Ottawa weighs plans on AI, copyright as OpenAI fights Ontario court jurisdiction
Canada's artificial intelligence minister is keeping a close watch on court cases in Canada and the U.S. to determine next steps for Ottawa's regulatory approach to AI.
Some AI companies have claimed early wins south of the border, and OpenAI is now fighting the jurisdiction of an Ontario court to hear a lawsuit by news publishers.
Evan Solomon's office said in a statement he plans to address copyright "within Canada's broader AI regulatory approach, with a focus on protecting cultural sovereignty and how [creators] factor into this conversation."
But there are no current plans for a standalone copyright bill, as Solomon's office is "closely monitoring the ongoing court cases and market developments" to help chart the path forward.
It's unclear how long it will take for those court cases to determine whether artificial intelligence companies can use copyrighted content to train their AI products.
:
Canadian news organizations, including CBC, sue ChatGPT creator
8 months ago
CBC/Radio-Canada, Postmedia, Metroland, the Toronto Star, the Globe and Mail, and The Canadian Press have launched a joint lawsuit against ChatGPT creator OpenAI, for using news content to train its ChatGPT generative artificial intelligence system. The news organizations say OpenAI breaches copyright by 'scraping content' from their websites.
The sole Canadian case to pose the question was launched late last year by a coalition of news publishers and the Ontario Superior Court is set to hear a jurisdictional challenge in September.
The coalition — which includes The Canadian Press, Torstar, the Globe and Mail, Postmedia and CBC/Radio-Canada — is suing OpenAI for using news content to train its generative artificial intelligence system.
The news publishers argue OpenAI is breaching copyright by scraping large amounts of content from Canadian media, and then profiting from the use of that content without permission or compensation.
They said in court filings that OpenAI has "engaged in ongoing, deliberate and unauthorized misappropriation of [their] valuable news media works."
"Rather than seek to obtain the information legally, OpenAI has elected to brazenly misappropriate the News Media Companies' valuable intellectual property and convert it for its own uses, including commercial uses, without consent or consideration."
OpenAI challenging jurisdiction
OpenAI has denied the allegations, and previously said its models are trained on publicly available data, and "grounded in fair use and related international copyright principles."
The company, which is headquartered in San Francisco, is challenging the jurisdiction of the Ontario court to hear the case.
It argued in a court filing that it's not located in Ontario and does not do business in the province.
WATCH | U.S. media companies sue OpenAI in late 2023:
New York Times sues OpenAI, Microsoft for copyright infringement
2 years ago
OpenAI also argued the Copyright Act doesn't apply outside of Canada.
OpenAI is asking the court to seal some documents in the case. The court is scheduled to hold a hearing on the sealing motion on July 30, according to a schedule outlined in court documents.
It asked the court to seal documents containing "commercially sensitive" information, including about its corporate organization and structure, its web crawling and fetching processes and systems, and its "model training and inference processes, systems, resource allocations and/or cost structures."
"The artificial intelligence industry is highly competitive and developing at a rapid pace," says an affidavit submitted by the company. "Competitors in this industry are many and range from large, established technology companies such as Google and Amazon, to smaller startups seeking to establish a foothold in the industry.
"As recognized leaders in the artificial intelligence industry, competitors and potential competitors to the defendants would benefit from having access to confidential information of the defendants."
A lawyer for the news publishers provided information on the court deadlines, but did not provide comment on the case.
Numerous lawsuits dealing with AI systems and copyright are underway in the United States, some dating back to 2023. In late June, AI companies won victories in two of those cases.
In a case launched by a group of authors, including comedian Sarah Silverman, a judge ruled AI systems' use of published work was fair use and the authors didn't demonstrate that use would result in market dilution.
But the judge also said his ruling affects only those specific authors — whose lawyers didn't make the right arguments — and does not mean Meta's use of copyrighted material to train its systems was legal. Judge Vince Chhabria noted in his summary judgment that in "the grand scheme of things, the consequences of this ruling are limited."
In a separate U.S. case, a judge ruled the use by AI company Anthropic of published books without permission to train its systems was fair use. But Judge William Alsup also ruled Anthropic "had no entitlement to use pirated copies."
Jane Ginsburg, a professor at Columbia University's law school who studies intellectual property and technology, said it would be too simplistic to just look at the cases as complete wins for the AI companies.
"I think both the question of how much weight to give the pirate nature of the sources, and the question of market dilution, are going to be big issues in other cases."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Sun
17 minutes ago
- Toronto Sun
CBC hands out record-breaking raises to offset loss of executive bonuses
Canada's national broadcaster paid $37.7 million in salary raises in 2024-25 to 6,295 employees — significantly more than previous years The CBC building at Front and John Street in Toronto, Sept. 6, 2011. Photo by Alex Urosevic / Toronto Sun file photo OTTAWA — Just months after Canada's national broadcaster announced the end of big-money bonuses to its senior execs, newly-obtained documents suggest the CBC handed out a record-setting amount of raises during the previous fiscal year. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Unlimited online access to articles from across Canada with one account. Get exclusive access to the Toronto Sun ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition that you can share, download and comment on. Enjoy insights and behind-the-scenes analysis from our award-winning journalists. Support local journalists and the next generation of journalists. Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Don't have an account? Create Account In access-to-information documents obtained by the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, the CBC handed out no bonuses in 2024-25, but awarded $37.7 million in wage hikes to 6,295 employees. That's an average of $6,000 per employee. CTF Federal Director Franco Terrazzano described it as 'sleight of hand' by the CBC. 'The CBC isn't saving people money if it's replacing taxpayer-funded bonuses with higher taxpayer-funded pay raises,' he said, noting the raises more than offset the cost of the eliminated bonuses. 'CBC misunderstood the assignment and learned nothing from the outrage it received across the political spectrum.' The documents also noted that no employee saw a pay cut in the last fiscal year. In 2023-24, previously-released documents state the national broadcaster handed out about $11.5 million in raises to 6,575 employees. Your noon-hour look at what's happening in Toronto and beyond. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. Please try again This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. In a May 2025 post, the CBC announced that after an independent review of how they compensate non-union employees and senior executives, the Crown corporation opted to discontinue their bonus program, which the broadcaster called 'individual performance pay,' to keep compensation within established norms. Recommended video 'Total compensation for CBC/Radio-Canada employees is in the middle (50th percentile) of compensation for employees in our peer group of media, private and public organizations,' the note read. 'In order to keep overall compensation at the current median level, salaries of those affected will be adjusted to reflect the elimination of individual performance pay.' CBC spokesperson Leon Mar disputed the CTF's interpretation of the release. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. 'To say that these adjustments 'more than offset the loss of performance pay' is incorrect, and to characterize these changes, which were made public on May 14, as a 'sleight of hand' is bizarre,' he said, reiterating that the raises were given to keep overall compensation at median levels to reflect the elimination of performance pay. In a statement previously sent to the CTF and provided to The Toronto Sun, the CBC said that because they hire people with competitive market skills, salary ranges 'reflect the need to attract and retain' skilled workers. 'If Prime Minister Mark Carney is serious about saving money, he needs to step in and put an end to the CBC gravy train,' Terrazzano said. 'Or better yet, Carney should defund the CBC.' bpassifiume@ X: @bryanpassifiume Read More Other Sports World Toronto & GTA Toronto Blue Jays Relationships
CTV News
17 minutes ago
- CTV News
Here's how Canada's LNG exports could make your heating bill go up
The LNG Canada industrial energy project is seen under construction in Kitimat, B.C., on Wednesday, Sept. 28, 2022. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Darryl Dyck Flames as high as a 30-storey building, ships nearly as long as the Eiffel Tower is tall, $40 billion dollars. Everything about LNG Canada is big — including its promises. Often referred to as the largest private investment in Canadian history, the megaproject connects B.C. shale gas reserves near the Alberta border to marine shipping routes on the northwest coast. More than a decade after the project was first approved, Canada's liquefied natural gas (LNG) sector is finally up and running: LNG Canada sent its first shipment to Asia on June 30. As exports start flowing overseas from the Kitimat, B.C., facility, two more liquefaction plants are under construction — Woodfibre LNG and Cedar LNG. Another, Ksi Lisims LNG, could be approved any day. The promise around all this industrial buildout has always been prosperity, but whether the industry can deliver, and for how long, is up for debate. 'An oversupply of LNG is widely expected, potentially starting as early as next year, with a massive wave of new projects coming online around the world, especially in the U.S. and Qatar,' Steven Haig, a policy advisor with the International Institute for Sustainable Development, told The Narwhal. 'When it comes to the economic benefits of LNG, Canada is really late to the party — and that party is almost over.' Haig and his colleagues recently penned a deep dive into the risks of locking in more LNG infrastructure, reporting that Canadian exports are unlikely to achieve 'energy security for importers or economic resilience for exporters.' 'What we explain in our analysis is that we are very likely moving into a period of oversupply with lower prices — and those lower prices may well be below what projects need to break even,' Haig told The Narwhal. 'If they run at a loss for too long, then they can become stranded assets, with economic implications for the people who work for these facilities or for communities that might become economically associated with them.' 'Higher domestic prices for Canadian consumers' are a possibility As Canadian LNG — the liquid form of natural gas, which is mostly composed of methane and in B.C. is extracted primarily through fracking — starts making its way into international markets, British Columbians and Albertans could also see a spike in their heating bills, according to Deloitte Canada. As the Financial Post recently reported, domestic natural gas prices could jump up by 60 per cent this year, and climb even higher next year. Haig said if the price a company can get from exporting LNG is higher than it can get selling natural gas domestically, prices in places like B.C. and Alberta will go up. This happened in Australia, where domestic prices tripled as Russia's 2022 invasion of Ukraine sent shockwaves through the supply chain. 'LNG links regional gas markets together in the global LNG market,' Haig explained. 'So a local supply disruption in one place can lead to skyrocketing LNG prices elsewhere.' 'When those high prices are in effect, then it can become more profitable for a gas producer in Canada, for example, to export that gas to the international LNG market than to use that gas in Canada's domestic gas market.' That, he said, can lead to higher domestic prices for Canadian consumers. LNG Canada is now operating its first phase, which will produce up to 14 million tonnes of supercooled gas per year. It's already approved and permitted to double production. Teresa Waddington, LNG Canada's vice-president of corporate relations, told The Narwhal earlier this month that talks are underway about whether or not to go ahead with the expansion. She said a final decision depends on a number of factors including 'overall competitiveness [and] affordability.' LNG Canada did not respond to new questions from The Narwhal by publication time. When the international consortium of oil and gas companies behind LNG Canada (Shell, Petronas, Korea Gas, PetroChina and Mitsubishi) first started courting Canada to develop an LNG export industry in B.C. in the early 2010s, they said it would boost the economy locally, provincially and federally. With recent trade threats from the U.S. government, that narrative is gaining traction again and politicians like B.C. Premier David Eby and Prime Minister Mark Carney are celebrating the sector as an economic saviour. Haig cautioned the narrative should be taken with a grain of salt. 'We're seeing this big push towards LNG expansion to diversify Canada's exports beyond the United States, but these are multi-billion dollar and multi-decade projects,' he explained. 'Their long-term viability is a serious concern as global markets shift towards cleaner and more reliable energy sources, like renewables. Investing in LNG as a supposed transition fuel in the meantime would be a long, costly detour.' 'It's not too late': Canada can reduce economic and climate risks by putting the brakes on LNG exports, expert says Alongside promises of prosperity, LNG Canada and other proponents of the sector maintain the gas is a so-called 'bridge' or transition fuel — a climate solution. The argument goes like this: burning gas to generate power is less harmful than burning coal, and B.C. exports will help countries like China substantially reduce their reliance on the 'dirtier' fossil fuel. The first part is the subject of much debate, especially when the entire lifecycle of LNG is taken into consideration. The second — that Canadian LNG will displace coal — Haig said simply isn't true. 'Coal is cheap, renewables are cheap and LNG is not,' he said. 'If we look at China's power sector, for example, it's renewables — not LNG imports — that are eating into coal's market share. This is mostly because renewables are cheaper than LNG and because LNG requires expensive new infrastructure, such as re-gasification plants and pipelines, to connect consumers with supply.' China, while still responsible for about one third of the world's greenhouse gas emissions, is outpacing the rest of the world by leaps and bounds in building renewables. In May this year, the country added the equivalent of 100 solar panels per second. As the Guardian reported in June, 'China's installed solar photovoltaic capacity has now surpassed 1,000 gigawatts for the first time, equivalent to half of the world's total installed solar capacity.' Haig said Canada is at a crossroads as it decides whether or not to approve more LNG projects, but added, 'it's not too late.' 'LNG exports can delay investments in renewables and generally increase global fossil fuel use, increasing global greenhouse gas emissions,' he said. 'Doubling down on LNG projects would likely expose Canadians to more risk and volatility, not less.' By Matt Simmons, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter, The Narwhal
Globe and Mail
17 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
LSET Successfully Organised the LSET Exchange Series Exploring Innovation, Strategy and Emerging Tech
"LSET Exchange session with students and an industry expert discussing innovation, strategy and emerging technology." LSET organised the LSET Exchange Series, featuring weekly discussions on innovation, strategy and technology. Students actively contributed insights on topics like AI and cybersecurity. While industry experts were invited to participate, the first session featured student-led discussion. The series has concluded, with future sessions to be announced. London, UK - 21 July, 2025 - The London School of Emerging Technology (LSET) successfully organised the LSET Exchange Series, a weekly programme of interactive sessions focused on key developments in innovation, business strategy and emerging technologies. The series brought together students, alumni and guest speakers for open discussions aimed at bridging academic learning with practical industry understanding. The sessions were delivered online, with selected events held in a hybrid format to enable wider participation. Each session promoted active dialogue, live Q&A, and collaborative knowledge-sharing on current and emerging themes in the tech and business landscape. Topics Covered Each week focused on a different theme. Sessions explored: Artificial Intelligence in Business and Technology Cybersecurity and Risk Strategy Solution Architecture and Systems Design Digital Strategy and Transformation Leadership and Innovation Culture Meet the Panel All sessions were moderated by Mayur Ramgir and featured contributions from LSET students specialising in Cybersecurity, Machine Learning, Automation Testing and Enterprise Development. While industry experts were invited to participate, they were not present during the initial session. Their involvement is anticipated in future sessions. Participants The first session welcomed: LSET Students and Alumni - participating in discussions and gaining exposure to emerging trends Guest Speakers - where applicable, contributing context to weekly themes Industry Experts - invited to join future sessions for enhanced professional insights Format and Engagement LSET Exchange sessions were designed as collaborative forums, distinct from traditional lectures. Each included a Q&A segment and encouraged open contribution from attendees. Topics were announced via the student portal and mailing list in advance. Recordings were provided to enrolled students for review. Outcomes The LSET Exchange Series offered: Opportunities to explore how emerging technologies are shaping modern industries Insight into strategy, innovation and transformation A platform for students to apply learning through discussion and peer engagement Future session schedules and similar initiatives will be shared through LSET's official channels. For collaboration or speaker enquiries, contact events@ View session details and event archive: Video Link: Media Contact Company Name: London School of Emerging Technology Contact Person: Jim Cohn Email: Send Email Phone: 02033699909 Address: 1 Cornhill City: London Country: United Kingdom Website:
