Budget to spell doom for Pakistan's IT industry: P@SHA
In a statement, Pakistan Software Houses Association (P@SHA) said budget is decisive blow to an industry that has carried the hopes of export-led recovery; youth employment and digital transformation.
It said an industry that today employs over 600,000 young Pakistanis—one of the country's largest and most vital pools of skilled talent.
Yet in a stunning act of neglect, the budget fails to address two urgent and long-standing demands from the sector: first, a defined and fair taxation framework for remote workers; and second, the continuation—and expansion—of the current tax regime for formal IT exporters.
What the industry has consistently asked for is not a one-time concession or patchwork relief, but a stable, 10-year tax policy framework—one that allows companies to invest, grow and compete with global peers. That has been ignored.
For over a year, the Pakistan Software Houses Association (P@SHA) has warned of a growing imbalance. High-earning remote workers employed by foreign companies; often indistinguishable from full-time employees, remain largely untaxed.
Meanwhile, P@sha said, companies based in Pakistan, employing and training local talent, are taxed, audited and over-regulated. This makes local hiring more expensive; while incentivizing capital flight and informal arrangements.
Talent retention is collapsing; export dollars are being parked abroad, and formal firms are bleeding value.
The government's refusal to act is particularly frustrating given the simplicity of the proposed solution: P@SHA has recommended classifying any individual earning over PKR 2.5 million annually from fewer than three foreign sources as a remote worker.
This affects only the top 5% of earners and avoids harming freelancers and small remitters.
The State Bank already tracks the necessary data. This is a policy that could be implemented overnight—yet has been ignored for years.
Worse still is the government's failure to extend the existing tax regime for exporters.
This regime was the foundation for over $700 million in investment commitments secured through the Digital Foreign Direct Investment (DFDI) initiative. The country spent hundreds of millions of rupees to secure this investment.
Sadly, with no continuity in tax policy and those investments are now in jeopardy. Foreign investors will not engage with a country where rules shift every year.
This is not just bad policy—it is a signal to the world that Pakistan's digital economy is not ready to be taken seriously.
The results will be devastating. Pakistan's IT sector—its fastest-growing, most globally competitive industry—may lose its momentum entirely.
Export growth will stall; jobs will disappear and the government's dream of reaching $25 billion in IT exports will not just be delayed—it will become permanently out of reach.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Crowding out development for debt: Pakistan's fiscal dilemma
Over the past fifteen years, Pakistan's federal budget has ballooned in size, but not necessarily in wisdom. From 2009-10 to the upcoming fiscal year 2025-26, the national budget has grown nearly sevenfold in nominal terms. At first glance, that sounds like a sign of progress. But look under the hood, and a troubling story unfolds - one where the lion's share of that growth is being swallowed by interest payments on debt, leaving little room for investments that actually move the needle on development. Let's put the headline numbers into perspective. In 2009-10, Pakistan spent about 28% of its federal budget servicing debt. In 2025-26, that figure is projected to reach a staggering 46.7%, with PKR 8.21 trillion earmarked for debt servicing. That means more than half of every rupee in the national budget will go toward paying interest - mostly on domestic borrowing (in outgoing fiscal year, it was actually around 52%). Budget FY26: Aurangzeb announces major tax relief for salaried class, solar sector In contrast, spending on the federal development program (PSDP) has plunged from around 27.5% of the budget to just 5.69%. That's not just a fiscal shift; it's a strategic retreat from the future. The numbers don't lie. Since 2009–10, interest payments have increased from under PKR 700 billion to PKR 8.2 trillion - an increase of over 1000% - while development spending has only marginally risen from approximately PKR 421 billion to PKR 1.287 trillion, a far more modest growth of 205%. Even after accounting for inflation and rising - in favor of meeting mounting debt obligations. Although defence spending is often a political lightning rod in budgetary debates, its share of the national budget declined in recent years - from 14.6% to 11.6% - despite substantial growth in absolute terms. However, it has risen again to 14.5% in the 2025–26 budget. The above-mentioned situation is not just a budgeting issue; it's a symptom of a much deeper problem in Pakistan's fiscal architecture. The government is caught in a debt spiral, where borrowing begets more borrowing, and interest costs cannibalize public finances. And this isn't just some abstract macroeconomic concern. When the government spends over 8.21 trillion PKR on interest payments but only 1 trillion on development (PSDP), the effects are visible in potholes that don't get fixed, schools that don't get built, and hospitals that remain understaffed and under-resourced. What makes this fiscal scenario particularly pernicious is how it affects the future. Development spending is not just about concrete and contracts, it's about human capital, infrastructure, innovation, and resilience. It's the bridge between today's challenges and tomorrow's opportunities. When development is consistently underfunded, it isn't just growth that slows; it's hope that erodes. Let's take education as an example. Without adequate public investment, education outcomes stagnate or deteriorate. A population that isn't skilled or productive becomes less competitive globally and more vulnerable domestically. Add healthcare to the mix - where public sector hospitals are already struggling - and you see the real cost of fiscal mismanagement: a weaker, sicker, and more unequal society. And here's the twist: even if you doubled development spending tomorrow, the impact would be limited unless the structural drivers of this debt crisis are addressed. Domestic borrowing dominates Pakistan's debt profile, and it's an expensive habit - particularly when the central bank keeps interest rates high to tame inflation. That, in turn, jacks up the cost of debt servicing even further, creating a vicious cycle. And let's not forget the crowding-out effect: when government borrowing soaks up capital in the domestic financial markets, there's less credit available for the private sector. That means fewer investments, fewer jobs, and slower economic dynamism overall. It's a policy maze, but not an unsolvable one. The first step is to acknowledge the elephant in the room: Pakistan needs a serious debt management strategy. Not just another patchwork rescheduling or a short-term IMF fix, but a comprehensive roadmap that involves restructuring terms, limiting non-productive borrowing, and - crucially - ensuring that new debt is used to finance investments with real economic returns. At the same time, there's a desperate need for tax reform. Pakistan's tax-to-GDP ratio remains dismally low, and the burden is disproportionately borne by those already in the formal economy. Broadening the tax base - by bringing informal sectors and elite exemptions into the fold - is politically tough but economically indispensable. Without more robust and equitable revenue generation, the development squeeze will only tighten. Rationalizing expenditures is another part of the puzzle. While subsidies may be politically expedient, they're often poorly targeted and fiscally toxic. The FY2025-26 subsidy bill is expected to hit Rs1.18 trillion, slightly higher than the entire PSDP allocation. If even a portion of that could be redirected towards health, education, and infrastructure, the impact could be transformative. But perhaps the most sobering takeaway from this analysis is the intergenerational unfairness built into our current fiscal structure. We're borrowing today to pay for yesterday's spending, while leaving today's citizens - and tomorrow's workforce - with decaying infrastructure, low-quality public services, and limited economic mobility. In many ways, it's a quiet betrayal of the country's youth. This is why Pakistan's budget crisis is not just about numbers. It's about national priorities and the values they reflect. When more than half of public funds are spent on interest payments, it signals a government that is stuck servicing the past rather than building the future. When development gets only 5.7% of the pie, it signals a political economy that is risk-averse, reactive, and inward-looking. So, what's the way forward? We need a paradigm shift - a fundamental rethinking of what public finance is for. It's not enough to balance books. We need to balance our opportunity. That means aligning fiscal policy with development objectives. It means investing in projects that boost productivity, generate employment, and reduce long-term fiscal pressure. And it means building the kind of institutional capacity that ensures public money is not just spent but spent wisely. Pakistan's economic destiny will not be decided by how much we borrow, but by how we invest. We still have a chance to change course, but the window is narrowing. For too long, we've accepted a fiscal model that prioritizes survival over progress. It's time to flip the script. Because development isn't just another budget line item. It's the story we write for our future. The article does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Business Recorder or its owners
Business Recorder
7 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Real estate stocks, miners propel Australian shares higher
Australian shares rose on Wednesday, helped by mining stocks due to a rise in commodity prices, while favourable interest rate cut expectations from the Reserve Bank of Australia provided a boost to real estate stocks. The S&P/ASX 200 index rose 0.4% to 8,577.0 points by 0050 GMT. Rate sensitive real estate stocks led gains among Australian equities, rising 1%, after taking cues from expectations of a imminent rate cut from the central bank when it meets next week. Swaps indicate a 95.1% chance of a quarter-point cash rate reduction at the central bank's monetary policy meeting next week. Lower borrowing costs would put more money into consumers' hands, boosting property demand. Financial stocks were largely unchanged, likely taking a breather after a stellar run so far this year. Top bank Commonwealth Bank of Australia and Westpac rose 0.3% each, while National Australia Bank gained 1%. Markets are now awaiting the retail sales data for May due later in the day after a dip in April raised concerns about consumer spending. Investors also await US economic data this week, to gauge the outlook of interest rate cuts from the Federal Reserve. In Sydney, mining stocks rose 0.9% after strong manufacturing data from China, Australia's top trading partner, boosted copper prices to a three-month high on Tuesday. Shares of BHP Group and Rio Tinto rose 1.2% and 0.6%, respectively. Higher oil prices boosted energy stocks, which rose 0.3%. Sector majors Woodside Energy and Santos rose 0.3% each. Shares of Australian pizza chain operator Domino's Pizza Enterprises fell as much as 19% to become one of the top losers in the benchmark index after the firm said its group CEO Mark van Dyck would be stepping down. Airline operator Qantas shares fell 3.7% after it confirmed a cyber incident at one of its contact centres impacting customer data. New Zealand's benchmark S&P/NZX 50 index rose 0.4% to 12,789.55.
Business Recorder
12 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Senate body recommends Extradition (Amendment) Bill, 2025
ISLAMABAD: The Senate Standing Committee on Interior and Narcotics Control recommended the Extradition (Amendment) Bill, 2025. The committee meeting chaired by Senator Faisal Saleem Rehman was held on Tuesday to review key legislative proposals and pressing national issues, including security preparations for Muharram in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Islamabad's water shortage. The committee discussed the Extradition (Amendment) Bill, 2025, which has been passed by the National Assembly and referred to concerned ministries for input. As per the objective and reason of the bill, since the enactment of Extradition Act, 1972, no amendments are made. The delay in disposal of extradition cases, reflect badly at international forums. The extradition requests are received from foreign jurisdictions through diplomatic channels. The cases are processed under Extradition Act, 1972 and have to be forwarded to the Federal Cabinet twice i.e. for initiation of the process by nominating inquiry officer and after receiving report from the inquiry officer for surrendering/extradition as per sections 7, 11, and 13 of the Extradition Act, 1972. Extradition cases are forwarded to the Federal Cabinet for consideration which takes considerable time due to busy schedule of the Federal Cabinet's official business. The ministry supported the proposed amendments. The Pakistan Citizenship (Amendment) Bill, 2025, was also reviewed, which seeks to address concerns of overseas Pakistanis who are unable to resume citizenship after acquiring foreign nationality. The amendment aims to bridge this legal gap in cases where dual nationality arrangements exist. Senator Hidayatullah Khan raised concerns over inefficiencies at passport offices, citing delays and mishandling of cases. Minister for Interior Mohsin Naqvi assured the committee that the matter would be investigated and emphasised the need for professionalism and accountability in public service. The committee also discussed quota allocations in prohibited areas, particularly, in Balochistan and KPK. Minister Naqvi informed that the policy is under revision and that NADRA-linked license cancellations are also being reviewed. The Criminal Laws (Amendment) Bill, 2025, moved by Senator Muhammad Tallal Badar, was examined. The proposed changes include life imprisonment and fines for crimes against women and for harboring individuals involved in hijacking. The Islamabad Capital Territory Food Safety (Amendment) Bill, 2025, introduced by Senator Samina Mumtaz Zehri, was deferred. The committee discussed the Point of Public Importance regarding the water crisis in Islamabad, raised by Senator Fawzia Arshad during a sitting of the Senate. She highlighted the situation in Sector G-6/4, where thousands of complaints remain unresolved. Naqvi informed that a task force, formed on the prime minister's directive, is reviewing key water projects, and Senator Arshad has been invited to attend the task force's next meeting to assess progress. The committee also recommended convening an in-camera meeting to address security concerns raised by Senator Saifullah Abro in Sindh. Members, unanimously, agreed that no compromise should be made in matters involving threats to members' families. On the issue of Muharram security preparations, the committee was briefed on coordination efforts in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, including inter-agency collaboration, drone surveillance, and sealing of provincial boundaries. Senator Abdul Qadir raised concerns about security gaps on the DI Khan–Balochistan route. KPK Police acknowledged the issue and reported that six new security posts have been approved under the Annual Development Programme (ADP), and coordination with the Ministry of Interior and NHA has strengthened response capabilities. Regarding the recent Mardan incident, KPK Police reported significant progress, including arrests of facilitators and the elimination of key militant elements. The chairman stressed the need for maximum on-ground presence and visible deterrence to ensure peaceful observance of Muharram. The meeting was attended by senators, Fawzia Arshad, Naseema Ehsan, Palwasha Khan, Saifullah Abro, Mir Dostain Khan Domki, Umer Farooq, Jam Saifullah Khan, IrfanulHaque Siddiqui, Shahadat Awan, Hidayatullah Khan, Minister for Interior Mohsin Naqvi, Muhammad Tallal Badar, and senior officials from relevant departments, while KPK Police participated online. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
