Leinster House bike shed report says no value for money assessment carried out
A new external report has also found that it did not present the costs to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission before going ahead with the project, nor did the body responsible for running Leinster House ask about the cost.
The new bike shed, which provides parking for 36 bikes, caused consternation in September when it emerged that the structure had cost €345,000.
A report written in September 2024 by OPW Chair John Conlon stated that the cost was 'completely not acceptable' and 'not consistent with the scale of the project'.
He referred the case to Deloitte to conduct an external audit.
The report, published on Thursday stated that 'a value for money assessment was not conducted for the Bike Shelter project and currently is not standard practice for elective capital expenditure less than €500,000'.
It also stated that the OPW did not 'communicate an estimate of costs to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission prior to the approval to proceed being received'.
Deloitte stated: 'Our internal audit review has identified the absence of some fundamental good practices in how certain elective capital works (including the Bike Shelter) below the €500K threshold are being initiated, approved, managed and delivered.
'The most fundamental of these control gaps is the absence of a value for money assessment which would have allowed informed OPW personnel to evaluate the cost benefit of building a covered bicycle shelter in the requested location within the Leinster House campus.'
Deloitte stated that while it 'appreciated' that the OPW 'deals with some very large multi-million Euro capital projects' and that many of its processes are designed for larger projects, 'the importance of adhering to good practice for all capital expenditure (including elective capital works below €500K) cannot be overstated'.
The report stated that some 'expected practices' outlined in the Public Spending Code were followed by the OPW.
This included the 'performance of a simple assessment, development of a project specification and plan, preparation of project costing, and development of a project procurement strategy".
It added that 'the reasons for the costs associated with the Bike Shelter project should have been documented in a value for money assessment which should have been performed within the OPW as part of a robust options appraisal process'.
Deloitte stated that 'a formal and documented sense check on cost vs benefit together with lower cost alternatives, and the option of doing nothing, should then have been presented back to the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission as part of a robust options appraisal'.
They said: 'Approval to proceed with the project should only have been formalised when these evaluations were complete.'
The report further found that the OPW did not inform the Houses of the Oireachtas Commission of the estimated project costs at any stage of the Bike Shelter project.
It added: 'The June 2021 decision to proceed with the Bike Shelter project was made without presentation or discussion of project costs – the HOC did not request cost information and the OPW did not present cost information.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Insolvencies steady but companies face 'significant headwinds' for rest of the year
Company insolvencies have declined slightly so far this year, but given the significant international trade tensions, businesses are facing 'significant headwinds to consider for the rest of the year'. According to Deloitte, so far this year there have been 407 insolvencies — down by 1% compared to the same period in 2024 — with the majority of these being seen in the services and hospitality sectors. There have been 173 insolvencies in the broad services sector, while there have been 66 in the hospitality sector. While the hospitality sector saw a 14% drop in insolvencies year-on-year, Deloitte said the sector continued to face a high level of insolvencies. The firm said hospitality had the highest number of insolvencies of any industry in this country when services are split into subsectors. 'Restaurants are disproportionately impacted within this sector, due to legacy debt issues, difficulty attracting and retaining staff, and energy in Ireland being the most expensive in Europe,' Deloitte said. Deloitte Ireland turnaround and restructuring partner James Anderson said while insolvency rates were 'broadly in line with 2024', given the 'ongoing geopolitical and trade tension, there are significant headwinds to consider for the rest of the year'. According to Mr Anderson, company-led closures are down so far this year, while company-led restructuring has increased. There were 14 Small Company Administrative Rescue Processes (Scarp) during the first half of this year — up from seven during the same period in 2024. The Scarp scheme was introduced in late 2021 to help small and micro firms which are still viable, yet insolvent, restructure their debts and avoid liquidation. However, uptake of the scheme remains low. 'Scarp has proven to be a successful process that saves companies and jobs. It is disappointing that awareness remains low despite a success rate of over 70%. It is crucial that an awareness campaign is invested in, so more people are aware of it,' Mr Anderson said. There have been 99 Scarp appointments since its introduction, which represents just 4% of all insolvencies in that time period. However, creditor-led enforcement activity has increased significantly across both court-appointed liquidations and corporate receiverships. 'Court-appointed liquidation activity arising from unresolved debts are up by 121%, with Revenue petitioning in 64% of these appointments,' he said. Deloitte said the rise in court liquidations could be attributed to companies being unable to meet phased payment agreements with Revenue as part of the covid debt warehousing programme. 'Corporate receiverships have increased by 37%, with significant activity by alternative lenders enforcing on real estate-backed loans which have defaulted or matured without resolution.' Read More Bar and pub sales drop 7% despite wider retail sales rise
RTÉ News
a day ago
- RTÉ News
Euro zone inflation picks up to ECB target of 2%
Euro zone inflation edged up last month to the European Central Bank's 2% target, confirming that the era of runaway prices is over and shifting policymaker focus to trade war-induced economic volatility. Inflation in the 20 nations sharing the euro currency crept up to 2% in June from 1.9% a month earlier, in line with expectations in a Reuters poll of economists, as energy and industrial goods continued to pull down prices, offsetting quick services inflation. Underlying inflation, a closely watched measure that excludes volatile food and fuel prices, meanwhile held steady at 2.3%, in line with expectations. Anticipating this fall, the ECB has lowered interest rates from record highs by two full percentage points over the last year, and debate has turned to whether it needs to ease policy further to prevent inflation becoming too low given weak growth. The development in services costs, which have been stubbornly high for years, is pivotal as it has raised fears that domestic inflation could get stuck above 2%. Last month, services inflation edged up to 3.3% from 3.2%, as prices rose 0.7% on the month, supporting the argument of policy hawks that domestic inflation remains uncomfortably high, reducing the risk of undershooting. Financial investors expect one more ECB rate cut to 1.75% towards the end of the year, then anticipate a period of steady rates before possible increases towards the end of 2026. The outlook, however, is complicated by the fact that it depends on the outcome of a trade dispute between the EU and the US President Donald Trump's administration. For now, the conflict has reduced price pressures because it has sapped economic confidence, pushing up the value of the euro and lowering energy prices. Indeed, the euro zone's economy is barely growing, with full-year expansion expected at less than 1%, as industry struggles after a multi-year recession, with private consumption weak and investment low. If US trade barriers stay, the EU is likely to retaliate and that is bound to be inflationary. Firms will then start rearranging value chains, which would add to increased production expenses. Once the cost of the green transition and the ageing of the working age population are factored in, then prices could come under more sustained upward pressure, economists say.
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
Euro inflation edges upwards to ECB's 2% target
Euro area inflation climbed marginally last month, with increases in services underpinning a 0.1% rise in overall price levels. New figures released by Eurostat on Tuesday showed inflation in the 20-country bloc rose to the European Central Bank's (ECB) 2% target in June, up from 1.9% in the previous month. Services inflation was expected to have the highest annual rate in June, the statistics agency said, rising to 3.3%, while food, alcohol and tobacco came in at 3.1% which was down marginally on the previous month. Meanwhile, annual energy prices continue to fall, though at a slower pace, dropping by 2.7% in June. Underlying inflation, a closely watched measure that excludes volatile food and fuel prices, held steady at 2.3%, Eurostat found, which was in line with expectations. Anticipating this fall, the ECB has lowered interest rates from record highs by two percentage points over the last year, with the debate now turning to whether it needs to ease policy further to prevent inflation from becoming too low, given weak growth. Future outlook Economists expect one more ECB rate cut to 1.75% before the end of the year, with a period of steady rates then anticipated before possible increases towards the end of 2026. The outlook, however, depends on the outcome of the ongoing trade negotiations between the EU and the US President Donald Trump's administration, who have until July 9th to confirm an arrangement. For now, the conflict has reduced price pressures due to its downward pressure on economic confidence, pushing up the value of the euro and lowering energy prices. Figures released by the Central Statistics Office (CSO) on Monday showed Irish inflation, measured by the harmonised index of consumer prices (HICP) climbed to 1.6% in the 12 months to June, with continuing food price hikes putting growing pressure on consumer costs. This compares with a 1.4% figure for the previous month and an annual increase of 1.9% for the overall eurozone in the same period. Energy prices are estimated to have fallen by 0.2% in the month, while decreasing by some 1.8% annually. Meanwhile, food prices continue to trend upwards, with a 0.3% rise in the past month contributing to a 4.3% hike since June 2024. Excluding energy and unprocessed foods, Irish inflation using the HICP is estimated to have risen by 1.9% since June 2024.
