SMRT Trains gets S$240,000 fine after officer killed by rod that shot out of machine
Mr Muhammad Afiq Senawi, a 30-year-old technical officer, died of face and chest injuries after a rod shot out of a hydraulic press machine and struck him.
He had been working at SMRT for more than two years at the time of his death on Mar 23, 2020.
SMRT pleaded guilty to a charge of failing to take necessary measures to ensure the safety and health of its employees, which carries a maximum fine of S$1 million.
On the day of the accident, Mr Afiq was operating a hydraulic press machine with another technical officer at a maintenance workshop in Bishan Depot.
Mr Afiq put a new part into the machine without first removing an old part. This resulted in the new part being misaligned and pressure accumulating in the machine.
The rod, which was not engaged in the machine, ejected, penetrated the metal fencing around the machine and hit Mr Afiq's lower jaw. He was treated on site and then in a hospital, where he died.
SMRT admitted that it failed to put in place a pressure gauge after the machine was dismantled for repair, even though this was a safety measure identified in the machine's operating manual.
The machine's pressure gauge was recorded as damaged in June 2018 and an engineering maintenance manager ordered it to be dismantled. He later overlooked its reinstallation.
It was not necessary for workers to monitor the exact pressure when operating the machine.
The Ministry of Manpower's prosecutor Kimberly Boo, said, though, that a gauge would have given the workers an indication of any disproportionate increase in force when the machine was in operation.
SMRT also failed to limit the maximum operating pressure of the machine through the use of pressure valves, which would have reduced the workers' exposure to a force way beyond what was needed for the machine's intended use.
The maximum pressure of the hydraulic press machine was about 98 tonnes, which exceeded the pressure necessary to perform the task of removing and installing a part to the machine that day, which was about 1.4 tonnes and 3.3 tonnes respectively.
The train operator further failed to ensure that the pieces in the machine were engaged and interlocked to prevent displacement of any single one.
The company had earlier identified the hazard of a part slipping or shooting out of the machine in its risk assessment of May 2018.
During sentencing arguments, SMRT's defence counsel said the accident was not the result of a flagrant disregard for safety, but represented an "extreme scenario" for which the possible safeguards were not in place.
She stressed SMRT's safety culture, track record of operating the hydraulic press machine for more than 20 years without incident, and that the company had remained free of work-accidents for the past five years.
She also said that SMRT's workplace injury rate was lower than the average in Singapore's transport and logistics industry, with last year's figure at 648 cases for every 100,000 workers yearly since 2020.
However, Ms Boo pointed to five of SMRT's previous workplace safety convictions for accidents between 2010 and 2020, which formed what she called a "pattern" of offending.
These included a S$230,000 fine for a December 2018 accident that resulted in a worker's leg being amputated, as well as a S$400,000 fine after two workers died after being hit by a train in March 2016.
Ms Boo said this gave rise to an "irresistible inference" that previous calls for robust safety practices and culture in the workplace were not heeded and she urged the court to send a strong signal.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
2024 EWL breakdown could have been prevented with better coordination: SMRT CEO
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox SMRT will work more closely with the Land Transport Authority and equipment manufacturers during fleet and systems renewals. SINGAPORE – The six-day disruption to train services on the East-West Line (EWL) in September 2024 could have been prevented with better coordination among all parties involved, said SMRT group chief executive Ngien Hoon Ping on July 31. Setting out the rail operator's view of the breakdown – one of Singapore's worst so far, affecting 2.6 million passengers – Mr Ngien said the right lessons need to be learnt so that the same mistakes are not made again. This means working more closely with the Land Transport Authority (LTA) and equipment manufacturers during fleet and systems renewals. 'We need robust, forward-looking life-cycle planning, clear roles and responsibilities, and much tighter cross-agency collaboration moving forward,' said Mr Ngien during a press conference on the latest financial results for SMRT's train division. On July 31, SMRT said the 2024 EWL breakdown has prompted 'deeper reflections' on the challenges of operating rail assets beyond their intended lifespan. Noting that MRT trains in Singapore are designed to be operated for 30 years, the operator called for a structured framework to manage ageing trains, suggesting that LTA issue a formal certificate to rail operators if such trains are used beyond their intended lifespans. Such certificates are already issued for new trains before they enter service. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore No entry: ICA to bar high-risk, undesirable travellers from boarding S'pore-bound ships, flights Singapore 5 foreign women suspected of trafficking 27kg of cocaine nabbed in Changi Airport Singapore Over half of job applications by retrenched Jetstar Asia staff led to offers or interviews: CEO Singapore Fallen tree branch damages two Yishun flats, showering one home owner in shattered glass Singapore Man accused of raping woman who hired him to fix lights in her flat claims she made first move Singapore Jail for ex-employee of agency under MOH who corruptly obtained $18k trip from 2 men Singapore ICJ's climate ruling may spur scrutiny of S'pore carbon tax, firms' climate action plans Singapore 'Switching careers just as I became a dad was risky, but I had to do it for my family' The process involves checks by the train manufacturer and an independent assessor to ensure all safety specifications are met. The 2024 EWL disruption was traced to a faulty part on a 37-year-old, first-generation Kawasaki Heavy Industries (KHI) train , which caused extensive damage to 2.55km of track and trackside equipment as it was being withdrawn from service. Investigations found that SMRT had extended the interval between overhauls for the KHI fleet without a detailed engineering and risk assessment. However, LTA did not review the extension either, nor did it require SMRT to seek its approval. SMRT, meanwhile, has cited repeated delays to the delivery of new replacement trains that would have allowed it to retire the faulty train earlier. The new trains were ordered by LTA in 2018, two years after the authority took over ownership of SMRT's rail assets under a revised financing model. Under this model, LTA makes decisions regarding upgrading and asset replacement. The new trains were meant to arrive from 2021, in time for the KHI trains to be decommissioned. But they were delivered only from 2023 onwards. This was one of the factors that LTA took into account when it lowered the fine that SMRT would pay to the Public Transport Fund – to $2.4 million from $3 million – as a penalty for the September 2024 incident. The decision came after SMRT made its final representations on the matter. SMRT chairman Seah Moon Ming said on July 31 that the rail operator was faced with a 'tough choice' over whether to overhaul the old KHI trains, or wait for the new ones made by French company Alstom to arrive. He said MRT trains are usually overhauled after clocking 500,000km, which is about every four years, and the planning for such these works takes place about 1½ years in advance, so that the operator can source for the necessary parts. The KHI trains were last overhauled in 2018. After repeated delays to the new trains, SMRT decided to overhaul the KHI fleet again in 2022, Mr Seah said. But SMRT had trouble procuring spare parts due to global supply chain disruptions during the Covid-19 pandemic. Hence, it could start on modular overhaul works only in December 2023 using the limited parts available. By September 2024, 18 of out of 66 first-generation KHI trains were overhauled. But the faulty train that caused the major disruption that month was not among them. Mr Ngien, who was LTA chief executive from 2016 to 2020, said more proactive and deliberate decisions about the KHI overhaul could have been made earlier if there was better coordination between LTA, the asset owner and SMRT. He also revealed that the new Alstom trains had issues with overheating batteries when they were first delivered in 2023. 'Frankly, it's not reasonable to expect the operator to have a contingency plan to continue to overhaul, just in case, in 2021, the trains (were not delivered). Even so, there must be certain discussions and agreement as to the funding,' Mr Ngien added, noting that SMRT paid for the additional overhauls to the KHI fleet. In its statement on July 31, SMRT lauded the announcement in March that up to $1 billion in additional government funds will be invested over the next five years to improve the management of rail assets here. 'This is a positive step in addressing the challenges Singapore faces in managing train fleet transitions,' it said. SMRT said it also plans to deepen direct engagement with equipment manufacturers, pointing to its partnership with Alstom to accelerate the testing of the new North-South and East-West line (NSEWL) trains being delivered. 'This proactive approach allows potential reliability and interoperability issues to be resolved ahead of full deployment. We remain on track to retire all first-generation KHI trains by end-September 2025,' the operator added. There are 13 KHI trains still operating today, and they are used only during weekday peak hours. Meanwhile, 63 new Alstom trains have entered service on the NSEWL so far, out of the 106 trains on order.
International Business Times
6 hours ago
- International Business Times
Singapore Driver, 44, Involved in Tampines Crash That Claimed Two Lives, Including JC Student, to Plead Guilty
A 44-year-old driver who was involved in a chain collision in Tampines that killed two people and injured several others is all set to plead guilty on Oct 23. On Thursday, July 31, Muhammad Syafie Ismail's guilty plea was set following one of several pre-trial conferences that preceded this event. For an incident that occurred at the intersection of Tampines Avenue 1 and Tampines Avenue 4 in April of last year, Syafie is facing five charges under the Road Traffic Act. Among his charges are failing to stop after an accident, dangerous driving causing death, and dangerous driving causing injury. After 7 am on April 22, 2024, he allegedly drove carelessly along Bedok Reservoir Road in the direction of Tampines Avenue 4. He allegedly caused a "sideswipe collision" when he abruptly changed lanes to pass a car, causing another vehicle to veer left and scrape its tires against the road kerb. After that, he allegedly ran a red light and struck three vehicles, one of which swerved and struck a van. Following the incident, 57-year-old Norzihan Juwahib, a worker for a pest control company, and 17-year-old Temasek Junior College student Afifah Munirah Muhammad Azril perished as van passengers. An 11-year-old boy was hurt when the van struck a minibus. Court documents indicate that Regent Law attorneys are Syafie's legal representatives. Syafie could spend two to eight years in prison and be prohibited from operating any kind of vehicle if found guilty of dangerous driving that results in death. He could be fined up to S$10,000 (US$7,700), imprisoned for up to two years, or both for reckless driving that causes harm. He would also be prohibited from operating any kind of vehicle. He could be fined up to S$5,000, imprisoned for up to 12 months, or both if found guilty of dangerous driving. Failing to stop after an accident is punishable by a maximum fine of S$1,000, a maximum jail sentence of three months, or both. In addition to the criminal case, Syafie is facing two civil lawsuits for negligence resulting from auto accidents.
Straits Times
11 hours ago
- Straits Times
Trump hits Brazil with tariffs, sanctions but key sectors excluded
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox SAO PAULO/BRASILIA - U.S. President Donald Trump on Wednesday slapped a 50% tariff on most Brazilian goods to fight what he has called a "witch hunt" against former President Jair Bolsonaro, but softened the blow by excluding sectors such as aircraft, energy and orange juice from heavier levies. Trump announced the tariffs, some of the steepest levied on any economy in the U.S. trade war, as his administration also unveiled sanctions on the Brazilian supreme court justice who has been overseeing Bolsonaro's trial on charges of plotting a coup. "Alexandre de Moraes has taken it upon himself to be judge and jury in an unlawful witch hunt against U.S. and Brazilian citizens and companies," Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said in a statement. Bessent said Moraes "is responsible for an oppressive campaign of censorship, arbitrary detentions that violate human rights, and politicized prosecutions — including against former President Jair Bolsonaro." Last week, the Brazilian justice levied search warrants and restraining orders against Bolsonaro over allegations he courted Trump's interference in his criminal case, in which he is accused of plotting to stop President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva from taking office in 2023. Trump's final tariff order and the sanctions followed weeks of sparring with Lula, who has likened the U.S. president, a close ideological ally of Bolsonaro's, to an unwanted "emperor." On Wednesday, Lula and his government closed ranks behind Moraes, calling the U.S. sanctions "unacceptable." Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore SMRT's finances hit by 2024 EWL disruption; profit after tax for trains division dips 8% Asia US-Malaysia tariff deal set for Aug 1 after Trump-Anwar phone call Business Deepening S'pore-Latin America ties a matter of urgency amid global trade uncertainty: Alvin Tan Singapore Underground pipe leak likely reason for water supply issues during Toa Payoh fire: Town council Multimedia 60 years, 60 items: A National Day game challenge Life Milo tees, kaya toast pimple patches, crockery: Here are the SG60 merch to collect Singapore SingHealth nurses get $5.7m from Wee Foundation for education, skills development Singapore 'Switching careers just as I became a dad was risky, but I had to do it for my family' "The Brazilian government considers the use of political arguments to defend the trade measures announced by the U.S. government against Brazilian exports to be unjustifiable," it said in a statement. Lula added that Brazil was willing to negotiate trade with the U.S., but that it would not give up on the tools it had at hand to defend itself, hinting that retaliation was possible. Still, Trump's tariff order threatened that if Brazil were to retaliate, the U.S. would also up the ante. DIPLOMACY AT WORK Despite Trump's effort to use the tariffs to alter the trajectory of a pivotal criminal trial, the range of exemptions came as a relief for many in Brasilia, who since Trump announced the tariff earlier this month had been urging protections for major exporters caught in the crossfire. "We're not facing the worst-case scenario," Brazilian Treasury Secretary Rogerio Ceron told reporters. The new tariffs will go into effect on August 6, not on Friday as Trump announced originally. Trump's executive order formalizing a 50% tariff excluded dozens of key Brazilian exports to the United States, including civil aircraft, pig iron, precious metals, wood pulp, energy and fertilizers. Planemaker Embraer, whose chief executive has met with officials in Washington and U.S. clients in recent days to plead its case for relief, said an initial review indicated that a 10% tariff imposed by Trump in April remains in place, with the exclusion applying to the additional 40%. The exceptions are likely a response to concerns from U.S. companies, rather than a step back from Trump's efforts to influence Brazilian politics, said Rafael Favetti, a partner at political consultancy Fatto Inteligencia Politica in Brasilia. "This also shows that Brazilian diplomacy did its work correctly by working to raise awareness among U.S. companies," he said. Brazil's minister of foreign affairs, Mauro Vieira, said he met with U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Wednesday to express the nation's willingness to discuss tariffs after negotiations stalled in June, though he stressed Bolsonaro's legal troubles were not up for debate. It remains unclear what Brazilian authorities "are bringing to the negotiating table to, for instance, open the domestic market," Goldman Sachs said in a note to clients. IMPACT SMALLER THAN EXPECTED The effective tariff rate on Brazilian shipments to the U.S. should be around 30.8%, lower than previously expected due to the exemptions, according to Goldman. Oil shipments to the U.S., which had been suspended, are set to restart after being spared, lobby group IBP said. Meanwhile, mining lobby Ibram said the exemptions covered 75% of mining exports. However, it was still too soon to celebrate, said former Brazilian trade secretary Welber Barral, estimating that Brazil exports some 3,000 different products to the United States. "There will be an impact," Barral said. Trump's tariff exemptions did not shield two of Brazil's key exports to the U.S., beef and coffee. Meatpackers expect to log $1 billion in losses in the second half of the year on the new tariffs, lobby group Abiec, which represents beef producers including JBS and Marfrig, said. Coffee exporters will also continue to push for exemptions, they said in a statement. The government said it was readying measures to protect Brazil's businesses and workers. If Brazil were to retaliate against Trump's measures, that "would generate a larger negative impact" on activity and inflation, Goldman said. "The political inclination may be to retaliate, but exporters and business associations have been urging the Brazilian administration to engage, negotiate and de-escalate." REUTERS
