Whakatāne Mayor Victor Luca pushes for second bridge with community petition
Since he became mayor in 2022, Luca has continued to push for a new bridge, speaking to the East Coast's MP at the time, Kiri Allen, and former Transport Minister Simeon Brown.
In August 2023, his request that council staff put together a proposal for a second river crossing was agreed to at a council meeting. However, the proposal never eventuated.
'That didn't go anywhere, so I decided to write it myself,' Luca said.
'I started in the second half of last year.
'We'll send that in to the minister with a petition, hopefully with a few thousand signatures on it.'
Last year, he also managed to have an application for funding for a full business case included in the Regional Land Transport Plan.
'The bridge proposal was ranked 12th or 13th in the Bay of Plenty, and I was quite hopeful at one point.
'But, unbeknownst to me, [central government] didn't provide a lot of funding and it seems as if most of it has gone to Tauranga and the Western Bay.
'We didn't get even a look in. But if you don't rattle the cage or stir things up, then you're not going to get a bridge.'
He emphasised the proposal was not a business case, and although it identified several potential locations that have been suggested by people over the years, it did not advocate for any particular location for a bridge.
'Every man and his dog are going to have a view on where it should go,' he said.
'It's all about advocating. The detail would come in a full-blown business case.'
The proposal outlines the 'significant challenges' faced by the Eastern Bay due to its largest town's reliance on the Landing Rd Bridge, constructed in 1962 and now under increasing strain from a growing population, seismic risks and climate-related threats.
It points out the Whakatāne district's population has nearly tripled since the bridge on Landing Rd was built and is projected to reach 42,500 by 2033.
The proposal asks for funding for a detailed business case, geo-spatial analysis, technical feasibility studies and benefit-cost evaluations.
It also asks the minister to initiate collaborative planning, such as partnering with regional councils, iwi and stakeholders to align priorities and resources, to incorporate lessons from Cyclone Gabrielle and focus on long-term climate adaptation strategies.
He said people needed to front up if the proposal was to get any attention from central government.
'If this town wants a second bridge, it needs to get out and sign up to a petition which could accompany a proposal, which will be sent to the Minister for Transport and Infrastructure Chris Bishop.
'It's still a fair way to go but if you don't do the advocacy and you don't have the nod from upstairs, you're probably not going to get anywhere.
'This is one step on the road. It's what I promised my community I was going to do, which is advocate for the bridge so that's what I'm doing.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
5 hours ago
- 1News
Seymour's response to UN 'quite alarming'
Thousands have signed an open letter following Regulations Minister David Seymour's scathing response to the United Nation raising concerns over the impact of Government legislation and policies on Māori. The letter to Albert Barume, UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, invites him to 'remain engaged' with Māori following Seymour's intervention last week. Indigenous rights advocate Tina Ngata, an author of the open letter, said Seymour's response was 'quite alarming' considering no conclusion from Barume's work has been made. She said on TVNZ's Marae: 'It is [Barume's] job, where concerns are repeatedly raised to him, to inquire more deeply and it's the first stage of that inquiry where he basically comes to us and says to our government… 'well, there are these issues that have been raised to me, can you please explain what this is about?'' Watch the full discussion panel on TVNZ+ ADVERTISEMENT Barume had written to the Government outlining concerns over the alleged 'persistent erosion' of Māori rights through 'regressive legislations and policies' that breached New Zealand's international obligations. He included a reference to the Regulatory Standards Bill. Seymour responded to his concerns saying they were 'presumptive, condescending, and wholly misplaced'. Quotes pulled from Regulations Minister David Seymour's response to UN (Source: 1News) He also stated: 'As an indigenous New Zealander myself, I am deeply aggrieved by your audacity in presuming to speak on my behalf and that of my fellow Māori regarding legislation that aims solely at ensuring clarity, consistency, and accountability in regulatory processes." He eventually withdrew the letter after he was pulled up by his coalition partner and Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters for overstepping. 'Shed some light' Indigenous governance partner at the Human Rights Commission Dayle Takitimu said indigenous advocates 'from across the United Nations framework', which included the Human Rights Commission, called on the UN to 'shed some light' on the Government's obligations under Te Tiriti o Waitangi, and the UN Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, that needed to be upheld. ADVERTISEMENT 'There's been a lot of advocacies saying – from various quarters – that people think that's not up to scratch at the moment, and the United Nations, through this special rapporteur, has responded to that, as Tina [Ngata] said, in a very initial way, prompting that discussion,' she said on Marae. Tina Ngata and Dayle Takitimu on Marae (Source: Marae) She acknowledged there was tension between human rights and domestic sovereignty that exists across all international law. 'But at the end of the day, the United Nations, in fact, exist to assist to resolve that tension and that conflict by viewing and monitoring human rights, so they are seen as universal and paramount across the global order.' Last week's incident prompted Ngata, alongside fellow Māori rights advocates Leonie Pihama and Tania Waikato, a lawyer for the Toitū Te Tiriti movement, to draft an open letter to Barume that invites him to Aotearoa amidst 'deepening political and constitutional crisis'. Ngata said the open letter reaffirms Māori have a right to international protection. 'It reaffirms that we will continue to be our own voice which called out to the United Nations for their oversight, and it invites them to continue that oversight, to remain in dialogue with us throughout this political crisis - and it is a political crisis. It might be a crisis of idiots and egos, but it's a crisis nonetheless and so we've called upon them to remain in contact with us and to maintain their oversight over what's happening in Aotearoa.' ADVERTISEMENT Quote pulled from UN Special Rapporteur Albert K. Barume's letter to New Zealand government (Source: 1News) When asked if the UN had the power to hold Aotearoa to account over indigenous rights, Takitimu said that because New Zealand subscribes to the 'international framework', and has sought legitimacy from it on occasion, it has to take the support with the criticism. 'Indigenous peoples have always utilised that framework, and so has New Zealand as a state party, and so that, again, comes back to the very foundations of the United Nations to set some sort of global standards, and they have, in regards to indigenous rights and human rights, and they are holding the New Zealand Government to account for that. That's exactly what they are set up to do.'
NZ Herald
7 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Kāinga Ora tenants accused of firing gun, threatening assault keep homes despite eviction bids
The tenant allegedly asked the boy: 'Do you want to die? Are you not scared of dying? I'll come and kill you right now.' However, the tribunal adjudicator decided there was not enough proof the man made the threats, despite it being confirmed he was facing criminal charges after police found a firearm at his property. The unsuccessful evictions appear to be speed bumps in Kāinga Ora's new policy of getting tough on state housing tenants. In January, Housing Minister Chris Bishop declared the 'easy ride' for disruptive Kāinga Ora tenants to be over. In March last year, the Government told the public housing provider to abandon its 'Sustaining Tenancies Framework'. That programme first started in 2017 as a pilot in which Kāinga Ora staff were urged to try their best to avoid evicting tenants and instead work with them to overcome their issues. Part of the policy's belief was that evicted tenants could be left with nowhere else to go, potentially leading them to cause more trouble on the streets or cost taxpayers more through poor health and medical expenses. The new Coalition Government argued, however, that disruptive and threatening tenants were causing neighbours to live in fear. They believed the threat of eviction would also 'spark behaviour change', forcing these tenants to behave better. That tougher stance led to a five-fold increase in evictions. A Kāinga Ora spokeswoman said about 85% of all its eviction applications to the Tenancy Tribunal were successful. 'Of the 88 applications we made in the past 12 months, 77 were successful,' she said. However, the Hamilton and Nelson cases showed tribunals weren't rubber-stamping every application. The spokeswoman said the tribunal needed a 'high standard of evidence'. 'While we always aim to meet that threshold, sometimes the evidence we are able to present isn't quite strong enough,' she said. In the Hamilton case, tribunal adjudicator Jenny Robson questioned how reliable the neighbour's evidence was. Robson noted that Kāinga Ora had presented evidence saying the neighbour - who was the grandmother of the teenage boy the tenant was accused of pointing the rifle at – originally gave a statement to police, saying she went outside to confront the tenant. She told police the tenant then threatened to also kill her and shot off more rounds from his rifle. But when Robson asked the grandmother what happened during the confrontation, she replied that the tenant ignored her. 'Her oral evidence was contrary to the statement she had given to the police,' Robson concluded. The woman's grandson also didn't appear at the tribunal, meaning Robson was left to doubt the evidence presented. The tenant himself refused to comment at the tribunal, saying he had pending criminal proceedings. In the Nelson case, the tenant's clean record over four and a half years helped save her tenancy despite her admitting she threatened her neighbour. The drama began when her boyfriend assaulted the neighbour's son on January 9. The boyfriend was bailed with conditions to stay away following the attack, but allegedly returned to the woman's flat within two weeks. When her neighbour called police to report the bail breach, the tenant overheard 'inflammatory language' about her boyfriend and confronted the woman, the tribunal said. The tenant wasn't evicted because his neighbour was found to have given contradicting statements about what he did to police and to the Tenancy Tribunal. Photo / 123rf 'The tenant does not dispute she threatened to assault the neighbour. The video evidence of such a threat was conclusive,' tribunal adjudicator Michael Brennan found. However, he noted that only one of seven neighbours had complained about the woman and she had not had run-ins before this incident. He ultimately decided there were enough mitigating factors to let her off. 'I have given the tenant the benefit of the doubt this time, but she should be clear on how any future repeat behaviours … may not result in the tenancy continuing,' he said. Ben Leahy is an Auckland-based senior journalist. He has worked as a journalist for more than a decade in India, Australia and New Zealand.
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
Growing alarm about South Australia toxic agal bloom
Australia correspondent Nick Grimm spoke to Melissa Chan-Green about growing alarm in Australia over a toxic agal bloom that has spread along the South Australian coastline. It has created an ecological crisis that threatens to engulf the Albanese government. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
