logo
[Robert J. Fouser] Misguided university reform plan

[Robert J. Fouser] Misguided university reform plan

Korea Herald10-07-2025
Over the past several weeks, talk of a promise from President Lee Jae Myung to 'create 10 universities on par with Seoul National University' has stirred debate.
The plan has its origins in a book by Kim Jong-young, a professor at Kyung Hee University, published in 2021. The plan aims at investing heavily in nine regional national universities to raise their 'level' to close to Seoul National University. The impetus for the plan comes from a broader push to promote balanced regional development. Minister of Education nominee Lee Jin-sook is pushing the plan, and it appears to have support in the National Assembly.
But is it a good idea? The idea of promoting balanced regional development goes back 50 years to the 1970s when President Park Chung-hee tried to limit the growth of Seoul north of the Han River.
Most presidents since Park have tried to push balanced regional development, mostly moving government offices and research centers out of Seoul. These efforts may have slowed the pace of concentration in Seoul slightly, but they have not changed the underlying attitudes toward Seoul as the place to be for success.
Until the underlying attitudes change, the idea of promoting regional universities faces strong headwinds because most professors and students would rather be in Seoul. At present, many, if not most, professors at regional universities leave their families in Seoul because of opportunities afforded to their spouses and children. Meanwhile, academically strong students prefer leading private universities in Seoul with a strong alumni network over a regional national university.
Rankings of universities around the world are subjective, but according to the 'Times Higher Education' World University Rankings 2025, among the top 100 universities, only Seoul National University, ranked 62nd, and Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, No. 82, made the grade. Sungkyunkwan University and Yonsei University tied at No. 102.
Another established ranking, the QS World University Rankings, is slightly more favorable, showing SNU at 32nd. Yonsei University ranked 50th, while Korea University notched in at 61st. KAIST did not participate in the survey, but Pohang University of Science and Technology, or Postech, came in at 102nd.
Together, these rankings show that targeted investment in regional science and technology universities like KAIST and Postech has made them competitive with SNU. They also show that leading private universities in Seoul are competitive globally. At first glance, the experience of KAIST and Postech suggests that investment in regional national universities could help move up the ladder and possibly compete with SNU and private universities in Seoul.
Such an outcome is highly unlikely.
Apart from the preference for Seoul, the number of professors and researchers leaving leading institutions for posts abroad increased recently, which means that existing institutions could face difficulties in attracting and retaining top-level talent. Regional universities, particularly private ones, face declining enrollments as the population of high school graduates continues to shrink. The flow of international students has slowed, compounding the problem.
In this difficult environment, using universities to promote balanced development stands little chance of success. Instead, the government should focus on increasing the research competitiveness of leading institutions and improving the educational quality of the rest. Leading institutions that have a record of research results should be rewarded with increased funding regardless of their location. If this means that a handful of elite institutions continue to get a large proportion of government funding, then so be it.
University education is about more than research; it's about the larger public purpose of fostering informed and engaged citizens. To do so, universities need to create an environment that promotes learning and encourages student engagement. Achieving these goals amid declining enrollment is difficult if universities are pressed to conform to the larger research university model. Instead, they should downsize and specialize, with a focus on teaching. The government should support those that do this successfully to mitigate that loss of tuition revenue from downsizing.
Together with targeted increases in funding, the government should reduce regulation and promote autonomy among universities. Outdated policies such as tuition freezes and limits on enrollment must go. The same holds true for regulations on hiring and promotion. Universities should be free to set their own priorities and hire and promote professors as they please.
South Korea needs a stronger higher education sector befitting of its international standing, but the proposed plan does little to advance those goals. It should be scrapped in favor of outcome-based funding increases combined with greater institutional autonomy.
Robert J. Fouser, a former associate professor of Korean language education at Seoul National University, writes on Korea from Providence, Rhode Island. He can be reached at robertjfouser@gmail.com. The views expressed here are the writer's own. -- Ed.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Lee to dispatch special envoys to Poland, Vietnam, Australia, Germany
Lee to dispatch special envoys to Poland, Vietnam, Australia, Germany

Korea Herald

time10 hours ago

  • Korea Herald

Lee to dispatch special envoys to Poland, Vietnam, Australia, Germany

President Lee Jae Myung will dispatch special envoys to Poland, Vietnam, Australia and Germany to deliver personal letters and discuss ways to expand bilateral cooperation, the presidential office said Friday. The envoys will depart consecutively starting Sunday and will meet with key officials in each country to convey Lee's message and explore opportunities to enhance friendly and cooperative ties, according to presidential spokesperson Kang Yu-jung. The delegation to Poland, comprised of Reps. Park Jie-won, Eeo Ki-kyu and Jin Sun-mee of the ruling Democratic Party, will leave on Sunday for a five-day visit. During their stay, they plan to meet with government and parliamentary officials to review the growing defense industry cooperation between the two nations and discuss ways to further develop their strategic partnership, Kang said. The Vietnam delegation will be led by former lawmaker Lee In-ki and include two additional DP lawmakers and will depart on Monday. The group will deliver Seoul's commitment to strengthening the comprehensive strategic partnership between the countries and will hold wide-ranging discussions on expanding practical cooperation particularly in infrastructure and energy. Former National Assembly Speaker Kim Jin-pyo will lead the Australian delegation, which is scheduled to leave on Monday for a four-day trip. The delegation will engage with Australian officials to discuss defense and defense industry ties, trade and supply chains and energy cooperation. The delegation to Germany will be headed by Lee Seog-yeon, a former minister of government legislation, and will depart on Wednesday. They plan to meet with German government officials to explore deeper cooperation in key sectors, such as manufacturing, digital transformation and artificial intelligence, as well as to exchange views on regional and global affairs. (Yonhap)

Lee visits Busan, pledges swift relocation of oceans ministry
Lee visits Busan, pledges swift relocation of oceans ministry

Korea Herald

time10 hours ago

  • Korea Herald

Lee visits Busan, pledges swift relocation of oceans ministry

President Lee Jae Myung visited Busan on Friday and pledged to swiftly relocate the oceans ministry to the southeastern port city. The relocation of the Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries from the central city of Sejong was one of Lee's campaign pledges. "I will swiftly execute the relocation of state organs, including the Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries, to Busan, as much as is possible," Lee said during a townhall meeting held at Pukyong University, adding he is not sure the ministry relocation will be possible before the end of the year. Lee said achieving balanced development across regions is a "national survival strategy" that cannot be avoided and requires consideration of each region's characteristics. "Climate change has increased the potential of Arctic shipping lanes and Busan is highly likely to benefit from that," he said. "If we do not prepare in advance, we will lose the opportunity." Lee called for discussing measures to develop Busan into a Northeast Asian hub city. (Yonhap)

Police forming team to prevent abuse against families of tragedy victims: report
Police forming team to prevent abuse against families of tragedy victims: report

Korea Herald

time2 days ago

  • Korea Herald

Police forming team to prevent abuse against families of tragedy victims: report

The South Korean police are forming a task force to prevent secondary victimization of people whose family members have died in disasters, in response to President Lee Jae Myung's directive. According to the Yonhap News Agency on Thursday, the National Police Agency has started recruitment of officers for the unit, tentatively named "investigative team against secondary victimization." The team will be headed by two superintendent-level officers — mid-level management position usually in charge of department at police stations. The National Office of Investigation will evaluate the applicants and, if none is deemed fit to carry out the role, will commandeer officers with sufficient experience in investigation and planning. Last Wednesday, Lee invited 200 family members of victims of tragedies with mass casualties, including the Jeju Air crash last year, an underground tunnel flooding in 2023, the deadly crowd crush in Itaewon, Seoul in 2022, and the sinking of ferry Sewol in 2014. He issued an official apology as the president, and pledged to form an investigative team to prevent secondary damage for bereaved families and survivors. The presidential office said last Thursday that Lee has ordered officials to compose a joint team of police and prosecutors to closely probe the Itaewon tragedy, while instructing a permanent team to prevent abuse of the victims' families.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store