece. But basically, Americans will have control. Americans will own the technology, and Americans will control the algorithm,' Lutnick said. Advertisement 'If that deal gets approved, by the Chinese, then that deal will happen,' he added. 'If they don't approve it, then TikTok is going to go dark, and those decisions are coming very soon.' 3 A deal that was in the works this spring that would spin off TikTok's US operations into a new US-based firm stalled. Chidori_B – A deal had been in the works this spring that would spin off TikTok's US operations into a new US-based firm, majority-owned and operated by US investors. This stalled after China indicated it would not approve it following Trump's announcements of steep tariffs on Chinese goods. Trump has three times granted reprieves from federal enforcement of the law that mandated the sale or shutdown of TikTok that was supposed to take effect in January.

Business Insider
10 hours ago
- Business Insider
Ghana secures first Paris Club debt deal from France
France has signed a bilateral agreement with Ghana to provide debt relief under the country's ongoing external debt restructuring programme, marking a major milestone in Ghana's efforts to recover from unsustainable debt levels following the COVID-19 pandemic. France signed a debt relief agreement with Ghana as part of an external debt restructuring program. This makes France the first Paris Club member to formally support Ghana's financial recovery. Ghana noted economic progress, including inflation reduction, reflecting positive indicators of recovery. The agreement, signed on Friday, July 25, makes France the first Paris Club member to formally commit to debt relief for Ghana. The development follows Parliament's approval of the indicative terms presented by the Official Creditor Committee (OCC), according to Citi Newsroom. Ghana's Finance Minister, Dr. Cassiel Ato Forson, who signed on behalf of the government, described the agreement as ' the most significant milestone' and urged other Paris Club members to follow France's lead. 'We expect to complete the process as soon as possible so that Ghana can breathe again, ' he said. ' Today is a milestone, a milestone in the sense that it has taken us some time to get here. But it is the most significant one. The most significant one, which will pave the way for others to also emulate the steps taken by France in signing this bilateral agreement,' he added. Officials express optimism over broader support from global creditors The signing ceremony was attended by French Ambassador to Ghana Jules Armand Aniambossou, Paris Club Secretary-General and OCC Co-Chair William Roos, and officials from both governments. Speaking at the event and during his presentation of the 2025 Mid-Year Budget Review in Parliament, Dr. Forson noted that inflation had dropped from 54% to 13.7%, adding, 'We have gone through turbulent signs but we can see that hope is in sight.' He also expressed optimism that Ghana's recent economic progress would be recognized by other members of the Paris Club framework, expediting the country's external debt restructuring process. Ambassador Aniambossou said France's decision reflected the strong ties between the two countries. ' When your friend or family member is facing difficulties, you have to show that you are there for them and take some key actions, ' he said. Paris Club Secretary-General William Roos called for stronger collaboration among creditors. ' We have to progressively build a strong trust between France, China, the G20 and Paris Club members,' he said.