Jevon McSkimming – Privacy And Democracy Vs Journalists
'I dont think journalists have yet learnt that their power of the pen or words they publish can perpetually harm a persons livelihood, their familys livelihood and in the case of Mr McSkimming, forever destroy his reputation and career,' says …
Opinion: Kerry Grass, Asia Pacific AML
Is Former NZ Deputy Police Commissioner Jevon McSkimming a victim of a malicious and orchestrated rumour? Was the rumour designed to derail his candidacy from New Zealand's next Police Commissioner and secure the role to Richard Chambers?
Since the time the news broke that NZ's next Police Commissioner was shortlisted to two candidates, I have been following that media trail. It was therefore an interesting article to read, shortly after, that one of the candidates had been stood down from employment duties. The media article reported that there was a pending investigation and gave some detail about the allegation.
What was then unfortunate to read but fairly common in New Zealand's media, was a small number of journalists who continued reporting details of the allegation. Such conduct by journalists I find very frustrating and it would seem they have ignored that Mr McSkimming has minimum rights afforded to him under New Zealand's laws. These laws include the Bill of Rights Act, the Privacy Act and the Employment Relations Act.
Section 27 of the Bill of Rights Act (BORA), afford Mr McSkimming to the Right to Natural Justice. It sets out –
(1) Every person has the right to the observance of the principles of natural justice by any tribunal or other public authority which has the power to make a determination in respect of that person's rights, obligations, or interests protected or recognised by law.
(2) Every person whose rights, obligations, or interests protected or recognised by law have been affected by a determination of any tribunal or other public authority has the right to apply, in accordance with law, for judicial review of that determination.
(3) Every person has the right to bring civil proceedings against, and to defend civil proceedings brought by, the Crown, and to have those proceedings heard, according to law, in the same way as civil proceedings between individuals.
To then read that journalists and the Minister of Police continued to publicly share their personal views and report details of the allegation – is beyond belief.
I don't think journalists have yet learnt that their power of the pen or words they publish can perpetually harm a person's livelihood, their family's livelihood and in the case of Mr McSkimming, forever destroy his reputation and career. This impact still eventuates if he is found innocent of the allegations that journalists and Minister Mitchell are reporting.
There is also the possibility the allegations were designed to derail Mr McSkimming's role as the next Police Commissioner. If so, the orchestration and malicious leaking were successful in the objective.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
8 hours ago
- 1News
What does a drug shipment 'catcher' earn for picking up the haul?
After a West Auckland builder was yesterday sentenced to five years in prison for collecting what he thought was a shipment of 200kg of meth, Yvonne Tahana looks at the economics behind drug operations. The value of a large consignment of drugs quickly spirals when you start doing the maths, as Detective Superintendent Greg Williams, head of Police's National Organised Crime Group, explains. Asked about the 200kg of meth that Joshua Auina-Anae thought he was picking up from a commercial unit in Hobsonville in November 2023, Williams said you're looking at 'about $130,000 a kilo... that's a wholesale price'. Inside police's fake meth bust that fooled a Kiwi builder - watch on TVNZ+ A quick calculation therefore gives the total price for the shipment, which unbeknown to Auina-Anae had already been intercepted in China, at $26 million. ADVERTISEMENT But Williams isn't finished. "Then it's cut down into ounce prices, which sell for around $5000 an ounce. And then by the time it hits the street, it's at gram prices which are sitting around $480 to $380 sort of price. Now you're in the range of $76 million to $96 million." Methamphetamine was swapped out with a dummy substance. (Source: NZ Police) So what did Auina-Anae stand to gain for going to collect the haul? He'd never been in trouble before and worked in construction – in fact, he ran his own business. But he found himself caught up in an international law enforcement effort involving a tip-off from China's Anti-Smuggling Bureau. 'Cleanskin', 'catcher' or 'door' This led to the meth he was expecting to collect being switched out for a dummy substance. And police and Customs were waiting for him when he went to pick it up in his role as, to use the various terms used, a "cleanskin", "catcher" or "door". ADVERTISEMENT The terms all point in roughly the same direction. Williams said: "The reality is that transnational crime sitting outside the country, and the organised crime groups sitting inside the country, often refer to 'doors' – doors into the country. Detective Superintendent Greg Williams says the incentive comes down to greed. (Source: 1News) "So often, a door is, 'I've corrupted someone within the system at the border or someone prepared to take this risk, someone without any criminal history who's prepared to be the front person or the 'catcher', and then they organise the shipment into the country." In the Auckland District Court yesterday, Judge Evangelos Thomas heard that Auina-Anae was at the bottom of the chain. A police DVD recording of the offender's statement "advised that he received orders to do the job from an unknown person". Auina-Anae's lawyer Jasper Rhodes said his client was expecting payment. "And he's been candid about that,' he said. ADVERTISEMENT The granite slabs the "methamphetamine" was imported in. (Source: NZ Police) However, he said the amount would be 'absolutely disproportionate to the profits that the leading offenders were expecting to earn". He wouldn't be expecting figures in the millions. Williams said he knew of a "catcher" in Christchurch pulling cocaine out of a container who received about $40,000 to take the risk. "And it comes down to that greed aspect to this, right? And that's the chilling bit here. These groups cannot operate unless they corrupt people in and around the border or people like this prepared to do it." Auina-Anae walked through a different door yesterday and as he begins his time behind bars, he can reflect on whether the amount on offer was worth the risk. Watch more on this story on TVNZ+
NZ Herald
9 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Identical twins Colin and Graham Whines deny beating and kidnapping Northland man
The charges include wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, wounding with intent to injure, threats to kill, kidnapping and unlawful possession of firearms and ammunition. Graham Whines is also charged with perverting the course of justice after he allegedly sent a text message with images of guns and ammunition to the complainant after the alleged assault. The court heard the twins had grown up with the complainant, Troy Hansen, in Auckland and then reconnected in the years after 2020 when the families discovered they had all moved to Northland. At around midnight on February 16, 2023, Hansen opened the door of his Whangārei property to the twins who had turned up unannounced. After Graham went to the bathroom, he allegedly grabbed hold of Hansen tightly while Colin allegedly struck him across the head with a beer mug. For the next three hours, the twins allegedly unleashed a brutal onslaught, raining down up to 50 blows with fists, feet and bar stools. They allegedly strangled him with a tablecloth, doused him in vodka and tried to ignite him. Throughout the ordeal it's alleged they repeatedly threatened to kill Hansen and his family. Hansen managed to escape and reach help at his parents' house and told them two Māori men had assaulted him at his house. This allegation was recorded on a 111 call and played in court. After being hospitalised with open wounds, concussion, broken ribs and a collapsed lung, he eventually told police it was not two Māori men but the Whines twins. When their house was searched, several firearms were located along with ammunition. Crown lawyer Pablo Hamber said DNA evidence placed the twins at the scene and the brothers had clearly executed a plan to assault Hansen. 'The Crown says when they are trying to escape and you stop them, it's unlawful. They're not consenting and the defendants knew they were not consenting,' Hamber said. Defence lawyer John Howell told the jury the twins were at the complainant's home but were not present when the violence took place. 'He makes a statement to police that it was two Māori men that did this to me,' Howell said. 'You must keep an open mind right through until verdict and my clients are innocent until proven guilty.' Judge Keith de Ridder is hearing the trial, which is expected to last one week. Photo / NZME Hansen gave evidence on Monday about the night he thought he was going to die. 'The first thing Colin said was, as he's got tears coming from his eyes, he's saying, 'we've been planning this for a whole year',' Hansen told the court. 'It was unbelievable' Hansen said that as he was being strangled, Colin repeatedly punched him – shattering the glasses on his face, then allegedly using the broken shards to try to gouge out his eyes. 'It was full strangulation,' Hansen said. 'How much pressure was being applied?' Hamber asked. 'It was unbelievable.' He said when his rib popped, Graham allegedly said, 'did you hear his rib crack?' After allegedly being assaulted for three hours, Hansen could not breathe as his lung had collapsed. He said he had a request of the brothers. 'I said, 'If you're gonna kill me can I have a cigarette and coffee before you do?'' 'You can kill me' Graham made him a coffee while the assaults continued and allegedly told his brother, 'We gotta kill him, Colin'. Hansen said the brothers were allegedly telling him to make a choice of which family member they would kill, to which he responded, 'You can kill me'. 'Graham was the one doing most of the stuff, he was doing most of the talking but they were both involved from start to finish.' According to Hansen, the brothers just stopped the assault and left, driving slowly out of his driveway. 'I just thought, this is weird.' When questioned by Hamber about why he had said it was two Māori men, he said he had made a promise to the accused twins he wouldn't tell anyone. 'I knew these boys had guns. They were threatening to kill my family. But I was always going to tell,' Hansen said. Under cross-examination by Howell, Hansen said he was not sure what the motive was but they were allegedly making strange comments that did not make sense. 'When he [Colin] was giving me a beating, he was saying, 'you gave me cancer',' Hansen said. 'What you're doing is making things up,' Howell put to the complainant. 'I don't think so, sir.' Judge Keith de Ridder is overseeing the trial, which is expected to finish on Friday. Shannon Pitman is a Whangārei-based reporter for Open Justice covering courts in the Te Tai Tokerau region. She is of Ngāpuhi/ Ngāti Pūkenga descent and has worked in digital media for the past five years. She joined NZME in 2023.
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
Private Security Personnel Licensing Authority cancels licences for guards accused of turning up to police events
By Jeremy Wilkinson, Open Justice reporter of The authority said Brent and Alison Shaw should have paid for the right security licence before they paid to have signwriting on their car. Photo: House and Farm Security / Facebook A security guard drew the ire of police for allegedly showing up to events and questioning witnesses, sometimes before the real cops turned up. Brent Shaw also painted a Toyota Wish with orange and blue patterns and lights similar to a police vehicle, and reportedly wore a uniform similar to actual police uniforms. Police became concerned that Shaw and an employee of his security business, House and Farm Security Service, were listening to police communications with a scanner and listed occasions where they would arrive at incidents in their security uniforms and signwritten vehicle, and collect information from people involved before police could arrive. The police radio frequency can be listened to in regional areas of New Zealand, but is encrypted within the main city centres. This prompted police to make a complaint to the Private Security Personnel Licensing Authority, which handles complaints about licensed security guards. Shaw and his wife Alison both had Certificates of Approval to work as employed security guards but didn't have a licence to run their own business because they couldn't afford the annual fees. Despite this, Shaw and an employee who didn't hold any kind of security licence would drive around New Plymouth in their signwritten vehicle for their unlicensed security business, House and Farm Security Service. The business advertised extensively through flyers, social media and business cards but only generated $320 worth of income in that period. According to a ruling by the authority released this week, the Shaws were found to have been running their business without a licence, and to have hired an employee to work as a security guard without a certificate of approval. "The fact the business was not successful and earned very little money does mean House and Farm Security Service does not fit within the definition of a crowd controller or property guard …" authority head Trish McConnell said. "Before spending money on their vehicle, uniforms, flyers and advertising Mr and Mrs Shaw should have applied for a security licence." Part of the Shaws' argument in response to the complaint from police was that they hadn't hired an employee because they didn't get any regular work, but had him work a one-off security gig at a local festival. McConnell said this was a breach of the licensing rules and in addition, they had allowed that worker to wear a uniform for several months and hold himself out as a legitimate security worker. It's the second time Shaw has fallen foul of the authority after receiving a warning in 2017 for operating a similar business without a licence. McConnell described the Shaws' conduct as "intentional and ongoing" and despite being warned about needing a licence, they didn't get one. McConnell cancelled both Brent and Alison Shaw's personal security licences and fined them $800, which was the cost of the annual licence for their business that they didn't pay when they set it up. Brian Shaw told NZME he denied having a scanner capable of listening to police communications, and turning up at incidents before actual police to talk to witnesses. Shaw claimed instead that on one occasion he had witnessed a car accident and taken down the details of a driver who had left the scene, which he passed on to police. * This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald .
