BBC accused of 'spurious' defence over Gaza documentary axe
Welcome to Media Watch. This week we look at the BBC's decision to axe a documentary on Gaza's health service as well as a Sky News reporter being accused of 'parroting propaganda' in his questioning of the Israeli ambassador to the UK.
BBC's 'spurious' defence after axing documentary
THE BBC has come under fire for 'censoring' the accounts of medics and aid workers in Gaza after axing a documentary about Israel's brutal bombardment.
Gaza: Doctors Under Attack explored the destruction of the health service in Gaza and was reportedly ready to be broadcast in February.
We told how the documentary was shelved last month following the controversy around How To Survive A Warzone, which featured the son of a Hamas official.
The production firm behind Gaza: Doctors Under Attack, Basement Films, said at the time that the BBC had postponed airing its film until after a review into How To Survive A Warzone is complete.
However, despite the fact that this review remains ongoing, the BBC has now officially scrapped plans to show the documentary after concluding that it "risked creating a perception of partiality" over the corporation's coverage of Israel and Gaza.
READ MORE: Ex-Unionist party leader backs Scottish independence referendum
Tom Chivers, who works for the Media Reform Coalition, said the BBC's excuse for shelving the documentary was 'spurious', adding it had 'abandoned any pretence' that it gives 'equal regard' to the lives of Palestinians.
He told The National: 'This is only the latest failure by the BBC to provide accurate, impartial and independent reporting on Israel's siege in Gaza and the appalling humanitarian crisis it has created.
'By censoring these accounts from medics and aid workers in Gaza, the BBC has abandoned any pretence that it gives equal regard to the lives and experiences of Palestinians.
'The BBC's excuse for refusing to broadcast the documentary rests on a completely made-up phrase. A 'perception of bias' has no basis whatsoever in the BBC's editorial guidelines.
'If this 'perception' test was applied to other topic of reporting, it would be impossible for the BBC to broadcast any news at all.
'This spurious, unjustifiable defence proves that the BBC is completely cowed by, and overly sensitive to, the objections of Israeli officials and those who wish to ignore or silence any reporting on the atrocities taking place in Gaza.'
The BBC said it was transferring ownership of the film material to Basement Films, and that the documentary had "not undergone the BBC's final pre-broadcast sign-off processes", as some reports had suggested.
Basement Films said it was 'relieved' that the BBC has released the film back to the company 'so that we can release it to the world'.
The company said the BBC had confirmed the film had been approved for broadcast and gave out six different release dates before eventually dropping it.
A Basement Films statement said: 'We would like to thank all the BBC people who worked on this film, those who approved it, those who praised and lauded it, and the scores of BBC staff members; on air editors, correspondents, producers, managers, technical staff and freelancers who told us to keep fighting and gave us sound advice, wrote group letters to their bosses, and asked us to keep fighting to have the film released as approved.
'Although the BBC are now taking their names off this film, it will remain theirs, and we hope it serves to open up the debate on how the nation's broadcaster covers what is happening in Gaza, and that people feel free to speak up and speak out, rather than stay silent or leave, and at some point get the journalistic leadership they deserve.
'But most of all we would like to thank the doctors and contributors and survivors, and to apologise for not believing them when they said the BBC would never run a film like this. It turned out they were right.'
Sky News reporter slated for Israeli ambassador interview
Elsewhere, Sky News reporter Wilfred Frost has been criticised for an interview he carried out with Israeli ambassador to the UK, Tzipi Hotovely.
Frost challenged Hotovely about Gazan children dying amid Israel's assault on the enclave.
Tzipi Hotovely: "We are not there to kill anyone, rather than the terrorists, but in the end of the day its Hamas that is creating this horrible architecture of children & people as human shields"
Wilfred Frost: "I think there's no doubt about that & I'm not questioning that" pic.twitter.com/8xF8nGB4il — Saul Staniforth (@SaulStaniforth) June 23, 2025
But he has been slated for suggesting he was 'not questioning' a statement by Hotovely that Hamas is to blame for using 'children and people as human shields'.
Appearing on Sky News on Monday, Hotovely said: "We are not there to kill anyone, rather than the terrorists, but in the end of the day it's Hamas that is creating this horrible architecture of children and people as human shields.'
READ MORE: UK not selectively applying international law, Labour minister insists
Frost replied with: 'I think there's no doubt about that and I'm not questioning that"
Also in the interview, Frost said 'we can both agree resoundingly about that' when Hotovely said 'they need to blame Hamas for creating this reality for the Palestinians'.
On the exchange, Chivers told The National: 'It's not the job of reporters to demure to government officials and repeat their propaganda, their job is to challenge them and report the truth.'
TV producer Richard Sanders described the interview as 'appalling'.
He said on Twitter/X: 'This is absolutely appalling and Sky should retract.
'There is not a scrap of evidence Hamas uses civilians as human shields. There is a mass of evidence that Israel does precisely this.
'We dealt with this issue at length in our Al Jazeera Investigative Unit film GAZA. This lie continues to be the principal justification for the slaughter of civilians in Gaza.'
On social media, Frost was accused of 'parroting propaganda', while one user said it was an example of 'why people are losing faith in traditional media'.
Sky News has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Rhyl Journal
27 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
BBC under pressure amid criticism of ‘death to the IDF' chants at Glastonbury
Rapper Bobby Vylan, of rap punk duo Bob Vylan, on Saturday led crowds on the festival's West Holts Stage in chants of 'Free, free Palestine' and 'Death, death to the IDF (Israel Defence Forces)'. A member of Belfast rap trio Kneecap suggested fans 'start a riot' at his bandmate's forthcoming court appearance related to a terrorism charge. Responding to the chants from Bob Vylan, the Prime Minister said: 'There is no excuse for this kind of appalling hate speech. 'I said that Kneecap should not be given a platform and that goes for any other performers making threats or inciting violence. 'The BBC needs to explain how these scenes came to be broadcast.' A member of Kneecap said 'f*** Keir Starmer' during their performance after the Prime Minister called for the band not to play at the festival. Avon and Somerset Police said video evidence from the performances would be assessed by officers to determine whether any offences may have been committed that would require a criminal investigation. Glastonbury organiser Emily Eavis said Bob Vylan's chants 'very much crossed a line'. 'We are urgently reminding everyone involved in the production of the festival that there is no place at Glastonbury for antisemitism, hate speech or incitement to violence,' she said in a statement. Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said Bob Vylan was 'inciting violence and hatred' and should be arrested and prosecuted. 'By broadcasting his vile hatred, the BBC appear to have also broken the law,' he said. 'I call on the Police to urgently investigate and prosecute the BBC as well for broadcasting this. Our national broadcaster should not be transmitting hateful material designed to incite violence and conflict,' he posted on X. Health Secretary Wes Streeting called it a 'pretty shameless publicity stunt' and said the BBC and Glastonbury have 'questions to answer about how we saw such a spectacle on our screens', speaking to Sky News. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch called the scenes 'grotesque'. 'Glorifying violence against Jews isn't edgy. The West is playing with fire if we allow this sort of behaviour to go unchecked,' she wrote on X. Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said she was 'horrified' and that the BBC should have cut the feed. 'Given the nature of the attacks on Israel, the BBC should not have kept broadcasting that. They should have cut the coverage immediately,' she told Times Radio. Liberal Democrat culture, media and sport spokesman Max Wilkinson said: 'Bob Vylan's chants at Glastonbury yesterday were appalling. Cultural events are always a place for debate, but hate speech, antisemitism and incitements to violence have no place at Glastonbury or anywhere in our society.' Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has spoken to the BBC director general about Bob Vylan's performance, a Government spokesperson said. The BBC said it showed a warning during the performance and that viewers would not be able to access it on demand. A spokesperson for the broadcaster said: 'Some of the comments made during Bob Vylan's set were deeply offensive. 'During this live stream on iPlayer, which reflected what was happening on stage, a warning was issued on screen about the very strong and discriminatory language. 'We have no plans to make the performance available on demand.' The Israeli embassy said it was 'deeply disturbed by the inflammatory and hateful rhetoric expressed on stage at the Glastonbury Festival'. The Campaign Against Antisemitism (CAA) said it would be formally complaining to the BBC over its 'outrageous decision' to broadcast Bob Vylan. 'Our national broadcaster must apologise for its dissemination of this extremist vitriol, and those responsible must be removed from their positions,' a spokesperson said. Bob Vylan, who formed in Ipswich in 2017, have released four albums addressing issues to do with racism, masculinity and class. Bobby Vylan's real name is Pascal Robinson-Foster, 34, according to reports. He is listed on Companies House as the director of Ghost Theatre Records, which is operated by Bob Vylan. Kneecap have been in the headlines after member Liam Og O hAnnaidh, who performs under the name Mo Chara, was charged with a terror offence. The group performed after Vylan's set on the West Holts Stage with O hAnnaidh exclaiming 'Glastonbury, I'm a free man' as they took to the stage. In reference to his bandmate's forthcoming court date, Naoise O Caireallain, who performs under the name Moglai Bap, said they would 'start a riot outside the courts', before clarifying: 'No riots, just love and support, and support for Palestine.' In the run-up to the festival at Worthy Farm in Somerset, several politicians called for the group to be removed from the line-up and Sir Keir said their performance would not be 'appropriate'. During Kneecap's set, O hAnnaidh said: 'The prime minister of your country, not mine, said he didn't want us to play, so f*** Keir Starmer.' Kneecap also gave a 'big thank you to the Eavis family' and said 'they stood strong' amid calls for the organisers to drop them from the line-up. A BBC spokesperson said an on-demand version of Kneecap's performance was available on iPlayer. 'We have edited it to ensure the content falls within the limits of artistic expression in line with our editorial guidelines and reflects the performance from Glastonbury's West Holts Stage. As with all content which includes strong language, this is signposted with appropriate warnings.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
After BBC's latest anti-Semitic storm, LEO MCKINSTRY on why free speech has never implied the right to incite violence
The BBC has reached a disgraceful new low in its accelerating ethical decline. In an astonishing dereliction of duty, the BBC did not pull the plug on punk duo Bob Vylan as they embarked on an anti-Semitic rant before a Palestinian flag-waving crowd. Instead, it continued to live-stream the performance, effectively treating the glorification of anti-Israeli violence as a casual dose of Saturday afternoon entertainment. A BBC spokesman said yesterday that they had issued an on-screen warning 'about the very strong and discriminatory language' during Bob Vylan's performance and it was later removed from iPlayer. But that limp response is utterly inadequate. Why was the live feed not immediately cut? Does anyone seriously believe the BBC would have shown such spineless inertia if a performer had dared to voice hardline anti-Islamic or anti-immigration rhetoric? Equally unconvincing was the stance of organiser Emily Eavis, whose father Michael co-founded the festival. She released a mealy-mouthed statement insisting that she doesn't necessarily share the political views of performers, and insisted the real themes of Glastonbury are 'hope, unity, peace and love'. After Saturday's spectacle, those words ring hollow. The trouble at Glastonbury on Saturday was caused not just by Vylan but also by the radical Belfast rap trio Kneecap, which has gained notoriety for its endorsement of Irish paramilitaries and the pro-Palestinian cause. And in November 2023, they released a video that stated: 'The only good Tory is a dead Tory. Kill your MP.' So incendiary is their message that many had called for their Glastonbury set to be axed. Eavis refused. Even the enfeebled BBC was sufficiently chary of livestreaming its Saturday performance at Glastonbury. But the baton of intolerance was taken up by Bob Vylan with chilling enthusiasm. The Kneecap warmup act lead the 30,000-strong crowd in a chant of 'Free Palestine' - an aggressive anthem widely loathed by Jews for its anti-Semitic overtones - before the band's frontman, who goes by the moniker Bobby Vylan, then started to rant, 'Death to the IDF ' – the Israeli Defence Force. Let's be clear: in practice, these morbid words amount to a call for the destruction of the Jewish people's homeland, since the IDF is the only effective barrier between the survival of Israel or the triumph of its enemies. Vylan and Kneecap like to wail about the supposed genocide of the Palestinians, but the emasculation of Israel would result in mass slaughter on an epic scale. Some purists might argue that, in a democracy, free speech must be protected and therefore these voices should be heard. But freedom of expression has never implied the right to incite violence or murder. Both those actions have always been serious criminal offences – and should be handled with the full rigour of the law. The broadcaster's own editorial guidelines state the following: 'Material that contains hate speech should not be included in output unless it is justified by the context. Broadcasting hate speech can constitute a criminal offence if it is intended or likely to stir up hatred relating to race, or intended to stir up hatred relating to religious belief.' Rightly, Lord Carlile – crossbench peer and former independent government reviewer of terrorism legislation – has warned that BBC executives could now face charges, as police investigate their handling of Vylan's performance. Meanwhile, the Left's sudden pious wailing about free speech reeks of hypocrisy, given that these are the very campaigners who are often at the forefront of cancel culture. Trying to silence their opponents is a favourite tactic, particularly through accusations of Islamophobia and racism. It was that same ideological suppression that allowed predatory grooming gangs to operate with impunity across towns in the North and Midlands. But then this whole saga is riddled with double standards and contradictions. Yesterday, the Metropolitan Police announced that they are not going to take any action against Kneecap over the trio's call to kill Conservative MPs, a decision that stands in stark contrast to the harsh sentence handed to Lucy Connolly, the wife of a West Northamptonshire Conservative councillor. She was jailed for more than two years for sending an inflammatory tweet about migrants during last summer's riots. To many, Connolly is a symbol of the two-tier justice system that has developed in Britain, where people from certain Left-wing groups – like pro-Palestinian demonstrators - are treated more leniently than those who express conservative views. But it is the BBC who made the greatest misjudgement in this case - and it is because its perspective has undoubtably been warped by its obsession with Glastonbury as an enormously significant cultural landmark, with the result that it treats the festival with uncritical reverence. No expense was spared. Hundreds of BBC staffers descended on Worthy Farm - all at licence fee-payers' cost. Every act was breathlessly praised. The broadcaster was less a neutral observer, more a cheerleader. Yet for all its resources, the BBC failed to conduct even basic checks on Bob Vylan -or to intervene when their set descended into an anti-semitic rant.
Powys County Times
an hour ago
- Powys County Times
British Israeli soldier killed in Gaza, reports say
A British Israeli soldier has been killed while fighting in northern Gaza, according to reports in Israel. He was named locally as 20-year-old Sergeant Yisrael Natan Rosenfeld from the city of Ra'anana. The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office said it is 'looking into reports that an IDF soldier who died in combat in Gaza is a British national'. The IDF soldier, of the 601st Combat Engineering Battalion, was killed by an explosive device on Sunday, the Times of Israel reported. The paper said Mr Rosenfeld moved to Israel from London with his family 11 years ago. Israel has been operating in Gaza since the Hamas militant group's October 7 2023 attack on Israel. More than 860 Israeli soldiers have been killed since the war began, including more than 400 during the fighting in Gaza. US-led ceasefire efforts have repeatedly stalled. The Israeli offensive has devastated Gaza and killed more than 56,000 people, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, a branch of the Hamas government.
