Lack of accountability means artist supports are 'a slush fund'
Carol Nolan was commenting on the response by Arts Minister Patrick O'Donovan to queries about the initiative.
Mr Donovan said: 'The current pilot scheme costs approximately €35million per year, based on 2,000 recipients receiving €325 weekly. ' The lack of accountability when it comes to artists' basic income means the scheme has turned into a Government slush fund, a TD has claimed. Pic: Gareth Chaney/Collins Photos
The net cost is likely to be less, given the high number of BIA [Basic Income for the Arts] recipients who were previously on social welfare supports prior to the BIA.'
Mr O'Donovan also said 'evaluation of the pilot is continuous, as participants complete a survey every six months'.
He said: 'My department is currently preparing a report examining the first 24 months of the scheme. A further interview research paper, written by an independent researcher, was published recently. Carol Nolan was commenting on the response by Arts Minister Patrick O'Donovan to queries about the initiative. Pic: Collins
'This paper collects the experiences of 50 BIA recipients, who have been interviewed by a sociologist.' Ms Nolan called the response 'almost absurdly laughable'.
She said: 'It is clearly stated in the reply provided to me that the evaluation of the pilot is continuous because participants complete a survey every six months.'
The Independent TD asked: 'Does the department really think this is what robust evaluation looks like [and] does it believe that a slush fund that has cost €100million to date is going to be criticised by the very same people on the receiving end of that cash?'
Ms Nolan accused Fine Gael TD Mr O'Donovan of implementing outdated Green Party ideology, as it was imple – mented by former arts minister Catherine Martin, adding: 'The entire scheme just reeks of that particular form of cultural entitlement to vast sums of public monies that is particularly pervasive in the likes of RTÉ where control of publicly financed spending is way down the list of priorities.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
37 minutes ago
- Irish Examiner
Government urged to show restraint amid €2bn overspend
Ireland's fiscal watchdog has warned the Government to exercise restraint on spending, calling on the coalition to set limits to offset what it has called a "weak fiscal framework." Speaking at an Oireachtas committee about Budget 2026, chair of the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council (Ifac) Séamus Coffey told committee members that current spending overruns this year are likely to exceed €2bn. 'Recent budgets have pumped money into an economy that is already performing well,' Mr Coffey told the committee. 'After accounting for exceptional corporation tax and a strong economy, the government is running a substantial deficit. This is equivalent to more than €2,500 per worker.' The Government is currently preparing its summer economic statement, a key budgetary document that will indicate the parameters for spending increases in the October budget. Speaking on Budget 2026 which will take place in October, the council chair and University College Cork lecturer said spending growth should be no faster than the sustainable growth rate of the economy, given that it continues to perform well in the face of rising uncertainty and looming tariff measures. 'That is not to say the government can't try to improve public services, support households that are struggling or upgrade Ireland's infrastructure,' Mr Coffey told the committee. 'But it means that choices would need to be made. If the Government wants to spend more in a certain area, or tax less in another, it needs to offset that by doing less in other areas.' "We don't want to see this boom and bust cycle that has plagued Irish fiscal policy for the last 40 or 50 years," Mr Coffey told the Oireachtas Budgetary Oversight Committee. The council also identified three key challenges for the Government, with these being an ageing population, the need to manage Ireland's climate transition, and infrastructure, which Ifac said is 'about 25% behind [Ireland's] peers'. The budgetary watchdog issued four key recommendations to the Government, the first of which was the coalition's need to reduce the ups and downs of the economic cycle. 'This means showing restraint when the economy is strong and being more generous when the economy is struggling,' Mr Coffey told committee members. Second, the Government was urged to set spending limits, net of tax changes, that it believes are sustainable to reduce the vagaries of annual pressure as Budget Day approaches. Third, Ifac urged the Government to focus on competitiveness and infrastructure, adding: 'While there is uncertainty over many issues, the shortage of infrastructure will need to be addressed regardless of what the international environment looks like.' Lastly, the watchdog has urged the Government to improve how it forecasts spending, calling out what it called a failure to account for overspending in 2024 when planning for this year. 'This created unrealistic budget figures from the beginning - a problem that keeps recurring,' said Mr Coffey. 'To avoid repeating this mistake, Budget 2026 and future medium-term plans must start with accurate baseline figures that include all likely overspends in 2025. Otherwise, spending projections will be wrong from the outset.'
Irish Independent
an hour ago
- Irish Independent
Louth man Tommy Donegan ran for Fine Gael in 1982 election
Tommy who was in his mid-sixties ran for the party in the November,1982 General Election in a bid to replace his famous father but just narrowly missed out. Paddy or PS as was known served as a TD in Louth from 1961 to 1981. He died at 77 year of age in 2000. He also served as Minister for Fisheries. Tommy never took the same interest in politics as his dad and pulled back from Fine Gael after failing to get elected. He instead concentrated on running the family farm in Monasterboice which he did so successfully while his late parents and his sister Roseanne ran the family business, the hugely popular Donegan's Restaurant which is still flourishing today. Tommy was a huge sports fan and followed the Irish soccer team all over the world and had lifelong memories from Italia 90 and the World Cup in the USA, four years later. A large crowd attended his funeral mass at his local church in Tinure last Tuesday week, June 24. Tommy is predeceased by his sister Annette and survived by sister Roseanne, his brother Vincent and children Leanne, Luke,Sam Tara and his beloved grand daughter Lily.
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Former Louth politician John McGahon appointed as CEO of Dundalk Chamber of Commerce
He is the Chamber's first CEO since Bill Tosh, and in announcing his appointment, the Chamber said his 'extensive experience in public service has equipped him with strong policy expertise and combined with his skills in strategic planning and public engagement, demonstrate his ability to represent and advocate for local business and community interests effectively." The former Fine Gael politician exited politics last November when he failed to win a Dail seat in the 2024 General Election amid controversary over his involvement in a pub assault. He had been found not guilty in 2022 by a Circuit Court jury of the assault of Breen White outside a pub in Dundalk in 2018. However, Mr White was awarded €39,000 by the High Court in a subsequent civil case. The Taoiseach Simon Harris had failed to back him and had commented that there were two Fine Gael candidates running in Louth. Mr McGahon subsequently announced that he would not be seeking re-election to the Seanad, saying: 'After a decade of holding elected office, I am looking forward to taking a step back from public life and spending more time with my wife Áine, family and friends.' He had followed in the footsteps of his father Johnny McGahon and his late uncle Brendan McGahon when he was elected as a Fine Gael councillor in 2014. He was re-elected to Louth County Council in 2019 and served as chairperson of Dundalk Municipal District for two terms. Having unsuccessfully contested the 2020 General Election he was appointed to the Seanad and served as the Fine Gael Seanad spokesperson on Environment, Climate and Communications, and on the joint Oireachtas committee on climate action, and the committee on the implementation of the Good Friday Agreement. Mr McGahon said he was delighted to be taking up this new role. "Dundalk has a proud business tradition, rooted in innovation, community spirit, and cross-border cooperation. I look forward to building on that legacy; supporting our local enterprises, attracting new investment, and strengthening the voice of business across the region,' "'It is a great opportunity to work alongside Hanna McDonnell, President of Dundalk Chamber, and the wider Chamber team to build on their success. Together, we can drive sustainable growth and ensure Dundalk continues to thrive as a dynamic hub for business,' he continues. Hanna McDonnell, President of Dundalk Chamber of Commerce said that his 'experience and strategic vision will be invaluable in advancing the Chamber's mission and positioning Dundalk as a hub for business excellence."
