Brazil's top court votes to hold social media platforms accountable for user posts
Six of the 11 Supreme Court judges voted to hold platforms responsible for third-party content seen as illegal, in a decision that could result in fines against social media companies for not removing some users' posts in the country.
The decision could impact the business of platforms including Meta's Facebook and Instagram, as well as TikTok, Elon Musk's X and other internet giants, such as Alphabet's Google, in a market of more than 200 million people.
Only one justice so far voted to not change the current law on the matter, which says that the companies can only be found responsible for third-party content on their platforms if the firms do not comply with a legal decision ordering the content removal.
Writing for the majority, Justice Gilmar Mendes said current Brazilian law represents "a veil of irresponsibility for digital platforms."
"Even if they are informed of the occurrence of crimes on their platforms, they (currently) cannot be held responsible for damages caused by keeping this content online, except in the case of a court order," he said.
Asked to comment, Meta sent a 2024 statement where it had said that a decision holding platforms responsible could make them "liable for virtually all types of content even without having been notified."
In a statement sent before the vote which gave the court a majority, Google said the current Brazilian law regarding social media can and should be improved, "as long as procedure guarantees and criteria are set to prevent legal uncertainty and the indiscriminate content removal."
TikTok and a representative of X in Brazil did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
The court did not agree on the scope of the decision, such as what types of content would be considered illegal. The court's head, Luis Roberto Barroso, said he will work with the court members to find a consensus.
Four judges still need to vote in the trial, which has been rolling over for months. Votes previously cast can still be changed, although that is not common. The trial is set to resume on Thursday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
24 minutes ago
- The Sun
US tariff negotiations update as August 1 deadline looms
WASHINGTON: US tariff negotiations with major trading partners are reaching a critical phase as the August 1 deadline approaches. The twice-delayed deadline could see higher duties imposed on economies with significant trade surpluses with the US, unless last-minute agreements are reached. The Biden administration has already secured deals with the European Union, Britain, Vietnam, Japan, Indonesia, and the Philippines. The EU agreement, announced Sunday, reduces tariffs on European exports to the US from a threatened 30 percent to 15 percent. South Korea faces heightened pressure as it races to finalize a deal. A government source told AFP that Tokyo's successful agreement has increased urgency for Seoul. Reports suggest South Korea may propose over $100 billion in investments, with major firms like Samsung and Hyundai Motor involved. National Security Advisor Wi Sung-lak confirmed negotiations are in their 'final and most crucial phase' to avoid a 25 percent tariff. India remains cautiously optimistic. Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal expressed confidence in reaching a deal, dismissing concerns over sticking points. However, local reports indicate chances of an interim agreement before August 1 are fading. Taiwan is working hard to secure favorable terms, with Premier Cho Jung-tai stating officials are negotiating around the clock. Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim emphasized efforts to protect Taiwan's industrial interests and deepen US cooperation. Canada and Mexico face uncertainty. While spared from initial 'reciprocal' tariffs, both nations could see duties rise—30 percent for Mexico and 35 percent for Canada—if no deal is reached. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum vowed to do 'everything' possible to avoid the hike. Brazil braces for political fallout. A 50 percent tariff on Brazilian exports, set for August 1, appears unlikely to be averted. The move is seen as politically motivated, with Trump citing Brazil's treatment of his ally, former president Jair Bolsonaro. With just days left, negotiations remain fluid. The outcome will shape global trade dynamics in the coming months. - AFP
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Tesla picks Samsung to make next-gen AI6 chips under US$16.5b deal, says Musk
SEOUL, July 28 — Tesla CEO Elon Musk said Monday that tech giant Samsung Electronics will provide his company with its next-generation AI6 chips, following the South Korean firm's announcement of a US$16.5 billion (RM69.7 billion) deal. Samsung said Monday it had secured an eight-year agreement, without naming the client, describing it only as a 'major global company' in a regulatory filing. Under the deal, the partnership — effective from last Thursday — runs through the end of 2033. 'Samsung's giant new Texas fab will be dedicated to making Tesla's next-generation AI6 chip. The strategic importance of this is hard to overstate,' Musk said on X. 'Samsung agreed to allow Tesla to assist in maximizing manufacturing efficiency,' he added, calling it a 'critical point' in striking the deal. 'I will walk the line personally to accelerate the pace of progress,' he said, noting Samsung's Texas plant was 'conveniently located not far from my house'. The deal represents about 7.6 percent of Samsung's projected annual sales for 2024, the company said. It declined to confirm the client was Tesla, even after Musk's message, citing confidentiality. The agreement is expected to provide a major boost to Samsung, which has faced headwinds in its foundry business, lagging rivals SK hynix and Taiwan's TSMC in the race for cutting-edge artificial intelligence chips. Samsung Electronics is the flagship unit of South Korea's Samsung Group, by far the largest of the family-run conglomerates that dominate Asia's fourth-largest economy. The company said this month that it expected operating profit to fall 56 per cent on-year and 31 per cent from the previous quarter, citing a slump in its core semiconductor division. Experts have attributed the decline to weaknesses in its foundry operations, which involve contract-based manufacturing of chips designed by other companies. — AFP
The Star
5 hours ago
- The Star
Brazil investors warn of political impact of US tariffs in election
Unpopular move: Protesters dressed as police, Trump and Bolsonaro demonstrating against the US president's announcement of 50% tariffs on Brazilian goods and against a US report that cited counterfeit product sales in Brazil, in Sao Paulo. — AP SAO PAULO: At a large financial market gathering in Sao Paulo, Donald Trump's threat to impose 50% tariffs on Brazil barely registers as a primary economic concern. What's truly unsettling money managers is the political fallout – the broader storm unleashed by the US president ahead of next year's elections. Since Trump issued the July 9 threat in retaliation for what he called a 'witch hunt' against Jair Bolsonaro, his conservative ally in Brazil, leftist President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva has seen a boost in popularity that's strengthening his reelection bid. Meanwhile, Bolsonaro's allies have struggled to mount a cohesive and persuasive response. 'The macroeconomic impact is small and the microeconomic risks are already priced in,' Ruy Alves, a partner and manager at Kinea Investimentos, said in an interview last Friday on the sidelines of the event organised by XP Inc. Investors fear that, under Lula, Brazil's finances would continue to deteriorate, with a negative impact on the currency and inflation. That would force the central bank to keep a very restrictive monetary policy in place, creating a vicious cycle that would eventually hit growth. 'The political impact could be big. And it could have an impact on the exchange rate,' Rodrigo Azevedo, co-chief investment officer at Ibiuna Investimentos, said at the same event. The real has so far avoided a major sell-off as double-digit local interest rates add to the appeal of the Brazilian currency against a globally weakening dollar. It has still weakened about 2% since Trump made his threat. Most of those losses came last Friday after Bloomberg News reported that Trump's administration is seeking new legal basis for imposing tariffs on Brazil, given that the country has a trade deficit with the United States. The fact that the Brazilian economy is somewhat closed limits the impact it will sufffer from the tariffs, according to the economists present at the event. XP estimates that a 50% rate would shave no more than half a percentage point off Brazil's growth in 2026. Some Brazilian companies could suffer a severe blow, but that has been largely priced in by markets, according to Alves, from Kinea. The most prominent case is aircraft manufacturer Embraer SA, whose stock price has sank almost 20% since the tariff threat. Yet veteran investor Luis Stuhlberger sounded more sceptical of the positive political effect that US tariffs may have for Lula in the longer term. 'This is just a short-lived gain,' he told the audience. 'Companies will go bankrupt, layoffs will happen, there will be silent defaults, strikes in agribusiness, truck drivers striking. The blame will fall on the government.' — Bloomberg
