Former Israeli prime minister calls Gaza ‘humanitarian city' a concentration camp

Middle East Eye

6 days ago

Israel's plan to forcibly confine more than 2 million Palestinians to a small area in the southern Gaza Strip amounts to a "concentration camp", former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has said.
"It is a concentration camp. I am sorry," the 79-year-old told The Guardian on Sunday, when asked about a plan outlined by Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz last week, which would see an initial 600,000 Palestinians held in an area built on the ruins of Rafah city.
According to Katz, Palestinians in the area would undergo security screenings and would not be allowed to leave. Eventually, the entire civilian population would be concentrated in the same location.
Katz also said Palestinians would then be encouraged to "voluntarily" leave the Gaza Strip for other countries as part of an "emigration plan".
Responding to the proposal, Olmert said: "If [Palestinians] will be deported into the new 'humanitarian city', then you can say that this is part of an ethnic cleansing," adding that ethnic cleansing was the "inevitable interpretation" of the plan.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
'When they build a camp where they 'clean' more than half of Gaza, then the inevitable understanding of the strategy of this [is that] it is not to save [Palestinians]," he said.
"It is to deport them, to push them and to throw them away. There is no other understanding that I have, at least," he added.
Israel's newspaper of record, Haaretz, reported last week that Katz's plan has the backing of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
As of 14 July, it remains unclear when construction for the proposed city would begin or whether it could proceed without international backing.
Katz envisaged that, if conditions permitted, the city would be built during a two-month pause in hostilities. Such a ceasefire is currently being negotiated between Israel and Hamas through intermediaries, but remains far from agreement.
'Concentration camp': Israel's planned new city in Rafah, explained Read More »
International law and genocide experts told Middle East Eye last week that the plans would violate multiple provisions of international law.
Under the Fourth Geneva Convention of 1949, populations in occupied territories "shall at all times be humanely treated" and may only exceptionally be placed under assigned residence or internment when there are "imperative reasons of security".
"A blanket decision to enclose hundreds of thousands of people in a concentration camp or zone clearly falls well outside the lawful exception and would entail an unlawful deprivation of liberty in breach of IHL and of human rights law," Eitan Diamond, a senior legal expert based in Jerusalem with the Diakonia International Humanitarian Law Centre, told MEE.
Experts also said that Katz's so-called "voluntary emigration" plan - a manifestation of US President Donald Trump's proposal to ethnically cleanse the enclave - was far from "voluntary".
"There is nothing voluntary about any emigration scheme that Israel devises in these circumstances," Martin Shaw, a prominent sociologist and author of several books on the subject of genocide, told MEE.
"The people of Gaza have been bombed out of their homes, lost their loved ones, starved and shot at when they try to get food.
"Israel will be using all this cruelty to force people to leave and to remove their right to return, as they have from previous generations of Palestinians."
Olmert says he is 'ashamed and heartbroken'
Olmert spoke to The Guardian on the same day that funerals were held in the occupied West Bank for two Palestinian men, including a US citizen, killed by Israeli settlers.
"[It is] unforgivable. Unacceptable. There are continuous operations organised, orchestrated in the most brutal, criminal manner by a large group," the former premier said.
"There is no way that they can operate in such a consistent, massive and widespread manner without a framework of support and protection which is provided by the [Israeli] authorities in the [occupied Palestinian] territories."
Olmert said that extremist figures within Israel's cabinet, who have backed violence in the occupied West Bank and Gaza and authorised settlement expansion, are more dangerous for Israel's long-term security than any external foes.
"These guys are the enemy from within," he said.
He added that growing anger at Israel internationally could not all be dismissed as antisemitism.
'I cannot refrain from accusing this government of being responsible for war crimes committed'
- Ehud Olmert, former Israeli prime minister
"In the United States, there is more and more and more expanding expressions of hatred to Israel," he said.
"We make a discount to ourselves, saying: 'They are antisemites.' I don't think that they are only antisemites, I think many of them are anti-Israel because of what they watch on television, what they watch on social networks.
"This is a painful but normal reaction of people who say: 'Hey, you guys have crossed every possible line'."
Olmert called for stronger international pressure on Israel in the absence of any serious opposition in Israel. He also criticised Israel's media for failing to report on Israeli violence against Palestinians.
He said he initially backed Israel's war following Hamas' surprise attack on 7 October, which killed around 1,200 people.
But he later became "ashamed and heartbroken" by the Israeli government's actions, which he says amount to war crimes.
"What can I do to change the attitude, except for number one, recognising these evils, and number two, to criticise them and to make sure the international public opinion knows there are [other] voices, many voices in Israel?" he said.
He said Israeli commanders had looked away as actions were taken that would "cause the killing of a large number of non-involved people".
"That is why I cannot refrain from accusing this government of being responsible for war crimes committed."
Israeli forces have killed more than 58,000 Palestinians since the war on Gaza began in October 2023, and wounded at least 138,500 more.