Couple finally win battle over neighbours' huge untrimmed hedge that left them suffering 'five years without sunshine'
Keith Smith, 71, and his wife Julie, 68, told MailOnline that the matter has been a 'thorn in their side' that has taken a massive toll on their mental health.
The couple have lived in their detached house, in the Prestonfield area of Edinburgh, for more than four decades.
However, they say things changed after their neighbours moved in and planted cypress trees that grew several metres high.
Mr Smith said the trees created a 'green wall' that went all the way along a fence dividing their gardens, preventing sunlight from getting into both the Smiths's garden and through the windows of their home - in what he brands a 'huge intrusion' and not suitable for adjoining gardens.
This prompted an official row with the owners of the cypress trees, David Hunter and Niena Hunter Mistry, that has rumbled on for five years and seen the gardens inspected several times by various officials.
Police have also attended over disputes between the neighbours.
Edinburgh City Council initially knocked back the Smiths's bid to have the trees chopped down, but the couple later successfully appealed to the Scottish Government, which said the cypresses had to be cut down to 8.5 feet.
The Hunters asked for one tree to be kept as it is, but that has also been ordered to be cut back to 8.5ft - and the Smiths say they are looking forward to this happening later this year.
According to Edinburgh City Council's website, a hedge must be over 6.6ft from ground level before being considered a 'high hedge' potentially having a negative effect on people living nearby.
Mr Smith, previously an employee of the local authority for 38 years, has now said that while the couple are hopeful the matter is dealt with, it has been 'a thorn in their side' and has caused them considerable stress and inconvenience, with many 'false dawns' along the way.
In a document to the government, the couple previously said: 'The cost to the public purse must be considerable in terms of government, council and police resources.
'We, the Smiths, have suffered hugely financially, emotionally and physically by this process and sincerely hope, this will now lead to resolution.'
The Hunters were unavailable for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
2 minutes ago
- BBC News
Brockenhurst residents complain as donkeys trash new wheelie bins
Livestock breaking into newly-introduced wheelie bins in the New Forest could help spread serious animal diseases, residents and animal owners have Forest District Council recently began a roll-out of wheelie bins and food waste caddies as part of efforts to improve recycling but free-roaming ponies and donkeys have been seen breaking into them and scattering Parry-Norton, chairman of the Commoners Defence Association (CDA), said there was a "real risk" of diseases such as African swine fever and foot and mouth spreading from contaminated food council said it was monitoring the situation and urged residents to report any incidents involving animals. Wheelie bins and caddies are replacing single-use black and clear plastic bags for New Forest residents' domestic and food waste, plus June, the council said it was aware of cases of donkeys in the national park "interacting with waste containers".Caroline Emery filmed a group of donkeys on Horlock Road in the village as well as waste scattered on Fathersfield Road on Friday."When is common sense going to prevail that those living on the side of the cattle grids where animals roam, should be able to keep their bins inside their gates, to prevent this happening and ultimately the death of livestock," she said. Other images posted on social media, showed food recycling bags within donkey droppings, having apparently passed through an animal's digestive village's Green Party ward councillor, Adam Parker, said: "It's happening all over the village – donkeys are intelligent, opportunistic foragers. "I'm really very concerns about health implications for New Forest wildlife." The national park's free-roaming ponies, pigs, donkeys and cattle are owned by commoners - people who own or occupy land with ancient rights Parry-Norton said the issue "would only worsen" when pigs are turned out into the forest in autumn."It is illegal to feed food waste to pigs," he said. "Donkeys are bad but if pigs get into these bins, there is a high risk of diseases like African swine fever or foot and mouth could potentially cost millions."The 2001 foot and mouth outbreak is thought to have originated from pigs being fed catering waste containing the virus. The CDA chairman called for the roll-out of wheelie bins and caddies to be suspended."They need to acknowledge the problem and sort out the problems. The bins are extremely flimsy and not stock-proof," he added,In a statement, the council said: "On a daily basis, we are monitoring the situation, particularly in key areas where we know there may be free-roaming livestock."We recognise that some areas face unique challenges."We remain committed to working with our community to ensure the service works well for everyone, and to deliver a more efficient and environmentally friendly way of managing waste and recycling for the long term."It said bins should be kept on properties until due for collection and food waste caddies should be left out with the handle pushed forward and down to keep the lid tightly move to wheelie bins was given the go-ahead in 2022, with the council insisting they were needed to increase recycling rates, while opponents argued they were unsightly and costly. You can follow BBC Hampshire & Isle of Wight on Facebook, X, or Instagram.
BBC News
2 minutes ago
- BBC News
New nursery recommended for Coventry school despite objections
Plans for a new nursery next to a Coventry school are being recommended for approval, despite more than 30 nursery, which would provide 15 places, is planned for a former caretaker's house next to Stoke Primary School in Briton Road, Barras school's application, which will be decided at a city council planning meeting on Thursday, said the conversion would be funded by a £65,000 government grant to increase nursery centre around parking on nearby streets, and other effects on residents caused by the proposed opening hours of 07:00 to 17:00. The school said the house had been unoccupied for more than three years, and had only been used for occasional meetings since.A report to members of the planning committee said the scheme had been referred to them because of the objections, gathered on a petition by a local planning officers assessed that the conversion would not have a "significant impact upon neighbour amenity or highway safety".They have recommended that it be approved. Follow BBC Coventry & Warwickshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
BBC News
2 minutes ago
- BBC News
Saltburn residents frustrated at summer hut refurbishment
Residents are angry at the "terrible timing" of a long-overdue refurbishment of the only shelter on a popular stretch of Victorian replica shelter is a community focal point on the lower promenade at Philip Thomson said it was a "disgrace" the local authority had not taken time to understand the impact on the local community of shutting the shelter in summer.A spokesperson for Redcar and Cleveland Borough Council said the work should be completed over "the next couple of weeks." Thomson said he has raised the issue of unsafe seating in the structure multiple times over the last two said: "On two occasions previously there have been cordons around the area but no work was carried out and the shelter was re-opened."I have asked for a detailed work schedule and a plan for start and finish, but I have been given none of that."Helen Khan, who lives in the town, said: "The shelter is the only one on the lower promenade at Saltburn."It is terrible timing on the council's part and it needs to be repaired as soon as possible as it is such a well used shelter."A council spokesperson said: "The materials are on order and we have an expected timescale for completion over the next couple of weeks. "We appreciate that some residents and visitors may be affected while the work is taking place, however other similar facilities are available on the lower prom." Follow BBC Tees on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
