Oklahoma agencies publish private school tax credit recipients under transparency law
Oklahoma officials have released the names of the thousands of taxpayers who received the new Parental Choice Tax Credit for tuition and expenses at private schools.
After repeated requests by Oklahoma Watch dating back to December, the Oklahoma Tax Commission sent the tax credit recipient data to the state's open data website. The information is limited to just the name of the taxpayer and the amount of private school tax credits they received in 2024. It doesn't include school or student information.
The tax credit program provides up to $7,500 annually per child for private school expenses. Lawmakers capped the overall cost of the program at $150 million in tax year 2024, but it rises to $250 million in tax year 2026.
If they qualified, most taxpayers received half the credit early in the year and the other half later in the year. The total credit amount doesn't show how many children in a family received the private school tuition tax credit. The top recipient received more than $24,000 in tax credits in the second half of 2024, according to the data.
The data is posted at the state's open data website, which is maintained by the Office of Management and Enterprise Services.
Oklahoma Watch requested private school tax credit data in December from the Tax Commission under the Oklahoma Open Records Act and the Oklahoma Taxpayer Transparency Act. Though most taxpayer data is confidential, recipients of tax credits are an exception under the taxpayer transparency law. Lawmakers passed that law in 2010 to address budget planning issues caused by transferable tax credits.
Initially, the Tax Commission referred Oklahoma Watch's request to the state's open data website, which lacked the relevant data. Commission attorneys later determined the data could only be released through the Office of Management and Enterprise Services. Although the Tax Commission administers the program, it would not release the data directly. After a delay and agency miscommunication, the data was finally posted on the state's open data site on April 29.
The Tax Commission last week released its latest snapshot of the recipients of the Parental Choice Tax Credit. It showed just 2,963 of the 36,921 students approved for the tax credit so far this year were enrolled in public school the previous semester.
In setting up the program, lawmakers gave priority consideration to families making an adjusted gross income of less than $75,000. Proponents frequently referred to that group as 'low income,' even though the state's median household income is $63,600.
About 2,700, or 9%, of the students in the program came from families that qualify for income-based public assistance programs, according to the data snapshot.
More than 27,000 students receiving the private school tax credit – almost 75% – came from families with household incomes above $75,000, according to the latest Tax Commission data.
Shiloh Kantz, executive director of the Oklahoma Policy Institute, said at a minimum, lawmakers should put additional accountability measures into the Parental Choice Tax Credit program. She said it would be helpful to know which private school the student attended and the local public school district. There should also be regular audits of the credit and the percentage of audits where errors were found. Those types of safeguards are built into state and federal programs like the earned-income tax credit, food stamps and Medicaid that benefit low-income families.
'We got told this program will uplift educational outcomes, that it offers families educational choice and opportunity through that choice,' Kantz said. 'But really it just rewards those people who can already afford private education, and it just leaves our public school students further behind, especially in a state where one in five kids live in poverty.'
Kantz said few private schools are adding capacity to take additional students. Meanwhile, some schools have increased tuition since the tax credit was implemented.
'So it is not about having parental choice,' Kantz said. 'It is about checking a box as a political red state to say, 'We did the thing.' But it's not helping working Oklahomans.'
The Legislature considered several changes to the program this year. Lawmakers didn't act on Senate Bill 229, by Sen. Julie Daniels, R-Bartlesville, this session. It would have eliminated the $250 million annual cap on the private school tax credit, a change Gov. Kevin Stitt called for at a rally at the Capitol in March celebrating the private school tax credit program.
SB 684, by Senate Pro Tempore Lonnie Paxton, R-Tuttle, could come up for a vote in the House this week. It mostly deals with accreditation organizations for private schools participating in the Parental Choice Tax Credit. But it also prioritizes existing recipients if they still meet income eligibility requirements.
This article first appeared on Oklahoma Watch and is republished here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
13-06-2025
- Yahoo
Homeowners perplexed as insurers give dubious explanation for skyrocketing rates: 'Just so people stop asking questions'
Oklahoma homeowners are getting hit with some of the highest insurance rates in the country, with many paying nearly three times the national average, reported Oklahoma Watch. While state officials blame hail damage for the sky-high costs, weather experts say the data tells a different story. Oklahomans now pay an average of $4,651 to insure a $300,000 home, more than double the national average. Even more shocking, residents spend 6.84% of their annual income on homeowners insurance compared to just 2.41% nationwide. The state's insurance commissioner points to hail as the main culprit. But meteorologists aren't buying it. "They might just say, 'Oh, I don't know, it's hail,' just so people stop asking questions," said Bruce Thoren, a National Weather Service meteorologist in Norman, per Oklahoma Watch. The numbers back up his skepticism. Data from 2020–2024 cited by the publication shows Oklahoma averaged 16.6 days of significant hail annually. Meanwhile, Texas, which has much lower insurance rates, dealt with 37.8 days of hail during the same period. These inflated rates create a double burden for families already facing rising costs everywhere else. When spending nearly 7% of your income just to protect your home, that's money you can't put toward other necessities or savings. The real problem appears to be a regulatory loophole created in 1999. Originally designed to increase competition in business insurance, the law was quietly expanded to cover homeowners insurance in 2004. Now, as Oklahoma Watch noted, Oklahoma's insurance department will step in if rates go too low, but it won't regulate when they spike upward. This hands-off approach lets insurance companies raise rates to cover losses from other states, leaving Oklahoma families holding the bag. Do you think your energy bills are too high? Always Usually Only in certain months Never Click your choice to see results and speak your mind. "They're not supposed to do that," Oklahoma City insurance attorney Simone Fulmer told the publication, though she observed there's little in state law to prevent it. Consumer advocates are calling for regulatory reform to bring Oklahoma in line with states like Texas, where the law requires that insurance rates be neither too low nor too high. The Oklahoma Insurance Department can investigate whether the market is competitive, but only if someone files a formal complaint. In over 20 years, this has happened just once, and ironically, the insurance commissioner served as both the person bringing the complaint and the judge deciding the outcome. If you're frustrated with your insurance rates, contact the Oklahoma Insurance Department. Its Oklahoma City office can be reached at 405-521-2828, and the Tulsa office at 918-295-3700. You can also support candidates who prioritize consumer protection over insurance industry interests. As Oklahoma Watch noted, campaign finance records show the top donors of Oklahoma Insurance Department Commissioner Glen Mulready have consistently been insurance companies, sometimes outspending other groups by four to one. Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.
Yahoo
06-06-2025
- Yahoo
McCall vying to be Oklahoma's next governor
After serving eight years as the Speaker of the Oklahoma House of Representatives, Charles McCall is now vying to be the next governor of Oklahoma. McCall was elected to House District 22 in 2012 and elected Speaker in 2016, serving as the state's longest-serving Speaker of the House. Outside of his political role, McCall is the CEO and Board Chairman of AmeriState Bank in Atoka. He previously served as Mayor of Atoka from 2005 to 2012. According to his campaign, while serving as Speaker, McCall focused on getting the state's fiscal house in order, helped decrease personal and corporate income taxes and was the leader of there Parental Choice Tax Credit, which allowed parents control over their children's education. ' When I came into speakership in 2017, it was just the worst of times here in the state of Oklahoma fiscally,' McCall said. 'We'd done a four-year contraction, no reserves, cut budgets, just really difficult. And I was picked to be the speaker because of that, because I was a banker.' McCall said the caucus chose him to help navigate the state out of a bad financial situation, which he said was achieved in about two years, he said. The past six has been 'record year after record year,' he said. ' So Oklahoma's now in a place where we're not in a hole. We are thriving, we have reserves now,' he said. 'What motivates me (to run for governor) and what I'm excited about is the opportunity that's on the horizon for the people, the state of Oklahoma, as well as businesses. I think we're just right on the cusp of taking another huge step forward.' He said the economy doubled its output in the past six years and the appropriated budget, which was about $6 billion when he became Speaker, is about $13 billion today. ' Oklahoma is no longer a flyover state. We are a fly-to state,' McCall said. ' We have people with great values and good work ethic. So Oklahoma's starting to be recognized on the national stage. We're already, in some areas, we're the best in the country already. But we really, once again, we're just on the cusp of being able to have a real breakthrough for the people of the state economically.' He said the next governor of Oklahoma needs to be somebody with business experience and success while also knowing how the government operates and being able to seize opportunities. He said Oklahoma has yet to land a big industry or company moving to the state, adding that the state has been on the shortlist but is always bumped out. The state has seen growth and success in the aviation and aerospace industry, McCall said, which is the state's second largest industry beating out agriculture and tourism. McCall said he thinks Oklahoma has the best opportunities to grow in the technology sector. ' Our low cost of energy and low cost of living and natural resources — and our proximity in the country— make us the ideal choice. We just have to have the right environment, the right incentive,' McCall said. ' I really think that's where the opportunity is. We're seeing a lot of investment in the state around technology right now. Data centers, in (particular) are the most emerging technology everybody is chasing.' The growth of data centers, and companies interest in building centers in Oklahoma, was a topic of discussion during a legislative summary in Chickasha with Rep. Dick Low, R-Amber, and Brad Bowles, R-Marlow back in February. Boles said it takes the same amount of power required for 250,000 houses to power one 500-megawatt data center. During the meeting with Grady County locals, Boles said potential centers would have to go through the Southwest Power Pool, which takes about two years to get approval. Boles also said he authored a bill during this year's legislative session that would allow data centers or large industrial companies to come to Oklahoma if they were off the grid. This would require the companies to provide their own power generation to the facility while going through the two year process to be added to the grid. McCall said data center companies want to come to Oklahoma because the state has the power capacities but added that the state is approaching some capacity within the power grid and will need to bring additional generation to that state. He also said he believe rural areas have the opportunity to grow as people are looking for more space to live, for quality of life and more space to roam and run, adding that he believes that's why people are leaving Dallas and Houston. EDUCATION While Speaker, McCall authored the bill that created the Parental Choice Tax Credit allowing parents control over their children's education and providing a income tax credit that can be used for tuition and fees for eligible private school educations. McCall said education was a top priority for him as Speaker and will continue to be if elected governor. 'I think the legislature's done what it needs to do in supporting the funding of education but there's some things that need to happen in the executive branch of government,' McCall said. Despite having an elected State Superintendent of Public Instruction, McCall said he believe the next governor will need to push for a 'very disciplined plan' to improve the state's education outcome. ' That's something that I'm prepared to do. I don't think it can be accomplished, you know, in year one or year two,' he said. 'I don't want to give anybody the expectations that we will move our education outcomes from 48th or 49th to in the twenties in two years. But tackling the problem… We just need to have some discipline on it and we need a good plan that addresses our weaknesses and deficiencies within education.' INCOME TAX In terms of finding success in economic development, McCall said he believes one of the keys is to bring down personal income tax. He said the state should follow the model Tennessee used, which decreases income tax over time as the economy grows. ' We've got to get down to zero because right now, people have a choice to move to Oklahoma or Texas… They are going to bypass Oklahoma because they get a 4.75% raise immediately just by living in Texas,' McCall said. 'They may drive over to Oklahoma for their job, but they want residency there just because they're saving money on the personal income tax.' McCall added that every time income tax was lowered while he was Speaker, the states revenue increased because there was more money left in individuals pockets. ' They're gonna spend it but they get to spend it the way they want to,' McCall said. 'It comes back to the state after it bounces around here (in) Chickasha, at Norman. Both at the city and county level, it throws off consumption revenue to the state of Oklahoma. I think every time we bring that personal income tax rate down and we quit taxing productivity and just focus on consumption, that's a net positive for the state.'
Yahoo
23-05-2025
- Yahoo
Financial issues found leading up to Mental Health Commissioner appointment
OKLAHOMA CITY (KFOR) — The Oklahoma Attorney General has shed light on financial troubles seen in Mental Health and Substance Abuse Commissioner Allie Friesen's past. The Commissioner then allegedly sent an email to employees calling out the AG on that. 'How can we expect a taxpayer who doesn't properly handle their own personal finances to be in charge of hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars?' Attorney General Gentner Drummond posted on social media Wednesday night, along with several past Tax Commission documents that showed Commissioner Friesen received liens from the state for several years of unpaid taxes. Drummond is running for Oklahoma's Governor, and recently called for Friesen's firing after lawmakers found several dozen million dollars were missing from the department. The documents the Drummond posted on Wednesday showed that Commissioner Friesen's recent lien on her property was released a day before Governor Stitt announced her appointment as Mental Health Commissioner. Report: Oklahoma mental health agency facing nearly $30 million budget hole When Stitt's office was asked if they knew about the financial troubles leading up to her appointment and for a statement, they responded with, 'Her taxes are paid. This is a desperate campaign tactic by Gentner Drummond. Oklahomans see through his game, and I'm sure they truly wish he would return to the work their taxpayers are paying him to do.' This comes as her department is under much scrutiny. The state auditor's office released findings from a scathing audit that reported their preliminary recommendations included hiring a qualified CFO with state government financial experience as soon as possible, evaluating the qualifications of recent executive hires, and scrutinizing recent and ongoing terminations to ensure they aren't retaliatory. An anonymous employee under the Department of Mental Health sent News 4 an email that was allegedly sent by Commissioner Friesen, which reacted to the AG's social media post. It reads in part: 'A Message from Commissioner Friesen: Recent Social Media Post Team, I want to address a recent social media post made by the Attorney General regarding tax liens that were filed against me personally— an issue that is, without question, fully resolved. These matters have been paid in full, long ago, and are not reflective of my ability to lead or serve. To be very clear: this is a non-issue being weaponized for political gain. What is an issue and one I cannot ignore—is the blatant violation of character, the disturbing misuse of public office, and the sustained campaign of political bullying I have endured from the Attorney General of our state. His anger toward me stems from one thing: I was the first leader in Oklahoma to remove him from a position of influence—and that decision was the right one. This is what it looks like when someone with power chooses to abuse it rather than use it for good. His post wasn't about accountability. It wasn't about truth. It was about retaliation. It was about ego. Let me say this plainly: we will not be distracted by individuals who see our agency's financial challenges-and our bold, courageous leadership to transform this system— as an opportunity to attack, rather than a chance to stand shoulder to shoulder in service to the people of Oklahoma. It is disheartening that some view our work as a threat to their influence. It is disappointing that, instead of leaning in to support meaningful reform, they choose to tear down those who are willing to do the hard work. But I will not be deterred and neither should you. To every single employee: You may not agree with every decision we make as an administration. That's okay. That's healthy. But you do have a choice in whether you support good over evil. And make no mistake—this kind of response is exactly what happens when you call out corruption. If we weren't doing something right, they wouldn't come for us like this. Our mission remains clear. Our purpose is stronger than ever. And as your Commissioner, I will continue to stand firmly-for you, for our organization, and for the people we serve. We will keep moving forward. We will keep doing what's right—even when it's hard. And we will not let those who thrive on intimidation, manipulation, or fear define who we are or what we accomplish. With Appreciation, Allie Friesen Email from anonymous public employee of Dept. of Mental Health 'I'm deeply concerned that a lot of what we've heard from the commissioner seems to be the position of the governor. I'm concerned about ongoing leadership,' said Senator Julia Kirt (D-OKC). Commissioner Friesen responded to the AG's posts to News 4 and said, 'The Friesen family has fulfilled all tax obligations, and the matter referenced was fully resolved with the Oklahoma Tax Commission prior to Commissioner Friesen's confirmation. The Oklahoma Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Services remains firmly committed to transparency and accountability. Under Commissioner Friesen's leadership, the agency has taken proactive steps to bring to light and address long-standing financial and operational issues. We continue to work closely with Governor Stitt, legislative leaders and have actively sought independent audits and investigations to ensure integrity in all aspects of our operations.' Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
