
ERA findings on Lyttelton Port Company restructure plan released
The Employment Relations Authority has found Lyttelton Port Company breached its obligations to the unions and workers through a proposed restructure of its container terminal operations.
The ERA has ordered LPC to halt its direct consultation process with the affected workers.
Lyttelton Port.
It must instead engage in structured consultation with the Maritime Union of New Zealand (MUNZ) and the Rail and Maritime Transport Union (RMTU) on the proposal within 20 working days.
The ERA ruled LPC's approach to developing its proposal to disestablish 35 positions, without involving unions, breached the requirements of the collective agreements and the wider duty of good faith under the Employment Relations Act.
MUNZ national secretary Carl Findlay said the determination is a significant win for port workers and clearly reinforces the importance of good faith and collective bargaining.
"This finding sends a strong message to employers that they cannot simply present a fully formed proposal for major change without genuinely engaging with the Unions who represent the affected workers,' said Findlay.
He said the collective agreements require a cooperative and collaborative approach, especially when jobs are on the line.
RMTU general secretary Todd Valster said the ERA's order for LPC to return to the table for structured consultation with the unions was a positive outcome for port workers.
"This is a good result for workers because it ensures their collective voice is heard at a meaningful stage of the process," said Valster.
"It means we can properly engage on the rationale, the details of the proposal, and explore alternatives that protect our members' jobs and conditions.
"Restructuring should not be presented from on high. It requires genuine engagement to find the best way forward for both the business and the people who make it run.
"This ERA determination reinforces that principle."
MUNZ and RMTU looked forward to engaging with LPC as directed by the ERA to ensure a fair process for all affected workers.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NZ Herald
5 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Housing market recovery delayed despite rising sales volumes
Cotality (formerly known as CoreLogic and one of the foremost authorities on the housing market) recently noted that volumes have been gradually rising for about two years. It points out that the rise in May activity pushed sales levels to 5% above anything we've seen at that point in the year since 2016. On that basis, the slump looks to be behind us, but we haven't seen a recovery on the pricing front. The REINZ house price index (HPI) has fallen for six out of the past seven months. Nationwide prices are unchanged over the past 12 months and still 16.3% below the peak in late 2021. That's not the case everywhere, of course. The South Island has performed much more strongly, with Canterbury, Otago and Southland more buoyant and all within 5% of the peak. The impact of a solid agricultural sector is likely to be part of the reason for that. In contrast, Auckland and Wellington have struggled and are still more than 20% below the heady levels of a few years ago. The median number of days to sell is also elevated, reflecting a sluggish market in which properties sit unsold for longer. It rose to 50 days in June, and has averaged 47 in the past 12 months. That's the highest since mid-2023, when interest rates were rising quickly and the economy was in recession. Excluding that period, it's the highest since 2008 and 2009, during the Global Financial Crisis. There are numerous reasons to explain our underperforming housing market. For a start, affordability is still awful. Prices have been flat for two years, having fallen almost 20% from the peak before that. However, the rise during 2020 and 2021 was so dramatic (48% in less than two years) that, even after the multi-year slump, prices are still more than 20% above pre-Covid levels. That boom was primarily driven by ultra-low borrowing costs, with the one-year mortgage rate falling to 2.2%. In data going back to the early 1960s, there's never been a time when interest rates have come close to being that low, and we might not see them again in our lifetime. Many would argue that prices were pumped up so much during that period that they might need to fall further (or at least languish for a little longer) for reality to catch up. Other costs of home ownership – such as rates, insurance and maintenance – have also increased sharply, while the policy backdrop hasn't been friendly to investors. Net migration has declined much more than expected, after hitting record highs in 2023. To use a technical phrase, it's fallen off a cliff. New migrant numbers (of working age) were comfortably above 100,000 a year 18 months ago, but they've dropped to fewer than 10,000 today. Apart from the Covid-era when the borders were closed, that's the lowest since the 2010-13 period, and before that 2000-01. For many of those who are still here, job security is a concern. The unemployment rate has been steadily increasing for three years, and it's sitting at 5.1%. Apart from one quarter during the unusual Covid period, that's the highest in more than eight years. People are reluctant to make major financial commitments when they don't feel completely safe in their jobs. Unemployment is expected to push a little higher, so a shift in sentiment could be unlikely until late this year or into next year. Nobody can accurately say where house prices will go from here. Plenty of people incorrectly predicted declines in early 2020, and just as many expected a recovery to be under way by now. Reserve Bank forecasts suggest prices will grow by 4.2% annually over the coming three years. That's below the long-term average (which has been 5.7% since 1990) but it's slightly above inflation, GDP and population growth expectations. All these headwinds, as well as a high number of listings, have swung the power balance in favour of buyers, including those looking for a first home. That's unlikely to change in the near term, which is good news in many ways. I'm not sure if any of us should be hoping for another boom. A stable-but-sluggish period for house prices could be a more desirable outcome for the economy, and society overall. For the first time in a long while, the housing market is working more for buyers than sellers, and that rebalancing might be exactly what we need. Mark Lister is investment director at Craigs Investment Partners. The information in this article is provided for information only, is intended to be general in nature, and does not take into account your financial situation, objectives, goals, or risk tolerance. Before making any investment decision, Craigs Investment Partners recommends you contact an investment adviser.

RNZ News
18 hours ago
- RNZ News
Calendar Girls strip clubs forced to take down posts about women involved in employment dispute
By Ric Stevens, Open Justice reporter of The owners of the Calendar Girls strip clubs have been forced to take down posts identifying dancers suing the firm. Seven women are currently pursuing an application in the Employment Court for a declaration of their employment status. A non-publication order was issued in May, suppressing their identities, after they raised concerns about their safety and damage to their reputations, due to the stigma attached to the work they had been doing. One of the women has now returned to court, alleging breaches of the order by Calendar Girls NZ Ltd, the company named as the defendant in their case. Chief Employment Court Judge Christina Inglis hastily scheduled a hearing this week to hear the woman. "I accorded urgency to the application, given the nature of the alleged breaches and the concerns that had underpinned the making of the orders of non-publication in the first place," the judge said in a recent judgement. The urgent hearing was set down for Thursday, but was cancelled, after lawyers for both sides agreed non-publication orders should be respected. "The defendants confirm that they have removed all offending posts," Judge Inglis said. However, her judgement did not detail what was in the posts. The seven women are seeking a declaration that they were employees of Calendar Girls NZ Ltd under the Employment Relations Act 2000. Being an employee, rather than a contractor, gives entitlement to a wider range of legal protections, including minimum conditions, protection from discrimination, health and safety, and the ability to bargain collectively. In 2023, dancers from the Wellington Calendar Girls club attempted to bargain collectively, after being offered a contract that they said was "manipulative". Nineteen were told to clear out their lockers and not come back to work through a Facebook post, after asking for changes to the way they were paid. In seeking non-publication orders in the current case, filed in the Wellington Employment Court, the seven women raised several concerns about having their identities made public. Women in the clubs use a professional name while working there and are instructed not to give their real names to customers. Chief Employment Court Judge Christina Inglis. Photo: NZ Herald / George Heard However, their case in the Employment Court has been taken using their real names. The women involved in the case feared publication of their identities would "severely impact" their employment and housing prospects, and their ability to travel. They said the stigma attached to their work at Calendar Girls had already led to judgements about their morality and respectability. The women are all young, and fear damage to their reputations and the impact on their families. They also said they had safety concerns about former clients and members of the public. One of the women is a member of a church and worries about others in the congregation finding out. Others have had tenancy applications declined and another woman said she was dismissed from a government agency, when it became known she had worked in the sex industry. Judge Inglis has now ordered Calendar Girls not to disclose the names, identifying particulars or photographs of the seven women who have taken the case. She said this applied to "all forms of communication, including oral, written, electronic and any other medium". The substantive case has been scheduled for a five-day fixture in February 2026. Calendar Girls NZ Ltd is a Christchurch-based company that operates clubs in Christchurch, Auckland, Wellington and Queenstown. This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald .


NZ Herald
5 days ago
- NZ Herald
Far North council staff ‘thrown under the bus' with restructure, union says
PSA Te Tai Tokerau organiser Athol Ringrose said workers were made to feel the change was because of their underperformance, lack of technical capacity and an increase in complaints. But when the union asked for data about this alleged underperformance, the council pointed to a 2023 review of the NTA. Ringrose said the information not only did not answer the question, it was provided after the council's consultation period. Ringrose says this was in breach of the Employment Relations Act - Far North District Council chief executive Guy Holroyd says the council has adhered to all requirements of the act. Despite the union's protests, the council continued, giving a date of August 4 for implementation. The workers have been left feeling angry, he said. 'They're really upset at being thrown under the bus. They're being painted as ineffective and unmanageable.' Some of the workers at Far North District Council's roading department have been working in the district for 20 years. Photo / NZME A council worker and union representative, who asked not to be named, believes the council has no data to show the in-house team has been underperforming. The workers have not only responded to complaints, they have planned out work for the next two years of the council's roading-focused Long Term Plan, she said. Another worry was the council's initial proposal named an incumbent service supplier as the 'winner' of the new professional services contract, the representative said. After concerns were raised by both the union and NZ Transport Agency, the council moved to an open procurement process. However, workers were told there would not be any opportunities for them to work with the external provider, she said. The union representative likened the restructure to the Hunger Games and said workers were left feeling 'absolutely gutted'. 'They're extremely disappointed and angry.' The job losses will result in a loss of expertise, with some working with the council and NTA for 20 years, she said. Far North District Council chief executive Guy Holroyd says the Employment Relations Act requirements were followed with the moves to outsource the roading department. Ringrose said the PSA's lawyers are considering legal action. Change driven by operational needs and market, council says FNDC chief executive Guy Holroyd said outsourcing the roading department was needed to improve efficiency and gain expertise not available in-house. 'The change is part of efforts to streamline operations, improve efficiency and provide better roading services to the community. 'Outsourcing certain functions will allow us to leverage specialised expertise and resources not currently available in-house.' Holroyd said communities and ratepayers can expect to benefit from improved service quality and cost-effectiveness. 'By outsourcing to specialised providers, we will achieve enhanced efficiencies and innovative solutions that better meet the needs of the Far North.' The council has followed a comprehensive process, including stakeholder consultations and risk assessments, and adhered to all requirements of the Employment Relations Act, Holroyd said. 'The council recognises the impact this transition will have on staff and is committed to supporting affected employees through this period.' The timing of the change was driven by operational needs and market conditions, he said. 'While it has only been a year since NTA was disestablished, the council identified an opportunity to enhance service delivery and achieve cost efficiencies in what is our single biggest budget line.' Holroyd said the council has been working with NZTA to ensure a fair and transparent procurement process is in place for the new professional services contract. Denise Piper is a news reporter for the Northern Advocate, focusing on health and business. She has more than 20 years in journalism and is passionate about covering stories that make a difference.