Is ChatGPT Dumbing Us Down? MIT Study Says Yes

Business Insider

6 days ago

Artificial intelligence might be getting smarter, but your brain might be doing the opposite. A new MIT study just dropped a bombshell: heavy reliance on ChatGPT can shrink cognitive effort, suppress brain activity, and kill memory retention. In plain terms, your brain could be coasting on autopilot while the AI does the heavy lifting. And that's not as smart as it sounds.
Confident Investing Starts Here:
Scientists Track Brainpower and Watch It Fade
MIT researchers strapped EEG headsets onto 54 volunteers and tracked their brain activity while writing SAT-style essays. One group used ChatGPT, another used Google (GOOGL) Search, and the last went old school, relying on pure brainpower. The results were crystal clear. The ChatGPT users showed the weakest engagement. Their brains were quieter, less focused, and less activated in areas tied to memory, logic, and executive control.
Even more revealing, the group relying solely on their own thinking outperformed others not just in neural engagement but also in writing quality and depth. They were thinking, processing, and retaining far more than the AI-assisted crowd.
ChatGPT Users Took a Backseat, and It Showed
What started as helpful guidance from ChatGPT quickly turned into full-on outsourcing. By the third writing session, users were simply typing the essay prompt into the chatbot, copying the answer, and pasting it into their work. No edits, no effort, no thought. Teachers described the work as polished but empty, technically correct but intellectually disengaged.
This isn't just about laziness. It's about what happens when convenience starts replacing cognition. You stop challenging your memory, you stop pushing for clarity, and you stop engaging with the ideas you're writing about. That's a recipe for mental decline.
Google Keeps the Brain Fired Up
The group that used Google fared far better. Unlike ChatGPT, Google didn't hand them neatly packaged answers. It forced them to sift through sources, analyze content, and stitch together their own arguments. That friction kept their brains active. Their EEG readings stayed higher, their essays were more coherent, and they actually remembered what they had written.
This matters because it shows that tech isn't the enemy, but how you use it is. Google helped support critical thinking, while ChatGPT replaced it.
Once You Go Full AI, Bouncing Back Is Tough
Even more concerning, the study found that switching away from ChatGPT didn't reverse the damage right away. People who started with AI and then went solo didn't show a quick recovery in brain engagement. Meanwhile, those who used their own brains first, then later tried ChatGPT, stayed sharper overall. It's like giving your brain a seatbelt before letting AI take the wheel. That early thinking effort makes a difference.
MIT Coins a New Problem called Metacognitive Laziness
Furthermore, lead researcher Nataliya Kosmyna warned that what we're seeing is not just a shift in learning, it's a drop in how we approach thinking itself. She calls it metacognitive laziness, the brain's natural tendency to let AI do the hard part when given the option. Instead of thinking about how we think, we're letting algorithms short-circuit the process. And that can have ripple effects far beyond one essay or school project.
Kosmyna stresses that this is early data, based on 54 people and limited writing tasks. But the findings raise a red flag for schools rushing to embed AI tools into classrooms. If ChatGPT is replacing the hard work of learning, then educators need to hit pause, not plug in faster.
Otherwise, we risk training a generation to look smart without being smart. And that's not progress, that's a problem.
What Is the Best AI Stock to Buy Right Now?
You can't buy OpenAI or ChatGPT stock, but if you're trying to tap into the AI boom without falling for the froth, Wall Street's got a shortlist of serious contenders.
Based on data from TipRanks' Comparison tool, Nvidia (NVDA) still leads the charge in investor love with a 20.4 percent upside and a 'Strong Buy' consensus. It is the chip king behind nearly every AI breakthrough from ChatGPT to Tesla's Dojo, and its $3.51 trillion market cap proves it is more than a one-trick pony.
But it is not the only contender. Amazon (AMZN) and Google (GOOGL) also hold 'Strong Buy' ratings with significant upside at 15.6 and 19.5 percent respectively. Microsoft (MSFT), meanwhile, is the quiet giant with its tight OpenAI partnership and 8.1 percent upside. Meta and Apple round out the tech elite, with Meta holding a pristine 10 Smart Score, suggesting it's got the tech, momentum, and analyst backing to keep climbing.
Looking for safety with a sprinkle of AI? IBM's 'Moderate Buy' may surprise, but it scores a perfect 10 on the Smart Score and offers a rare 2 percent dividend yield.