
Civic body faces legal dilemma over impact fees for shops on Saijpur lake land
Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation
(AMC) grapples with the legality of constructions built on waterbodies.
The dispute involves around more than 40 shops that were built and sold by the Saijpur Bogha municipality around 1980 on what was designated as lake land. The area later came under the jurisdiction of the AMC.
These shopkeepers have now applied to the AMC for impact fees to regularize illegal extensions on the existing structures, creating a complex legal situation.
According to AMC sources, while the area is marked as a lake on the Town Planning (TP) scheme map, revenue records show it as govt wasteland.
The lake, which falls under Final Plot No. 24 of TP Scheme No. 35/2, spans 49,355 sq m and has since been developed as a recreational space.
"According to the state govt laws, impact fees cannot be collected for constructions on lakes or govt land," said a senior AMC official who requested anonymity. Despite the shopkeepers having purchased the land from the municipality, it remains govt property, and AMC cannot collect impact fees without the collector's opinion.
The situation highlights a broader issue facing the AMC.
In 2022, the corporation identified 142 waterbodies in Ahmedabad, but possession requests for 33 of these were denied by the collector's office, with 26 locations reportedly having no lakes.
While the AMC has developed Saijpur Lake into a public space, the status of the shops and their illegal extensions remains in limbo. The validity of the original lease and sale agreements made by the former municipality is also under scrutiny.
The matter remains under discussion as authorities work to resolve the complex legal and administrative challenges surrounding these old property transactions on protected land. The resolution could set a precedent for similar disputes.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Hindustan Times
15 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Ludhiana: Consumer forum directs firm to pay ₹5k for deficient service
The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Ludhiana, has directed Eureka Forbes Limited to pay ₹5,000 to a Khanna resident for failing to provide after-sales service under its Annual Maintenance Contract (AMC) for a water purifier. The commission partly allowed the complaint and ordered Eureka Forbes to pay a composite compensation of ₹ 5,000 to Verma within 30 days. (HT Photo) The complaint was filed by Vineet Verma, a resident of New Narotam Nagar, Khanna. Verma had purchased an Aquaguard Delight NXT water purifier for ₹8,799 from Amazon on January 15, 2023. Along with the purifier, he enrolled in the company's Gold AMC plan by paying ₹3,039, valid from February 1, 2024, to January 31, 2025. The AMC was supposed to cover door-to-door maintenance and repair services for the water purifier. However, just a day after the AMC commenced, the purifier stopped functioning. Despite several complaints made by Verma via emails and customer support calls, Eureka Forbes failed to send a representative to repair the purifier. Verma sent eight reminders, followed by a legal notice from his advocate, but received no response from the company. Frustrated by the lack of action, Verma approached the consumer forum seeking a refund of the purchase amount, the AMC charges, and compensation of ₹1 lakh for the harassment and mental distress caused. He also sought ₹15,000 for litigation expenses. During the proceedings, Eureka Forbes failed to appear before the commission despite being served notice. As a result, the company was declared ex parte in November 2024. In its ruling, the commission observed that the company's failure to provide the agreed services amounted to an 'unfair trade practice.' Citing Section 2(47)(viii) of the Consumer Protection Act, the commission noted that the company did not withdraw its deficient services or offer a refund, despite being given ample time. The commission partly allowed the complaint and ordered Eureka Forbes to pay a composite compensation of ₹5,000 to Verma within 30 days. If the payment is not made within the stipulated period, the company will have to pay interest at 8% per annum from the date of the order until the amount is paid in full. The ruling serves as a reminder to companies about their obligations under consumer protection laws and the importance of honouring service agreements.


Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
Several shops remain unsold, AMC to use them as its offices
Ahmedabad: The Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC) was unable to sell 206 shops, 56 offices, and 11 warehouses constructed in 24 buildings across the city, including urban poor housing schemes, commercial complexes, vegetable markets, and health centres. As a result, a circular was issued to use all these offices, shops, and warehouses as the corporation's own offices. Proposals were requested from various departments to temporarily use these properties as offices for different departments. These 273 properties, with an estimated value of around Rs 90-100 crore, will be converted into offices. You Can Also Check: Ahmedabad AQI | Weather in Ahmedabad | Bank Holidays in Ahmedabad | Public Holidays in Ahmedabad Sources from AMC said, "For the past 10 years, AMC has been making plans to sell shops and offices in urban poor housing schemes, staff quarters, and multi-level parking structures. Most of the schemes failed to attract buyers. Particularly, efforts to sell shops and offices in Navrangpura multi-level parking, Sindhu Bhavan multi-level parking, and Prahladnagar multi-level parking did not attract bidders. For the past two years, offices and shops in Sindhu Bhavan Road multi-level parking and Prahladnagar multi-level parking have not been sold, and shops in Navrangpura multi-level parking have remained vacant for the last 10 years. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo " Additionally, shops built in various urban poor housing schemes in the city, and the Geeta Mandir Health Centre building are also not getting buyers, said a source. The official said, "In July 2023, AMC announced the sale of 68 office-type units on Sindhu Bhavan Road, Bodakdev, floor-wise instead of individually, with a base price of Rs 197 crore. Only the ground floor property was sold for Rs 80.46 crore. However, the bidder deposited only 10% of the amount, Rs 8 crore, with AMC's estate department, and over a year has passed without the remaining 90% being paid."


Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
Pirana dumpsite to give way to ‘waste to wonder' park
Ahmedabad: The Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation's road and building committee on Friday approved the appointment of a consultant to develop the 'Pirana Gyaspur Master Plan for Resource Recovery through Waste Management', launching an ambitious initiative to convert the 700-hectare Pirana dumpsite into a recreational hub. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The project will employ scientific methods including biomining and bioremediation to safely close the landfill site. The waste will be securely capped and overlaid with extensive green infrastructure featuring urban forests, nature trails and public parks. The 'waste to wonder' park will include a jungle safari, biodiversity park, dedicated cycling tracks and a heritage plaza documenting the site's transformation. The development will also establish a circular economy and waste innovation campus complete with R&D laboratories, startup incubation facilities, a waste museum and a school. The proposal from the AMC states, "The dumpsite at Pirana, which covers 700 hectares, is planned to be transformed into a 'waste to wonder' park. Waste will be securely capped, and a green and vibrant landscape including urban forests, nature trails and public parks will be developed. This project is expected to provide employment to 3,000 people . Over 30 lakh tonnes of legacy waste will be processed, and more than 50 acres of green public spaces will be developed. " In a separate decision, the committee sanctioned IIT Gandhinagar's appointment to conduct a comprehensive structural stability assessment of the Sardar Patel Stadium in Navrangpura. The evaluation, budgeted at Rs 28.75 lakh, addresses critical safety concerns at the venue. The stadium, recognised in the World Monuments Watch List-2020 as a significant 20th-century urban heritage monument, has shown signs of structural deterioration.